10 Red Flags For The Future Of Triple H's WWE
WWE and the problem with rose coloured glasses making red flags just look like flags.
WWE is a better product under Triple H than it was before Vince McMahon resigned in disgrace.
It is.
That said, this won't be some gushing hyperbolic celebratory article about 'The Game' has saved the entire industry or anything. Paul Levesque is just another exorbitantly wealthy man booking shows, not unlike his Father-In-Law or his nearest current rival across the pro wrestling divide. But as Tony Khan also proved with striking ease upon the launch of All Elite Wrestling, the creative bar set by McMahon had fallen so pathetically low that a toddler could trip over it and produce a funnier and sweeter moment than anything the former chairman had managed in nigh on 20 years.
With two full years of largely excellent and thoughtful creative before cracks appeared, Khan's AEW opened up a chasm between what a wrestling show even looked like compared to what WWE had morphed into. Triple H's honeymoon period addressed that humiliating gap, and showed early flashes of becoming the platonic ideal of a World Wrestling Entertainment that served the needs of its consumers without alienating the rich stakeholders that clearly endorsed the low energy TikTok video the brand had become.
It was always destined to be a high-wire act longterm though, as evidenced by some early warning signs that should remind anybody invested in 'The Game's rebuild to approach with caution...
10. The Clash At The Castle Detail Nobody Cared About At The Time
Clash At The Castle had just about everything.
An awesome stadium-sized crowd, a host of excellent contests including one nailed-on Match Of The Year contender, and a heady mix what an idealised version of WWE should strive to always be as a live viewing experience. Even the timing of it was perfect - Triple H had assumed the reins of the shows in July, optimism about the future of the main roster was at an all-time high and a stadium show-starved UK audience received the event as if it was every bit the SummerSlam sequel the company promoted it as.
It was a special, special event. But WWE is still WWE no matter which McMahon family member holds the power. And that WWE doesn't know how to book a show that would't follow all that praise with a "but".
It wasn't even that apparent until the main event made the bold (but correct) call to have Roman Reigns defeat home nations challenger Drew McIntyre, but elsewhere the card featured zero title changes, heels winning all-but two matches and a heel turn at the climax of one of those. Dominik Mysterio's switch ruled, actually, but the main message was that even in a dreamlike state of satisfaction, WWE's default will always be to keep supplying platefuls of sh*t.
As the first heel to retain his Championship at WrestleMania having turned heel on the show one year earlier, there's a strong chance Hunter believes in this more than Vince McMahon himself.
9. Everything That's Sucked About The Miz & Dexter Lumis Story
Yes, everything in wrestling can be subjective and yes there there's nothing inherently wrong with Dexter Lumis or The Miz if you happen to be a massive fan of either. This entry is not strictly a burial of either man, but the fact that neither have Cagematch profiles loaded with stars doesn't help.
Lumis was one of the odder reintroductions from the latter days of Triple H's dilapidated version of NXT, having seemingly done as much as he could have done with the...murderer gimmick before a "budget cut" release replaced could have been a more realistic "creative has nothing for you one".
His return amidst a slew of others classified him as a kayfabe outsider to the company, and a run with Miz has since revealed that 'The A-Lister' is trying to keep something secret that Dexter (and now Johnny Gargano) knows, but the first attempt at their match was a bait-and-switch and everything since has reduced Gargano to playing a jumped-up little sh*thead and Tommaso Ciampa to injured odd man out.
The secret could apparently "cancel" Miz, which is something WWE historically don't handle well either. This is, to quote Chris Jericho in 2019, "a stupid idea by bad creative", and proof that Hunter can be as guilty of that as his disgraced Da-in-law.
8. Impromptu Matches Are Still The Norm More Than The Exception
If you're prone to enjoying your chosen hobbies with an analytical eye or just capable of critical thought in general, WWE's presentation of professional wrestling has been fundamentally broken for decades.
