10 Iconic Wrestling Images That Show History Repeating
Haven't I seen you somewhere before?
Jim Cornette reckoned that it was safe to recycle an idea in wrestling approximately once every seven years, but Jim Cornette's reckoned a lot of stuff lately so it's a shame the good stuff ends up drowning like Braun Strowman in a swamp fight.
When the 'Prince Of Polyester' was almost universally beloved for takes such as the above, it was in the year 2000, when he was predicting that John Cena and Batista would main event WrestleMania in five years. The wrestling legend knew and knows his wrestling sh*t, and it's a genuine shame that a series of confused and difficult personal biases have resulted in the objective being lost to his hypocritical subjectivity in recent years.
He wants wrestling to repeat what works, even though there's equal evidence that the genre constantly needs to move and evolve. It feels as though he's rooted in this belief more than ever because of clicks and the toxic discourse following a snitch tag, again making a nonsense of a half-decent philosophy. Wrestling's uniqueness means that the hits can be played louder and somehow sound different, as was the case these reimagined moments...
10. Cody Goes All In
A glorious match that was effectively the making of Cody as the AEW lead babyface a full year before the company (and his in-ring role) was made real at Double Or Nothing 2019, the NWA Worlds Heavyweight Championship match at All In leaned on family history as much as the belt's less-than-impressive present.
That's not to discredit Nick Aldis' work with the title before and after this quick switch with Cody, but the 'American Nightmare' evoking 'The Dream' was doing the work here.
He craved and cradled that title as if Aldis had been disrespectfully walking around with Dusty's ashes. As if Aldis was as bad as WWE locking down all of his Father's ideas in a trademarked vault. The chance for validation and vindication was available to the man that was deemed chiefly responsible for making the evening's miracle take place.
Much like Dusty's own victories over Ric Flair, this felt like one for America, for the common man, and for the dream.
9. Becky Lynch Becomes The Man
The (real, not WWE) universe offered several bizarrely prescient links between the 2018 rise of Becky Lynch and 1996/97 ascendency of Stone Cold Steve Austin, but they were all ultimately rooted in the hopes of the fanbase more than anything intended by the booking.
There was a loud longing from audiences that the company please not screw this one up, pointing to how well it worked the last time to convince the company to follow the same course.
Did they direct Nia Jax to break Becky's face? Of course not, but what a wonderful bit of happenstance it was. 'The Man' had her wings unfairly clipped, but spread them wider than ever before the confirmation with a blood-soaked pose that confirmed her as the top star in the entire industry. Mirroring two Austin flashbacks in one moment (Austin's broken neck at SummerSlam and dramatic blood loss at WrestleMania) this was Lynch taking the complimentary comparisons and making them all her own.
8. Curtain Call
For years after the fact, The Kliq argued (with some merit) that their infamous "Curtain Call" show-closing embrace wasn't some business-killing moment but a rightful celebration of all they'd tried to achieve in a struggling empire.
The first Madison Square Garden sellout in years saw heels and babyfaces hugging as two big farewell to the company and holy sh*t was this breaking-the-magicians-code stuff in 1996, but did the lack of empty seats actually justify the lack of kayfabe? They definitively did in 2015, when a rocking Barclays Center hadn't found their minds from a Sasha Banks/Bayley match before losing them again as the Four Horsewomen embraced for one last time on the black and gold brand.
Triple H probably felt a kinship with Bayley as the one remaining on NXT as the others departed, but her run with the belt was the polar opposite of a burial. She took an already-prestigious title and helped cement it in the god tier of titles ahead of Asuka's legendary stint.
7. Hulkamania Will Live Forever?
Well, no, but they got a fun month or so out of it.
Hulk Hogan winning his sixth and final WWE Championship in 2002 is retroactively viewed as Vince McMahon's lost touch yet again showing itself after months of other atrocious misfires. It is in fact the one thing that looked like a fairly logical move.
Hogan was red (and yellow) hot upon returning to his old persona following his clash of ages with The Rock at WrestleMania, in a way that felt far closer to earnest adoration that full-throated nostalgia. The emotions meant for different things at the box office, but McMahon wasn't to know as fans blew roofs off for their old favourite after months of being fed ex-WCW stars that brought no excitement whatsoever.
Many panicked at Hogan's politics returning to run roughshod on the organisation, but it couldn't have been further from the truth. Including the loss of this very reign, he'd never done more jobs at any point in his career.
6. Paul E & Easy E
The above graphic was produced by WWE as blockbuster news broke of a June 2019 restructure that seemed almost entirely in tribute to how the wrestling landscape had looked nearly two decades earlier.
With ratings tumbling, Vince McMahon bizarrely turned to a past he'd previously bantered off to try and make the future a little brighter. Naming Paul Heyman and Eric Bischoff as Raw and SmackDown Live "Executive Directors", the Chairman allowed the respective former ECW and WCW chiefs a chance at managing his brands.
The positions reimagined the creative process somewhat, but the organisation's familiar failings (systemic rot, McMahon's own narrow-lensed autocracy, browbeaten roster) overpowered any creativity either man still had in the chamber.
