10 Biggest Missed Opportunities From WWE Draft 2016

WWE's new era hits a number of bumps in the road.

By Andy H Murray /

The 2016 WWE Draft should’ve been a night of possibilities for fans, wrestlers, and company executives alike. Public consensus is that WWE’s product grew stale a long time ago, and it’s been reflected in poor TV ratings. Fans have grown jaded with the company’s tired storytelling patterns, continued push of unwanted protagonists like Roman Reigns, and the lack of opportunities afforded to young, up-and-coming superstars.

Advertisement

WWE had an excellent chance to turn all those criticisms on their head last night. In bringing back the Brand Split, the company seemed to recognise that something needed to be done to breathe life back into Raw and SmackDown, create two independent brands with their own identity, and legitimise the “New Era” rhetoric that the McMahons have been spewing since WrestleMania.

While WWE have succeeded in giving their product a facelift, it’s not the one that the fans wanted, and the general reaction has been mostly negative thus far. While we won’t know how the product will change until Shane and Stephanie each have a couple of shows under their belt, first impressions aren’t good, and the rosters are far from inspiring.

Have WWE blown their big chance? That remains uncertain, but they’ve certainly fallen at the first hurdle. It’s easy to be cynical in situations like this, and it would be wrong to jump the gun, but WWE have already squandered several Brand Split opportunities on the very first night.

Here are the 10 biggest missed opportunities from the 2016 WWE Draft.

10. WWE Network's Draft Centre Live

1252876

WWE’s Cruiserweight Classic Bracketology show on Wednesday, 6th July was a breath of fresh air. For the first time in what seemed like an eternity, WWE presented their product like a legitimate, competitive sport with a preview show more reminiscent of ESPN SportsCenter than anything else. Mauro Ranallo brought razor sharp analysis and supreme presenting skills, while Daniel Bryan brought enthusiasm and the kind of wrestling breakdowns that only a competitor of his experience can provide.

Advertisement

It was one of the best shows that the WWE Network has ever put together, and not only did it get each of the featured CWC participants over, but it generated a great amount of buzz for the tournament. With its success, WWE had a great opportunity to ape the format with last night’s Draft Centre Live show: instead, we got the same old WWE pre-show fodder with Renee Young, Corey Graves, Lita, and Booker T.

The show was a mess. Neither Renee nor her guests seemed to know what was going-on at any given time, with draft picks and interviews appearing without warning or introduction. Then there were the interruptions, with each participant doing their best to talk over the others until they had no choice but to quieten down.

It sucked the life out of what should’ve been a huge, era-defining occasion for WWE, and should be considered the night’s first failure.

9. No Returning Superstars

As soon as news of the Brand Split’s imminent return broke on May 25th, fans started wondering just how the company were gonna fill the extra roster spots. WWE, after all, had been struggling to pad-out their 3-hour Raw broadcasts with a full roster, let alone one cut him half by a Draft. How could they possibly fill all that airtime without increasing the talent pool?

Advertisement

Naturally, this led to a boatload of speculation, and aside from wide-scale NXT call-ups, WWE were reported to have contacted several former employees with a view to joining the Raw or SmackDown roster and helping ease the transition.

This didn’t happen. As soon as WWE published their list of eligible superstars on Sunday evening, it became clear that they had no intention of throwing the likes of Kurt Angle and MVP back into the mix, and that’s a shame. While a number of the speculated names (hi, Carlito) wouldn’t have brought anything more than nostalgia to the roster, a few familiar faces would’ve popped the crowd, shaken things up, and added a new layer of excitement to what turned out to be an unexciting draft.

8. Botching The NXT Call-Ups

Sunday afternoon also brought news that six NXT call-ups would be made as part of the Draft, and fans of WWE’s lauded developmental show immediately hit fever pitch. While reports of “up to a dozen” NXT call-ups were wide of the mark, six of NXT’s biggest and brightest were to finally get their opportunity on the big stage.

Advertisement

It was exciting, and the internet was ablaze with talk of Finn Balor, Shinsuke Nakamura, and Bayley. Unfortunately, WWE failed to deliver on the initial excitement, and the promoted crop of Balor, American Alpha, Mojo Rawley, Nia Jax, Carmella, and Alexa Bliss has done little for the company.

Balor and American Alpha are outstanding talents whose call-ups are more than warranted, and Alexa Bliss has blossomed as a heel lately, but the rest do little to inspire anything other than a strong “meh” from most WWE fans. Rawley, Carmella, and Jax are still a few steps behind most of their NXT colleagues, let alone the main roster workers, and it’s bewildering that WWE opted to bring them up ahead of the Nakamuras and Bayleys of the world.

