10 Best WWE Pay-Per-Views Of The Decade

The WWE Network might have killed pay-per-view, but quality came back to life in the 2010s...

By Michael Hamflett /

WWE

A common way to assess exactly how the WWE landscape changes over time is to look at gaps of around ten years for the befores and afters. On the precipice of 2020, it's easy to assume that little has changed since the not-so-halcyon days of 2010.

Advertisement

It's the year The Nexus collapsed under the weight of WWE's booking and their faith in John Cena. It's the year CM Punk ended as a commentator before transforming the next one with a series of remarkable curtain-pulling promos. It's the year that two of the prior decade's dependable stars headlined WrestleMania only so one could depart never to really be replaced.

It...doesn't otherwise feel like ten years ago.

Whilst much has stayed achingly familiar, the monolithic and minted organisation have mastered the "solid, if unspectacular" pay-per-view format. There's only been one genuine duffer of note in 2019, and that was mostly down to one of the worst finishes in company history. They've reset their standards, but exactly how many could be considered "best"?

Well, one, as it turns out. But that's why the entire decade has been mined for this list instead...

10. WrestleMania 31

A thoroughly enjoyable WrestleMania despite the foreshadowing of the extended run-time, the 'Show Of Shows' Bay Area setting shone a bright light on the audience and roster alike. The daytime scene wasn't ideal for The Undertaker's senseless squash of Bray Wyatt, but then, the meeting between 'The Deadman' and 'The Eater Of Worlds' wasn't ideal for the card itself.

Advertisement

Away from that, Seth Rollins gave Randy Orton his best WrestleMania singles match in forever before returning at the end of the show to become the first Money In The Bank winner to cash in on 'The Grandest Stage'. His intrusion was a sublime solution to the super-heated Roman Reigns/Brock Lesnar main event.

Speculation had previously ran rampant that Lesnar's UFC return was imminent, but a deal-sealing WWE contract signing earlier in the week added substantially more intrigue to the bloodletting of 'The Big Dog' sure to satiate his increasing number of dissenters. Manhandling Reigns as few others had, Lesnar had punched himself out by the time 'The Architect' arrived to build his part in a hastily-rearranged triple threat main event.

Sowing the seed for one of the greatest rookie years ever, Ronda Rousey shooed off Stephanie McMahon and Triple H alongside The Rock in a retrospective WrestleMania Moment™. Then undefeated and a white hot mainstream star, Ronda's placement in a WWE ring was a genuine coup for the group, much like Sting's maiden McMahon voyage on the undercard.

9. Royal Rumble 2017

A tactical masterclass from WWE in removing the hex on their annual 30-man war, Roman Reigns' surprising appearance as the final entrant in 2017's topliner infuriated the mammoth San Antonio crowd enough that Randy Orton didn't have to celebrate his second Royal Rumble victory to the vuvuzela hum of irritated indifference.

Advertisement

The contest was loaded with distraction pieces; 'The Big Dog' took over The Undertaker's yard, Bill Goldberg again made Brock Lesnar look foolish having already squashed him like a bug two months earlier, and Braun Strowman, Baron Corbin, Dean Ambrose and Rusev all benefited from extended stints in the clash.

Despite this, the show was ultimately stolen by AJ Styles and John Cena. Their absorbing New Japan-style effort drew on all of Cena's cribbing of the genre whilst harnessing Styles' awe-inspiring skill.

Elsewhere, three of the four title matches on the undercard delivered, too. Charlotte's defence of the Raw Women's Championship against Bayley was enjoyably logical as a first chapter, Kevin Owens' cheap win over Roman Reigns was the best defence of his joke-heavy Universal Title tenure, whilst Neville's capture of the Cruiserweight Title set the tone for months of quality defences from the 'King' of the division.

8. WrestleMania 35

Actual wrestling history trumps typical WWE bullsh*t, and the gravitas of two magnificently booked moments carried an uneven card to such a degree it became the very best of the supersized WrestleMania era.

Advertisement

Moving from the margins to the main event, the Women's Championship Winner Take All clash between Ronda Rousey, Charlotte Flair and Becky Lynch fell a touch short on quality but brought bags of catharsis in crowning 'The Man'. Her SummerSlam-to-WrestleMania stint was the stuff of dreams for a performer, if not whatever endgame the writing team had in mind.

