10 Failed AEW Experiments

The less remembered about The Nightmare Collective the better.

By Psy White /

Depending on where you mark your personal calendars for when AEW began, the company is now three years into its life having been founded on January 1st 2019.

Advertisement

Whether you've watched AEW from the very first show or joined in along the way, everyone who has tuned in has seen a show that has made its way out of its awkward infancy and now knows how to tie its own shoelaces. Still, as the company tries new things, there will always be risks. But you have to hand it to AEW and Tony Khan for getting the company to where it is in such short order and also for not playing it totally safe all the time.

If there's anything most can all agree on it's that WWE tends to get formulaic a certain amount of the time. Still, what the two promotions do have in common is trying things that don't work out.

It's the nature of storytelling, as well as television, that not all your ideas are going to stick - and honestly, trying to please everyone all of the time is one hell of a tall order.

In this list a look will be taken at some of AEW's teething troubles as they've looked to make a mark on the wrestling landscape.

10. Abadon

Having a monster on your roster has been a common thing for most wrestling brands for the last 25 years. Not the muscle-bound God types; quite literally the undead or otherwise inhuman. Many try for dark characters with supernatural edges, but few have the visuals quite like AEW’s Abadon.

Advertisement

Fans were stunned by her first appearance, and the potential was clear.

The problem with Abadon is a lack of credibility. Hell, if you don’t watch AEW Dark you’d be forgiven for forgetting she was still signed with the company as her on-screen appearances for Dynamite and Rampage have been few and far between. Her most significant story saw her quite literally taking a bite out of AEW Women’s Champion Hikaru Shida but failing to pick up the important win. In October 2021 she was defeated on Rampage by Britt Baker.

Whilst her win record on AEW’s YouTube content is rather impressive, she hasn’t ever gained any ounce of momentum on the shows where it matters despite her unique and still quite frankly powerful presence.

At the end of the day, a good storyline is all that it’ll take to get Abadon on the right path to becoming a key figure of AEW's women's division. The real question is, why haven’t they found that storyline yet?

9. The Bunny And QT Marshall

Sometimes, if they’re done right, fake wrestling romances for the purpose of storyline can be enjoyable. Obviously, it definitely helps if it’s not a star that has been seen on-screen with their real life partner. It creates an easy to ignore air of plausible deniability.

Advertisement

When Allie debuted in AEW and went on to become The Bunny, it made perfect sense for her to join The Butcher and her husband The Blade in their dark and violent tag team. Six months later however, and totally out of the blue, Allie reverted back to her former ring name and a more normal look as she became the on-screen valet and love interest of QT Marshall.

AEW have tried quite a few different ideas and roles for The Factory’s leader but none of them have ever really seemed to connect. This short lived fling is perhaps easily forgotten about but for the weeks that it occurred it had AEW fans scratching their heads.

Marshall and Allie’s lack of screen chemistry didn’t help a storyline that seemed to come out of nowhere but thankfully disappeared nearly as quickly as it came. When QT was out of action at the beginning of the COVID-19 pandemic, the story was quietly finished and Allie eventually found her way back to The Butcher and The Blade.

8. Sammy Guevara, Babyface

This one perhaps needs to include a caveat. Whilst Sammy’s impressive in-ring skills are enough to keep fans happy, his babyface personality didn’t land all that often.

Advertisement

Thankfully, Sammy adopted the 'Love, Actually' cue card gimmick and he could cut a promo without even having to talk. Not that he's bad on the mic, but Guevara has an undeniable arrogance that began to grate. The cue cards were a unique idea which was decent for a little while - before it overstayed its welcome.

Which might be an accurate way to describe Sammy as a babyface character as a whole because before he flipped back to heel, people were already desperate to boo him.

After starting a new real-life relationship with Tay Conti, Sammy’s wiseass attitude slipped too far out of the realm of relatable hero and into obnoxious heel. The two parading around with each other was a pure heat magnet, drawing ire from the live crowd and the online fanbase. AEW did the right thing and Guevara was soon bathing in the boos.

