10 Forgotten AEW Wrestlers You Totally Don't Remember

Tony Khan has booked a LOT of now-forgotten wrestlers since AEW launched.

By Jamie Kennedy /

Insert jokes about Tony Khan hiring every wrestler under the sun here.

Advertisement

Criticisms about Khan's scattergun approach to roster management are valid, but he isn't going to change now. AEW is five years old, and literally hundreds of workers have passed through the doors. Not all of them get one of those shiny #AllElite graphics, to be fair. You've probably forgotten a few who have though!

Old episodes of Dark and Dark: Elevation act as a reminder of Tony casting a wide net. Those shows normally didn't grab many viewers (at least not consistently), so it's fun to pore over the archives and find some names even the most hardcore wrestling fan would struggle to remember. For example, do you remember a one-off masked gimmick, or who his opponent was that night?

Current WWE main man Cody Rhodes pops up too, because he wrestled someone obscure on an episode of Dynamite in 2020. It's a match from Cody's history books that nobody will talk about at length when he's cutting his Hall Of Fame speech, that's for sure.

Keep score at home and find out how many of these folks you properly recall!

10. Danny Limelight

Danny Limelight goes under the spotlight.

Advertisement

Indy regular Danny joined the AEW train in 2021 and immediately nailed down a spot for himself on lower-rent programming like Dark and Dark: Elevation. He wrestled 18 matches for the company that year, then...OOF! Limelight vanished in a puff of smoke and returned to the independents.

Some of Dan's opponents on Dark included NXT man Ethan Page, Konosuke Takeshita, Christopher Daniels and even Jon Moxley. Limelight also teamed with Matt and Mike Sydal vs. Takeshita, Michael Nakazawa and Kenny Omega on one edition. The guy's shared the ring with some of All Elite's finest then. At least he can brag about that.

Here's the thing: Danny flies totally under the radar for all but the most hardcore of AEW fans. Like, you'd need to be the kind of fan who devours everything Tony Khan produces to even know who Limelight is. Cool Spider-Man ink though; or maybe it's a homage to 2000s nu-metallers Cold.

9. Ray Jaz

Missed opportunity if this wrestler didn't learn to play sax and become the world's top wrestling saxophonist. Ray Jaz sounds like somebody who belts out tunes at your local jazz bar. If you have a local jazz bar, that is. Alright, enough stalling/nonsense and more chatter about Ray's AEW stint.

Advertisement

Jaz worked 8 matches for the promotion between 2020-2022. Again, like Danny Limelight, all of them happened exclusively on shows like Dark and Dark: Elevation. Come on, Tony. Toss the guy a bone and stick him on Rampage or ROH every now and then, eh? That wasn't meant to be for Mr. Jaz.

Still love that name, by the way.

For context, his full name was Raymond Jazikoff. His rivals during forays onto AEW programming included Daniel Garcia, Anthony Ogogo (who almost made this list but missed out), Scorpio Sky and Bryan Danielson. Well, it was technically Danielson, but more on that to come later.

8. Mel

Do you remember The Nightmare Collective headed by Brandi Rhodes? The group could be considered one of AEW's worst ideas, certainly in terms of how it was executed on television. Brandi and Awesome Kong were joined by Luther and then Mel as members. Pretty much everything they did played before crickets.

Advertisement

Mel was indie veteran Melanie Cruise. She worked just 5 matches for All Elite in 2020, but debuted on Dynamite as an enforcer for the Collective at the tail end of 2019. Fans relentlessly bashed the whole thing online; it was clear to everyone watching shows that Brandi's stable just wasn't going to fly.

So, Mel bowed out with a squash match win over Red Velvet on the 25 August 2020 edition of Dark. She'd managed one Dynamite bout: A tag-team effort with Rhodes vs. Hikaru Shida and Kris Statlander on 15 January. This was a nondescript and unsatisfying flirt with the big time for Cruise, to say the least.

She hasn't wrestled since 2022.

7. Trench

It's big hench Trench!

Advertisement

Y'know, it's challenging to find much info on any matches Trench worked for AEW despite being tied to a worker who's currently AEW World Champ. He was kinda just known as the big enforcer with all the face tattoos during a spell in the Mogul Affiliates with Swerve Strickland.

If you do know Trench, then it's probs as the 'face tattoo guy' who hung around with Swerve and would-be Brock Lesnar impressionist Parker Boudreaux. Let's spit some facts: Strickland is much better off on his own away from hangers-on like this. The Mogul stuff really did nothing for him.

Trench was quietly let go in the summer of 2023, and barely anyone noticed. That's not meant to sound dismissive or cruel to the guy - it's simply fact. He didn't actually do much of anything during his years in All Elite, so no-one watching shows asked what had happened to him when he stopped showing up to stand around ringside looking mean.

6. John Skyler

John Skyler has gone on to receive some praise for his performances in TNA. Good for him, because wrestling under AEW's banner was a non-event experience for the dude. He first started showing up as just another warm body who could work some spots on episodes of Dark in 2020, and Skyler never progressed beyond that.

Advertisement

In 14 matches for the group, John stared at the lights...14 times.

Look, wins and losses aren't necessarily everything when you're on the 'D' and 'E' shows like Dark and Dark: Elevation, and at least Skyler got to work with the likes of Billy Gunn, Orange Cassidy, Miro, Brian Cage and more. Those matches likely stood him in good stead, but Rampage, Collision and Dynamite were still one million miles away.

