10 Current Top WWE Talents Who Are Missing A Truly Classic Match

It takes a lot for a match to be considered an 'instant classic'.

By Gareth Morgan /

The term 'instant classic' is thrown around in modern wrestling as often as the label 'world class' is when talking about the current crop of footballing sensations.

Advertisement

However, it takes an awful lot more than the WWE Universe mindlessly chanting 'FIGHT FOREVER' for a clash to be established as an all-time great. There has to be stakes, serious drama and a level of in-ring storytelling which you simply don't find every single week on Monday Night Raw.

So, with that being said, it's not a surprise that it can take some time before a talent can sit back and honestly claim that they've been a part of one of the most memorable matches in WWE history.

In fact, some stars that have been plying their trade in Vince McMahon's ring for well over a decade are still yet to produce a match which can be classed as a must-watch for any old or new WWE fans.

They still have time, of course, and hopefully a few of the entrants on this list can prove your writer wrong in the coming months. Yet, as things stand, these ten current top WWE talents are still missing a truly classic match.

10. Bayley

It must be said that Bayley's recent run as SmackDown Women's Champion has been nothing short of brilliant.

Advertisement

She's comfortably evolved into a piece of sh*t heel and her enjoyable work in the ring has been matched by her seriously improved game on the microphone.

However, even with her recent run proving that there's still life in the former 'Hugger', Bayley has yet to produce a match on the main roster to rival her stellar work on NXT with the likes of Sasha Banks and Asuka.

It's not all Bayley's fault, as she has often been thrown into terrible programmes and wasn't given the chance to develop into anything more than a smiley goof during her babyface run. Yet, there have been moments in recent times when it's looked like she could be about to add another historic bout to her collection, only for her to stumble to a Bayley vs. Ember Moon at SummerSlam 2019 performance instead.

If ever there was a potential upcoming feud which could finally land Bayley her first truly classic match on the main roster, her long awaited implosion with long time buddy Banks could be (and definitely should be!) the one to do it.

9. Alexa Bliss

One of those aforementioned terrible Bayley feuds involved the 'Goddess of WWE' herself Alexa Bliss.

Advertisement

Despite the fact that the current Women's Tag Team Champion can also claim to be a three-time Raw and two-time SmackDown Women's Champion, it does still feel like we're yet to see the star hit her peak in the ring.

There was a time when Bliss threatened to break into the classic match club with her battle against Charlotte Flair at Survivor Series in 2017, but their eventual champion vs. champion clash could only settle for being a decent showcase of their abilities.

She's faced every Horsewoman and even battled against 'The Baddest Woman on the Planet' Ronda Rousey, but her appearance in the 2018 Money in the Bank ladder match still probably ranks as her most critically acclaimed encounter in a WWE ring. Yet, even that won't be making it into MITB top tens any time soon.

For a star as talented as Bliss undoubtedly is, you have to imagine that - if she is able to avoid more frustrating injuries - she'll still have plenty of opportunities to produce a genuine classic in the coming years. An eventual break-up and war between herself and Nikki Cross may even be the feud which opens the door for it.

8. Sheamus

Sheamus has been wrestling in WWE since 2009, held multiple World Championships, won the Royal Rumble, held the Money in the Bank contract and even been the goddamn King of the Ring, but he still hasn't honestly been part of a truly classic WWE match.

Advertisement

Madness.

He did manage to put on some decent performances during his 'The Bar' days alongside Cesaro against teams like Dean Ambrose/Seth Rollins and The New Day. However, they still didn't quite deliver that timeless smash hit.

Even before he attempted to take the Tag Team world by storm, Sheamus was trying his damnedest to churn out a top level singles match against the likes of Daniel Bryan at Extreme Rules 2012 and Roman Reigns at TLC 2015. Yet, both of those fairly strong contests were eventually forgotten about in the months that followed them.

Sheamus has recently returned to Friday Night SmackDown and looks like a star reborn, kicking the p*ss out of anyone who stands in his way.

