10 Most Terrifying Wrestlers Of All Time

Just in time for Halloween.

By Jacques Martin /

Over the years, professional wrestling has given audiences several characters that were created to terrify the masses.

Advertisement

Of course, in the world of sports entertainment, the line between frightening and comical is often razor-thin. To illustrate the previous point, look no further than acts like The Yeti and Damien Demento. The pair were supposed to be creepy but were far more likely to incite laughter than a feeling of genuine terror.

That being said, when done correctly, the "creepy heel persona" can work brilliantly.

Of course, when one thinks of terrifying wrestlers, it's easy to default to vampires, boogeymen, and characters that are clearly designed to be eerie. However, some of the most frightening wrestlers weren't trying to portray the supernatural.

As we are about to see, there are several reality-based personas that are more than capable of sending a chill down any wrestling fan's spine.

While there are a few obvious entries, this list isn't full of lazy choices like Gangrel, Kevin Thorne, or wrestlers who were supposed to be some sort of actual monster. Instead, we are going to focus on characters that were genuinely terrifying — often for very different reasons.

10. Ox Baker

At 6'5" with black, bushy eyebrows, looking intimidating came somewhat naturally for Ox Baker. Take those elements combined with the shaved head and Fu Manchu, and you have one scary looking individual.

Advertisement

However, it wasn't just Baker's appearance that made him terrifying. In an era when kayfabe was still alive and well, the big man was said to have killed two of his opponents with his finishing move, the dreaded 'Heart Punch'.

A few days after a match with Baker, a wrestler named Alberto Torres died of a ruptured appendix. However, the AWA decided to blame the Heart Punch as part of the storyline.

Roughly a year later, in August 1972, another one of Baker's opponents, Ray Gunkel, passed away in the locker room after their match. This time, it was a hematoma caused by the finisher that resulted in a heart attack. In essence, albeit indirectly, the move was responsible for someone's death and, once again, was worked into the storyline.

It must have been an uneasy feeling for 1970s wrestling fans to sit ringside in close proximity to villainous-looking, 340-pound man who was said to have killed two people.

9. The Undertaker

Of course, a list of terrifying wrestlers wouldn't be complete without mentioning The Undertaker.

Advertisement

Mark Calaway took a gimmick that should have been a total disaster and turned it into one of the most iconic personas professional wrestling has ever seen. Who would have thought a character that is essentially supposed to be a walking dead guy would have a thirty-year run as a headlining act?

The slow, precise movements and rolling the eyes back, help add to 'Taker's supernatural mystique. However, perhaps the most frightening (and coolest) thing about "The Deadman" is his entrance. The chilling music combined with his slow walk to the ring is still unsettling after all these years.

Even though we now know he's really just a tall guy from Texas, The Undertaker still remains one of the creepiest characters to have ever set foot in a professional wrestling ring.

8. 'The French Angel' Maurice Tillet

Given that he wrestled in the 1940s, there are probably a fair number of folks who are reading about Maurice Tillet for the first time. That being said, there may be something strangely familiar about the 5'9" Frenchman who was once billed as the "World's Ugliest Man".

Advertisement

This familiarity likely stems from the fact that 'The French Angel' is rumored to have been the inspiration for the popular Dreamworks character Shrek.

Tillet's head was twice the size of an average man's his height. His hands were large enough to shuffle three decks of cards at the same time. The Frenchman's unusual proportions were the result of a condition called acromegaly.

Despite his appearance, outside the ring "The Angel" was a well-educated gentleman who received a law degree — though he never actually used it.

Gentleman or not, Tillet's old 1940s black and white promo photos are some of the creepiest images pro wrestling has ever seen.

7. Paul Bearer

When it comes to creepy wrestling managers, no one has done better than Paul Bearer.

Advertisement

His signature high pitched voice combined with his contorted facial expressions helped make The Undertaker's kayfabe father one of the most memorable characters to ever grace the small screen.

In truth, Paul Bearer often walked the line between being eerie and comical. That being said, there was still something very unsettling and believable about the persona.

Even though this over the top character was clearly fictional, as a fan, it was hard not to wonder if there wasn't something legitimately off about the man. Of course, creating that sort of believability is the ultimate goal for any wrestling personality.

The urn-toting mortician helped launch the career of one of the greatest wrestlers of all-time. The memory of Paul Bearer's shrill voice and chilling promos will no doubt continue to haunt fans for years to come.

6. Andre The Giant

On the surface, Andre The Gaint may seem like an odd choice for a list like this. After all, he wasn't portraying a supernatural being or crazed madman.

Advertisement

However, as a child, I was fortunate enough to see Andre perform live, toward the tail end of his career, and found him absolutely terrifying.

My father took me to a house show in the late 1980s; it would be the first and only time I ever saw the inaugural WWE Hall of Famer perform. At that point, Andre was donning the infamous black singlet and having a hard time getting around.

