10 Best Wrestling PPVs Of 2019
The Grandaddies of them All.
2019 maintained the incredible form of this wondrous generation of pro wrestling talent.
To illustrate just how good we have it, All Elite Wrestling created the mildest strain of anxiety, post-Double Or Nothing and ahead of the TNT debut, by having the temerity to produce two merely very good shows. Fyter Fest was overwhelmed by the controversy of its drastically misjudged, comedy-heavy pre-show, and the worked-but-botched chair shot Shawn Spears levelled at Cody. But the in-ring action was largely eclectic, excellent and forward-thinking: AEW got Darby Allin over and built Riho's emotional connection with the crowd in Daytona Beach. The exhilarating six-man semi-main was played down by many because it was familiar.
Fyter Fest was AEW's second show.
Their third, Fight For The Fallen, was also well above average, if over-long and counter-productive. Kenny Omega and CIMA used move-spam as both crowd-popping content and advanced storytelling, in that the latter's meteora undid him. The Brotherhood Vs. The Young Bucks, excessive but not ineffective as a winding story match, suffered through an exhausted, overheated crowd.
Wrestling is so good, now, that good has somehow become disappointing...
10. WWE Money In The Bank
WWE's pay-per-view record in 2019 was very mixed, and much of that mixing happened over the course of a single show...on most if not all shows.
Being a WWE pay-per-view, Money In The Bank wasn't perfect, but it was as close as WWE managed all year. The titular Women's match was a tight, engrossing affair in which Ember Moon starred and Bayley emerged triumphant. Triumphant is the word; over the course of an inspired show-long storyline, WWE booked an effective babyface, and what's more, that babyface was Bayley.
The men's match was a strong contender for the upper echelon of the wider, MITB canon: all seven men damn near ended their careers in a brutal, dramatic spectacle designed as such for storytelling purposes: their toil contrasted grimly with Brock Lesnar's scavenging, for a little bit of the "F*ck off" heat. Pointless, but brilliantly so.
AJ Styles and Seth Rollins reversed their respective perceptions, as fading talents and babyface busts, by constructing a real banger pitched wonderfully between dream match and unvarnished fight. The Stomp-to-Styles Clash reversal here was as inspired as it was physically impossible - a low-key contender for spot of the year. And, to highlight just how great he is, Kevin Owens gave Kofi Kingston his best WWE Championship defence.
Elsewhere, the springtime chaos was, at least, perversely entertaining. Shane McMahon won a match via sweating, which, in fairness, was as in-character as Kazuchika Okada winning via Rainmaker.
9. NXT TakeOver: XXV
Considered one of the lesser TakeOver events, since the brand reached the heights of fawning critical acclaim, that this was still so good is testament to the formula Triple H has built: at two hours and 38 minutes, the show was an incredibly easy watch, and a largely incredible exhibition of modern pro wrestling.
Matt Riddle Vs. Roderick Strong was a unifying force of a pro wrestling match. Surely, nobody could have disliked it, but that's not to say it was broad, or safe: this wince-inducing sprint was a propulsive, relentless quest for legitimacy. The Fatal 4-Way Ladder match made expert, enterprising use of the bland and the untested by constructing a story of the Street Profits' spirit to overcome the chicanery of the Forgotten Sons, all of which was underpinned by a bravura, committed performance on the part of Kyle O'Reilly.
Tyler Breeze's experiment as a Serious Wrestler didn't land, but Shayna Baszler Vs. Io Shirai sure as sh*t did. This was a tremendous performance on Baszler's part; she strategised around Shirai's risk-based offence to craft an immersive, believable story that furthered her aura as a killer.
Johnny Gargano Vs. Adam Cole II wasn't as transformative as the original, but it was still an incredible back-and-forth mirror match that used themes of familiarity and exhaustion to put it over, to the highest level, as a dramatic war between two super athletes determined to out-last the other.
8. NJPW Best Of The Super Juniors Final
On how many shows are you granted the privilege of watching a wrestler announce himself as the best in the world?
Another question: how difficult is it to become the best in the world, in 2019, a year in which the talent on the global stage is of such an awesome standard?
At the Best of the Super Juniors final, Will Ospreay announced himself as the best wrestler in the world throughout 33 minutes and 36 seconds of unreal drama. Ospreay was phenomenal here, fighting the strength of his colossus opponent with pure fire, evading every propulsive onslaught with jaw-dropping agility, in one of the greatest matches of all time. Benefitting from Shingo Takagi's monster push, NJPW engineered a giant-killing atmosphere for the ages, and Ospreay levelled up to the occasion with a performance as hermetic as it was heroic.
As a one-match show, the BOSJ final was an honourable mention. That's how good the match was.
But as one dragon was slain, another monster rose in his wake: Jon Moxley, who pulverised Juice Robinson in an ultra-violent spectacle. The BOSJ final was a wonderful illustration of Gedo's unparalleled ability to book successively, but there, as ever, endured Hiroshi Tanahashi, the one constant. His desperate double-leg dragon screw counter to Jay White brought a sense of pathos to a show built on violence and technique.
