The Walking Dead: 10 Big Differences Between The Comics & TV Show

Rick that is not your wife you hussy!

By Tom Baker /

The only group of fans more traumatised than people who watch The Walking Dead, are people who read The Walking Dead. Whilst the AMC series about a group of survivors making their way across a zombie-infested United States has become a ratings sensation in its so far five seasons (with a sixth and a spin-off to come), it might have an even bigger following in its original form. The Walking Dead comic €“ written and created by TV show consultant Robert Kirkman and drawn by Charlie Adlard €“ is a fair ways ahead of the story on TV, clocking in at over a hundred issues at this point. Bear in mind this is a monthly book, too, so whilst the series has been on screens for five years at this point? The comics have that beat by a good seven years on top of that. For the most part the adaptation has followed the source material fairly closely, and looking at where the comics have gone since give a good idea of what's to come next. But it may be less reliable than you think, since the TV show has made some significant changes to the original text over the years. Mostly it's in the form of people having even more violent and horrifying deaths €“ which, considering some that appeared in this past season, is mighty impressive €“ and plot twists even more shocking than you saw on screen. Those and some unconventional relationships figure into The Walking Dead's ten big differences between the comics and the show.

10. Rick May Actually Have Killed More In The Comics

Rick Grimes is racking up a series body count on The Walking Dead TV series. The fifth season closed out with the leader of the group being treated with suspicion by their new hosts at the Alexandria Safe Zone...mainly because troubled priest Father Gabriel told them that Rick had done some €œterrible things€ to survive. Which, admittedly, he has. Whilst Rick and the crew are adept at chopping up walkers without remorse at this point, there's been a few occasions when Office Grimes put a bullet in the head of an un-undead individual. In fact, that's how the season finale ended €“ but he might have an even higher body count in the comics. Amongst others, Rick was responsible for the death of Martinez, who is killed by The Governor in the TV show. In the comics, Rick strangled him for reporting back their whereabouts at The Prison to The Governor. He also shot zombified Shane, Otis and Allen...oh, and during a bandit attack, he bit a guys ear off ad then stabbed him. Hardcore stuff.

9. Lori's Death Is Even Worse In Print

The demise of Lori Grimes was a long time coming. Rick's philandering wife fell victim to the current (well, long-existing) trend of underwriting women characters as annoying and shrill €“ very much in the mould of Skyler White €“ which probably didn't help her case, but fans found a real reason to dislike her when it was revealed she was pregnant, and she wasn't sure if Rick was the father. Audiences will never get a straight answer on whether baby Judy is the daughter of Shane or Rick, because she died in childbirth €“ a fraught scene towards the start of third season, where trouble with the baby results in an emergency c-section and, unfortunately, Lori's untimely death. Still, it could've been a lot worse. On TV, she got to give a tearful goodbye monologue to her son Carl. In the comics, meanwhile, Lori managed to survive childbirth. That's the good news; the bad news is that she doesn't last much longer. During an attack by The Governor, she's shot whilst running for cover, collapsing on the baby she was carrying and crushing her to death. Yeesh.

8. Daryl Only Exists On TV

Daryl Dixon is everybody's favourite Walking Dead character. Not that he had a lot of competition, at least in the early days. Whilst the rest of the cast were poorly-developed cyphers and plot contrivances who spouted awkward dialogue, Daryl was the cool, stoic redneck with a troubled past, a lack of trust, and a dab hand with a crossbow. Daryl Dixon is everything the rest of the cast weren't. His arrival was preceded by his far less palatable brother, the racist hick Merle Dixon, briefly a part of Rick's crew before he goes apesh*t on T-Bone and they handcuff him to a roof, promising to come back for him...which of course they don't do for ages, returning to find that he sawed through his own hand. Merle turned up in the third season, having being rescued by The Governor, and had a none-too-cheery family reunion with Daryl, who had a slightly less combative relationship with the Grimes posse. They seem like vital parts of the plot, right? And yet neither of the Dixon brothers exists in The Walking Dead comic book, invented by the writers to test the group's moral compass early on.

7. Shane Originally Died Way Earlier

The ongoing antagonism between Rick and his former fellow cop Shane provided a lot of the drama in the first two seasons. Shane and Lori Grimes had a one-night stand, finding comfort in each other's arms during the early days of the zombie apocalypse, whilst Rick was in the hospital and presumed dead. That one night is the catalyst for a whole lot of upset. It spirals into Shane almost assaulting Lori, frustrated that his feelings for her are not mutual and are spurned when Rick shows up alive. In the second season Shane goes properly insane €“ which is pretty entertaining €“ before finally confronting Rick with what happened, threatening to kill him, and getting a bullet in the head. That's a lot more prolonged and drawn-out than it was in the comics. Where the secrets and resentment between Rick, Lori and Shane provides a rich vein of drama on screen, in the source material it provides a powerful climax to the first story arc. Yes, the group have barely moved on from their camp ground outside Atlanta before Shane gets murderous...and there, it was Carl who shot him.

