10 Best WWE TLC Matches EVER - According To Dave Meltzer

Reach For The Stars

By Michael Hamflett /

Professional wrestling at its very safest is still one of the most dangerous activities the human body can experience, without the potential horrors of a Tables, Ladders and Chairs encounter.

Advertisement

Though it's decreased the actual need for the high-risk match in the first place, kudos to WWE for managing to narrow the carnage down to one night a year. And credit to the organisation this year for managing to arrive at their annual festival of wooden and metallic mayhem without completely over-saturating the gimmick altogether, instead electing to dedicate most of the build-up to the return of The Shield.

Over the last seven years, the event has endured cringeworthy force-feeds of particular weapons into storylines, with 2014's iteration even adding 'Stairs' to facilitate a wretched encounter between Erick Rowan and The Big Show.

Simply loading one match with the wholesale stipulation has always been infinitely preferable. Wrestling Observer boss and stoic pragmatist Dave Meltzer has liberally sprinkled snowflakes for the best efforts, with one contest in particular coming thisclose to the elusive five-star rating he so rarely doles out to anything WWE.

Of course, those stars don't necessarily make stars, but some of these beloved and well-regarded matches absolutely did.

(NOTE: In the event of a tied rating, the most recent match gets preferential treatment. Wrestling evolves at a breakneck pace, and any older contest outperforming a contemporary equivalent is deserving of the elevated status)

10. Bray Wyatt Vs Dean Ambrose (Tables, Ladders, Chairs & Stairs, ***3/4)

Less than three years after this clash, it seems unfathomable that Bray Wyatt was merely ever in a good match, let alone a memorable one, but his TLC '14 feud decider with Dean Ambrose afforded him a rare blowoff victory in impassioned fashion.

Advertisement

Their rivalry had plotted a course tragically similar to how most of Bray's conflicts would progress in the future, with sppoky bullsh*t such as a diversionary hologram distracting Ambrose in a match against Seth Rollins lingering longer than any of their actual battles.

The moments of brutality came from the unhinged Ambrose's willingness to embrace his inner darkness to unleash outer agony. Decimating Wyatt with a kendo stick, he then hit an elbow drop with a steel chair, but an effort to finish the 'Eater Of Worlds' off for good saw him launched through a table on the arena floor.

Wyatt followed up with similarly gruesome attacks with the weapons at his disposal, but Ambrose looked in firm control until a p*ss-poor finish saw him undone by a rouge TV monitor.

Attempting to swing the device at Wyatt's head, the wire disconnected with an inexplicably fiery explosion. As audience brain cells fried alongside his own, Dean was left prone to a match-winning Sister Abigail.

9. Sheamus Vs Roman Reigns (Tables, Ladders & Chairs 2015 ****)

'The Big Dog' and 'The Celtic Warrior' had underrated chemistry often overlooked by a wrestling audience that held them both in utter contempt.

Advertisement

After Seth Rollins' 2015 WWE Title reign came to an injury-enforced ending, the company tried and failed to generate Daniel Bryan-levels of sympathy for Roman Reigns by having Sheamus cash in his Money In The Bank briefcase on him immediately following his Survivor Series title win.

The damage was already done though, as fans sh*t on the very notion of the two feuding for the championship in place of stars they actually wanted to see. Subsequently, expectations were through the floor for their December show-closer, allowing the tension to build steadily before champion and challenger abused one another with some vicious attacks.

Sheamus even managed to sever his own arm following a devastating White Noise from the steel stairs through a table on the floor, but Reigns would return fire with an equally frightening powerbomb through a ladder.

Roman was ultimately beaten into defeat by Rusev and Alberto Del Rio in a dramatic conclusion that then saw Triple H obliterated by the vengeful challenger post-match. Breathtaking as it was, the tacked-on beatdown felt as much like a make-good from the company booked ahead of what they assumed would be an unsatisfying headliner.

8. CM Punk Vs The Miz Vs Alberto Del Rio (Tables, Ladders & Chairs 2011, ****1/4)

24 hours removed from 2011's edition of the annual Tables, Ladders and Chairs pay-per-view, CM Punk opened Monday Night Raw by introducing himself, World Heavyweight Champion Daniel Bryan and United States Champion Zack Ryder as the present and future of the organisation beyond the stasis controlled by John Cena, Randy Orton and the rotating parade of their half-heartedly promoted rivals.

Advertisement

Bryan had cashed in his Money In The Bank contract an hour or so after Zack Ryder dethroned Dolph Ziggler and not too long before the 'Straight Edge Superstar' would take down 2011's two best heel nearly-men. Punk's prediction of a new tomorrow was at that point a false dawn, but the signs were there after an unexpectedly excellent triple threat stuntshow capped off an entirely Cena-less supercard.

Early signs of unity between Del Rio and Miz dissolved in predictable fashion, but the story of the match remained Punk's need to to take out both individuals before even standing a chance of retaining his beloved belt.