Fingers crossed a proposed feud with Jeff Hardy could produce an overdue classic for the Irish star who more than deserves a five star pat on the back for his service.

7. Natalya

She's been confidently putting over talent and comfortably the safest pair of hands in the women's division for what feels like an eternity, yet it's still hard to pinpoint a match on Natalya's CV which screams out 'true classic'.

Advertisement

Her recent submission battle with Becky Lynch at SummerSlam 2019 summed up the Hart family member's match output for much of her career perfectly. There was absolutely nothing wrong with the bout itself - it was actually arguably Lynch's best match since becoming champion - it just didn't set the world on fire.

You could argue that the closest Natalya has come to that legendary status match-up was when she went up against Charlotte Flair at the first NXT TakeOver in 2014. Yet, even that pales in comparison to the later Sasha Banks vs. Bayley and Asuka vs. Ember Moon NXT barn burners.

It's incredible to think that a star who has been plying her trade as part of either Raw, SmackDown or ECW for over a decade somehow hasn't produced a WWE match that will be replayed for generations to come.

Natalya could surprise us all and put on an absolute banger with Shayna Baszler, Asuka or even Nia Jax (sorry, I got carried away) in the next few years. She definitely deserves at least one universally adored smash hit, so here's hoping she gets her moment.

6. Bobby Lashley

Outside of the world of WWE, Bobby Lashley found himself involved in some pretty awesome World Championship encounters with the likes of Kurt Angle and Austin Aries during his time with TNA/Impact Wrestling.

Advertisement

However, inside of Vince McMahon's empire, Lashley's list of top level wars isn't what you would class as long.

During his first run, a WWE title match with John Cena at The Great American Bash in 2007 was about as good as it got and his current spell in the company hasn't really delivered the goods, either.

You can't look past his Last Man Standing match with Braun Strowman at Extreme Rules 2019 as his one and only high standard contest since returning to the company in 2018. Even that wasn't the best match on a PPV which included The Graveyard Dogs vs. Shane McMahon & Drew McIntyre, AJ Styles vs. Ricochet and Aleister Black vs. Cesaro.

Lashley should be putting on absolute classics with the likes of Brock Lesnar and the new WWE Champion Drew McIntyre, but he's sadly not been given the chance to be anything more than an annoying piece of arm candy since joining forces with (and getting 'married' to) Lana.

Hopefully a new alliance with MVP can lead to some high quality matches with Raw's top performers in 2020.

5. Baron Corbin

The words 'instant classic' and 'Baron Corbin' haven't often been used in the same sentence since his call up from NXT in 2016.

Advertisement

Corbin excels as a piece of sh*t on the mic, regularly making you want to see his babyface opponent triumph over him on the night. Yet, when it comes to the eventual action in the ring, more often than not fans are left begging the good guy to put them out of their misery.

Though he does tend to find some form in multi-man matches, when faced with the prospect of a one-on-one encounter Corbin simply doesn't rise to the occasion. His bout against 'Big Match' John Cena at SummerSlam 2017, god awful retiring of Kurt Angle at WrestleMania 35 and recent snooze-feud involving dog food with Roman Reigns all point to a performer who doesn't seem destined to produce a legendary match for the ages.

Corbin could prove your writer wrong and start churning out Match of the Year contenders on a weekly basis over on SmackDown, but it feels more likely that he'll continue to tediously work through sub-par clashes on the blue brand.

4. John Morrison

There's definitely still time for the recently re-signed John Morrison to find himself in a legendary WWE match. But, as of writing, we're yet to see him be part of one during his two tenures with the company.

Advertisement

Like so many on this list, Morrison has put in decent showings in a few multi-man matches. However, a star of his unquestionable quality definitely should have at least one true WWE classic on his resume.

