10 AEW Wrestlers Who Are Almost Unrecognisable Since Debuting

Four years is forever in wrestling, especially for some of AEW's biggest stars...

By Michael Hamflett /

The quickest way to see how some of AEW's central characters look completely different from when they first started with the company is to fire up Fight Forever.

Advertisement

The game's an awful lot of fun, but is so rooted in the past that it's a wonder that an empty Daily's Place isn't the default location for your matches. Loading up the roster around its 2023 release to find some of 2021's best and brightest was an unfortunate byproduct of the many delays the game experienced, and does hamper the experience somewhat if the goal is to pick up and play a version of your favourite recent All Elite Wrestling feud.

It's a reality the wrestling and gaming industries have collided with for years, such is the speed of a product that airs new live content the bulk of 52 weeks a year. Change and evolution are crucial to longevity per Chris Jericho and others like him, but those that do just that make the passage of time all the more shocking.

Remember Le Champion? That was 50 years ago. Or that's what those memes would have you believe anyway. Time's arrow neither stands still nor reverses. It merely marches forward. Want proof?

10. Kris Statlander

For a performer that had fans pining for her return and unanimous support behind her being the one to dethrone former TBS Champion Jade Cargill, the awesome and affable Kris Statlander most definitely wasn't for everyone when AEW first launched.

Advertisement

Or, perhaps more reasonably, the alien Kris Statlander wasn't for everybody.

The gimmick was a difficult circle to square in a company that rewarded expression or at very least attempted to encourage it. A sporting framework underpinned by wins and losses wasn't going to be destroyed by one character believing herself to be from another planet, but the nature of her potential powers stood in the way of what the majority of AEW hardcores seemingly wanted. Her giving various friends and broadcasters the "Boop" was used as a stick to beat her with too.

It was only ever inoffensive at its absolute worst, but that was enough for the bad faith voices to get louder the more the gimmick didn't exactly take off. Two devastating injury breaks came with the hidden positive of having an organic opportunity to scale things back until she became a more convincing comeback story than she ever was extra-terrestrial being.

9. Max Caster

'Platinum' Max Caster landed in All Elite Wrestling looking like the man that would go on to win the hearts of the masses and Tag Team Champions, but but the shiny pink and silver aesthetic and a microphone in his hand was only ever half the story.

Advertisement

Pairing Caster with Anthony Bowens was a Tony Khan masterstroke made all the more awesome by the wrestlers themselves, but the former was always going to struggle beforehand after starting life alongside Luther and Serpentico.

Perhaps it was done to highlight exactly how odd it all looked, and the trio were marching to their doom against Luchasaurus, Jungle Boy and Marko Stunt on the June 11th 2020 edition of AEW Dark anyway. But nonetheless, alongside the perennial YouTube defeat artists, Caster couldn't have felt more like a cartoonish caricature with a gimmick rather than a pro wrestler that just happened to a music-adjacent character trait.

Typically, one can sell t-shirts and the other sells tickets. The Acclaimed mastered both.

8. Jamie Hayter

Jamie Hayter's All Elite Wrestling career remains one of the stranger ones in the organisation's relatively brief history.

Advertisement

Working as an incredibly engaging but wacky heel back on some of the earliest AEW telecasts, Hayter probably would have thrived immediately had the division been able to claim a little more television time on Wednesdays. But it didn't and she didn't, and the pandemic put her on the other side of the world from the place she was looking to make her name.

When she did come back nearly two full years later, it was on the side of a former foe who'd since made the switch. Britt Baker was now a heel and Hayter was the heater, but a connection with the crowd and her charisma resulted in the pair of them turning face together. As an ostensible heel, Hayter became Women's Champion before 'D.M.D' got the belt back, and a 2023 return from injury - whenever it arrives - will be one of the most anticipated ones in the entire company.

7. Big Bill

When MJF introduced William Morrissey to AEW audiences in 2022, he did so having teased an opponent for former bodyguard Wardlow that was bigger, stronger and taller than 'The War Dog', and added that "you can't teach that" in order to effectively give the game away.

Advertisement

An Impact Wrestling standout walking through the company's forbidden door relationship with the group, Morrissey looked familiar with his jeans-and-jacked aesthetic, but couldn't be further away from the place he occupies today as wrestling's real charismatic enigma.

Big Bill is banter reborn, and stood at seven foot tall and ready to boot your head clean off. Arm aloft and simply loving being him - and why wouldn't you? - he'll sometimes enjoy a lollipop ahead of the action or from the apron, and he's clearly having the time of his life as an unserious *sskicker.

Anything but bland (or somebody unable to work through predictable chants about his most famous former gimmick), Big Bill's a keeper in a way W./William Morrissey never stood the chance of becoming.

6. Julia Hart

Julia Hart took a "Boop" and a beating from Kris Statlander in her AEW debut on Dark in May 2021, but as a babyface playing a literal cheerleader for the Varsity Blondes, her lot in life was always likely to be limited to smiling and dancing as the team took losses.

Advertisement

For such fully-drawn personas, that's often how gimmicks such as these go, but her change came thanks to an interaction between the team and the House Of Black. After being misted by Malakai Black she spent months in an eye patch, and while the incubation period for the turn was far too long to remain believable, her eventual linking up with the trio was a major turning point in her career.