A thrashing of The Miz with a steel chair set him on his way, but Del Rio took control of a large portion of the match after the millionaire's henchman Ricardo Rodriguez handcuffed him to a ladder. The cuffs played a part in a spectacular conclusion after Rodriguez took the biggest bump of the match, flying off an enormous ladder in the ring through a table on the floor.

Miz had shackled Punk to the middle turnbuckle, but the resourceful Punk unscrewed the rope entirely, racing through the detritus to take out both challengers and grasp his beloved belt.

7. Kane Vs Edge Vs Alberto Del Rio Vs Rey Mysterio (Tables, Ladders & Chairs 2010, ****1/4)

Another forgotten gem from an era where the company began bastardising the stipulation through overuse, Edge dethroning Kane to commence his final (save for a 1 day abeyance switch with Dolph Ziggler) reign with the World Heavyweight Title deserves a second look for those who only associate this show with the figurative and literal burial of Wade Barrett in the main event.

Advertisement

Paul Bearer had died (again) in the build-up, rattling the 'Big Red Machine' sufficiently enough to take his eye off the prize, allowing main protagonist Edge to guide most of the match through a series of logical spots that clearly benefited from his experience.

Such stunts included a rare splash from Edge from a ladder in the ring on Kane as he lay prone on a table on the outside. When the quartet fought to the stage, Mysterio dove from prop tables to temporarily oust the Champion from the match altogether.

All four re-entered the fray as the match continued at a frantic pace, before Del Rio took a terrifying fall through a table, Mysterio was incapacitated by a Tombstone and Edge speared Kane through a table on the floor.

The last man standing atop the rungs as he so often was, Edge tearfully celebrated, obvlivious to the finality his victory would be tinged with.

6. Jeff Hardy Vs CM Punk (SummerSlam 2009, ****1/4)

The final truly sensational match of Jeff Hardy's second run with WWE, this SummerSlam loss came right as he was due to exit the organisation and just before a personally damaging drugs bust at his home a month later. His substance abuse history had been alluded to in the angle itself, with Punk at his sardonic worst in the majestic heel variation of his 'Straight Edge Superstar' persona leading into the dramatic showdown.

Advertisement

A relatively brave choice for the show's top spot in an era swallowed whole by the presence of John Cena, Batista, Randy Orton and D-Generation-X, Punk and Hardy knew expectations were sky high, but the pair delivered one of the strongest singles TLC efforts in the near-20 year history of the match.

Punk was devilish with the weapons, electing to inflict punishment on the Champion with unnecessary roughness and aggression born out of the frustration he'd felt since Hardy took the title back from him a month prior. In response, the 'Charismatic Enigma' took his usual array of wild risks, including a gorgeous Swanton Bomb on the challenger through an announce table from the summit of easily the tallest ladder the company has ever used.

Jeff's last bump was less memorable but just as painful. Losing a fistfight underneath the belt, Hardy fell hard to the edge of the ring from the top rung, sacrificing himself for the cause one last time.

5. Edge Vs John Cena (Unforgiven 2006, ****1/4)

A gripping finale to their original series, John Cena and Edge's Toronto tour de force was a rites of passage for 'The Champ' as he sought to beat the WWE Champion at his own game.

Advertisement

Largely unimpeded by anybody else in his maiden year as the company's brave new home, John Cena had only found true opposition in the form of a red hot 'Rated-R Superstar', with Edge twice managing to finagle his way into the WWE Title picture by screwing with 'Big Match John'.

His second reign had kicked off with a win over then-Champion Rob Van Dam, but Edge had proved too slippery for Cena since, adding further stakes to what was announced as the challengers last chance at the prize.

Not fancying a move back to SmackDown at the time, Cena was positioned unfamiliarly as an underdog, both in his desperation to win and in the body of the contest itself. Considered a TLC veteran for good reason, Edge combined his natural wile with fierce tenacity, propped up further by the boisterous support of his home town crowd.

It wasn't enough. Never giving up, Cena overcame the odds before doing such a thing was one of his most tired cliches. His triumphant FU on Edge through two tables represented a fresh anointment as 'the man'.

4. AJ Styles Vs Dean Ambrose (Tables, Ladders & Chairs 2016, ****1/2)

Ignoring the predictable James Ellsworth turn at the conclusion of the contest, Dean Ambrose and AJ Styles' hard-hitting 2016 show-closer had all the necessary ingredients to make a late play for match of the year.

Advertisement

Exceptional in every outing at the time, Styles brought his best yet again, squeezing the another fine main eventer's effort out of the 'Lunatic Fringe' as he had done for the entirety of their feud.

Perhaps building on his hardcore history with Combat Zone Wrestling, Ambrose has proven a choice performer in plunder wars, but his final battle with AJ delivered a more measured approach to the carnage.