As a 9-year-old child (or thereabouts ), I couldn't take my eyes off the man; I had never seen a human being even close to that size.

I believe his opponent that evening was Hillbilly Jim if memory serves me. The entire match (including the entrances) couldn't have been more than two minutes long.

Almost as soon as the bell rang, Andre wrapped his massive hands around his opponent's throat and draped him over the top rope. Then, he looked up. His eyes were open wide, and he looked almost possessed. The big man then glared out into the audience and for a moment (though it may have just been a child's imagination), I could have sworn he looked right at me.

Roughly 30 years later, I still recall the uneasy feeling that came over me that night as a terrified young boy. To say I was frightened would be a massive understatement.

As for the match, after 'The Eighth Wonder of the World' refused to relinquish the chokehold, the referee disqualified him.

I don't recall who else wrestled that night, and I've probably seen over a thousand live matches since. However, even if I see a thousand more, I'll never forget the feeling that came over me when an angry giant looked me straight in the eyes.

5. The Fiend Bray Wyatt

In an era when fans can learn almost anything about their favorite wrestler online, it's much harder to promote a supernatural character or make them feel mysterious in any way.

Advertisement

However, in the post kayfabe error, The Fiend Bray Wyatt is doing an excellent job of keeping fans on their toes and has a frightening entrance that rivals The Undertaker's.

Moreover, Wyatt is perhaps the best character of his generation. His 'Firefly Fun House' performances are brilliant, and his superb acting has helped make the segments one of the best things WWE has done in a very long while.

Between his current persona and the old cult leader character, Bray Wyatt has given us two of the best boogeymen the WWE has ever seen.

Simply put, the man (Windham Rotunda) is eerily good at playing a psychopath and one of the most talented performers in the game today.

4. Jake 'The Snake' Roberts

Jake 'The Snake' Roberts didn't need his pet Damien to terrify the masses — though he certainly helped. With Roberts, is was his often soft-spoken, cerebral promos that made him such a creepy character.

Advertisement

At a time when most wrestlers screamed at the top of their lungs to get their point across, 'The Snake' calmly looked into the camera and shared his twisted thoughts. His relatively laid back demeanor and sinister expression always commanded the viewer's attention.

Roberts's approach was effective and it made him stand out. Watching a vintage Jake Roberts interview is roughly the equivalent to taking a masters' class in "how to cut a promo."

The WWE Hall of Famer is the perfect example of a wrestler who knew how to strike fear into the audience without overdoing it. This is one of the many reasons Jake Roberts' work holds up so incredibly well, even decades later.

3. Mankind

Though he would later find success as a comedy act, there was nothing funny about the Mankind that debuted in WWE back in the late-'90s.

Advertisement

From speaking to his pet rat George to pulling his own hair out, early Mankind was a disturbing individual. His iconic 1997 promo, in which the schizophrenic mad man attacked Jim Ross on Raw, was some of his best work. The incident also helped Mankind establish himself as a truly unpredictable individual.

The master of the mandible claw's creepy persona made him the perfect rival for The Undertaker in what would become (arguably) the most memorable feud of The Attitude Era. Foley's willingness to take excessive abuse, as he did in his legendary Hell in a Cell match, only served to make the deranged character even more believable.

These days, Mick Foley often portrays a teddy bear-like authority figure. However, in his prime, he was a pretty scary dude.

2. Bruiser Broody

At 6'8", 300lbs, Bruiser Brody was a naturally imposing figure. Of course, his unkempt long hair and bushy beard also helped significantly contribute to his unsettling appearance.

Advertisement

However, with Brody, it was his unpredictable nature and hard nose style that made him a truly scary individual. He was known to come to the ring swinging a chain, and often left it up to the audience members to get out of the way. He was frequently involved in matches that left him bloody and was very hostile with audience members.

When Brody and his longtime rival Abdullah the Butcher would fight outside the ring, fans would be sure to keep a safe distance so as to avoid being on the receiving end of a shot from either man — accidental or otherwise.

Bruiser Brody made everyone around him fear for their wellbeing when he performed, and it was never really clear how much of his behavior was intended to be part of the show.

1. Abdullah The Butcher

Abdullah the Butcher was "hardcore" before the term was even created. Debuting in the late-1950s, he was billed as a psychopath from Sudan (he was actually from Canada), and became known for bringing a rusty fork to the ring.

Advertisement

The Butcher lived up to his name and was involved in some of the bloodiest matches professional wrestling has ever seen. He would often legitimately stab opponents with sharp objects, including, but not limited to, his signature fork. Back in 2014, an opponent accused the WWE Hall of Famer of infecting him with hepatitis C. He claimed to have contracted the disease from one of The Butcher's blades.

Even opponents had to feel uneasy about stepping in the ring with Abdullah, as he was said to have cut other wrestlers without prior consent.

With a head full of scars, the blade-wielding madman was a shining example of a character that made fans think that "maybe this professional wrestling stuff isn't so fake after all".

Advertisement