YOU Season 2: 10 Things That Must Happen

Will Joe's crimes finally catch up with him?

By Toni Stanger /

Lifetime’s YOU has been a buzzy hit ever since it dropped on Netflix last year. Based on the book by Caroline Kepnes, it tells the story of Joe Goldberg, a bookstore manager who sets out to date aspiring writer Guinevere Beck.

Advertisement

Throughout Season 1, Joe manipulates, stalks, and berates Beck. He invades her privacy, kills her friends for his own convenience and keeps other secrets from her. Whilst seemingly charming on the outside, Joe has got a very dark and twisted soul.

Beck eventually finds out what he’s capable of and she ends up trapped inside the book vault in the store’s basement. Let’s just say that things don’t end too well for her. Then, in the last scene of Season 1, we’re introduced to a character we presumed to be dead – Joe’s ex-girlfriend Candace.

YOU has been confirmed for a Season 2, which will be roughly based on Kepnes’ follow-up novel Hidden Bodies. Judging from the book and how Season 1 ended, here are some things we must see in Season 2.

Contains spoilers for YOU Season 1 and Hidden Bodies.

10. We Find Out What Happened Between Joe And Candace

At the end of Season 1, Joe’s ex-girlfriend Candace makes an appearance in his bookstore. This is a huge plot twist as we’re led to believe she’s dead in the series, and in the book she actually is dead (Joe drowned her).

Advertisement

In Season 2, we need to find out exactly what happened between her and Joe – including both past and present. We know that they broke up, but why did she leave the country and change her name? And why is she back?

In Hidden Bodies, it’s actually Amy who appears in his bookstore. Amy is his ex-girlfriend after Beck and it’s her who Joe follows to Los Angeles. He sets out to find and kill her after she cons him and breaks his heart.

It seems that TV Candace may be a combination of Book Candace and Book Amy, so it’s possible that TV Candace will also fall into some of Amy’s storylines.

9. Joe Will Let Candace Live

In Hidden Bodies, Joe goes to Los Angeles to track down and kill Amy for what she did to him. But he finds himself getting distracted by other things – such as his new love interest, who is aptly called Love – and takes a while to get to her.

Advertisement

When Joe finally does catch up with Amy, he decides to let her go. If Candace’s character will be combined with Amy’s character somehow, it’s possible that Joe could be following her to Los Angeles to kill her.

Regardless of what path the series chooses to follow, it would be great to see Joe let Candace live just like he did with Amy. We know that Joe and Candace have a lot of history and he has a soft spot for her. He wasn’t seeing hallucinations of her throughout Season 1 for nothing.

8. Joe Meets His Match With Love

Joe thinks he really understands women and that he’s such an incredibly ally, which gives his character a huge sense of entitlement. He also believes himself to be better than everyone as exhibited throughout Season 1 when he’s judging the New York lifestyle, along with Beck and all of her friends.

Advertisement

Joe was able to really manipulate and control Beck in Season 1 with his faux charming personality. But in Hidden Bodies, Joe meets his match with Love (The Haunting of Hill House's Victoria Pedretti). She’s an heiress to her parents’ grocery store fortune, making her feel confident and secure in herself, unlike Beck who was struggling.

Love also stands up for what she believes in. She’s headstrong and doesn’t back down when Joe bullies her. This proves as quite a challenge to Joe who is a control freak and plans his relationships out by controlling who he’s with.

It would be fantastic to watch the power dynamic shift sometimes, so it’s vital that Love remains a headstrong character. It’ll also be great to see someone on screen who isn’t as vapid as Beck’s character was. We need someone to challenge Joe.

7. Joe Confesses His Sins To Love

Beck rejected Joe when she found out about his true nature, which ultimately resulted in her death. In Joe’s eyes, she couldn’t love him for who he really was but he still helped her.

Advertisement

In Hidden Bodies, Love tells Joe that he’s too closed off and she can’t be with him unless he breaks down his barrier. So he tells her everything – he confesses the stalking and the murders and she accepts him and stays with him.

It would be fascinating to see someone on Joe’s side in Season 2, especially as he usually keeps everything to himself. But it also creates a lot of tension as the writers could do anything with it – she could betray him or eventually become scared. However, Love is strong woman and seems like she is confident he won’t hurt her.

6. Love Becomes Pregnant

Love becomes pregnant in Hidden Bodies and Joe is over the moon that he’ll be a father. This has to happen in Season 2 as it really raises the stakes. Can this murderer really be a father? Do we even want him to be?

Advertisement

If Joe does confess his sins to Love, it’s possible she could change her mind about Joe considering how this might affect their child’s upbringing. But she could also see it the other way – that he will do anything to protect them.

A pregnancy would mean that he really can’t mess up his relationship with Love and start over. It’d be too difficult.