That's not to say it was in short supply - Styles slammed Dean onto a ladder with wince-inducing force, before Ambrose returned fire by launching the steel device square at the champion's head. Spot of the match went to the 'Phenomenal One' for hitting a springboard 450 splash from the inside out, through Ambrose and the table he lay on in the aisle.

More terrifying tumbles followed, with announce tables reduced to firewood as the athletes continued to ache. Ellsworth's turn was fatal. Ambrose careered through the air landing hard through two ringside tables following the chinless wonder's late ladder push. The slightly dispiriting conclusion couldn't ruin what had otherwise been a monumental affair.

3. Team Hell No & Ryback Vs The Shield (Tables, Ladders & Chairs 2012, ****1/2)

A contest that should be the blueprint for this Sunday's main event, The Shield's maiden offering was one of their very very best.

Advertisement

Having arrived a month earlier in secret collusion with Paul Heyman and CM Punk, Roman Reigns, Dean Ambrose and Seth Rollins were known talents away from WWE's bright spotlight but a largely unproven commodity on the main roster, not least as a triumvirate in a generation that has neglected any version of tag wrestling.

Obviously, this six-man war didn't require catch-as-catch-can nor the disciplines of tag ropes and five-counts, but it did deliver a powerful representation of the devastation and destruction the trio would become known for in their short original run.

Placed in the middle of the card but categorically considered the main event, the contest didn't even flirt with pre-stunt pleasantries after Daniel Bryan, Kane and Ryback attempted to take revenge on the group from the off after a month of suffering the collectivist assaults from the group.

The strength-in-numbers psychology dominated the entire match. Breathtakingly simple, the tactic from the group was to always stay a man up on each foe. Deck one guy, then another one. Ideally in threes but at least as a pair. It worked. Everything that went their way did so because of their unity, even in the contest's brutal conclusion.

Though Seth Rollins had plunged through four tables at the hands of Ryback by the stage, Ambrose and Reigns teamed up to decimate Bryan in the ring, hitting an elevated powerbomb through table to polish the 'Yes Man' off.

2. Edge & Christian Vs The Hardy Boyz Vs The Dudley Boyz (SummerSlam 2000, ****1/2)

The very first and almost the best, the match was first devised as much for Mick Foley to make Wizard Of Oz jokes as it was build on sensational ladder matches featuring Edge, Christian, The Hardy Boyz and The Dudley Boyz.

Advertisement

But SummerSlam 2000's breathtaking triple threat yet again redefined the possibilities of a wrestling stunt show, taking the riskiest elements of concepts only previously tiptoed around and weaving them into the narrative structure of a pro wrestling chase for gold.

Allegedly the backstage architects of destruction, Edge, Matt Hardy and Bubba Ray Dudley helped intricately sew the traditional single issue in between a selection of jaw-dropping bumps that almost certainly took years of careers. Bubba's and Matt's were perhaps the most frightening of the lot.

As the match raced towards a climax, each performer readied themselves for a final fall. Like an orchestral crescendo, bodies crashed and boomed like cymbals and gongs as the big finish emerged.

Bubba flew first, falling from the centre of the ring through four tables on the floor. Edge and Christian were double-crotched after Lita freed the ladder up for Matt to climb. He was then terrifyingly tipped backwards onto more ringside tables, leaving Lita herself exposed to a Spear from Edge that saw her inches off busting the back of her head open on a ladder. D-Von and Jeff were the last to suffer. 'E&C' launched a ladder at them as they hung defencelessly from the belts themselves.

The champions scuttled up to retain their titles, and were then helped away immediately through a sea of annihilated challengers.

1. Edge & Christian Vs The Hardy Boyz Vs The Dudley Boyz (WrestleMania 17, ****3/4)

Finding new beauty in hideous destruction, WrestleMania 17's TLC 2 is one of the great wrestling sequels on a show that already has possibly the greatest of all time.

Advertisement

It is justifiably remembered most for a legendary scene in which Edge soars through the sky at waiting target Jeff Hardy, but the spot was emblematic of the story the match tried worked diligently to tell.

Like the original it had to work extra-hard to follow, TLC2 was far from just a sequence of increasingly terrifying spots. The sequences and bumps were still mortifyingly dangerous, but they were again drawn together convincingly as the desperation of each performer grew. Jeff hung because he'd climbed a ladder before his grounding was lifted away, whilst Edge saw an opportunity to swat the 'Charismatic Enigma' away from his title and took it.

Neatly involving Rhyno, Lita and Spike Dudley as the respective run-in buddies of the three teams, the match afforded big spots for all of them, including Lita almost removing the 'Manbeast's head with a steel chair.

The three would have to go at it once more alongside Chris Jericho and Chris Benoit in the controversial unadvertised TLC3 a few months later, but they'd never come together as a six again. This Dallas showdown was a perfect sendoff.

Advertisement