In the grand scheme of Sammy’s run, his time as a face was certainly fun and contained many memorable matches but as a solo character, it just failed to connect.

7. Weigh-Ins

The idea of including weigh-ins in AEW was of course to give the biggest fights in the company an extra level of importance and legitimacy; the term “big fight feel” taken to the next level. As a nod to genuine combat sports, opponents would get into the ring, step onto the scales and see if they qualified for the match.

Advertisement

In combat sports that have weight divisions and championships associated with them it’s important that combatants make weight before the fight. In AEW however, there are no weight specifications for any title. So, from the offset, it didn’t really make any sense.

Each of these weigh-in segments tended to be long, boring and ultimately didn’t add any extra level of excitement to the upcoming event. The worst of the bunch of course was Cody Rhodes squaring up to boxer Anthony Ogogo where, due to an issue with the scale, it took host Paul Wight an excruciatingly long 60 seconds to find and read the correct figure.

In its early days AEW was trying its best to find its own identity. It needed to be more than the biggest indie in America but it was perhaps trying too hard to be different from WWE. These kinds of experiments were teething problems along the way before AEW found its own take on sports entertainment.

6. The Nightmare Collective

During the first year of AEW, it was easy to let minor missteps go as the company found its footing. However, one particular storyline was something that both fans and the company wanted to move away from as soon as possible.

Advertisement

The reasons The Nightmare Collective failed are numerous. Firstly, it narratively made no sense. One week on Dynamite, Brandi Rhodes turned heel out of absolutely nowhere and started cutting the hair off of her enemies. This was in stark contrast to her husband Cody, who was over as the face of this exciting new promotion.

The two characters didn’t acknowledge each other on screen, but the blurred lines of reality and story that wrestling lives in made it hard to comprehend these two characters living together.

The Collective as a group was a confusing mess. Brandi used the stable to introduce Awesome Kong to AEW which made sense at first, but due to injuries, she couldn’t stay the course and retired. This left Melanie Cruise who had been initiated by shaving her head, and Japanese deathmatch star Luther; neither of which AEW’s roster had much familiarity with nor thought they posed much of a threat.

Listening to fan reaction that ranged from boos to often total silence, the story suddenly ended with Brandi getting therapy to undo all of her evil urges and everything was back to normal.

5. Brodie Lee As Mr McMahon

One of the earliest moments of true AEW greatness and boldness was the debut of Brodie Lee. It forged a path forward for many overlooked stars of the company’s competition. Even with the rumours swirling when Lee came forward as The Dark Order’s true leader, The Exalted One, wrestling Twitter shattered into a million pieces.

Advertisement

Every second that Brodie was on screen in AEW, and allowed to do whatever he wanted, he was captivating. However, many believe that there was a slight misstep along the way with his character.

Brodie came out of the gate by filming backstage vignettes where he played the incredibly strict and uptight mastermind of the Dark Order stable. Some loved it and some had no idea what was going on, which was quite understandable if you didn’t have a handle on the backstage talk about WWE’s chairman Vince McMahon. Jabs at Vince’s hatred of sneezes and calling yawning “weak” were clear digs at Brodie’s former employer, and the “Mr Brodie Lee” character always ate first.

Reactions were at the very least mixed, ranging from calling it hilarious to pointless, cheap humour.

Either way, Brodie’s character transformed into what it needed to be and he went on to claim the TNT Championship, leaving a mark on All Elite Wrestling forever.

4. Casino Battle Royale

AEW has had its issues with production along the way, most of these forgivable because shooting live television is no easy task and the show is still quite young. However, the very nature of the Casino Battle Royale means that it’s always going to look sloppy.

Advertisement

Most wrestling fans will agree that WWE’s Royal Rumble is a time honoured tradition that even lapsed viewers will tune in for every year, just for the spectacle. Every company wants their slice of this very delicious pie, and AEW tried their best to put their own spin on it. Rather than introducing each competitor one by one over the course of the match, the Casino Battle Royale organises them into four groups named after card suits and one random selection of wrestlers joins the fray every few minutes.