WWE had a fantastic chance to bring some of their most talented young performers to the forefront: instead, they spent half their picks on wrestlers who still haven’t finished their wrestling education.

7. Not Giving The Club A Chance

The Club stable has been great for AJ Styles, Karl Anderson, and Luke Gallows alike. For Anderson and Gallows, it’s given them an instant affiliation with one of the roster’s most popular wrestlers, and thrust them straight into high-profile storylines with the likes of Roman Reigns and John Cena. Styles’s heel act, meanwhile, benefits immensely from the strength in numbers brought by his former Bullet Club associates, and the three have excellent on-screen chemistry.

Advertisement

Unfortunately, WWE decided to send them their separate ways last night, with Styles going to SmackDown, and Anderson and Gallows to Raw. While the latter duo have insisted that The Club will divide and conquer rather than split outright, it’s hard to see how this benefits Styles in-particular. While Gallows and Anderson and can now link-up with former Bullet Club leader Finn Balor on Raw, Styles is on his own.

That’s not to say Styles isn’t strong enough to succeed without them, as he’s still one of the best wrestlers on the planet, and someone WWE clearly has big plans for. It’s just disappointing that we’ll never get to see The Club reach full strength with him at the helm. The alliance is only a few months old, and it feels like WWE have cut The Club off at the knees without giving them a chance to hit full flow.

6. Not Sending Kalisto To Raw

Stephanie McMahon’s announcement that the much-missed Cruiserweight division is to return to Monday Night Raw felt like a breath of fresh air. WWE has struggled to make its midcard title divisions feel important over recent years, but the Cruiserweight Classic has been very well-received from critics and fans alike, and reintroducing one of the WCW’s most exciting title divisions should do wonders to refresh Monday nights.

Advertisement

While WWE got off to a great start by drafting Finn Balor and Nevile (two elite athletes who can absolutely anchor the Cruiserweight division going forward), they made a huge blunder not throwing Kalisto into the mix.

WWE’s roster isn’t exactly flush with sub-205lb talent at the moment, and while they’ll almost certainly bolster the ranks with a few post-CWC signings, Kalisto is a glaring omission. He’s tailor-made for the resurgent division, and while he’ll likely never surpass Balor in terms of popularity, he’s a far more exciting proposition than Sin Cara, his fellow former Lucha Dragon.

Who knows what the future holds for Kalisto now. WWE looked to be onto something when they put the US Title around his waist, but his reign, like most things in WWE’s midcard, quickly fell towards afterthought status. Maybe they’ll realise the error and send him to Raw in a post-Draft trade, but it seems unlikely.

5. Getting The Draft Order Wrong

In selecting Charlotte and Finn Balor third and fifth respectively, WWE sent the message that these were truly important superstars whom the company believed in, and saw as a huge part of their future. While Charlotte was already enjoying a prominent position on the card, her and Balor were legitimised as big-time players on the WWE roster. Picked over the likes of John Cena and Roman Reigns, their stature grew immediately, and the buzz for Balor’s debut has never been louder.

Advertisement

On the other end of the spectrum, Kevin Owens, once touted as a potential top 10 pick, fell to 18th. Cesaro, one of the company’s most talented all-round technical wrestlers, hit a lowly 28th, lagging behind such luminaries as Nia Jax (25), Baron Corbin (19), and The Big Show (23).

Cesaro had every right to be upset in his fiery, post-Draft shoot. This was a great chance for WWE to give wrestlers like him and Owens the recognition that their talents deserve. The low position likely won’t hinder Owens’ future, but for Cesaro, it’s a potentially devastating blow, and one that confirms the WWE have no interest in ever advancing him beyond his current level.

The draft should’ve enhanced Cesaro and Owens. Instead, WWE completely undermined all tenets of the supposed “New Era” by drafting swathes of directionless midcarders over some of the most talented superstars on their roster.

4. Sending Carmella Out On Her Own

Enzo & Big Cass have been vital to Carmella’s act since the inception. Debuting in NXT as a former hair stylist who lost her job when Enzo & Cass dropped a vat of hair removal cream on a customer’s dog (yes, really), Carmella became an ever-present alongside the beloved duo. Her “Princess of Staten Island” character draws heavily from Enzo in particular, and while she’s yet to perfect the act, Carmella was a welcome addition to the crew.

Advertisement

The trio were split-up with Enzo & Cass’ post-WrestleMania promotion to the main roster, but Carmella kept grinding towards the NXT Women’s Championship. She missed-out on her opportunity after losing a triple-threat match with Nia Jax and Alexa Bliss, but Carmella was still learning her trade, and looked set for at least another half-year in developmental.