6. Tomas Was A Stand-In For A Comics Character

After Shane's been shuffled off his mortal coil by a traumatised child, the comics wastes no time in introducing a new antagonist. When the group rock up at The Prison they're greeted by Dexter, an inmate (convicted of murdering his wife and her lover) who survived the outbreak trapped in whilst trapped in the facility's cafeteria. The fact that he's a prisoner kinda puts people on edge. He's perfectly civil at first, a gentle giant of sorts. Then his history puts him at odds with the group too many times, and he organises a mutiny with some of the other survivors against Rick. The coup fails, with the Grimes brigade failing to €œget out of his house€, being shot in the head by Rick after a zombie bite. Strangely, Dexter never appears in the TV version of The Prison. His closest analogue is Dexter, another inmate. The reason for his imprisonment is never explained, although he too is discovered in the cafeteria with other survivors, immediately demands that the rest of them leave the prison (mistaking them for bandits at first), and tries to sic zombies on Rick, only for Officer Grimes to shoot him.

5. Kirkman Has No Explanation For The Walkers

The zombie apocalypse gets explained towards the end of The Walking Dead's first season. The Centre For Disease Control, or CDC, is the first port of call for Rick's group of survivors, figuring that if anybody knew what was going on, the government agency would. On arriving at their headquarters in Atlanta, however, they just find despondent scientist Dr Edwin Jenner, who has an exit plan sorted out. A plan which involves locking the rest of the survivors inside the CDC with him, and then blowing it up. That's because, to his mind, there's no way of curing the zombie plague €“ because everybody in the world is infected, and as soon as they die, they return as a shambling flesh-eater. The characters are the walking dead, see? The CDC has never appeared in the comic books, even to this day. There's been over a hundred issues so far, with the TV show up to about the seventy mark, and there's no sign of the group retracing their steps to meet up with the comic book Dr Jenner. Which also means that, so far, there's been no explanation for the outbreak, with the survivors more focussed on not dying.

4. Comics Carol Is A Flirt

Carol starts off very similarly on both page and screen. Different hair style, admittedly, with the comic book version going for the longer bob of a prim housewife than the pixie cut Melissa McBride sports in the TV show. Otherwise, they're almost totally identical: both befriend Lori, both have a kid called Sophia, and both had an abusive husband they're glad to see the back off. From there, the paths diverge wildly. The Carol Peletier in the TV show starts off as demure and a bit annoying in her passivity. Then her daughter dies, having been lost in the woods towards the start of the second season. In the comics she's still alive, and has been adopted by Glenn and Maggie. That's because Carol ended up dying before her in the comics, the end of a series of self-destructive choices which culminated in letting a herd of zombies chow down on her. That's after a run of enjoying her single life that involves suggesting a polyamorous arrangement with Rick and Lori and dating Tyreese. It's when her new beau cheats on her that she finally goes off the deep end.

3. Dale Lasts Longer, And Hooks Up With Andrea

Dale was one of the most irritating characters on the TV show. A constantly invasive presence who stuck his nose in wherever it wasn't needed €“ most often in Andrea's business, saving her from killing herself in the CDC at the end of the first season €“ when he finally bit the bullet, nobody really shed any tears when a zombie bite and a Daryl bullet splatter his Hawaiian shirt in blood. In the comics, Dale has a much similar look to his TV incarnation €“ the bucket hat and all €“ but is marginally less irritating. In fact, most of the good traits that Hershel took on during the third season were ported over from Dale's comic book incarnation, since he lasted a lot longer than he managed to on screen. Clawing on through The Prison arc, the comic book Dale ended up starting a proper relationship with Andrea, and the two of them wound up adopting Allen's kids Ben and Billy after he died. The age difference was still sort of weird, and it meant Andrea went in a very different direction in the TV show from the comics as well. Dale still met his maker eventually, however, bitten and then euthanised by his lover.

2. Tyreese Is Totally Different

Hoo boy, did Tyreese get a raw deal in the comics. Far more intense than his TV incarnation wound up being, besides a tumultuous relationship with Carol €“ which ends after a dalliance with Michonne, who's far less enigmatic and far more promiscuous €“ he manages to also be far more integral to the main cast, essentially acting as Shane's replacement as Rick's new (and slightly less unhinged) right hand man. Things go downhill when his daughter Julie and her boyfriend Chris enter into a suicide pact at The Prison, following one last shag. Unfortunately Chris mucks it up and shoots Julie first, instead of doing it at the same time, killing her. Tyreese finds him, kills him, and is never quite the same since. Eventually Tyreese meets his end at the hands of The Governor, which too is very different from his fate on the TV show. The character still had a pretty tragic past in the AMC series and plenty troubled, but it never got quite as involved or traumatic as it did in the comics. He was mostly a large, quiet presence who died in the mid-season premiere this year, bitten by a zombie whilst investigating a new outpost.

1. Rick Was Supposed To Lose An Arm...And Gains A Bit More

The Governor is another character who was noticeably altered in the course of translation. The despotic ruler of Woodbury was a cool, terrifying presence played by Brit David Morrissey on screen. In the comics he was Latino, with a slicked-by mullet and handlebar moustache, and his insanity was present from the off. As evidenced from Rick's first meeting with The Governor, which involved him getting his hand hacked off. Rick Grimes of the comics managed to deal with the pain and inconvenience of losing his shooting hand to fight another day, but had to stump for a...stump for the rest of his days. Apparently the makers of the television series had considered doing the same, but ultimately decided against adapt the plot point because it'd cost a lot in special effects. The fortunes of Rick Grimes went further downhill from there, including the death of his wife and newborn kid, his son getting shot in the eye and almost dying, and his son shot his best friend. The one shining light in his life is that, after losing Lori, he winds up hooking up with Andrea (if getting Dale's sloppy seconds can be considered good). At this point they've been together long enough that Carl calls her mom, and they don't look like they'll ever break up. At least until comic book Andrea goes the way of TV Andrea...