10 Most Bizarre Hardcore Matches In Wrestling History
Wrestling: you're both dumber and funnier for enjoying it.
You are meant to feel excited - but mostly terrified - when a promoter books the “stipped-up” blow-off match.
Through total overkill and excess, this is nigh-on impossible to achieve in the modern era; you’ve seen virtually every demented spot there is, and they can’t seem to hurt that much, since the same wrestlers specialise in certain attractions.
“This incredibly dangerous match shortens careers, and is an absolute last resort - which is why we do it the same time every single year!”
AEW has managed to preserve the aura of the Texas Death match, after overdoing its Lights Out attraction and turning Anarchy In The Arena into something that’s probably more fun than scary. WWE still promotes wild stunt shows, but in 2024 is more into melodrama and “cinema” than violence as a selling point (that said, this year’s Women’s Money In The Bank ladder match was one of the most frightening attractions of the decade).
Many of the following matches were difficult to take seriously under the old premise/selling point - which makes you wonder why the promoter even bothered. Is it reductive to state “Because wrestling is absolutely stupid”?
Not really…
10. Eye For An Eye Match
WWE realised, early in the Pandemic era, that 27 minute matches between Apollo Crews and Aleister Black weren’t what the fans were after. The ratings told a rather bleak story.
WWE fans prize spectacle above most everything else - which was difficult to achieve in an empty glorified gym. In terms of noise, the ambience wasn’t too dissimilar to a standard abysmal 2019 Raw taping. WWE fans had grown accustomed to nobody giving a toss.
But visually, Christ almighty: the Performance Center backdrop was bleak.
Then. Now. Together. Forever.
Then. Now. Forever? Distanced, more like.
And so, WWE decided to get very, very hokey with its attractions. When not veering into the realms of “cinema” - features by which McG would be appalled - the company booked an Eye For An Eye match between Seth Rollins and Rey Mysterio at the aptly-named Horror Show at Extreme Rules.
The aim of the match was for one man to remove the other’s eyeball. Senselessly, Seth and Rey worked hard and put on a flashy plunder brawl lasting 18 minutes, and for what? It could have been the Match of the Year for 17 minutes; the last minute was always going to position it as the Worst.
Seth pretended a pool ball half-painted pink was Rey’s actual eye, and won. The prop was absolutely pathetic, almost as bad as the idea itself.
9. Arcade Anarchy
Arcade Anarchy should not have worked.
The Best Friends Vs. Miro and Kip Sabian programme had dragged on longer than a Triple H match at WrestleMania; Miro’s ‘Best Man’ schtick was a misfire; the levity of the tone risked veering into silly territory.
In reality, the match was a brutal and memorable spectacle that located an impossible sweet spot between fun, violent and moving.
The uso of Lego-as-thumbtacks was particularly inspired. It was an in-character choice by the in-arrested-development Best Friends unit, and while few people have experienced the sensation of an unprotected chair shot to the dome, everybody has stepped on a toy or a plug. Arcade Anarchy was a match you could both watch and feel.
Very well-crafted - as fans probably should have expected, actually, from underrated genre wizard Chuck Taylor - it was also the site of Kris Statlander’s return from a lengthy injury layoff.
This saw AEW operating at its thoughtful, detail-obsessed best: the space alien character emerged from the Toy Story alien claw machine.
8. Lights Out (NXT Version)
In the Florida territory, the Lights Out match was designed to convey the idea that the imminent violence was such a frightening and dangerous prospect that the promoter could not sanction it, lest he was legally liable.
AEW attempted to revive it as their signature gimmick, and for one night, it worked: Kenny Omega Vs. Jon Moxley actually terrified people at Full Gear 2019. Beyond that, the stip was bastardised as a glorified plunder match that could have existed under any name - Street Fight, No DQ, whatever.
Shawn Michaels’ NXT attempted a version of it, but because it’s NXT, it was a joke. You see, one of the wrestlers involved, Wendy Choo, was sleepy. So they turned the Lights Out (which you do before you go to sleep). Instead of a table, Choo put opponent Tiffany Stratton through a bed frame. Instead of a black sack, Choo emptied Lego pieces from a pillowcase. Oh, and because Stratton plays a spoiled princess, one of the chairs was pink.
What is Shawn Michaels cooking, exactly?
Crap?
Is he frying up a big greasy load of crap?
7. Anus Explosion Death Match
The object of the Anus Explosion Death Match was for one wrestler to insert a firework into the anus of another wrestler, and then light it.
Promoted well past FMW’s peak drawing years on a schlocky curiosity basis, it sort of worked; for a match held in Korakuen and not the huge stadiums of the heyday, its legend prevails. It’s an unforgettable premise, taking on a life of its own that vastly exceeded its appeal at the time.
The premise works, because the prospect is terrifying. A searing firework ripping you several new assholes, rocketing past your guts, and exploding through what’s left of your internal organs? Who would want to experience that?
….and who wouldn’t want to check it out?
The premise worked, the finish…did not.
Basically, an unmasked Hayabusa, working as ‘H’, wrestled his tormenting doppelganger ‘Hayabusa’ (Mr. Gannosuke), had his anus exploded. Except he didn’t. It was a firecracker, not a good or spectacular firework, and it sparked pathetically nowhere near his asshole.
The structural integrity of Hayabusa’s anus remained intact; the only thing that got ripped off was the fans.
6. King Of The Road Match
WCW was the funniest wrestling promotion to ever exist.
It was also the most tragic wrestling promotion to ever exist. It wasn’t bad in a lazy way. It was bad because they shot for the stars with a quite deluded sense of ambition. No idea was too grand. WCW was a simple southern promotion, you might say a group of cockeyed optimists, which just wanted to do mad things.