Regardless of whether or not her progress warrants a shot on the main roster, WWE have made a mistake in bringing her to SmackDown with Enzo & Cass working on Raw. The trio work well together, and Carmella has struggled for traction since going solo in NXT. WWE are only diminishing her chances of long-term success by not attaching her to Enzo & Cass’ immense popularity early-on.

3. Getting The New Announce Teams Wrong

Mauro Ranallo has been a revelation on SmackDown, and his play-by-play skills have gone a long way to revitalising commentary in WWE. His incisiveness, pitch perfect delivery, and years of experience calling live sports made him a perfect choice for the blue brand’s lead announcer, and his presence even appeared to be pulling Jerry Lawler back to his Attitude Era best.

Advertisement

Raw’s much-maligned team of Michael Cole, JBL, and Byron Saxton, however, continued to be one of the Monday night flagship’s major bugbears. Their interactions had become tiresome, they did little to explain or sell the action before them, and more often than not their contributions descended into little more than a series of finely-chosen soundbites, Maggle.

Corey Graves, on the other hand, has been so strong in his role as NXT’s color commentary that he’s already been compared to the great Bobby Heenan. It was announced late last night that he would be joining the Raw announce team, but it’s a bittersweet promotion.

For all Graves’ talents, he’s going to be working alongside Cole and Saxton. He’s a huge upgrade on JBL, but given Cole’s regression and Saxton’s complete lack of anything, it’s worthy of caution. Besides, how is Graves going to fare with Vince McMahon and Kevin Dunn feeding him lines all night? SmackDown, meanwhile, will retain Ranallo, and “gain” JBL and David Otunga on a full-time basis.

WWE were right to promote Graves, but the balance is all wrong. As the company’s best color commentary, it would’ve made a lot more sense to place him alongside Ranallo, WWE’s best play-by-play guy.

2. Breaking Title Divisions Apart

WWE confirmed a lot of fans’ fears last night by splitting their understocked Women’s and Tag Team divisions and sending a near-equal split to Raw and SmackDown. Both divisions were already relatively thin, and by halving them, all WWE have done in the interim is create two top-heavy divisions with a huge gap between the haves and have-nots on each brand.

Advertisement

On SmackDown, for example, Becky Lynch is joined by two NXT call-ups, Natalya, Naomi, and, ahem, Eva Marie. American Alpha are great, but what are they going to gain from wrestling The Ascension, Breezango, and The Vaudevillains on a weekly basis?

This was a golden opportunity to keep both divisions together, place them on separate brands, and promote them heavily on a week-in, week-out basis. WWE’s renewed focus on women’s wrestling is admirable, but what’s the point if Charlotte and Sasha Banks are deprived the opportunity of facing world class wrestlers like Becky and Natalya?

Splitting the divisions does give wrestlers like Becky an opportunity to succeed on their own, but that’s the only advantage. Throw SmackDown’s tag teams on Raw and replace them with the red show’s women, give both divisions at least 30-40 minutes of TV time equal week, and their importance amplifies tenfold. As it stands, WWE have blown the opportunity to truly rebuild two of their more prominent divisions.

1. Failing To Create Any Brand Distinction

WWE’s most glaring missed opportunity of all, however, is their absolute failure to create any significant differentiation between the two brands.

Advertisement

The whole point of the Brand Split is to increase ratings by switching a number of different creative directions. Last time around, WWE did a great job of establishing SmackDown as a wrestling-centric show away from Raw’s over-the-top sports entertainment. SmackDown pushed the art of competition to the very forefront, and while still home to some of the company’s most important storylines, the brand was better known for pushing outstanding weekly matches between the likes of Kurt Angle, Eddie Guerrero, and Rey Mysterio.

While the distinction fell apart towards the end of the first Brand Split’s shelf-life, it was a big success at the beginning. SmackDown was a genuine alternative with its own identity, and that made it worth watching. It was refreshingly different to Raw’s garish soap opera, and many hoped the same would happen with the 2016 Draft.

Unfortunately, it did not. While WWE didn’t necessarily need to go down the same entertainment vs. wrestling path, they did need to separate the brands’ identities and make SmackDown important again. As it stands, they have failed.

Keeping the Women’s and Tag Team divisions together and making them brand-exclusive would’ve been a good start. Instead, we have two talent rosters that are barely distinguishable from one another, with a relatively equal proportion of male singles, tag team, and female competitors on each.

This is a huge problem, and it sets the Brand Split off to the worst possible start. It’ll now take a huge creative effort to create the brand distinction required to ensure the Split’s long-term success: here’s hoping they can make it.

Advertisement