The Walking Dead: The Comic vs The Television Show

We compare and contrast the series with the comic books and discuss their differences.

By Felix Vasquez jr. /

If you're like me, you've enjoyed The Walking Dead television series and are waiting on baited breath for news on season three coming in October of 2012 on AMC. I've been a hardcore The Walking Dead fan since the beginning and have followed the series through individual issues since it started in 2003, and I've followed it every month since then.

Advertisement
There are fans still catching up through the trades, but I've been there through every turn, and I've also come to adore the television series. Premiering in 2010, The Walking Dead is one of the most popular television shows of the new millennium and is the highest rated series on cable television. It's smashed all viewing records on AMC, and continues to make money hand over fist with its video game series, and novels. The series has been met with its fair share of debate. Some purists dismiss it for straying from the comics. Some fans love it because strays from the comics. And some people watch it just to bash it mercilessly. Those people I have no use for. Now nineteen episodes in, The Walking Dead shows no sign of fading away any time soon, so I thought I'd compare and contrast the series with the comic books and discuss their differences. I remain a hardcore fan of both properties, but this is just to see where one property is superior and the other inferior. Feel free to discuss your own positions below.

The Premise

Edge: The Comic

Ultimately what helps the comic prevail over the show is that there's less clarification for folks who aren't familiar with zombie lore. The first season as well as the second season as a whole spend time explaining zombie physics to the audience. The season finale of season one is entitled TS-19 an episode that is meant to spell out the zombie laws to the audience. And some of season two is also spent explaining what zombies are and what they do. Kirkman never spends too much time on that and instead focuses more on character, exposition, and survival. Click "next" below to read part 2...

Days Gone Bye

Edge: The Show

Advertisement
While "Days Gone Bye" is a quintessential storyline in the canon of "The Walking Dead," even Robert Kirkman himself admits that Frank Darabont vastly improved upon the storyline and added some fine touches to the story. When Rick awakens in the hospital it's much more dread soaked, we gain a better insight in to Rick and Shane's friendship in the prologue, Morgan Jones and his son Duane are given much more screen time including their very own gut-wrenching sub-plot as Darabont draws parallels to Rick and Duane through the pilot. There's better clarity to Rick's journey, Rick's entrance in to the city is more harrowing, and Glenn's introduction is better. In the comic Glenn saves Rick and helps him scale the roof tops to make it to the forest where the camp is. In the first season, Glenn has more to do and there's more of a fight to make it out alive. The pilot is arguably the best episode of the series to date.

Rick Grimes

Edge: The Comic

Rick Grimes in the television show is a complex and complicated man. He is constantly evolving from one phase to another and in season three we'll see him change in to someone new and vastly radical to the man we saw in season one. In season one he valued human life, in season two he realized even humans are deadly, and in season three we'll see something new. But the Rick Grimes in the show is softer and less hard edged than the Rick Grimes in the comic in spite of Andrew Lincoln's mesmerizing performance. Grimes in the comic is more adaptable and much more interesting to read. He's much more confrontational and less passive when approaching new challenges, and his entire strategy for survival is much more engrossing.

Shane Walsh

Advertisement

Edge: The Show

Shane in the comic books is a mere footnote in the mythology of "The Walking Dead." It was a major stepping point in Rick's survival where he'd experienced true violence and was forced to see his friend die. Shane in the comics is a loser. He's a petty, juvenile, sad sack who uses his role as the leader of the group to show off for Lori. When Rick appears there's a power struggle and Shane is offed pretty quickly. Jon Bernthal completely embodies the presence of Shane and the larger focus on Shane in the series benefited the character in the end and gave Rick much more incentive to keep his friends at arms length. Shane's descent in to madness is much more disturbing in the series, and Bernthal plays it brilliantly. Hell, AMC based an online game around the exploits of Shane Walsh. That has to be indicative of Bernthal's portrayal of the character.

Dale Horvath

Edge: The Comic

Advertisement
Let's call it for what it is. The series completely pissed away Dale Horvath, one of the most important and entertaining characters of the comic book. And that was because once showrunner Frank Darabont was fired, DeMunn protested and vowed to quit. AMC granted him his request and offed Dale. Though the writers tried to salvage his death by using it as a point for the group to attempt to keep their humanity, Dale was sadly wasted. Such a rich character gets a real focus in the comic books with his own adventures, and an impromptu romance with Andrea; he offers heart, strength, and wisdom to the group, and goes out in about as demented a manner as Kirkman could muster up. Dale is a very key character who the series could never figure out how to utilize.

Shock Factor

Edge: The Comic While the series has its merits and is superb it's yet to reach that level of sheer shock and awe that the comics reach time and time again. There are moments in the comic series that literally left me gazing at the page for ten minutes with my jaw agape. The comic features a ritual suicide, a child killer, torture, rape, and Shane's death in the comic is much more surprising than what we were served in the series. For shock factor, the comic books are the way to go. Ultimately the series has yet to reach that level where it's bold enough to challenge audiences conventions.

