10 Most Wasted Talents In WWE History

The seed can only germinate in Vince's grapefruits.

By Michael Sidgwick /

WWE.com

Vince McMahon is the greatest promoter in the history of professional wrestling.

Advertisement

The competition is stiff. Paul Heyman is largely credited with being the Mudhoney to McMahon's Nirvana - the man whose ideas he co-opted to break back through into the mainstream consciousness.

His own father, of course, a famously fair man among crooks, left the WWF in such a strong position that his son's national expansion wouldn't have been possible otherwise. Nepotism aside, Cowboy Bill Watts' popularisation of episodic TV programming is imprinted inextricably in pro wrestling's DNA. WCPW's own Eric Bischoff is particularly notable given that he entered and changed the game as a relative outsider.

Vince Jr. is by no means perfect, despite his standing as the unchallenged king of pro wrestling sports entertainment. His recent track record is evident of that. While he gets something of a pass in 2016 - this week's RAW really was as good as everybody is saying it is - he still has an irritating knack of impeding a wrestler's momentum just when they really begin to make a connection with the audience.

Going even further back, Vince was famously loathe to go all in on stars who had the gumption to make their name elsewhere. If only he had some of them at his disposal right now...

10. Goldberg

The Goldberg character books itself.

Advertisement

Famously limited between the ropes, Goldberg's arc in WCW was planned out meticulously. Learning as he went along, he was protected in the short, dynamic squash matches in which he carved out his fearsome aura.

When he ascended to the main event, even the legendarily inept latter-period WCW were astute enough to keep his matches as short as realistically possible. He was no Ric Flair in there, so he was presented as a wrecking machine accordingly.

His treatment in WWE was more wilful obstruction than oblivious bumbling. Tasked with wrestling standard back and forth bouts exceeding ten minutes in length, Goldberg, exposed as a worker, blended into the background.

Wrestling fans are notoriously hard to please, but one thing we're almost unanimously in favour of is recycling. Wrestling is - or should be - simple. If WWE had replicated Goldberg's streak, it's unlikely that fans would have cried unoriginality. Goldberg wasn't comfortable wrestling epic matches. Fans were bored watching them.

He left after just a year, citing creative frustration. His heart was never in the business, and moreover, nobody else could afford him or were willing to pay. Unlike some of the entries on this list, he shrugged off the experience...

9. Kaval

Brandon 'Kaval' Silvestry was doomed in record time.

Advertisement

Signed before WWE embraced the Independent scene, the former Low Ki, a decade-plus pro, was introduced to viewers as a rookie on the unquantifiable, counterproductive NXT TV show.

This was bad enough in itself. Kaval was a well-versed, immensely talented and unique wrestler. He was not a peer of Percy Watson. Worse still, his assigned 'pros' were Laycool. The original incarnation of NXT posed so many unanswerable questions that it remains unfathomable five years later.

Was this a rib? Did the dichotomy between his deep voice and overtly feminine screen partners make some easily-amused official laugh? Was it some sort of failed attempt at creating a groundswell of support from the minority of Independent fans, at whom the series decidedly wasn't aimed at?

Regardless, Kaval actually ended up winning the competition - but it was impossible to take him seriously afterwards, despite his thrilling but unsuccessful pursuit of Dolph Ziggler's United States championship. Incidentally, his defeat there rendered weeks' worth of TV time thoroughly pointless.

Kaval was so disheartened by his tenure that, before a brief retirement, he successfully sought his release the same year he debuted on the main roster.

8. Alex Riley

Alex Riley, another alumni of NXT season 2, wasn't exceptional between the ropes - but he was dynamite in the personality department.

Advertisement

NXT was seemingly designed to batter the confidence out of those unlucky enough to appear on it, in the hope that the mortifying experience would weed out the weak. Riley however was unflappable. Hilariously proclaiming that the show should be renamed Alex Riley and the Seven Dorks, Riley even had the perfect face for the job. He looked like the quintessential, cruel jock, and acted the part with impeccable belief.

Riley's composure throughout what was an ordeal for most everybody else was rewarded with an instant main roster push, during which he was paired with his pro The Miz. Their subsequent, premature split was far too hasty, but despite being a natural heel, Riley also managed to excel in the face role.

