10 INSANE Risks WWE Took With Their Biggest Stars

Stone Cold Steve Austin & Sable sitting in a tree, "Seth Freakin' Rollins", and Hulk Hogan: Crybaby.

By Michael Hamflett /

Before WWE leveraged those very initials and the idiosyncratic product itself into unheard-of television rights fees deals in the 2010s, wrestling was strictly a star-driven industry.

Advertisement

Promoters needed rosters like coaches need teams, but wrestling shows always needed stars far more than squads need star players. The highest quality wrestling sadly hasn't always translated to drawing the most money, but much of the best stuff has been given breathing space thanks to a cash cow on top bringing the punters in.

Hulk Hogan absorbed Andre The Giant's chokes and punches then dropped a leg at WrestleMania III to etch his name in American pop culture history, even if the quality of his match was left for dead by Ricky Steamboat and Randy Savage on the undercard. Ric Flair somehow combined being a top draw and chief broomstick operative as the NWA's touring World Champion, but as territories faded so too did that particular art.

The big companies getting big numbers on big stations needed big deals in big matches, and all the rest would follow. It thus beggars belief then that any of the below box office behemoths were put in such sketchy situations...

10. Hulk Hogan

In all sports, winners win primarily because they simply hate the feeling of defeat, and the Hulk Hogan character won a lot.

Advertisement

But what an absolute pr*ck he was in defeat.

A weakness in his game even when he was at his absolute peak as monolithic megastar, 'The Hulkster' always looked like a petulant child if he was booked to lose, contradicting much of his pious messaging in the protest. This was especially prevalent in Royal Rumbles, where - likely much to Hogan's chagrin - he simply couldn't win them all.

Despite going back to back as winner in 1990 and 1991, his performances in 1989 and 1992 are just as memorable for how poorly he took the completely fair eliminations. In the first pay-per-view iteration of the classic battle royal, he illegally assaulted The Twin Towers after they'd teamed up to toss him, and to tee up Ric Flair's famous win he pulled Sid Justice to the arena floor having been fairly thrown over seconds earlier.

The second case was so egregious that WWE had to dub in cheers in reruns - the '92 live crowd had no patience for his pet lip and stood firmly behind big Sid when the behmoths stared each other down in the post-match.

9. John Cena

Dragged into WWE's systemic cruelty of Zack Ryder in early 2012 as he patiently waited for his WrestleMania build with The Rock to kick back off, John Cena looked even lamer than usual due to being positioned as a patronising, girlfriend-stealing blowhard.

Advertisement

At first, the intentions from the company seemed mostly noble. Ryder had won the United States Championship and regularly working alongside the company's biggest star seemingly offered him the next logical leg up. It was his impending burial hiding in plain sight.

Transitioning from being Cena's friend to his pathetic sidekick in 'The Champ's p*ss-weak programme with Kane, Ryder was reduced to the bumbling buffoon spot in segments with 'The Big Red Machine', taking the brunt of his physical assaults to build up to the infamous scene in which he was pushed off the stage in a wheelchair and neck brace.

Flirtations with Eve Torres were instead used to garner her heat for a heel turn, triggered in part by her and Cena kissing in front of Ryder's gutted gurning face. 'Big Match John' typically faced backlash from 50% of the crowd at the best of times - it was astonishing this angle didn't finish him for good.

8. Sable

In 1999, the acrimony between WWE and Sable grew to such an extent that the former Women's Champion left the company outright, filed a multi-million dollar lawsuit and virtually put all of wrestling behind her by the summer despite playing an enormous role in an 18 month period that had completely transformed the entire company.

Advertisement

It really didn't have to be that way.

Sable's April 1999 Playboy issue did monster, record-breaking numbers, speaking to the phenomenal success of performer and promoter during that time. Splitting from Marc Mero in 1998, a limited-but-game Rena Mero showed phenomenal fire in her debut match at WrestleMania XIV, and when aided by the likes of Luna Vachon and Jacqueline and Mero himself, she shone as brightly as industry top star Stone Cold Steve Austin.

The success of the Playboy spread didn't really scan as much of a surprise, but a narrative rapidly emerged that she was suddenly disinterested in the rigours of wrestling as a result. WWE rather forcibly and prematurely turned her heel to match what they believed to be happening behind the scenes, squandering a top babyface and straining a working relationship until it collapsed completely.