Here's hoping somebody who checked out Dark content got a kick out of what John brought to the dance. His recent match in TNA vs. Chris Sabin was worth checking out, and it looks like Skyler will be booked regularly going forwards. Again, nice to see, but he wasn't memorable in AEW.

Side note: AEW actually paid John for 7 months whilst injured, and gave him access to their own medical team despite the fact he was never on a full-time contract. That's a lovely gesture, one which Skyler himself put over in interviews after the fact.

5. Ace Romero

AEW's fondness for Battle Royals/Battle Royales is well-known, and the amount of spots TK needs to fill does sometimes lead to some interesting names popping up. Ace Romero sits neatly in that category after his one and done showing at Double Or Nothing 2019. He was part of the Casino Royale on the 'Buy In' portion before the main pay-per-view started.

Advertisement

All Elite fans haven't been treated to more Ace since.

Romero was in the "Hearts" part of the draw, and managed one elimination before being ousted himself. For the record, Ace chucked Marko Stunt out of the match and ended his World Title dreams. What a monster. Seriously though, Marko had the last laugh when his then-pal Jungle Boy eliminated Romero and the big man walked off into the sunset.

Since then, Ace had worked a few years in IMPACT/TNA, and kept his career going on the indy scene. He might be one of the only wrestlers Tony Khan took a right good look at and decided not to sign/use a couple more times. There's always one.

4. Tiger Ruas

Tiger Ruas spent a full 6 years in WWE's system as Arturo Ruas between 2015-2021. You might remember him as one of the extras a super-sweaty Shane McMahon talked over during those short-lived Raw Underground segments on the Monday night flagship. Someone was impressed, because Ruas got drafted to Raw in the 2020 Draft.

Advertisement

WWE quietly moved him back to NXT then released him in June 2021.

AEW came calling, and Tiger ended up trading 6 years in WWE for 6 matches in All Elite. You guessed it: All of them took place on Dark or Dark: Elevation. His biggest showing was surely a decent back-and-forth scrap vs. PAC on the 2 November 2021 episode. Other than that, Ruas mainly worked tags.

Suddenly, being biffed by Dabba-Kato and Braun Strowman on Raw Underground didn't seem so bad. AEW didn't take up the option to sign Ruas full-time, and there's no record of him wrestling anywhere else since 2022. What a strange pro career all in.

3. Baron Black

Baron Black worked more AEW matches than almost anyone else on the list. In total, his haul currently sits at 52. Not bad for somebody who wrestled as part of the Dark and Dark: Elevation crew. Black did get to debut on the 'A' show though - he lost to Shawn Spears in a short bout on the 29 April 2020 Dynamite.

Advertisement

It was off to Dark after that.

Baron has had more tag partners than anyone else on the old YouTube programs. Check this out for a list: Tony Donati, Frank Stone, D3, Louie Valle, Nick Comorato, Frankie Thomas, VSK, Fuego Del Sol, Mike Verna, Royal Money, Shawn Dean, Aaron Solow, John Skyler, M'Badu, Tamilian Vaneesh and Ryzin. That's just some of them, not all.

A lot of those names could've made it into this article themselves, but they either didn't get the early Dynamite treatment or didn't work too many matches on the lower-tier shows. Some of them were one-offs too. Black wasn't, but he's still tough to remember unless Dark was appointment viewing.

2. Infinito

Tony Khan is no stranger to a masked wrestler, but he clearly didn't see enough in Infinito following the flyer's one and only AEW match vs. Ray Jaz on the 30 November 2021 Dark. That's surprising, because Infinito showed a lot of potential and actually looked like someone who had been wrestling for 20+ years.

Advertisement

That's because Bryan Danielson was under the hood.

This must've been something Bryan fancied doing for a giggle. His jump from AEW has been hugely productive for Danielson, who has been having a hoot since joining the company and enjoys the freedom Tony Khan gives him. Becoming Infinito and wrestling on Dark was all Bryan.

Ray Jaz would've been delighted to wrestle Danielson, hokey gimmicked name or not. The kicker is that a ton of fans wouldn't see Bryan as Infinito. Dark was already a hardcore fan only deal, but it started sliding down the pecking order even furhter once Rampage launched.

1. Warhorse

Warhorse's quartet of AEW matches ranged from unbelievable opportunity to, 'Oh, well so much for that'. He debuted on the 29 July 2020 episode of Dynamite vs. none other than Cody Rhodes. Cody was pretty giving to ol' Horsey as well - they went 10 minutes before Rhodes retained his TNT Title following a hard-fought match.

Advertisement

How did Tony Khan follow up on that? By waiting until November 2021 for Warhorse's next All Elite match, of course. He'd lose to Andrade El Idolo on the 9 November Dark, then show up again for matches in June 2022. The indy veteran didn't repeat his trick by showing up in 2023 though, and he hasn't been spotted on AEW TV in 2024.

It was fun for him while it lasted.

Nobody out there will look back on Cody's AEW career and namecheck Warhorse as one of his key opponents, right enough. Their match happened during the closed-door pandemic days mid-COVID 19, which only makes it even more of a curiosity.

What other AEW stars have been totally forgotten since the promotion launched? For more like this, check out 10 Lockdown Era WWE Superstars You Totally Don't Remember and 10 Forgotten WCW Wrestlers You Totally Don't Remember! 

Advertisement