Bischoff was gone amidst rumours of staff hardly ever seeing him outside of catering, while Heyman's short-term position of power seems to have done him few political favours. AJ Styles, Luke Gallows and Karl Anderson have all been outspoken critics of the now-former Raw and SmackDown boss, with 'The Phenomenal One' requesting a move to SmackDown to avoid working alongside him in the wake of his friends' April 2020 firings.
5. The Two Woman Power Trip
Sasha Banks’ Raw Women’s Title win infuriated many due to the disappointing booking of her win over Asuka. Not least because it was two weeks removed from another banger between them being lost to WWE bullsh*t.
The clash at The Horror Show At Extreme Rules was the match of the night before the magic was ruined by a horrendously cheap conclusion. The follow-up was much the same, but the ‘Golden Role Models’ becoming BayleyDosStraps and 2BeltzBanks has evoked a fairly well-liked storyline from just past the peak of the company's creative and commercial zenith.
Stone Cold Steve Austin and Triple H's Two Man Power Trip act was novelty good rather than good good, but much like Bayley and Banks in their current roles, the omnipresence was earned. The work was good and the characters became domineering enough that their eventual decline informed one of the best matches in Monday Night Raw history even before 'The Game's devastating quad tear lionised it for entirely different reasons.
If the conclusions arrived at for the Smackdown and Raw Women's Champions are even half as good as that, they'll surpass the original by some margin.
4. Baddest Men On The Planet
AEW went looking for "TYSON AND AUSTIN! TYSON AND AUSTIN! TYSON AND AUSTIN!" vibes when they brought 'The Baddest Man On The Planet' in to rehash some old hostilities with Chris Jericho and give the launch of the TNT Title about of real sports pizzazz. Instead, they only mined some very well-founded criticisms.
Two decades and change is a long time, but the magic of that 1998 moment felt a million years old when the actuality of the booking came to pass.
Tyson's entourage looked pretty daft, but not as silly as their leader as he flexed in Jericho's face (when he could finally rip his shirt off) to set up...something the company will presumably eventually get back to. People in 1998, for their open shame and naivety, were able to look past the glorification and promotion of a convicted rapist. Present day is not that less-informed past and fans of the theoretically-progressive wrestling company in 2020 understandably wanted All Elite Wrestling to do much much better.
3. The Leader Of The Old Generation
There was a familiar feeling to Diesel's sudden reimagining as WWE Champion and "Leader Of The New Generation" when he managed to secure the industry's top prize in November 1994.
The company chose Madison Square Garden as the place to conduct the transitioning of the title from new Champion Bob Backlund to 'Big Daddy Cool', just days after the former had defeated Bret Hart and the latter had turned babyface on Shawn Michaels. Backlund had performed 'The Hitman's duties once before, losing the gold to the Iron Sheik in order to pass it off to Hulk Hogan in another short match inside WWE's home base.
The comparisons were intended - WWE aimed to present their next great hope as being even better than the original to try and will a second Hulkamania into existence - but they were superficial at best. The setting, nature and key players provided all the necessary echoes, but Diesel wasn't the man to drag an entire industry out of its near-fatal rut.
2. Game Of Thrones
People loved Cody smashing the throne.
Grabby symbolism to pander to ardent acolytes it might have been but wrestling's got a rich history of that - as well the 'American Nightmare' knows. Vince McMahon trained his audience to loathe any form of wrestling outside of his own vision of it, and this was Cody's personal take on it.
The smart acknowledgement that Triple H was as much to do with the current monopoly as Vince himself was inspired too. It took a shot at somebody that had been partially babyfaced thanks to a well-liked NXT product and the general consensus that he could "fix" much of what was wrong about WWE. Cody found his own billionaire rather than trying to battle the existing one and his son-in-law.
The AEW EVP isn't a man of the people in spite of this grandiose statement aiming to suggest otherwise. He's the latest promoter/power player to heap dirt on the old ways in an effort to plough forth with the new. Just as Vince McMahon reduced other rivals to "rasslin' in smoky bingo halls" and Eric Bischoff gave away results on Nitro, Cody used 'The Game's ridiculous weapon to smash an accepted institution.
1. The Ratings War
Eric Bischoff wasn't so much on top of the world as he was in total control of it when he borrowed a fan sign to gloat in full frame about how easy things appeared for WCW in 1997.
A loaded shot of 'Easy E' living his best life stands up to 2020 scrutiny too. Raw fears ratings more than ever before, wishing it could pull numbers like WWE managed right around the time this moment was captured.
The company at large are being bombarded with viewership failures beyond the state of the former flagship as well - SmackDown has failed to even approach figures akin to the ones they drew for a star-laden Night One on Fox in October 2019, while NXT has lost the majority of Wednesday Night ratings wars to AEW since the nascent league hit the ground running the very same month.
When Bischoff flaunted the sign, WWE burst forth from the slump and made him suffer for his arrogance. This may be the one bit of history in this shot they simply can't repeat.