Andrea

Edge: The Comic

Advertisement
Ultimately, the Andrea in the comic is the individual that made me actually crush on a comic character. It takes a lot of talent to make me smitten for a drawing on a piece of paper, but lo and behold, Kirkman accomplished the task. Andrea begins as a basically ho hum supporting character who bonds with her sister Amy. When Amy is killed by a zombie, Andrea uses her death to empower her and Andrea becomes a warrior. Andrea becomes a woman Rick wants to stay back, in to a warrior Rick insists on having in the front line. Andrea in the series however can be grating and occasionally narcissistic. Andrea in the series tends to come off as whiny and mopey and for the most part the writers really have to force the fact that she's becoming a warrior. I enjoy how they retconned Andrea to become a student of Shane's, but so far her warrior instincts haven't kicked in. I'm still waiting for the selfless, powerful Andrea to appear. At this point we just have an Andrea who is doing it for herself.

Gore

Edge: Tie

One of the many facets of the zombie movie that's been missing from many modern zombie films is that key moment where the zombies tear in to a person and gobble on their intestines and skin. "Dawn of the Dead" 2004 is a film I detest because not once do we see zombies tearing in to anyone. The comic delivers the gore in spades with many scenes of grue and cannibalistic carnage. The zombies are so hungry for humans you can sense they'll even eat the feces of a human if ever presented with the opportunity. The zombies in the comic look rotten and decaying. The series masters this look offering unique walkers who look rotten and decaying while also presenting their own interesting traits and features. The gore has also been rich thankfully with a zombie autopsy in season two, and many moments of zombies ripping in to people and feasting on their entrails. But then with Gregory Nicotero you're promised excellence and you get excellence.

The Apocalypse

Edge: The Comic Kirkman is following the tenets of Romero's zombie lore. Skip the origin of the zombie infection and just show what happens when man falls under the weight of its own evil and misguided sense of self-preservation. Man was wholly unprepared and it fell. Rick's awakening in this new world shows that he miraculously survived and has been reborn in a new reality. The show has taken steps to explain somewhat how the world ended by backtracking. Darabont planned to also backtrack and show how the world ended. Some things are best left to the imagination and that's what Kirkman is best at. The series however shows flashbacks to the carnage leading up the end that, while compelling, don't do much to improve the situation these characters are presently in, thus making them meaningless.

Supporting Cast

Edge: The Comic No knock on the actors of the series, but we've yet to be given a rich supporting cast yet. We have T-Dogg who has been given five lines in the last two seasons, Hershel's family were nothing but expendable extras destined to die in the finale, Carol whose storyline has been expanded to whine alongside Lori, and we had the Morales family from season one who left to seek their own fortune from the group. While Daryl has become a stand out among the new characters, his popularity has been something of a fluke thanks to good writing and Norman Reedus' charismatic performance. The supporting cast for the comic borders on legendary with some interesting supporting characters and sub-plots including Tyreese, and his daughter, Allen who is left with his twins when his wife is killed by zombies, and of course Axel. The series has yet to present a cavalcade of compelling characters.

Showrunners: Frank Darabont vs. Glenn Mazzarra

Edge: Mazzarra Hey, I don't doubt Frank Darabont is a great storyteller. The man can create an aura of hopelessness and carnage. While I wasn't crazy about "The Mist," Darabont created a world where there was no bright light at the end of the tunnel. At the end of the day though there's a big difference between Mazzarra and Darabont. Glenn Mazzarra is getting things done while Darabont seemed to be taking his time. The first half of season two that most people complained about was the work of Darabont. Even worse Darabont wanted to include wild card episodes in every season that would spotlight a new character and feature a portion of a story that wasn't totally connected to the series. While the idea for the premiere featuring the origin of the tank zombie in the pilot starring Sam Witwer sounded great, how it factored in to the storyline was tough to justify. Once the series returned from its hiatus, Mazzarra took over and the show went in to hyper drive delivering plot motion, plot twists, and a killer season finale. While the conditions on which Darabont was fired is a big insult to a seasoned Hollywood veteran, Mazzarra has the series moving forward in a much better capacity. I won't pretend he's a master show runner, but he's getting the job done.

Overall Quality

Edge: The Comic

Advertisement
I hate to sound like one of those whiny fan boys, but the series has left me asking "why?" on many occasions. Why stow the comics supporting cast in favor of throwaway characters? Why end the first season at the CDC when you could have taken them in to Wiltshire Estates and ended on a bleak note? Why oh why hasn't the series taken the shocking turns the comic has yet? Damned if I know. While the series is superb, it doesn't have the guts the comic book does, and I'm still waiting for it to display some turns that will have the audience questioning their limits. But hey, the series isn't over yet, so I could be proven wrong at any point.