The parallels were evident in Kofi Kingston's unexpected march to the 'Show Of Shows', having forced his way into the headliner with stirring displays as Ali's replacement earlier that year. A gauntlet match/Elimination Chamber run earmarked him as the natural challenger for The New Daniel Bryan, and he made on good on his word with a fantastic tear-soaked victory.

There was a lot to like elsewhere too - Seth Rollins conquered Brock Lesnar (the first time) in uniquely emphatic fashion, Shane McMahon and The Miz delivered a fun brawl, a big bump and meme of the evening, whilst Roman Reigns low-level return against Drew McIntyre ensured that the disdain the audience once had for his character couldn't tank another show.

7. Extreme Rules 2012

Extreme Rules 2012's chaotic main event survives scrutiny on rewatch as much due to the sheer ferocity of Brock Lesnar 'Beast'-like beatings as it does the divisive result. John Cena's decimation at the furious hands of the former UFC Heavyweight Champion was diluted slightly by the farcical decision to put 'The Champ' over after a pillar-to-post pasting from the recent returnee.

Advertisement

So often (rightly) accused of not giving a single f*ck, Lesnar used a lack of emotion to his advantage by creating hitherto unseen carnage amidst his every destructive step. Shock and awe filled the scene as the realisation of what his return truly represented seeped through to the open-mouthed crowd.

The card also played host to WrestleMania rematches far superior to the disappointing originals. Chris Jericho and CM Punk predictably benefitted from the Chicago locale (and Street Fight stipulation), whilst Daniel Bryan and Sheamus atoned for their infamous 18 second opener with a spectacular 22 minute two-out-of-three falls tussle.

The Big Show returning the Intercontinental Title to Cody Rhodes by stepping through a table was a disappointing and dispiriting back-track, but there was little else to complain about on a typically electric evening at the Allstate Arena.

6. SummerSlam 2013

Even after a 'Ring Of Fire' opener that foreshadowed the burning heap of sh*t that was Bray Wyatt's entire career, SummerSlam 2013 was an explosively fun show propped up by two huge matches featuring four bonafide stars.

Advertisement

Shortly before AJ Styles and Daniel Bryan marginally bettered his battle with 'The Beast', CM Punk's spirited fight with Brock Lesnar represented the former UFC Champion's finest all-round effort since returning to WWE a year earlier. Enthused by a programme for the first time since his lengthy WWE Title run was punctuated earlier that year, Punk was a ball of a fury against his bigger foe and lost nothing in what turned out to be his last headline-worthy match.

His spiritual successor fared better in a main event that made for one of the company's best matches of the decade. Hand-picked challenger Daniel Bryan defeated WWE Champion John Cena before surrendering the strap to opportunistic Money In The Bank winner (and secret Authority hitman) Randy Orton. The sad scene drew the sympathy intended on night one, but begat an unstoppable snowball of adoration for the 'Yes Man' that rolled all the way to WrestleMania.

But more on that later.

5. Money In The Bank 2011

CM Punk and John Cena had marginally better matches as the years progressed, but few benefited from their chemistry quite as much as the Allstate Arena crowd awash with Chicago pride. A white hot atmosphere buoyed the battle from something potentially pedestrian into positively pulsating. Punk's victory and departure with the WWE Championship was at very least the majestic scene the evocative angle had promised.

Advertisement

Time's been a little unkind to both the pay-per-view and the match in which 'The Voice Of The Voiceless' iconically collapsed Vince McMahon's house of cards with a single blown kiss. The company's miserable mishandling of the moment in the aftermath did much to deflate the tension created by the legendary Las Vegas "Pipe Bomb". Bottled though, the show overflows with magic as result of the moment.

Alberto Del Rio won a Money In The Bank ladder match in which he was by far the least interesting proponent, Daniel Bryan surprisingly won another in which he was, and Randy Orton and Christian continued their astonishingly entertaining feud with another exceptional and understated pay-per-view gem.

Beyond these, the show is stuffed with filler, but Punk had Hulkdust up his sleeve that night - almost of all of it gets over.

4. Survivor Series 2016

Bill Goldberg's crushing 86 second victory over 'The Beast' left jaws on floors in November 2016, and not just because they'd badly botched Big Bill once before. This spellbinding use of both men ultimately carried much of the promotional weight behind 2017's Royal Rumble and WrestleMania cards, and had the world talking for weeks in its aftermath.

