10 Key Personalities That WWE Underappreciates

Who has WWE taken for granted?

By Matt Davis /

It's fair to say that, over the past thirty five years, Vince McMahon and WWE have established a poor habit of greatly under-appreciating some of their most valuable contributors. Regardless of how they ended up in the unenviable position they are in, too many former WWE personalities have had their place in history slighted for one reason or another. In almost every case, it is varying degrees unfortunate and sad to see the hard work and sacrifices that these individuals have made throughout their career not receive the same type of recognition had it been credited to someone else, someone that is on the good side of Vince & Co. Despite what Vince McMahon would have people believe, loyalty to the WWE doesn't always pay off. Sure, there are some individuals whose careers would make a good argument against this point. Guys like The Undertaker, Pat Patterson, Howard Finkel, and Shawn Michaels come to mind. But tell that to Bret Hart, Bobby Heenan, or even Shane McMahon. Some stars may deserve the heat, but the ten personalities we're looking at here are given nowhere near the amount of respect that they should be. The good news is that, in many cases, this doghouse is not a place of permanent residence. Time has proven that WWE have the ability to resolve issues like they did with Bruno Sammartino and Alundra Blayze, but the mending of fences doesn't always include a return to previous prominence. Even after making up, the company still may not give these individuals the proper credit they deserve. Sometimes it's one-strike-and-you're-out. There's a number of people that have ended up on this list - the list of the most under-appreciated former WWE personalities - but these 10 personalities remain the most egregious.

10. Jim Ross

Jim Ross is well respected throughout the industry as one of, if not the, greatest play-by-play man in pro-wrestling history. As good as JR is at calling matches, he may have been even better at scouting talent. Just look at some of the names that WWE signed under Ross' watch: Brock Lesnar, The Rock, Mick Foley, Kurt Angle, John Cena, Edge, Randy Orton, Batista...the list goes on. No one in the history of talent relations can lay claim to hiring a list of superstars quite like JR can. Imagine if JR decided to pass on just one of those names. How different would the world of sports-entertainment be? Obviously, the Oklahoman isn't perfected as there have been some potential signees he's missed over the years (AJ Styles, Kharma, etc), but his track record is exemplary but speaks for itself. Why, then, is the single greatest commentator in WWE history, who also happens to be significantly responsible for the talent development of the greatest stars in company history, not treated with the utmost respect by WWE?

9. Kevin Nash

One thing that has proven to be true throughout the history of Vince McMahon's WWE is that while loyalty isn't always rewarded, disloyalty leaves a stench that can never be completely washed out. It can be temporarily covered up, hidden or even ignored, but the odor will eventually overpower everything else, leaving a long-lasting, negative effect. Unfortunately, several people on this list have made a decision that, like the bad smell, has stayed with them much longer than it should have. No matter how much they wish they could move on from it and wash it out, WWE just won't let them. Had Big Daddy Cool Diesel remained with the WWF in 1996 instead of signing with rival WCW, Kevin Nash could have reached WWE icon status, on the level of Shawn Michaels, The Undertaker and Steve Austin. By early '96, the big seven-footer was well on his way to this "spot" regardless of his in-ring limitations, his friends, or his love of backstage politics. But then he signed with Ted Turner and WCW and made history. When he returned to WWE in 2002, his status within the company was far from what it would've been had he remained with Titan. Injuries didn't do Big Sexy any favors, but similar setbacks didn't prevent Austin, Undertaker or Michaels' from keeping their place on the Mount Rushmore of WWE lore. His WCW defection is unlikely to spawn any major regret on Nash's part, considering the amount of money it netted for him and his family. Still, in terms of his pro-wrestling reputation (now owned by WWE), his career narrative, and his position within the company, there's no question Nash's legacy suffered when he turned away from Vince McMahon in 1996 The 2015 Hall Of Famer is regarded as being a key player during the 90s, especially throughout the Monday Night War, but his name and place within the industry has been softened over the years. Yes, he's a Hall of Famer, but he isn't the main event Hall of Famer that he should be.

8. Kurt Angle

The 1996 Olympic Gold Medalist is often spoken of as being one of the quickest learners in pro-wrestling history. In addition, his workrate was second-to-none and he is often considered the greatest wrestler of his generation by many of his peers. Shawn Michaels, generally considered one the best ever, has even named Kurt when discussing opponents he thought he may have had to train harder for (when discussing his preparation for their WrestleMania 21 classic). Aside from Michaels, Kurt Angle has had so many legendary matches with Brock Lesnar, Rey Mysterio, The Rock, Triple H, Austin, Shane McMahon and scores more that his place in wrestling history should be firmly planted. But as important as Angle was to WWE between his 1999-2006 run, his legacy and contributions have been all but ignored since he was granted his release in 2006. Whether there are lingering personal issues, ill-will, or some other secret reason for Angle seemingly being blacklisted from WWE, he is one of the greatest workers of all-time and also, currently, one of the most under-appreciated personalities in WWE history. That WWE won't grant Angle a part-time comeback after he lobbied so hard for it, speaks volumes.