The former ECW, Intercontinental and multi-time Tag Team Champion was extremely consistent during his first spell with the company and put on brilliant matches against stars like Sheamus and his long time associate The Miz. Yet, the parkour enthusiast still wasn't able to flip his way to a truly epic spectacle.

He had more luck outside of WWE and developed into a top level star in Lucha Underground and Impact Wrestling.

Since returning to the company, Morrison has been hurled straight back into a team with Miz and has spent most of his time battling in thrown together tag matches. However, the few glimpses of brilliance we've seen in his contests against The New Day and the rest of SmackDown's tag division definitely suggests that Morrison could put on at least one serious classic if he's given the chance to strike out on his own.

3. Shinsuke Nakamura

The difference between the Shinsuke Nakamura who was able to explode through matches in NJPW and the one we've been subjected to in the last couple of years is startling.

Advertisement

It's not like he suddenly altered his style as soon as he signed for Vince McMahon's company, either. On NXT, 'The King of Strong Style' was still pummelling opponents and lacing some serious drama into his wars against Samoa Joe and Sami Zayn.

Yet, as soon as he arrived on SmackDown Live in 2017, something seriously changed and we haven't seen that same beautifully brutal Nakamura since.

Some suggested that he had been told to turn down his destructive style, while others claimed that the star was simply preserving himself as he crept towards his 40s. Regardless of the reason, the closest thing we got to the Nak of old was his blow-off against AJ Styles at Money in the Bank 2018 and even that was the best of a 'meh' bunch of clashes from a feud which should've showcased two of the very best of their generation.

Nakamura has been consistently putting on average-to-good clashes for years now and it seems like any hope of a game-changing WWE classic involving the former IC Champion may be lost.

2. Bray Wyatt

Many will quickly argue with Bray Wyatt's inclusion on this list as they will point to his recent Firefly Funhouse extravaganza at this year's WrestleMania as an 'instant classic'.

Advertisement

However, while this insanely genius cinematic spectacle was undoubtedly a seminal moment for the company, can you really class the contest as a genuine match?

It was without a shadow of a doubt one of the most entertaining and compelling pieces of WWE content we'd seen in years, but the 'match' consisted mostly of promo/hallucination segments before Cena was eventually planted with a Sister Abigail for the 'Fiend' win.

In terms of actual live contests involving wrestlers which aren't being traumatised in a Funhouse, the number of contests involving Wyatt that can be classed as top level battles is pretty low.

The Wyatt Family vs. The Shield matches way back in 2014 are probably about as close as Wyatt has come to being involved in a few critically acclaimed matches. However, even those wars don't hold a candle to modern classics like Roman Reigns vs. Brock Lesnar at WrestleMania 31 and Lesnar vs. John Cena vs. Seth Rollins at the 2015 Royal Rumble.

Wyatt definitely is still young and creative enough to produce a seriously legendary match without the use of pre-recorded cinematic effects, but only time will tell if he's able to do that in his current 'Fiend' guise.

1. Drew McIntyre

Your writer is a HUGE Drew McIntyre fan and that is why this entry is so incredibly painful to write.

Advertisement

Despite running through Raw's current roster like the dominant WWE Champion he is rightly being booked as and conquering 'The Beast Incarnate' Brock Lesnar at WrestleMania 36, can you honestly picture one McIntyre match which will go down in WWE history as truly classic?

The moment he lifted the title above his head at 'Mania will definitely stand the test of time. However, the match preceding it will definitely not.

His match alongside Dolph Ziggler against Seth Rollins and Dean Ambrose at Hell in a Cell 2018 was definitely fun, his appearance in the 2019 men's Money in the Bank ladder match was admittedly fantastic and his previously mentioned teaming with Shane McMahon against The Graveyard Dogs at Extreme Rules 2019 was a hoot. But, will any of those matches be remembered as the best of their era in ten years time?

You can bet that McIntyre will add a modern great to his record in the next year or so and this entry will very quickly become null and void, but as of this moment we're still yet to see a true McIntyre classic.

Advertisement