10 Most Ridiculous Variations Of WWE Matches
What's better than a cage match? A cage match surrounded by horny dogs, of course.
Innovation is essential to progress. Especially in professional wrestling.
Without innovation, we would still be stuck with four hour-long grapple-fests that, while resembling actual Greco-Roman wrestling, would bore the audience to tears (if there even was an audience anymore). It was because of innovation that the Hardyz and Edge & Christian moved from just tag team matches to tag team ladder matches to triangle ladder matches (now with the Dudley Boyz) to the iconic TLC matches, which, to this day, have yet to be matched in quality.
Furthermore, it was because of innovation that those three-team ladder matches moved on from being focused on midcard teams and midcard belts to drastically altering the main event scene, with Money in the Bank becoming an annual staple.
However, some innovations are just misguided. A few add a rule to a match that renders said match illogical. Sometimes, the rules themselves are outright confusing. And others, the match is altered in a way where you’re embarrassed as a fan to be watching it.
Frankly, there's a whole slew of match types which should have never left the creative meetings.
10. Extreme Elimination Chamber (December To Dismember 2006)
Much has been written about December to Dismember 2006, not least of which its debacle of a main event, the "Extreme" Elimination Chamber. What was so "extreme" about it?
Two men (Rob Van Dam and Hardcore Holly) would start off one-on-one like a standard Chamber match, and also like a standard Chamber, a new wrestler would come out of their pod every five minutes. However, in every pod, each wrestler had a weapon they could use upon entering the match. CM Punk had a steel chair, Test had a crowbar, Bobby Lashley had a table, and Big Show had a barbed wire baseball bat.
Obviously, the question is: Why do you need weapons to make an Elimination Chamber seem extreme?
By 2006, the Elimination Chamber was still fairly new, and hadn’t been run into the ground. Matches such as the inaugural contest from Survivor Series 2002 showed how brutal and chaotic things could get just from having six men inside the steel structure. Adding gimmicky weapons is redundant at best, and at worst, reeks of desperately trying to make the match feel like it was ECW. Ironically, it was arguably the most tepid Elimination Chamber at that point. Lashley, the winner and Vince’s obsession at the time, emerged from the match completely unscathed, despite going one-on-one with the Big Show, who had a barbed wire baseball bat!
Nothing says ECW Champion quite like a ripped adonis protected by management.
9. Kennel From Hell (Unforgiven 1999)
Of course this match was going to be on this list. Which others feature animals copulating?
So Al Snow and the Big Boss Man were feuding over the Hardcore Championship. To play mind games with Al, Boss Man did the classic heel move of killing Al’s dog and feeding it to him. “Classic,” of course, meaning “really stupid and trying too hard to shock.”
So rather than, well, calling the police and having Boss Man arrested, Al did the next best thing and challenged him to a new match entitled Kennel From Hell. Essentially a cage match variation, Kennel From Hell had the two start inside a steel cage which was surrounded by the Hell in a Cell. In the ring area outside the cage, however, were dogs. These dogs were supposed to be rabid, but of course, the WWF was not going to incur the wrath of animal rights groups and law enforcement by actually putting wild dogs in their match. Thus, these dogs had attendants, and showed no signs of hostility whatsoever. Rather than try to attack Al and Bossman, they instead pooped, peed, and got their freak on with each other.
Side note: this was the last pay-per-view Vince Russo booked for the WWF. What a way to go out.
8. Sledgehammer Ladder Match (TLC 2011)
In the chaos that was the Summer of Punk storyline from 2011, Kevin Nash found himself involved. Originally set to feud with Punk, Nash was unable to get medical clearance in time for Night of Champions, and thus, Kliq-mate Triple H picked up the slack. However, not one to deny his buddy a payday, Hunter took on Nash at TLC in a “Sledgehammer Ladder Match,” wherein the match would end via pinfall, but if either man could climb a ladder and grab the sledgehammer hung above the ring, it was a legal weapon.
Goldberg and Scott Hall had performed a similar match for WCW back in 1999, where that match was a “Stun Gun Ladder Match,” and the objective was to retrieve a taser and zap your opponent with it. The difference between that match and the one at TLC 2011 was that Goldberg and Hall were at least both mobile. The same could not be said of Kevin Nash, whose age, massive size, and bad knees had caught up to him. Triple H, himself a big guy, had to carry the slog of an encounter. It’s one of the slowest, most plodding ladder matches you will ever see in the modern era.
7. Chairs Match (TLC 2009)
The TLC match has become so watered down in modern WWE, thanks in large part to its status as a yearly pay-per-view event. To add to the nonsense, almost every TLC pay-per-view features, in addition to the titular match, a tables match, a ladder match, and a chairs match. What, you ask is a chairs match? Join the club, because nobody can figure that out either. The running joke of chairs matches is that nobody has any idea what the rules are exactly.
Ostensibly a No Holds Barred match, it’s an excuse for wrestlers to perform chair spots. Namely: hitting each other with them, and taking back bumps onto a large pile of them. Thrilling stuff! Except, the problem is that in the inaugural contest in 2009, it wasn't even clear if it was a No Holds Barred match.
The story of the match between Batista and The Undertaker was that nobody--not the refs, not the commentators, not the wrestlers, not the fans--knew the exact rules. The commentators were openly asking if they could get counted out. For all we knew, they could, since Batista originally won the match via a low blow, but Teddy Long came out and reversed the decision, saying that chairs were legal, but low blows weren’t. So the question became: if Batista had used a chair to hit ‘Taker below the belt, would it have counted? Nowadays, WWE seem to have classified chairs matches as No Holds Barred, but even to this day, nobody’s quite sure.