A superb presentation of a spectacular roster in perfect balance, the BOSJ final was, somehow, yet another New Beginning for an endlessly brilliant promotion.
7. AEW All Out
Something like Joey Janela retrieving a tennis racquet from under the ring - and bantering it off as an in-joke - has simply never happened on a big-time North American wrestling pay-per-view.
That's what endears fans to AEW. It's a promotion of expression. Who cares if only a set number of fans were ever going to understand the reference? Niche is so much more interesting than the broad, if done well, and the demented Cracker Barrel Clash was done very well. It was a phenomenally entertaining horror comedy.
The opener also intersected the fun and the dramatic: Jungle Boy's ace babyface work created a grand platform for the blitzkrieg pop hot tag of Luchasaurus. Kenny Omega Vs. PAC saw the Cleaner enter a superb, restrained performance designed to put over the BASTARD's top-level heel character by de-emphasising his cloudburst offence and struggling through a physical beating. The low points of the show were in fact good - the blow-away in-ring standard comes with it a warped perception - but the final three matches were all very good, at a minimum, and were all different.
Cody Vs. Shawn Spears was over-booked, but it over-delivered as an old-school spectacle; Escalera de la Muerte was as astonishingly violent, creative and rich ladder war; Chris Jericho Vs. Hangman Page, a physical banger that told a neat story of experience as a weapon, was one hot crowd away from being a classic.
6. NXT TakeOver: Phoenix
Another typically excellent TakeOver offering, Phoenix benefitted from a more diverse complexion than the typical TakeOver offering.
Tommaso Ciampa and Aleister Black's main event didn't feel much like a TakeOver headliner, but was superb in its own right; Black's limb selling was masterful, and Ciampa tore it apart with the precision and graduating drama of an IWGP Heavyweight titan. More of a fight than a melodramatic spectacle, it isn't talked about enough as a classic NXT Championship match.
Ricochet and Johnny Gargano wrestled something more on-brand on the undercard: an electric, content-stuffed back-and-forth banger underpinned by a great tweener performance on the part of the latter. The action was jaw-dropping at points here - a thrilling exhibition of that accelerated melodrama in-house style.
In another, welcome departure from the TakeOver formula, of clinically assured excellence, Bianca Belair failed in her pursuit of Shayna Baszler's Women's Championship. Her slightly unpolished performance got over because it felt like she was fighting with her heart on her sleeve. Matt Riddle and Kassius Ohno maintained the show's theme by assembling a proper lip-purser of a scrap, and the opening tag match, between the War Raiders and the Undisputed ERA, was perfectly-judged in both length and dynamic.
5. AEW Full Gear
Tarnished very slightly by a production hiccup - the noise of the Baltimore crowd was inferred more than it was heard - Full Gear was nonetheless a very strong and very memorable effort.
The Young Bucks put over Proud-N-Powerful in a return to 2018 NJPW storytelling long-form. Nick Jackson's selling here was of the elite level, and the match itself smashed the remit: Santana and Ortiz emerged from it as major players. Hangman Page and PAC perhaps wasn't the wisest choice to follow - it also went 20 minutes - but everything else about the match was deeply intelligent. A gripping, physical, totally believable sequel, it rewarded those who paid attention to the original, particularly in the superbly-constructed finishing sequence.
SCU Vs. Private Party Vs. Lucha Bros. was exhilarating if uneven. Joey Janela Vs. Shawn Spears was almost its exact opposite - solid and well-worked, if not too exciting - but the card recovered with Riho's successful defence of the Women's Championship. Sakura's rag doll bullying and that lightning-quick finishing sequence made for a perfect blend of emotive drama.
Cody Vs. Chris Jericho was the perfect Cody Vs. Chris Jericho match: a slow-burning, understated big-time babyface versus heel masterclass, the likes of which were thought lost to time, but was made timeless here.
Jon Moxley and Kenny Omega disturbed, thrilled, and gripped even those who loathed it by executing an unforgettable festival of scarcely-believable ultra-violence.
4. NJPW G1 Climax Day 3
Virtually every day of the 2019 G1 Climax - wrestling's greatest ever tournament, until the next G1 Climax - yielded awesome, over, next-level pro wrestling action with the most important of stakes and the most motivated of elite-class performers.
Consider this a pick 'em of sorts.
Every New Japan fan will likely hold a different night closer to their hearts. Other nights featured subjectively and objectively better matches, but Day 3 intersected all that was great about the best time of the year to be a wrestling fan.
Will Ospreay and SANADA was just a ridiculously precise display of athletic oneupmanship, of the sort that informs so much wrestling storytelling nowadays that that the extraordinary can veer, somehow, into the ordinary. This was different. This was too impressive. Kazuchika Okada and Zack Sabre, Jr. wrestled the sort of match even Okada's few detractors could not deny: it was as tight at, 12:05, as it was expertly worked. In a year in which his excellence also felt familiar, at times, this was Okada in fat-free undisputed Best In The World form. Kota Ibushi took that as a challenge and surpassed him by weaving the shoot ankle injury he had no physical right working through into a gripping masterpiece of babyface sympathy opposite EVIL.
