10 Baffling WWE Creative Ideas Fans Still Can't Work Out

What were the writing team smoking to come up with this stuff?

By Jamie Kennedy /

Those involved in WWE (and pro wrestling in general) often point to the fact that the industry doesn't take holidays as an example of just how brutal the business of wrestling is. Wearing it like some badge of honour, those within the grappling game remark that there is no off-season, and thus wrestling is tougher than any other form of entertainment. In many ways, that's true, but it's not only on the people actually performing that the lack of a break starts to take a toll. WWE's writing staff are required to come up with fresh ideas constantly, and make sure they're consistently up to scratch with what the audience would want to see - such pressure can't make working for creative the most enjoyable job at times. Sure, writers are doing something they often love, but that constant stress must be tiring. Perhaps it's only natural then that these people, who have to juggle lives outside of wrestling with the countless hours of writing, will pen angles which - being candid - flat out suck. This list aims to look at 10 different times when wrestling fans were left scratching their heads, unable to grasp exactly what the creative team were trying to achieve.

10. Suicidal Tendencies

http://www.dailymotion.com/video/x6jsi8_road-warrior-hawk-falls-off-the-tit_sport Traditionally known as The Roadwarriors, Hawk and Animal were rebranded as The Legion Of Doom upon their arrival in WWE in the early-90's. One of the most physically-impressive tag-teams ever to grace the ring, LOD had a killer look, and whilst they weren't exactly technical marvels, they didn't have to be. Power moves and aura were what made The Roadwarriors so great, and they truly deserve their legendary status. Sadly, a lot of fans remember a darker time for the duo. Towards the end of their run with WWE, Hawk and Animal were placed in a storyline which didn't really do a lot for them, and it's hard to see what the objective was with this angle. Playing up Hawk's real-life drug and alcohol problems, the company went one step too far in the eyes of many, looking to book the man's suicide live on Raw. By this point, Darren Drozdov, known as Puke, had entered the picture, and the insinuation was that he pushed Hawk from the top of the titantron, apparently killing him, all because he wanted to take his place in LOD. Obviously, this was truly ludicrous, and fans were left feeling a bit confused and deflated by the whole ordeal.

9. "WCW" Invasion

Buying out his main competition in 2001, Vince McMahon's purchase of WCW was a shocking moment in the history of pro wrestling, and WWE have never again been pushed quite as far by any wrestling company as they were by the Atlanta-based promotion. In buying out his main rival, McMahon promised to keep the WCW name afloat, and there were serious talks about relaunching the company separately from WWE. By having two successful promotions running in tandem, Vince theorised that he'd have twice the money, and better yet, he could manipulate storylines for one or two big 'Us vs. Them' Pay-Per-Views each year, which were sure to be box office hits. Of course, things didn't turn out that way, as McMahon neglected to buy out the contracts of a lot of top WCW stars, leaving him with only a few headline names. To remedy this, the likes of Steve Austin, Stephanie and Shane McMahon, and even Kurt Angle were placed on the WCW side, leading to a big "WCW" vs. WWF showdown at the Survivor Series 2001. Fans weren't fooled, as this apparent invasion came down to The Rock vs. Steve Austin, who had both been top WWE stars throughout the Monday Night Wars.

8. The Coronation Of A Crappy King

Classic King Of The Ring moments include Bret Hart overcoming the odds, defeating the dangerous Bam Bam Bigelow in 1993, and Steve Austin's infamous promo which led to the birth of 'Austin 3:16' in 1996, one of the most well-remembered catchphrases in wrestling history. The King Of The Ring show is largely much-missed, but try telling that to fans who paid money to see the 1995 version of the event. Desperately thin on the ground for main event level talent, the creative braintrust decided that the 'King' moniker could make anybody a star, and thrust Mabel, who had previously been a comedy tag wrestler, into the spotlight. Fans were upset enough that genuine top names such as Shawn Michaels and The Undertaker were eliminated from the brackets in the early rounds, but enough was enough by the time Mabel won the entire tournament, going on to face WWF Champion Diesel at Summerslam just months later. This was a case of the writing staff being short on ideas, and terribly misreading what their audience wanted to see.

7. WWE (Don't) Want Ryder

Speaking of which, Zack Ryder's plight has been well documented. There was a time when WWE arenas were booming with chants of, "We want Ryder", as fans screamed at the top of their voices to let top brass know they had faith in the Long Island native. Unfortunately for the audience, WWE themselves did not, and didn't see Zack as a top star. Yes, WWE played along for a little while, acknowledging Ryder's YouTube show, and even making him United States Champion on PPV, but his time in the sun went sour fairly quickly. Throughout his push, it was clear that WWE didn't really want to put Ryder in the position he was in, and would rather have had others take his place. This was evidenced by the fact that the company couldn't wait to pull him out of the limelight, after they'd made the guy look like a total dork, in an awkward love storyline with Eve Torres. Quite why WWE felt the need to wield this proverbial sword of power over their own fanbase is pretty confusing. After all, surely it'd be better to give the paying customer what they want?