5. Joe Tries To Kill Love’s Brother

Love has as twin brother called Forty (Heathers' James Scully). He has problems with drug and alcohol abuse and struggles with his sobriety as he goes through the 12-step programme. He relies heavily on his sister and is everything Joe hates about LA privilege.

Advertisement

In Hidden Bodies, Forty steals Joe’s screenplays without giving him credit for the writing which causes Joe to kill him – or so he thinks. Forty is actually rescued and when he returns home he pretends not to remember what happened to him.

Forty then blackmails Joe into writing more screenplays for him. Joe realises that he can’t actually kill Forty because it would emotionally destroy Love, so he plays along. However, Forty eventually gets killed anyway as he’s hit by a car.

This fixes Joe’s Forty problem and allows him to write for Hollywood. Whilst it’s a little far-fetched that the one person he wants dead but can’t kill actually dies, there's definitely going to be an entertaining dynamic between them.

Hopefully Season 2 will stick to this, but will fully explore Forty’s troubled character before his untimely death.

4. Ellie Is The New Paco

In the book, none of Joe’s neighbours actually existed which includes Paco, Claudia and Ron. At the end of the series, they were seen moving to LA for a fresh start after Joe killed Ron. It’s unclear whether they’ll return in Season 2, but it’s probably unlikely.

Advertisement

There is a new character called Ellie (Jane the Virgin's Jenna Ortega) who seems to be similar to Paco in the sense that she is “secretly living with minimal adult supervision or nurturing in his life.” When things get difficult, Ellie isn’t afraid to work cons on the adults around her, which includes Joe.

The cons should be interesting to watch unfold, because it’s hard to know how Joe will react. Will he get mad at her or will he relate to her being neglected and find a new opportunity to become a teacher?

Now that Paco has moved on, it would be great to see him form a relationship with Ellie. (It would help the pregnancy storyline if that goes forward too, as it would convince us that maybe he can be a dad).

In Hidden Bodies, Amy is a con-artist who tries to commit credit card fraud in Joe's store. It seems Ellie’s character could borrow these sort of tricks from Amy to form her character, which is sure to be fun to watch.

3. We Learn More About Joe’s Past

Love and Forty’s family have their own problems, meaning that Joe isn’t the only one with family issues. In Hidden Bodies, he finds acceptance amongst them and is referred to as the “professor” by her family as they note he’s very well-read and intelligent for a non-graduate.

Advertisement

Joe finds a sense of purpose in Los Angeles, which will be great to see, but we will also dive back into Joe’s own family life. Show producer Sera Gamble said: “Joe was already a teenager by the time he even met Mr. Mooney. There’s a lot more to explore about Joe from earlier in his life.”

It will be intriguing to watch these things unfold across Season 2. Learning about Joe’s childhood is something we need to see – although it does not justify his behaviour, it will be helpful to see what could have contributed to how he turned out.

2. Joe Is Haunted By Hidden Bodies

“The problem with hidden bodies is that they don’t always stay that way. They re-emerge, like dark thoughts, multiplying and threatening to destroy what Joe wants most: true love.” Taken from the blurb of Hidden Bodies, this definitely summaries the fun and tension we’ll facing in Season 2.

Advertisement

In Season 1, Joe kills many people: there’s Benji, Peach, Ron and more. In Season 2, he will be constantly worried that some things will come back to bite him. He is going to be very worried about the private investigator Peach’s family hired to look into her apparently suicide – especially as he left a jar of his pee at Peach’s house when he couldn’t reach a toilet.

Gamble said: “Dr. Nicky is in prison and he is adherently protesting his innocence.” It’s too soon to say whether John Stamos, who portrayed Dr. Nicky, will return for Season 2, but if he does this will be something else bugging Joe.

Having these worries heavily burden him throughout Season 2 should result in an intense watch. Will Joe be able to stay in control and keep his life from unravelling?

1. Joe Is Arrested

In Hidden Bodies, the police put everything together and tie Joe to the deaths of Peach and Beck. He’s arrested and it’s left unclear whether or not Joe will get away with it or go to prison, as they lack hard evidence. This means the book ends on a cliffhanger.

Advertisement

It would be highly entertaining and possibly rewarding to see Joe be arrested at the end of Season 2. It would raise the stakes massively, causing people to be anxious about his fate and further question whose side they are really on.

The PI hired by Peach’s family could bring her and Beck to justice and Dr. Nicky would be exonerated. Considering Joe’s crimes and the fact everything catches him up, Joe will definitely have to be caught.

Hopefully the series won’t end on a cliffhanger like the book unless they plan to continue the story into a third season. At this time, Kepnes’ book series only contains two novels so Joe’s fate is completely unknown.

Advertisement