7. Scott Hall

Scott Hall's career will be forever linked with that of Kevin Nash, aka Diesel, and vice versa. Like Nash's portrayal of Diesel, Hall's Razor Ramon was the very first superstar that WWE presented as a babyface despite having many of the characteristics and behaviors associated with a heel. In this regard, Scott Hall's personification of Razor Ramon planted the seeds for future anti-hero personalities, most notably Stone Cold Steve Austin. Along with Nash, Hall left for WCW in 1996 and returned to WWE in 2002, but the decision to defect to the competition in the mid-90s is something that WWE will never allow 'The Bad Guy' to forget. Nash's injuries were the scapegoat for his failed return in 2002, while Hall's struggles with substance abuse were enough for WWE to cut him loose and distance themselves from him. Over the past few years Hall has cleaned himself up quite a bit and the company has been giving him chances to get more involved with the current product. The 2014 Hall Of Famer recently began helping out NXT talents at the WWE Performance Center. Regardless of what the future holds, Scott Hall's impact on the sport of professional wrestling, and WWE specifically, has few equals. Unfortunately, Hall and Nash both had their name forever stamped once they signed for WCW, and while Vince McMahon may forgive, he never forgets. The forthcoming WWE-produced Scott Hall documentary sure will be interesting...

6. Ken Shamrock

Ken Shamrock is a WWE pioneer as he was one of the very first shoot fighters that the company presented as part of their main roster. The World's Most Dangerous Man was the biggest name in MMA in the mid-90s and, despite having trained as a pro-wrestler before making his name in the UFC and Japan, his signing with WWE was big news. It also asked big questions regarding his chances for success in making the transition. Some of those questions were answered immediately upon his debut when he was positioned in a very high profile spot, guest refereeing the WrestleMania 13 Submission Match between Bret Hart and Stone Cold Steve Austin. Following his post-match altercation with The Hitman and the way the company booked Shamrock throughout the Summer and Fall of 1997, it seemed like the sky was the limit for him. Unfortunately, Shamrock would never reach the main event heights that he seemed to be so destined for early in his WWE career. By all accounts, the man caught on to the WWE style rather quickly and, unlike fellow UFC alumni Dan Severn (who would enter the company a year later), Shamrock "got it". His successful crossover from the UFC paved the way for future athletes of other non-traditional sports and genres to make a successful run in the world of sports-entertainment. Despite his legitimate status as a pioneer and the impact he had on paving the way for future stars like Kurt Angle, Brock Lesnar, and others, Shamrock remains relatively overlooked by WWE today. Whether there is some sort of tension between Shamrock and the company isn't quite clear, but the former Intercontinental Champion deserves more recognition than he has received up to this point.

5. CM Punk

CM Punk has been one of the most influential wrestlers of the current decade. His (in)famous 2011 "pipe bomb" promo blended kayfabe and reality in a way that had not been seen in years. His look was far from the WWE preferred, yet he still found a way to break into the main event scene. Punk crossed over into the world of pop culture, eclipsing professional wrestling, making him the type of superstar that's very hard to find and hold onto in today's entertainment world. These are just some examples of why Punk should be held in higher regard than he is within the company, but the issues surrounding his 2014 departure, and more so Punk's actions after it, have pitted these two sides against each other in a very real feud that is unlikely to be settled for years. The bottom line is that WWE didn't know what they had with Punk until it was too late. In 2011, the company had a last-minute chance to change things and salvage their relationship with the real-life Phil Brooks, but they dropped the ball. Far from completely innocent in terms of how his time in WWE was handled, Punk is not even mentioned on WWE television today. Many of his contributions to the company are ones that WWE would rather not have, but he still did plenty of good for the company that they should have appreciated him more than they did.

4. Randy Savage

Make no mistake about it - 'Macho Man' Randy Savage is still vastly under-appreciated by those in power in WWE, despite being inducted into the WWE Hall Of Fame in 2015. The fact that he wasn't inducted into the Hall Of Fame back when the company "resurrected" the institution in 2004 was a slap in the face to the all-time great. The overused cliche' of "he should have his own wing" would apply here if not for the fact that an entire wing wouldn't be large enough to properly honor the Macho Man. Randy Savage's influence on not only WWE, but the industry as a whole is immeasurable. At a time when Hulk Hogan was to wrestling what The Beatles were to music, Randy Savage was every bit as believable as The Hulkster and was just slightly below Hogan in terms of star power. This wasn't because of anything Savage lacked and in fact he often out-shined Hogan in many areas. It was because the amount of promotion, marketing, hype and support that the WWE machine gave to Hogan paled in comparison to what Savage saw. For Randy to be in the position he was in, rivalling Hogan's popularity and celebrity status in the 80s, despite the lack of equal support from the WWF really says it all. He got over based on talent, hard work and sheer force of personality. Despite public outcry for Savage to be inducted into the WWE Hall Of Fame for years, it wasn't until 2015 that the Macho Man finally received the honour, being inducted posthumously. Still, WWE doesn't give Savage the treatment that he deserves, which would be similar to the treatment Vince McMahon himself receives. Ignoring the hundreds of WWE superstars that the Macho Man inspired, if it weren't for his talents and success in drawing viewers during the 80s and 90s, professional wrestling and WWE would not exist in the way we know it to now.