His star was on the rise, but if backstage whispers are to be believed, he annoyed John Cena to such a palpable extent that he was demoted because of it. During a Reddit AMA, Tyler Reks disclosed that Cena would happily transgress upon locker room code by rifling through Riley's bag and "chew him out" for taking supplements - in an apparent attempt to get him fired.

As weak as his Twitter game was, Riley was too talented to have succumbed to office politics.

7. Bam Bam Bigelow

An argument can be made that Bam Bam Bigelow, having headlined WrestleMania, doesn't warrant inclusion on this list. But that was a different time and an exceptional circumstance.

Advertisement

Bigelow's distinguished look is among wrestling's most iconic and fearsome; with his painful-looking skull tattoo and flame-adorned bodysuit, Bigelow's unique appearance was genuinely terrifying. He didn't, unlike many big men of the era, rely solely upon it. He was also an incredibly talented performer, somehow capable of hurtling his mammoth frame around the ring in the manner of an acrobat without compromising his formidable power game.

Bigelow didn't just move gracefully for a big man. He moved gracefully, full stop.

Bigelow was something of a wrestling journeyman, flitting around various midcards in short term stints despite his arresting mixture of talent and marketability.

He should have been rewarded for his 'Mania XI performance against Lawrence Taylor - one of if not the best matches involving a non-wrestler - with a prolonged run atop the WWF mountain. His momentum in the heel role was subsequently squandered by an ill-fated face turn, which didn't catch on.

That King Mabel was pushed at his expense borders on the insulting.

6. Mike Awesome

Awesome's run in the WWF has been reduced to a trivia question. His only notable accomplishment was striking the first blow in the doomed Invasion angle by wrestling the Hardcore title away from Rhyno.

Advertisement

While he didn't help his cause by celebrating his win in goofy fashion, Awesome was senselessly demoted to Sunday Night Heat shortly afterwards, booked in straight, short matches in which he was unable to unleash his fierce arsenal of aerial and impact moves.

Awesome's reputation was tarnished by Vince Russo's poison pencil in his WCW stint - but not irrevocably. He blew away the rotten stigma attached to him through his Fat Chick Thriller and That 70s Guy personas with just one awesome bout against Masato Tanaka at One Night Stand 2005. There was scope for rehabilitation.

His work in the original ECW was so uniquely brilliant that it might have done him more harm than good in the eyes of McMahon. His awe-inspiring planchas and dives, fairly common for men of his size in this day and age, were once the source of discontent among some members of the old guard. They felt as though a wrestler of his proportions stretched credibility by performing them.

Awesome wasn't just an excellent talent in his own right - he was among the best the ECWCW faction had to offer, and should have been elevated to the top of their ranks in a silent enforcer role.

5. Cesaro

Forgive the risible cliche, but if the dictionary did pictures, Cesaro's mugshot would be plastered right next to the word 'Preternatural'.

Advertisement

His gifts are unreal. There is nothing he cannot do in the ring; his fusion of the European and U.S. style is like nothing else seen in wrestling, and he's one of the most creative practitioners of the art. He seems to devise a thrilling and unseen reversal on a weekly basis.

And yet, he's booked to lose constantly. This year alone, he's only been used to fortify The Miz's Intercontinental title reign and appear as an extra or the designated jobber in several multi-man outings - despite often being the most entertaining part of them. Cesaro, in his classic mini-series with John Cena last year, also demonstrated - as if he there were any doubt - that he could wrestle big four main event-quality singles matches.

What's more galling about his treatment is that Vince has pushed lesser talents with similar characteristics to the moon before. Vladimir Kozlov was hardly a wizard on the mic, but his legitimately tough-looking persona saw him defeat the Undertaker cleanly.

Cesaro, unlike many of his contemporaries who also honed their sumptuous in-ring game on the Independent circuit, actually resembles a WWE superstar in the classic mould.

What's not for Vince to like?

4. Doug Basham

Jim Cornette has gone on record as saying that Doug Basham was the best developmental talent to have ever been mishandled on the main roster.