6. Reigns Gets An Attitude Adjustment

Remember when Roman Reigns was being cheered like crazy, as fans couldn't wait to see him win the 2014 Royal Rumble match? Fast forward only one year, and those same crowds of people were tripping over one another to show their collective displeasure at the same guy being shoved down their throats. Many have pointed to the idea that Reigns has been given too much too quickly, but the fact is that he's been around the WWE main roster for a few years now, and has shown glimpses of having potential to be a top star. Unfortunately, instead of rolling with what fans like about the guy, his genuine ass-kicker look, big power moves and natural likeability, the writing staff seem desperate to turn him into John Cena-lite. Shockingly, this isn't working, and the hammy promos Reigns is being handed - along with his unconvincing delivery - isn't doing it for anybody. Fans are confused, and have already started to turn on someone WWE hope can lead them into the future. If the worm turns completely, there may be no going back. Roman Reigns should not be like John Cena, and vice versa.

5. It's The Gobbledy Gooker!

To younger fans, the thought that WWE once partly-promoted one Survivor Series event around what was inside a giant egg should make those same youngsters delighted that things are the way they are nowadays. People can look back with misty-eyed nostalgia all they want, and there's a lot of great moments to recall, but The Gobbledy Gooker is not one of those. Credit to Hector Guerrero for going along with this one, he was likely just happy to have a gig for the biggest company in the land, but he should be thankful for that big dumb headpiece hiding his face, otherwise this is one booking he may never have been able to live down!Fans were disappointed when a guy dressed as a giant bird came awkwardly ambling out of the egg, but what were folks expecting? It was an egg! Even so, this is an auspicious moment in WWE history, and the kind of thing fans should avoid showing non-fans who wonder why they like wrestling so much.

4. Fans Wish Raw GM Had Stayed Anonymous

During the Summer months of 2010, right through the Winter and into 2011, the Anonymous Raw General Manager character was treated like a focal point on WWE television. Not an episode of Monday Night Raw would go by without Michael Cole saying to fans, "Can I have your attention, please?", before reading out the mantra from this unidentified authority figure. Suddenly, the angle was dropped in the Summer of 2011, with next to no explanation as to why. Fans had been expecting something major as pay-off - after all, a year is a pretty long time in modern wrestling, so it seemed only natural that WWE would use the story to debut some new wrestler they had high hopes for, or kick start a hot feud which could make some money.Instead, the nameless GM schtick was wheeled out randomly in July, 2012, and it was revealed that none other than Hornswoggle was the man behind the curious emails which had previously been flooding the promotion's flagship show. Needless to say, this was a terrible end to things, and people reacted accordingly, with extreme apathy. The angle has since been re-aired, making another appearance in November, 2014.

3. Wrestling For Custody

Any match pitting Rey Mysterio against Eddie Guerrero should be remembered with a smile, because both performers were incredible when working against one another. The styles of both men meshed so well, and the action flowed smoothly - to tell the truth, you could have put Mysterio vs. Guerrero on every show of the year, and they'd still be rocking the house by December 31. Tragically, WWE felt the need to jazz up a feud between the men in 2005. Looking to book a big Ladder Match between the pair at Summerslam, the writing staff needed something to literally hang in the balance, given that neither men held a title belt at the time. Enter Mysterio's son, Dominic.During a heel promo, Eddie dropped the bombshell that he was actually Dominic's real father, and wanted custody of his son. Therefore, in typical wrestling fashion, the custody of a child was hung above a wrestling ring, right in front of 20,000 people. It wasn't exactly necessary, and the entire story made fans pretty uncomfortable.

2. McMahon The Younger

One of the biggest on-screen associations any wrestler could have would be with Vince McMahon. Fans take most things seriously which the WWE owner is involved in, so it's only natural that they'd then view a performer as important if they were linked with him. In 2007, an angle started up which revolved around the idea that someone on the roster was McMahon's son, a bastard love child born out of an extra-marital affair. Immediately, fans were interested, and it was generally accepted that it'd be Mr. Kennedy, who would then get a main event push to go along with his new family ties. That is rumoured to have been the original plan, until Kennedy got himself suspended for repeat violations of WWE's Wellness Policy. The story had to be changed somewhat, but surely the writing staff could have come up with something better than Hornswoggle, who was later installed as McMahon's son.Worse yet, just a few months later the whole thing was revealed to be a ruse, and Hornswoggle was actually Finlay's son. Huh? As far as a Plan B goes, that's a pretty rotten one.

1. Love Me Even In Death

Where does any wrestling fan start when analysing the tale of Katie Vick, Triple H and Kane? Definitely one of the most tasteless, insulting and asinine storylines in WWE history, the company really topped themselves with this saga. Even though fans had been led to believe for years that Kane had been burned in a fire set by The Undertaker, it turns out he had a life before being introduced by Paul Bearer to destroy his storyline brother. Let's see, this angle included the following; ignorance of history (how many times has WWE changed Kane and The Undertaker's respective pasts to suit the present?), drink driving and subsequent fatal car crash, necrophilia, accusations of psychosis and simulated sex with a mannequin, in a funeral home no less. Was there anything else the creative team felt necessary to bring to the party? Perhaps there isn't quite enough going on there. In all seriousness, this story did nothing for anyone involved, and had WWE under the microscope from several groups, who quite rightly wondered what the hell this wrestling promotion were gaining from booking one of their top names to sexually assault a dummy on live TV. What other storylines left you scratching your head? Do you remember any of the ones on this list? Let us know down in the comments section below!