KENTA Vs. Hiroshi Tanahashi stood in awesome contrast to the rest of the show: a towering d*ckhead performance on KENTA's part, when Tanahashi clutched his leg to block the PK, it got the blood pumping for the most unadulterated wrestling thrill of get-f*cked babyface vengeance.
3. NJPW Wrestle Kingdom 13
NJPW almost secured the top spot just four days into the year, such is the annual, guaranteed awesomeness of Wrestle Kingdom.
NJPW almost secured Match of the Year honours with Kenny Omega and Hiroshi Tanahashi's epic, philosophical war. This was a genius match of unreal depth and drama fought between two masters. A fusion and clash of two divergent styles - timeless psychology, perfected versus pulsating new school danger, perfected - this masterpiece was the best possible Omega Vs. Tanahashi match, and the think of the expectation that covers.
Jay White defeated Kazuchika Okada in an excellent, audacious deviation from the usual Okada epic; this urgent, counter-driven match set White on course for legitimacy. Chris Jericho Vs. Tetsuya Naito saw the former put on one of the very best matches of a legendary career. He looked like a killer, putting Naito through such agony in an expertly-paced, white-hot brawl, and Naito was the perfect foil. The one match that could be considered a disappointment - KUSHIDA and Taiji Ishimori's slightly too-slow sprint - was still very good.
In addition to a blast of electric multi-man offerings, Zack Sabre, Jr. and Tomohiro Ishii delivered on the colossal expectation of the elusive Stone Pitbull Wrestle Kingdom feature bout with a super battle of technique versus resilience. The opener, moreover, between Will Ospreay and Kota Ibushi, was as unhinged, but far more intelligent than expected.
A sell-out crowd, big-time production, sublime, restrained pacing: Wrestle Kingdom 13 was near-perfect.
2. AEW Double Or Nothing
AEW Double Or Nothing was a great show, and it was a special show. The upstart company delivered an all-timer at the very first attempt - a record, surely - and in doing so, created so much promise about the future of mainstream pro wrestling in North America. That promise was delivered upon across four hours of eclectic, expressive and emotional action.
The opener, pitting SCU against CIMA, T-Hawk and El Lindaman, previewed the company's exhilarating in-house style and introduced a new audience to the welcoming charisma of its veteran three-man unit. The women's matches ranged in quality from good to excellent; the joshi six-woman in particular was a thrilling, charming bruiser the likes of which U.S. wrestling barely promotes. The undercard of AEW's prospective doubles division announced itself via the Best Friends Vs. Hybrid 2 in a quietly inspired attraction: even the filler seemed unmissable.
Cody Vs. Dustin Rhodes was profound in its emotion and euphoric in its ability to rebuild ground thought forever broken. This unbearable, blood-soaked storytelling masterclass - an unforgettable epic of atonement, in so many senses of the word - evoked actual tears in the MGM Grand.
The Young Bucks used ring rust as a storytelling mechanism, ingeniously, in an advanced story match that doubled as an exhilarating feat of spellbinding athleticism, while Kenny Omega and Chris Jericho straight f*cked one another up in an understated, physical main event war.
A celebration of and introduction to a new, necessary product, Double Or Nothing wasn't just special: it was vital.
1. NXT TakeOver: New York
The WhatCulture list editor doesn't allow for amendments to numbering, so please be advised that this wasn't the second-best show of the year. It was the joint-best - the 1 or the A to AEW's Double Or Nothing.
One of the greatest nights in the history of professional wrestling, NXT TakeOver: New York was the greatest ever illustration of the black-and-gold brand's power: perceived by some as a soulless big-budget PWG reboot, this scintillating, all-killer show was loaded with emotion. Ricochet and Aleister Black stood on the verge of tears following defeat in the opener. This was their send-off, and clearly, they didn't want to go anywhere.
And why would they?
Their blistering match with the War Raiders made perfect use of their characters to inform the next chapter of NXT's tag division, though Vince McMahon turned that page much too quickly. When the colossal Rowe and Hanson somehow levelled up to the risk, pace and athleticism of their maverick opponents, this awesome burst of sequencing doubled as bravura storytelling.
Matt Riddle and the Velveteen Dream confidently obliterated any murmurings of a styles clash by crafting an exquisite tale of legitimacy versus audacity settled by Riddle's copycat over-confidence. Pete Dunne and WALTER constructed a gripping, detailed slow-burner that paid itself off with an explosion of congruous, jaw-dropping big spots that put over the epic nature of Dunne's UK Championship reign. The Women's four-way was very good and well-judged, at 15 sprinting minutes, and in the main, Adam Cole and Johnny Gargano delivered an all-timer.
So dramatic, well-worked and emotional that it transformed an entire crowd, this was Bret Hart Vs. Steve Austin for the modern era.