Advertisement

Moreover, the brevity of the double main event's second half was complimented by a magnificent Raw Vs SmackDown Live! five-on-five Survivor Series fight.

Going just shy of an hour, the reds and blues went to war in emphatic fashion, fooling audiences that this non-issue really was worth killing yourself for. Crossing brand lines, The Shield's brief reunion during the match played hell with AJ Styles and Shane McMahon on the Tuesday team, particularly when Roman speared 'The Money' out of the sky in a coast-to-coast attempt-gone-wrong that rendered him legitimately concussed.

The Women's and Tag equivalents weren't without charm either, if nothing else highlighting the early success the company had made of the most recent roster split. Such an expression of show solidarity seems almost impossible in the post-Wild Card era.

3. Royal Rumble 2018

Ronda Rousey's show-closing arrival at the conclusion of the pay-per-view and first ever Women's Royal Rumble caused a the sort of earthquake WWE had been waiting for for years. Yet on reflection, it was was just one of the moments that shook audiences to the core following a spectacularly-booked supercard.

Advertisement

Shinsuke Nakamura survived the collected onslaughts of John Cena, Roman Reigns and the WWE writers in clawing his way to Royal Rumble glory in a battle royal that also made great use of Finn Bálor, Rusev and even Heath Slater. In fact, virtually nobody in the match was wasted, just as they weren't in the well-paced and furnished Women's equivalent later in the show.

Playing smartly on the historic occasion, the match was flooded with several nostalgic reminders of divisions gone by before Asuka took her rightful place atop the pile with the match-winning elimination of Nikki Bella. Each legend felt welcome whilst each regular felt special - the chemistry betwixt the two opposing forces hadn't ever felt better.

The undercard - as with most Rumbles - wasn't the hottest since records began, but was loaded with AJ Styles, Kevin Owens, Sami Zayn, Brock Lesnar and Braun Strowman and others before they'd all had their usefulness entirely drained later that year.

2. WrestleMania 30

Long before they started blowing nostalgia shows, WWE never flubbed their celebrations. And there was no greater particularly in the case of the 'Showcase Of The Immortals'.

Advertisement

WrestleMania XXX didn't have the Madison Square Garden aesthetic of I, X and XX, but the stunning New Orleans Superdome was well-stuffed replacement for one of the greatest stories WWE never told. Daniel Bryan's coronation as an actual top guy wasn't even on the board for the 'Show Of Shows' until infuriated fan sentiment effectively insisted it into life. His cathartic pinfall victory over Triple H opened and stole the show, setting the stage for his glorious triumph against pushed poster boys Batista and Randy Orton in the main event.

Typically, it couldn't have come under more challenging circumstances. 75,167 managed to somehow rebound from the collective devastation over Brock Lesnar's cruel streak-ending win against The Undertaker. The shared shock and silence as the three-count turned into a 21-1 graphic was memorable and mesmerising.

Away from the seriousness on top and a hugely enjoyable undercard, the event's first-time on-camera meeting between Mount Rushmore inhabitants Hulk Hogan, Steve Austin and The Rock was a delight. Going on first, it was a perfect complement to the historic events that would later unfold.

1. Evolution

Evolution was a rarity for WWE, and not just because it helped the company catch up with the rest of the world in having the thought and consideration to promote an event filled entirely with females. The pay-per-view, independent of the overdue ethical implication, was a show that brought the company's own press-aware bullsh*t in line with a product that over-delivered on their promises.

Advertisement

A perfect storm (and you'd think there was some sort of natural disaster inside the building considering the rabid atmosphere it housed throughout), the card was a pro wrestling and sports entertainment spectacular, booked and paced immaculately with barely even a minor quibble to raise in the aftermath.

Nostalgia acts shone in intricately placed spotlights, Ronda Rousey and Nikki Bella assembled a powerful and worthy main event whilst Charlotte Flair and Becky Lynch stole the show with a Last Woman Standing match that was for many the organisation's best match of the year.

On off-camera curtain call saw the entire roster celebrate together, and it was key to leaving a visual with the audience for future echoes. For all this magnificent wrestling show delivered a magnificent wrestling show, it also rewarded every female that had fought harder than they should have had to just to get the opportunity in the first place. It turned out to be better late, than never. Here's hoping we can one day say the same about a sequel.

Advertisement