10 PG Era WWE Superstars You Totally Don't Remember
You'd think fans would remember these WWE PG era stars, right? Maybe not!
You'll get different answers on exactly when WWE's PG era ended depending who you ask. There's no dispute over when it started (all programming switched to PG certification on 22 July 2008), but the ending? Yeah, that's a little harder to thrash out. Some say it finished in 2014 when a "Reality Era" (?!) kicked in, but WWE technically moved away from ironclad PG rules in 2024 - Paul Heyman encouraging people to erm...kiss certain appendages and The Rock turning into a brutal, bloody 'Final Boss' will do that.
To be on the safe side, only wrestlers pre-2014 were considered for this list.
There are a lot of forgotten faces to ponder anyway. For example, do you remember who Mark Henry's old WWE protege was? How about someone who appeared as an original member in a tag-team that was instantly spoiled as soon as it came to the main roster? Also, surely no-one recalls Vickie Guerrero's short-lived love interest?
Wrestling fans tended to groan a lot during the earliest days of PG, but WWE's scramble to create new, family-friendly stars did produce gold for misfit collections like this.
Remember this lot?!
10. Kenneth Cameron
WWE wrecked The Ascension with impressive speed when they were called up to the main roster in 2014. Announcers rubbished them as LOD/Demolition/Powers Of Pain knock-offs, and some even remarked that they couldn't hold a candle to those legends. Yep, it was as counterproductive as it sounds, but things had already changed.
Originally, The Ascension was a full-blown stable in old developmental territory FCW. Then, members Conor O'Brian and Kenneth Cameron hit the revamped NXT hard when it first launched in 2012. Unfortunately, Cameron was then fired for behaviour outside the ring, and WWE pivoted to installing Rick Victor as Conor's partner instead.
For reference, KC was future TNA and NWA star Bram/Thomas Latimer.
You probably won't remember much about his WWE run at all, but he was responsible for giving The Ascension a 'handsome vampire' edge when it first launched. Later, creative tweaked the team to become more demonic and even a little satanic.
Cameron's time was totally forgotten.
9. Lena Yada
This former Diva worked exactly one TV match on WWE's main roster, and it'd be a surprise if anybody out there even remembers it. Lena Yada teamed with Beth Phoenix, Jillian Hall, Katie Lea, Layla, Maryse, Natalya and Victoria to beat Brie Bella, Candice Michelle, Eve Torres, Kelly Kelly, Mae Young, Michelle McCool, Mickie James and Tiffany on the 3 November 2008 Raw.
Phew! Do you think that's enough bodies, WWE?
Yada never even got involved before the finish, because the bout only went 90 seconds or so. Women's wrestling was a different animal in 2008 than it is now! Almost shockingly, Lena was part of WWE's scene for around three years - she popped up during the 2005 Diva Search auditions, then was hired full time (as a backstage announcer) in 2007.
WWE cut her approx one week after that 16-woman tag on Raw. Without being cruel, her departure barely made a ripple amongst fans. Yada was just another Diva that blended in with the crowd. Her brief stint on ECW was totally forgettable too.
8. Michael Tarver
OK, so some out there will be laughing and saying things like: 'Of course we remember Michael Tarver. He was in Nexus'. He was, but people tend to think of Wade Barrett, Ryback, Heath Slater or Daniel Bryan's attack on Justin Roberts when they think of the group. Hell, fans would put future leader CM Punk and his minions like Michael McGillicutty ahead of Tarver.
Fellow originals Justin Gabriel and David Otunga also get more head space too.
Tarver is the forgotten man from the first Nexus lineup, but he was a founding member who actually seemed to have some potential early on. WWE handed Michael some promo time to do his thing, and it looked for all the world like he had the chance to become a breakout star once the faction splintered.
It wasn't to be. Tarver suffered an injury and was released shortly before his return to TV could be thrashed out; he did pop up in the background on Raw and SmackDown before being cut, but fans never learned what creative had in mind for him.
7. Bam Neely
Bam Neely has the dubious distinction of looking like a generic base model for CAWs in the old SmackDown vs. Raw games. His plain black vest and blue jeans look was uninspired, and the tribal ink on big Bam's arm defo looked like something from the THQ series. That tattoo is probably still in 2K's games today.
Someone go hunting.
Neely debuted as Chavo Guerrero's bodyguard on ECW in the summer of 2008. His alliance with Chavo led Neely to featuring on telly alongside La Familia stablemates like Vickie Guerrero and Edge. That was as high up the WWE food chain as Bam would go. Apparently, Vince McMahon didn't see that much in him.
Chavo's heavy was released from contract come January 2009. Anyone hoping Neely would go on to enjoy a sparkling career elsewhere would be disappointed. He wrestled his last match in 2010 and hasn't been seen since. Poor Bam didn't even enjoy the spoils of an ex-WWE star run in TNA.
6. Ricky Ortiz
In July 2008, a wild-haired ball of energy landed on ECW as Atlas Ortiz. One week later, extreme announcers Mike Adamle and Tazz were calling him Ricky, and the Atlas name was never mentioned again. WWE clearly had high hopes for Ortiz, because they drafted him to SmackDown in 2009.