One such mad thing was the infamous ‘King Of The Road’ match from Uncensored 1995 between Dustin Rhodes and the Blacktop Bully - which was fought on the caged-off trailer on the back of the latter’s truck.
While it was moving.
Hey, taking inspiration from Mad Max worked for WarGames - but this was less ‘Mad Max’ and more ‘Sh*tty Pete’. The truck trundled along at a leisurely pace - it was too slow to convey a sense of careening danger, but evidently fast enough to make the wrestlers climb the structure very tentatively.
Almost as deranged as it was boring, it was as impressively bad as Savage Vs. Steamboat was impressively good.
5. Dungeon Match
At Fully Loaded: In Your House - promoted in 1998, during which the WWF for better and worse was creatively frenzied - Owen Hart defeated Ken Shamrock in a completely unique and, yes, bizarre gimmick match.
It was a submissions rules match performed (and pre-taped) in the unique locale of the legendary Hart Family’s Dungeon - a wild move, considering Bret Hart’s infamous exit from the promotion in the prior December.
It wasn’t a classic, or anything, but it was adventurous and brief: the exact sort of match through which the WWF was such a compelling and breezy watch during that era.
It stood out because the Dungeon was an unforgiving physical environment of thick walls and floor. Every single bump looked agonising; it’s little wonder it went under five minutes. It wasn’t visually satisfying in the manner of other plunder brawls - there were no exploding tables, nor any huge freefall stunts - because the Dungeon was a dank, poorly-lit dump.
It was, however, an aural nightmare with a thudding physicality that made you question the wisdom of what Owen Hart and Ken Shamrock were doing.
4. Chamber Of Horrors
At WCW Halloween Havoc ‘91, Sting, the Steiner Brothers and El Gigante defeated Abdullah the Butcher, Vader, Cactus Jack and the Diamond Studd in a ‘Chamber of Horrors’ match.
It was drastically terrible, but not in a so-bad-it’s-good sort of way. It just went on and on and on forever.
The actual cage wasn’t even good, which wasn’t a good omen - it looked like a sturdy domed jail cell that nobody was willing to throw themselves into - and that’s before you consider the dire, goofy props and non-weapons. Caskets, shrunken heads: the bollocks littering the ring was about as scary as Kane.
To win, a wrestler from one team had to place an opposing wrestler into the ‘Chair of Torture’, pull the ‘Fatal Lever’, and “electrocute” them. Cactus Jack, under the mistaken impression that Rick Steiner was in the chair, pulled the lever. Abdullah was in it, and he sold the electrocution, despite a production delay, by vibrating.
Still a better cage match than Triple H Vs. Shawn Michaels at Badd Blood 2004.
3. Kennel From Hell
This was a quintessentially Vince Russo idea, in that it was brain stem dead.
What, bro, is better than a cage match, which is automatically better than a regular old boring catch-as-catch-can?
A match with two cages.
At Unforgiven 1999, Al Snow and the Big Boss Man wrestled a match within the ‘Kennel From Hell’: the old WWF blue bar cage housed within Hell In A Cell. The twist?
Snarling dawgs were trapped between the cages, baying for blood.
At least, that was the idea; in reality, they were tame, only marginally less horny than Jerry Lawler a mere few feet away, and busting to piss n’ poop. They posed no threat to Snow and the Boss Man, and nor did Snow and the Boss Man pose a threat to one another, since they basically spent the entire, quite literal s***-show climbing the cages.
It was an atrocious execution of an unworkable idea that anybody not named Vince Russo could have foreseen being terrible.
Never work with children or animals - or Vince Russo, who’s dumber than both.
2. Judy Bagwell On A Forklift
Vince Russo was obsessed with poles.
Weirdly, the pioneer of the Kennel From Hell match was obsessed with watching wrestlers climb. He famously deemed traditional wrestling a boring pursuit, one in which he didn’t believe the “casual fan” held much interest. He did not think wrestling fans would enjoy wrestling watches, but he did think they’d enjoy watching them climb and retrieve an object from a pole. Climbing is one of the least-watched sports globally. To determine something equally as unpopular, as a comparison, burrow through Russo’s TNA pay-per-view buy amounts.
At New Blood Rising - the most infamously terrible mainstream wrestling show of all-time - Buff Bagwell defeated Kanyon in a ‘Judy Bagwell on a Forklift’ match.
You see, the joke here was that Judy, Bagwell’s shoot mother, was a rotund lady. And could not, therefore, fit atop a pole.
It was less a ‘hardcore’ match and more ‘a stunningly mediocre chinlock fest masquerading as a mean-spirited fat joke’, but it gets no weirder.
It’s more bizarre than Davey Boy Smith.
1. Invisible Match
A new trend developed within the late 2010s indie boom: the irony match.
Pioneered by Game Changer Wrestling, these matches were largely a visual gag. The match graphic acted as the punchline to such an extent that the match itself was often immaterial. Scott Steiner once wrestled Hornswoggle, to provide an example of the genre. The promise was never really delivered. You were meant to laugh at the idea and get conned into paying for it.
Except, GCW did deliver on at least one occasion: a match wrestled between two “invisible” wrestlers, the Invisible Man and Invisible Stan.
This was actually a triumphant experimental piece of comedy masterminded and performed - incredibly - by referee Bryce Remsburg.
Almost as good a one-man show as Bret Hart at SummerSlam 1992, Remsburg was great - but the fans also played an instrumental role, picking up the cue of a camera operator retreating backwards to know when Invisible Stan was “passing” them and reacting accordingly.
Remsburg summoned the illusion by frantically pounding the mat with back-and-forth two counts, giving the impression that the two wrestlers were engaged in a scorching duel of cradle attempts.