Advertisement

He's fond of recalling the story of his hair loss. Apparently, the RAW writers simply fancied seeing what he looked like bald, and without giving advance notice to Cornette or consideration to the continuity of OVW's TV product, they unceremoniously shaved his hair off. Cornette, naturally, was furious. He reasoned that they could have at least given him time to book a hair vs. hair match.

You'd be forgiven for thinking that Basham didn't have much in the way of personality. He did - he just wasn't allowed to showcase it during his stint in the bland Basham Brothers tag team.

As a heel in OVW, he'd make his entrance to the Superman theme, presuming that his faithful would want autographs, which he'd write and get his assistant to hand out before his matches - regardless of whether or not he was asked.

The matches themselves were also hugely entertaining. Basham had a way of hooking the audience even during their quieter stretches, patronisingly mimicking his opponents' selling.

Soberingly, Basham was even better in the face role. He must wonder to this day what went wrong for him.

3. Vader

Vader was so, so good in the early 1990s - easily in the top 5 worldwide talents.

Advertisement

He made suspension of disbelief incredibly easy. His offence looked absolutely brutal. Like fellow big man Bigelow, he was capable, inconceivably, of unleashing a devastating aerial repertoire.

He had a terrifying aura back in the day, too. In a match with Stan Hansen on an AJPW Vs. NJPW supercard, his eye popped gruesomely out of its socket. He reattached it and simply held it in place via his eyelid before continuing the match.

His work with Hansen may well have made Vince apprehensive, but he was able to tone down his act - to a degree. Vader worked safely enough with the likes of Hulk Hogan, who despite (or because of) being welcomed into wrestling with an intentional leg break, was famously averse to working stiff.

McMahon, however, didn't create Vader, who was signed only to be credible fodder for Shawn Michaels' first reign with the WWF title. His push towards their disappointing SummerSlam match was halfhearted at best. He wasn't even booked to appear in a singles outing at WrestleMania XII, relegated instead to a multi-man tag team opener.

Like Cesaro after him, Vince with Vader could have had his cake and eaten it too. He pushed Mabel with more conviction just over half a year earlier.

2. 'Dr. Death' Steve Williams

Dr. Death was a legendary proponent of All Japan Pro Wrestling's King's Road style, racking up three WON five star matches on the way to puroresu immortality.

Advertisement

He was a man who even looked authentic. With his rock-shaped head and accomplished real sports background, Williams enhanced his legitimacy with his incredibly stiff offence, which was an enthralling blend of suplexes and characterful, football-inspired charges. Williams could even dive through the ropes to deliver a devastating-looking tope and execute graceful handspring elbow strikes.

The infamous WWF Brawl For All tournament, held in 1998, was arranged purely to build real-life tough guy Williams up to mount a title challenge against his 'Rattlesnake' namesake. Unlike some of the other men on this list, Vince, who had courted Williams for years, had big plans for him. He just botched the execution spectacularly.

Bart Gunn shattered Williams' main event prospects, hard man reputation and hamstring in an unplanned humbling.

Williams has since gone on record as saying that the WWF gig, in which an unwelcome Jim Ross was imposed as his mouthpiece, was never a good fit.

1. Paul Heyman

The Paul Heyman-booked SmackDown product of 2002-3 holds a special place in the heart for many wrestling fans.

Advertisement

It famously outperformed the flagship RAW in the ratings battle, which is the cynical but only viable explanation for his being stripped of the pencil.

Stephanie McMahon has spoken about his removal from the Head Writer position on the Ladies And Gentlemen, My Name Is Paul Heyman documentary, but her words are typically inscrutable. She talks cryptically about his refusal to tow the line, as if he could get away with implementing any ideas deemed unsuitable by Vince McMahon, who has final say on everything pertaining to WWE television.

It's not as if Heyman was interested in reprising the more unsavoury elements of ECW. Demonstrating versatility, his vision for the SmackDown brand was markedly different from RAW. Framed in a more realistic context, Heyman's programme utilised tournaments and emphasised athleticism, drawing in viewers who preferred the primary element of the sports entertainment formula.

Heyman does a masterful job of advising Brock Lesnar, but he's even better with a pencil than he is on the stick. He and we would have been much better off if he was writing for Curtis Axel rather than speaking on his behalf.

Advertisement