7. Rey Mysterio

A number of WWE full-timers were beyond consoling when they lost friend and colleague Eddie Guerrero in 2005, and Rey Mysterio stood bravely as one of the most heartbroken.

Advertisement

Brothers in all but blood, the two wrestled epics with and against one another, infamously feuding shortly before 'Latino Heat' passed in a silly story that has since charmed viewers in the passage of time.

On the first of two tribute shows, Mysterio wrestled Shawn Michaels in something of a dream match and one the pair wanted to have in the fallen star's honour. In the weeks to follow, Guerrero included an "EG" tribute arm band as part of his permanent gear, and scored tag team gold with Batista in another sweet presentation of two men that loved Eddie coming together to share both the real pain of his loss and the storyline success of a title gained.

But WWE didn't know when and where to stop. Mysterio went the distance to earn a WrestleMania title shot in the 2006 Royal Rumble, crediting his #2 position to Guerrero playing a prank from heaven. If that ever-so-slightly soured a sweet tone, an awful follow-up programme with Randy Orton conclusively destroyed it.

Mysterio was barely even a sympathetic figure by the time he became World Heavyweight Champion in Guerrero's honour at the subsequent 'Show Of Shows', and was booked so poorly with the belt after the fact fans simply never felt motivated to latch back on.

6. Randy Orton

In 2019, Randy Orton defeated Triple H in what barely obscured itself from being a Saudi Arabia celebrity match.

Advertisement

This Super ShowDown scuffle was the first time they'd wrestled one-on-one in just under a decade, and as a man sliding into retirement against one still very much in an elongated prime, 'The Game' at very least lost cleanly to his former stablemate and protege.

To a select cynical few, this result registered as a genuine shocker.

For what felt like minor eternities at the time, Hunter so comfortably got the better of Orton in matches and programmes in 2004, 2007 and 2009 that it seemed as though he was trying to become a Legend Killer himself before the first part of the moniker had even been established.

Orton's first World Championship reign brought about his severance from Evolution and title loss to 'The Game' just three weeks later. At No Mercy 2007, he was handed the WWE Championship only to literally immediately lose it to Hunter before winning it back in a main event after the 'King Of Kings' had already been forced into a third match in the middle of the card against Umaga. The duo stunk up the WrestleMania 25 headliner, and Orton looked at the lights there too.

As well we know whether any of us like it or not, Randy Orton did indeed make it to WWE's elite tier in the end. But a litany of losses against its fiercest gatekeeper cast major doubts for a decade.

5. CM Punk

Not that they would bother anymore, but when WWE tells the story of CM Punk' career-altering 2011, the order typically goes as follows:

Advertisement

- CM Punk sits on a stage in Las Vegas and has a big old moan. Calls the microphone a "pipe bomb" in his hands.

- Defeats John Cena at Money In The Bank for the WWE Championship, the rascal.

- Big star forever after that and what's he always f*cking moaning for?

This of course wilfully neglects a truly abysmal summer full of so many plotholes and potholes that it by rights should have killed all the incredible and incendiary momentum he'd built up over June and July, but this was one of the first cases of the company failing to kill a push they didn't really like with corporate dark arts. Namely, beating him like a drum.

Punk retained his belt in screwy fashion at SummerSlam (but celebrated anyway), before being battered by Kevin Nash and beaten by Alberto Del Rio. Then he lost a number one contender's match to Cena on Raw. He lost to Triple H at Night Of Champions before teaming with 'The Game' to lose to The Miz & R-Truth at Vengeance. Sandwiched between those setbacks was a loss in a triple threat with Del Rio and Cena inside Hell In A Cell.

Only at November's Survivor Series - and still somehow beloved by the crowd - did he get back on track, regaining his stolen WWE Championship so he could get on with the job he'd clearly earned months earlier.

4. Seth Freakin' Rollins

A change made bang on time of writing that may already have been abandoned by the time you read this, WWE have elected to formally rebadge Seth Rollins as "Seth Freakin' Rollins".