3. Bruce Prichard

When WWE speaks about it's high-ranking officials over the years and the importance and influence several former associates to Vince McMahon have had, one name is often glossed over. We've heard about Pat Patterson and George Scott's contributions to the business, as well as Gerry Brisco, Gorilla Monsoon and Chief Jay Strongbow, but the one name that doesn't get mentioned nearly as much as it should is Bruce Prichard. Prichard was an integral component to WWE television throughout a career which lasted over 20 years. Prichard was responsible for many of the biggest wrestling storylines and angles of the 80s and 90s, such as the oft-highlighted D-Generation X invasion of WCW at Norfolk, VA. There was an obvious falling out that lead to Prichard's release in 2008, as he did not get along with Stephanie McMahon. Unfortunately, this is not the first time that a conflict of personalities involving Stephanie has lead to the company moving on from and ditching a valuable employee. That's something Vince McMahon used to do on only the rarest of occasions as business usually came first. At the very least, Bruce Prichard belongs in the WWE Hall Of Fame for all of his contributions to the world of sports-entertainment, specifically WWE. At the most, he should still be working with Vince and held in the same regard as Pat Patterson, since it was primarily those three men that penned the stories which laid the foundation for everything that WWE would become.

2. Bret Hart

Bret Hart should have been the Babe Ruth of professional wrestling. This was a phrase the Vince McMahon often used to describe the perennial WWE icon whose loyalty to the brand was unmatched. In reality, Bret was probably more like Willie Mays than Babe Ruth, as Bret was a five-tool player that could do it all better than pretty much anyone. Bret Hart was the model employee. Bret helped keep the WWF alive in times when it was circling the drain. Bret helped right the ship when numerous interim captains had it veering off towards an iceberg. Bret was the locker room leader - even The Undertaker listened to Bret. Bret's skills and professionalism as a teacher produced many future stars, none bigger than the company saviour (who is treated with the amount of reverence that Bret should be), Steve Austin. For some reason though, Bret as the company's premier performer was never enough for Vince as he was always looking past The Hitman in hopes of spotting the 'next big thing'. First it was Hulk Hogan during his brief return in early '93, then it was Lex Luger followed by Diesel, and next up was Shawn Michaels, but on every occasion, Bret once again found himself with the WWF Championship around his waist, which signalled that Bret was the top guy in the business. Even after turning down an incredibly lucrative offer from WCW ($9m over three years), Vince McMahon didn't appreciate Bret enough, despite the fact that Bret had signed a 20-year contract with Titan for far less money. How was he thanked for this display of loyalty? The Montreal Screwjob. While Bret and Vince would eventually settle their differences, Bret's status within the company would never reach the heights it did back in the mid-90s. Once again, Vince McMahon's misguided personal feelings and memories of the past have lead to a performer whom many consider to be the greatest of all-time not receiving the proper treatment. He is Babe Ruth, Willie Mays, and Mickey Mantle all rolled into one, but he's treated more like Frank Thomas or Cal Ripken, Jr. Both are Hall Of Famers that are still well respected, but they're not considered to be on the level of the greatest.

1. Vince Russo

Love him or hate him and love or hate his style, the impact this man had in turning the company around and opening Vince McMahon's eyes to what sports entertaining could be in 1996 cannot be denied. Vince Russo's writing and ideas helped the company move away from superstars like The Goon, Mantaur, and T.L. Hopper to instead pushing Stone Cold, The Rock, and Kane. Russo went from a staff writer for WWF Magazine to the head writer for the entire company inside a matter of months. Russo would struggle outside the WWF banner and his writing was far from perfect, but the fact is that his contributions to the WWF in the mid-to-late 90s were a catalyst for their financial turnaround. Russo was arguably just as important as the talent during his run because the performers are only as good as the stories that are written for them. Russo definitely could have handled his 1999 departure in a better, more professional manner, but this is far from the worst act ever done to a McMahon, yet the company refuses to give Russo the credit he deserves. Over the years, WWE has shown more respect to men like Ted Turner and Eric Bischoff than one of their own. That's right folks, WWE has shown more gratitude to the men who tried to put them out of business rather than the man whose vision and writing helped save the company. For that reason, there's no other personality that could take the top spot than Vince Russo.