6. Stairs Match (TLC 2014)
Now here’s one that’s just plain silly. We can go ahead and classify this as a variation of the chairs match, as it's the same sort of lame idea. In late 2014, Big Show and Erick Rowan were feuding, and after attacking each other with stairs, it was decided they would compete in a stairs match - where the use of stairs as a weapon was legal.
To their credit, Show and Rowan tried hard to make creative use out of the stairs. Unfortunately, there wasn’t much they could do without exposing the fact that the “steel” stairs were more akin to aluminum foil than the 500-pound steel behemoths the commentary likes to sell them as. Thus, there hasn't been a stairs match since, which I’m sure makes all of you very sad.
5. Cage Matches That Can End Via Pinfall And Escaping The Cage (Various)
The original cage matches were designed so that nobody could weasel out of the fight and no one on the outside could interfere. Eventually, WWE changed it so that to win the match, you had to escape the cage first, which generated classics such as Bret Hart vs. Owen Hart at SummerSlam 1994. At some point, it was decided that cage matches could end via escape, or pinfall or submission. And since the cage has a door with an attendant, and is open-air, its function as an enclosure is completely useless.
It’s especially egregious when it’s used to blow off a feud. For example, in 2013, Triple H and Brock Lesnar finished their trilogy with a cage match at Extreme Rules. Here were two behemoths ready to kill each other, and a few minutes in, they’re trying to win by just walking out of the cage. It’s fine to have matches that are only won via escape, but the fact that WWE try to add pins and submissions to the equation means it’s hard to take cage matches seriously anymore.
4. The Triple H-Carlito Match (Unforgiven 2007)
Here’s a stipulation that doesn't seem to have been repeated, and for good reason. It was a No Holds Barred match, but only for Carlito. Should Triple H have used any weapons, he would be disqualified. Carlito took advantage, and brought a great deal of weapons to the ring. Was this an opportunity for the younger star Carlito to get one up on established main eventer Triple H?
No. Triple H instead ran roughshod over poor Carlito, destroying him in about 10 minutes. As an added middle finger, he even got in a low-blow on Carlito while the ref was distracted. Triple H is the greatest babyface of all time, guys. Matches like these are a reminder that for every instance when Triple H puts over someone on a big stage, he’s also prone to crap like this.
3. Any Tag Match For A Singles Title (Various)
The Attitude era was famous for overbooked nonsense, and what’s more overbooked and nonsensical than a tag team match for a singles title? Matches of this type play into the Attitude era’s love of uneasy alliances and people turning against each other.
Nowhere was this more prevalent than at King of the Ring 2000, when The Rock, Kane, and The Undertaker took on McMahon-Helmsley Faction members Triple H, Vince, and Shane in a six-man tag match for the WWF Championship. It was a chaotic main event that saw ostensible partners Rock, Kane, and ‘Taker attack each other in addition to the heel team. After all, whoever got the pinfall won the title, so what reason did these three have to cooperate? Moreover, in the midst of the chaos, Rock didn't even pin the champion Triple H to win the title, but Vince. What a definitive and satisfying conclusion to Hunter and Rock’s months-long feud, amirite?
There are other examples of tag matches for singles titles, and all of them follow the pattern of being overbooked and nonsensical at their core. Unless it’s two stables desperate to keep a title “in the family,” there’s really no reason to have matches of this type.
2. The RAW Bowl (Monday Night RAW 01/1/1996)
Vince McMahon would like very much for you to associate his brand with anything other than that wrasslin’ nonsense. For example, he drools at the prospect of earning the same amount of prestige and exposure the NFL does, as evidenced by the XFL debacle. But five years before Vince tried and failed to make a football league, he unleashed the RAW Bowl unto the world just in time for college bowl season and the NFL playoffs.
In a match that pitted the 1-2-3 Kid & Sycho Sid vs. The Smokin’ Gunns vs. Owen Hart & Yokozuna vs. Razor Ramon & Savio Vega, this was actually WWE’s first Fatal 4-way match (sort of). Its rules were so ridiculous, that WWE themselves made a video making fun of it:
As hilarious as it is to see WWE willfully bury their own creation, that video lies at the end. They actually did the RAW Bowl twice, with it making a comeback in 1997. Only this time, it was for an episode of Superstars, and thus called the Superstars Bowl. That match pitted the Nation of Domination vs. Doug Furnas & Philip LaFon vs. The Godwinns vs. Owen Hart & The British Bulldog. This time, there was no green ring, and everyone was dressed as themselves (aside from the Godwinns, who had jerseys under their overalls). The New Generation Era was generally chockful of absurdity, but the fact that WWE would try this match again is absurd.
1. TLC Matches That End In Pinfall (TLC 2012 And 2014)
In essence: what is a TLC match? You could say that they’re a ladder match with extra gimmicks. Ordinarily, you’d be correct. However, in 2012 and 2014, WWE exposed them for what they really are: a naked excuse to do spots with tables, ladders, and chairs. You see, there’s nothing that stops competitors from utilizing spots with those weapons in other extreme stipulations (I Quit, Last Man Standing, etc), but when you add the name TLC, the fans are conditioned to expect spots with those weapons and those weapons alone.
Such was the case in 2012, when The Shield took on Team Hell No and Ryback, and in 2014, when Dean Ambrose fought Bray Wyatt. There were no titles on the line, so using the ladder was pointless aside from being something off which to jump. But really, these were just No Holds Barred matches with fancy names.
Now granted, the match between The Shield and Ryback/Team Hell No from TLC 2012 is awesome, but why was it a TLC match? Well, simple: they were at a show called TLC, and WWE cares more about branding than they do making sense. It doesn’t matter if the original logic behind TLC is watered down. What matters to management is cramming a match called TLC onto a show called TLC.