Advertisement

Not to get lost in another shoegazing lament about wrestler monikers but typically, getting heated about a name is more of an in-the-moment gut reaction than something that sticks around long term. Observers were proved correct when, in 2008, they opined that somebody called Dolph Ziggler could never main event WrestleMania. But that was nothing to do with his Boogie Knights sound-alike label and more total systemic ineptitude for well over a decade.

Had he been pushed in reasonable scale with his growing gifts, Dolph Ziggler very well might have main evented WrestleMania, just as Seth Freakin' Rollins might if he keeps his new middle name for more than a week. Getting used to it will take longer, but WWE never stops and we all glumly make the time to do just that.

It really could go either way - Vince McMahon's instincts gifted the world "Burn It Down" in his entrance theme, and for about two years it was the hottest element of his act. What do we freakin' know?

3. Becky Lynch

Becky Lynch should have been permitted to fall in love with a fellow superstar and it not almost derail the run she'd worked over a decade and a half for, but such is life atop WWE's typically unstable tree.

Advertisement

Rising to fame, fortune and iconic status in 2019 as 'The Man', Lynch's historic WrestleMania 35 win over Ronda Rousey and Charlotte Flair came as result of the latest case of WWE audiences rejecting what they were being fed when she'd turned heel the prior summer. All went swimmingly too, until her relationship with Seth Rollins was needlessly thrust into kayfabe's grisly maw.

A mixed tag feud beckoned with Lacey Evans and Baron Corbin, headlining a Stomping Grounds show that infamously only opened three sides of the building up due to poor sales. The quartet weren't entirely responsible - no performers are now - but an evident malaise had crept in as result of the angle.

The exact same crowd that stuck with her through years of doldrum booking simply didn't have half the energy to power her out of unfavourable circumstances after the mountain had been scaled. Especially when the end product was so dire. After a dispiriting two-month run, the idea was nuked.

2. Sunny

Though the internet was relatively primitive by today's standards, it did at least still exist in 1996, just as an FYI for all those incredibly weird folk that say things like "Imagine if Twitter had been around when False Equivalency Did A Thing!" to try and make a useless point about useless booking.

Advertisement

And while you couldn't condense a terrible thought into 280 characters back then, you could at very least engage slightly more with the things you loved due to websites and forums that were still finding themselves along with the brave new medium. And on this internet, Sunny was queen.

AOL's most downloaded celebrity of 1996, 'The Golden Haired Fox' was in demand when little else about WWE was, but Vince McMahon's attempt to transfer her obvious magnetism onto a listless tag division failed her and failed miserably.

Sunny started the year with The Bodydonnas before briefly alligning with The Godwinns as a way to set up one final pivot to The Smoking Gunns. Tag gold followed her as was her remit, but the only "Hulkdust" principle didn't work this time around. The teams weren't so much hot as burned by the glare of her superstar aura, and when it all came crumbling down eith the collapse of the Gunns in October, WWE didn't really have a Plan B.

By the end of the year, she'd surrendered her last managerial duties when Farooq left her employ to form the Nation Of Domination. Guest referee/ring announcer roles and a short stint with The Legion Of Doom was all she had to fill her time between then and her July 1998 release.

1. Stone Cold Steve Austin & Sable

Chasing numbers through any method they could in the heat of a wrestling war they were mostly losing, WWE's experimental 1997 was and is a thing of hideous beauty.

Advertisement

Such was the case in May when, on a sardonic hunt for a potential tag team partner, Stone Cold Steve Austin stormed in on a half-naked Sable.

The aims were threefold and cynical; A white hot 'Rattlesnake' was so dismissive of earnestly needing a partner that he was willing to - gasp -pick a woman?!?!?!?!?! Hilarious, eh? That she had to cover herself with a cannily-placed Austin 3:16 shirt surely helped shift a few thousand more of those. And of course, the tease of accidentally seeing some f*cking t*ts because the goddamned horniness of everything was really starting to get out of hand by then.

It was trivial nonsense not that becoming of what Austin was building for himself, and his abrupt and aggressive nature in this specific environment doesn't scan great through the modern lens.

A year later, they'd share the screen one more time in throwaway scene Bruce Prichard still fondly recalls on his podcasts to this day. The company were never able to revisit the strange fascination, and that's perhaps for the best.

Advertisement