Naturally, the aesthetics needed a huge shift too - out went the bright colours, cheerleader outfits and academia attires. Instead (and to this day), it's all black and with a typically fetching hat to boot.

5. QT Marshall

QT Marshall as the Rhodes Family's nepo-puppy seems like a fever dream rather than an 'American Nightmare' when watched back through 2023 eyes, but perhaps that's because QTV's alienated so many fans in such a short space of time that anything would scan as better by comparison.

Advertisement

Marshall had charm, fantastic babyface fire and the innate ability to make himself seem less talented than he actually was in order to shock audiences when he pulled off something cool. But it was also known exactly what role he had behind the scenes in the company, and in an industry where doors are so often opened because of who you know rather than what, the in-ring didn't really matter.

The wrestler/producer was a 'Natural Nightmares' wannabe alongside Dustin Rhodes with heart-eyes for Allie before she embraced being The Bunny forever, before becoming a bargain bin Tony Soprano as the leader of a breakout heel version of the Nightmare Family of trainees that went nowhere and finally settling into the antagonistic leader of the QTV gang.

Ironically, he looks the most television-ready and comfortable he ever has, but the gimmick - specifically the damage its done to the aura of Hobbs - has felt wasteful of the organisation's time and resources.

4. Daniel Garcia

Daniel Garcia is a pro wrestling fan, and if it wasn't immediately clear when he walked purposefully to the ring with the burgundy trunks of Bryan Danielson and the purpose of Katsuyori Shibata, it was the second he locked up.

Advertisement

A slight-but-rapid fire grappler, Garcia and partner Kevin Blackwood were comfortably outmatched by The Butcher & The Blade on the 15th September 2020 edition of Dark, and just about everything beyond Garcia's core values have changed since.

Not that he'd want you to know that, of course.

The pro wrestling genius still lingers below the surface whenever Garcia makes his entrance in 2023, but as a member of the Jericho Appreciation Society he continues to dance in his leather trousers thanks to a stubborn and misplaced belief in Chris Jericho's teachings about how to make it. The JAS leader donated to a gofundme set up for Garcia and others following a car crash in 2019, he couldn't possibly no longer have Garcia's best interests at heart, could he?

3. Athena

Much like a couple of notable others on this list that have experienced a substantial creative upgrade after a shaky start, it was Ember Moon that debuted in AEW when Athena landed in the organisation at Double Or Nothing 2022.

Advertisement

That's not to say the former NXT Women's Champion didn't have a fantastic run at one time (and, as was the case too many times over the years, was before her career was under the stewardship of Vince McMahon), but the babyface Moon gimmick had run its course before she'd even departed the company. Beyond the surprise of her signing, there wasn't much fresh about a character that had criminally been allowed to go stale for years up to that point.

Athena - the Ring Of Honor Women's Champion and the performer that embraced an awesome heel turn in late 2022 - walks, talks and wrestles like an entirely different person. Full of sardonic hatred for her opponents rather than reverence, it's as if she's beating the tar out of the industry that nearly derailed her peak years rather than the poor challengers being lined up to eat a loss.

2. Nick Comoroto

Nick Comoroto was wild enough to volunteer himself for losses against Darby Allin, Will Hobbs and Team Taz in 2020 before losing via referee's decision to Jon Moxley in January 2021.

Advertisement

As far as Dark/Dynamite jobber lore, that wasn't bad, and felt like yet another fairly elegant long-term story from a company that had excelled at them for much of their first two years. Unfortunately, the size, stature, quasi-straitjacket entrance attire and fantastic hair didn't propel him beyond looking at the lights in the empty arena era, so he tweaked his aesthetic to try and mesh with the mafia-adjacent aspect of his new relationship with QT Marshall.

After a brief run as a funny hat-wearing heavy of Marshall's dodgy Tony Soprano bit, Comoroto has embraced his inner clown, trimmed the wild and bushy beard (though looks the type to grow the whole thing back with little more than a sneeze) and sucks on lollipops between being asked to go by 'Nicky Boy' in his new home Ring Of Honor.

It's not quite as terrifying-looking, but his work on the show thus far suggests it's best to not judge this book by the new cover.

1. CM Punk

What a difference two years make.

Advertisement

CM Punk doesn't just look different because he does exactly that by choice to differentiate between periods of his career. This isn't a hair or a beard thing, as effective as he's been juggling each style to suit the climate his character is about to inhabit.

On any given Collision in 2023, the former AEW Champion's eyes tell a different story to the one that giddily walked down the ramp on the second-ever episode of Rampage in 2021. With a range of emotions coursing through him as he announced his return to the industry in a literal and figurative sense, Punk was as earnest and sincere in front of a pro wrestling camera as he'd been since openly weeping his way out of Ring Of Honor in 2005. If he didn't feel at home before the broadcast kicked off, he'd made the promotion his personal playground by the time it'd ended.

In the shadow of Brawl Out and the absence that followed, Punk's temperament is (wonderfully) just ever-so-slightly...off. It's all to inform an impending heel turn that'll play more with those most devoted to his rivals within The Elite, but it has to be this way. Happy-to-be-there Punk isn't right for the role, and nobody should want it any other way.

Advertisement