Cutting from in-ring action to one entrance isn’t too bad but trying to capture what’s going on in the match when five men individually make their way to the ring means you’re guaranteed to miss stuff. This can be anything from high-spots to eliminations and the constant cutting back and forth of cameras feels needlessly chaotic.

They’ve gotten better over time and with practice, but the Casino Battle Royale still hasn’t carved its own identity and instead feels like AEW’s poor attempt at miniature, messy Royal Rumbles.

3. Miro’s Gamer Character

Luckily, we are now deep enough into Miro’s AEW run that fans do their best to forget the finer details of how we got here. Those who were watching at the time quite likely regard Miro’s debut as the strangest waste of promising talent that the company took on board.

Advertisement

Coming in hot after his WWE contract termination, gone was the Bulgarian Brute in favour of The Best Man. Introduced by Kip Sabian to play the role at his upcoming wedding, Miro’s persona was an unclear mix of ideas. He was part Mr Perfect, claiming to be the best at anything, but also came to be known as little more than a “gamer” due to his popularity on Twitch.

It was a surprising use of a promising name - and not in a good way.

After capturing the TNT title however, Miro’s gimmick shifted direction to “God’s Favourite Champion”, a delusional but unstoppable force who believed that his success had been handed to him from powers on high. Finally, things not only started to make a lot more sense but it was a believable on-screen character for the heavyweight to perform.

Elements of Miro's gamer days do still exist, such as yelling “game over” before locking on his finishing submission. Thankfully however, The Redeemer is now a world away from his confusing early booking.

2. Cody Rhodes, Unaware Villain

When AEW came on the air for the first time, Cody Rhodes was the biggest face of the company.

Advertisement

As things progressed, fans went from a little tired of Cody’s schtick to downright exhausted. Three years as The American Nightmare had turned the crowd sour. Worst of all, Cody’s presence was starting to feel pompous. He was often away from the company to work on television appearances, and when he was on Dynamite he had the single most bombastic entrance on the roster.

Fans booed Cody routinely, even at his most theoretically sympathetic moments. The debate began whether the unbreakable heroic nature was all part of a story. Was Cody self-aware enough and now playing it all up for the boos? Was he going to become a Homelander-esque character who was oblivious to how he was, indeed, the villain?

Many people thought this was asking too much of Cody and these people were vindicated. The American Nightmare's interviews and promos that said he was a good guy who wouldn’t turn heel which turned out to be the case. The EVP left AEW before the hypothetical story many had speculated on bore hypothetical fruit.

Whilst Cody returned to the WWE as a megastar and the company’s top babyface, it’s a shame fans will never get to see the potential of unaware heel Rhodes that many had pictured in their heads.

1. Exploding Barbed Wire Deathmatch

A combination of a myriad of different hardcore indie concepts, the Exploding Barbed Wire Deathmatch was meant to be AEW’s nod to wrestling's violent past. At AEW Revolution 2021, Kenny Omega battled Jon Moxley in what has to be the most talked about main event in AEW’s history.

Advertisement

Covering the ropes in barbed wire hooked up to explosives and then adding wire-wrapped weapons into the mix, from tables to baseball bats, guaranteed one of the most insane spectacles in AEW to date. This sort of thing was expected out of the hardened brawler Moxley but Omega was on a streak of proving he would go the extra mile for the sake of entertainment. The pair ended up bloody and lacerated in a truly horrific but ultimately captivating event.

However, the match’s quality is overshadowed by the show’s finish. The other gimmick to the match was the thirty minute timer where, if someone was still in the ring at the end, they’d get caught in an explosion. Eddie Kingston ran to the ring to cover his beaten and bloody friend Moxley, as they were engulfed in… well, just a few puffs of smoke and some little sprinklers.

Poor rigging turned this deadly explosion into one of the most embarrassing moments in AEW history. Not surprising at all then that the promotion has never gone back to the concept.

Advertisement