That was a false dawn.
Ricky was released in August mere months after joining the blue brand. Admittedly, this was a puzzler at the time, 'cause Ortiz looked like he had plenty to offer. Wrestling wasn't kind to the dude post-WWE either. He retired in 2013 and is only remembered (by some) as a footnote in industry history.
It's easy to forget that Ricky went on a fairly lengthy undefeated streak on ECW TV following his debut. Maybe he would've found more success had he come along a little later when NXT was in full swing, or something like that. Ortiz certainly had a great look and some personality.
5. Lucky Cannon
Hey, look! It's Mark Henry's protege!
Lucky Cannon was already a former FCW Champion by the time he appeared as a rookie on the second season of NXT's "reality show" format in 2010. Henry was his mentor on the program, and big Mark did his best to give Lucky some spotlight. Early on, he looked like a frontrunner to break out and emerge as a star.
Cannon would never make it above NXT's glass ceiling onto Raw or SmackDown. He was let go by WWE in August 2011, and only worked a few shots on the independent scene before seemingly hanging up his boots for good. Being honest, that's a waste. Ol' Lucky had some charisma to him, and seemed like a prospect WWE could develop.
The first run of NXT shows should be studied. Vince McMahon and his writers handed ample TV time to young, aspiring wrestlers and hoped for the best. It really was experimental, but mass interest was short-term. Then, WWE themselves started taking the p*ss out of the cast.
4. Manu/Sim Snuka
Cody Rhodes and Randy Orton's WWE Title feud will be a modern-era treat and might've already happened by the time some read this. If so, then enjoy the chat about their time together in the Legacy faction between 2008-2010. One thing's certain: Neither Cody or Randy will mention members like Manu or Sim Snuka.
Both get a split entry here.
The pair joined Orton's generational stable during a weird period that saw Ted DiBiase exit stage left to film The Marine 2. Manu was ushered in first, then Sim had to prove himself before earning some Legacy colours. That...didn't last long. In fact, Snuka barely became a member before he was on the outs again.
WWE briefly tried to turn Sim and Manu into babyfaces who vowed revenge on Randy, but it fell on deaf ears with live crowds. Both came across as glorified enhancement workers hanging onto Randy and Cody's coat tails, so they were never going to get over.
3. Caylen Croft
Dear readers, the Dude Busters. Dude Busters, readers.
That's current AEW man Trent Beretta on the left there. He teamed with Caylen Croft as arguably the least WWE in 2009 duo you'll ever see. Seriously, Beretta and Croft were everything Vince McMahon stood against at the time. Their debut really shows how little attention the boss was paying to ECW before it folded in February 2010.
The Dude Busters then tried to make something happen on SmackDown, but they didn't stand a chance now they were firmly on Vince's radar. Beretta and Croft became Superstars regulars (a death knell for workers during that era) before Caylen was released from his contract in November 2010.
His last match? A dark match before SmackDown that month vs. Luke Gallows. No, Croft hasn't worked in-ring since leaving WWE behind. That's a pity, because he did have talent. Wrong place, wrong time for the Dude Busters. They'd have torn it up in AEW.
2. Eric Escobar
Former FCW Champion and three-time FCW Tag Champ Eric Escobar seemed to have the world at his feet when he debuted on WWE's main roster in September 2009. WWE clearly agreed that he was special - they put heat magnet Vickie Guerrero in Eric's corner immediately. She was coming off a hot union with Edge.
That was successful, so maybe creative figured Vickie was an automatic win for any wrestlers tied to her. Hmm, maybe not. Escobar lasted as a heel until November, split from Guerrero then floundered. By January 2010, he was gone. Just like that! WWE weren't hanging around to see if Eric would work out as a babyface.
They'd seen enough, it seems.
Vince McMahon was well-known for changing his mind frequently on various wrestlers, but this was quick even by his standards. Escobar debuted in a prominent spot next to Vickie, scored some impactful wins, then found himself on the scrap heap. It was a whirlwind main roster run. A short one though.
1. Jackson Andrews
At least Eric Escobar worked a bunch of televised matches before being discarded. Big Jackson Andrews didn't get to do that, but he was more of a Diesel-esque bodyguard for Tyson Kidd than anything else. That's being kind, to be fair. Jackson debuted on the 6 December 2010 Raw and was released by May 2011.
Yikes.
So, what went wrong? The monster muscle man had a look that'd make Vinnie Mac dribble, but perhaps he lacked basic fundamentals. If so, then why bother calling him up to the main roster from FCW in the first place? Surely putting Andrews out on the road to learn his craft would've been a smarter plan.
WWE rushed Jackson to TV and found out first hand how limited he was. The association with Kidd died a quick death, at least. Mark Henry put Andrews in his place on the 27 December Raw, and any credibility Jackson had evaporated in front of everyone's eyes.
What other WWE PG era stars have been forgotten? For more like this, check out 10 WWE New Generation Era Superstars You Totally Don't Remember and 10 Most DANGEROUS Wrestlers Ever!