Regardless of what it isn't in 2022, everybody within the company lost of sight of what it was supposed to be a long, long time ago. An edition of Raw or SmackDown is supposed to be a live emulation of a sporting show that ultimately becomes an entertainment one due to the wins and losses not being on the up-and-up. A silent contract between audience, performers and promotion has existed to support this in the decades since kayfabe was shattered, and everything makes sense accordingly.
And at a fundamental level, that is why matches out of nowhere from the "spontaneous" decisions made by an authority figure or dreamt up by the wrestlers themselves simply shouldn't exist. There shouldn't be space on a fully booked show for them!
It encourages creative laziness too - the October 24th Monday Night Raw had one match announced for the bulk of the week before the broadcast, and even that had been carefully disguised as a non-title one. This is unacceptable for a three hour show, or certainly if the viewer is expected to have any respect for themselves or their own valuable time.
7. The Women's Division Quick Fixes Haven't Worked
The list of women that have been added to the talent pool since Triple H took over is long, and it was necessary surveying the rosters on both shortly before Vince McMahon resigned in disgrace.
But simply filling television time with the performers isn't the solution, and 'The Game' should know this more than most. Nobody within the industry had a better reputation than him when it came to booking female divisions, and there's absolutely still time for him to actively work at this problem than just paper over the cracks, but early signs aren't great.
Damage CTRL have mostly just been in a rotational war with Bianca Belair, Alexa Bliss and Asuka since returning, and decent matches playing to virtual silence are evidence of the wider disconnect with crowds. On SmackDown, Ronda Rousey's awkwardly skipped back and forth between heel and babyface due to a useless SummerSlam match finish that simultaneously killed Liv Morgan's credibility in the process. That show's list of credible contenders is wafer thin too, explaining why Bayley, Iyo Sky and Dakota Kai have been permitted to work both shows despite Rey Mysterio using the divide to avoid seeing his estranged son.
There was more to do than perhaps even he realised, but at what point exactly will he actually weave some of that much-needed 2014/15 magic?
6. The Matt Riddle Reset
Matt Riddle's feud with Seth Rollins should have been the perfect example of WWE once again functioning in the way wrestling companies are supposed to.
Rollins was coming off the back of an epic trilogy with Cody Rhodes, and even in defeat, the work had been so fantastic that he was at long last established (and accepted as) the WWE ring general he'd long worked to be. Riddle go Triple H in the hot seat at just the right time, got his first name back, and got a big win at Extreme Rules in a match not awesome enough to be epic but not bad enough to undermine months of otherwise-excellent work.
And after that? Bongos with Elias and the stoner too stupid to realise that yet another partner is almost definitely going to turn on him. Losing to Rollins one last time was the cherry on that space cake too. It's Survivor Series season, which - if Triple H has really starred fixing things - is really Road To The Road To WrestleMania season - and one of his biggest projects of the summer should be moving onwards and upwards rather than spinning his wheels.
5. The Match Lengths On Extreme Rules...
...were completely unacceptable, save for one that still seems unbelievable.
Ronda Rousey should have dispatched of Liv Morgan in half the 12 minutes it took her, and maybe would have if she'd been permitted to do more fun weapon stuff than gently swing a bat that she was evidently worried might actually connect. Finn Bálor and Edge's I Quit snoozer got great in the last five minutes but that didn't excuse the twenty four that came before it. And Karrion Kross and Drew McIntyre's strap match going 10:20 is itself the new greatest mystery in wrestling. Unlike the lost Bret Hart/Tom Magee tape though, it's the match nobody wants to watch.
This was all vintage Triple H stuff. TakeOvers became long and over-indulgent too, and at the horrendous expense of the brand and wrestlers' credibility. Hunter will likely take a hard line on this one, which is identical stubbornness to that of the man he replaced. It's worth him reflecting on what else - beyond AEW - brought his golden era NXT's momentum to a screeching halt...
4. Everything That Happened To NXT In The End
A multifarious nightmare of a show by the time the letters were ripped away from him and pelted with a paintball gun, everything that NXT once stood for was bastardised and broken by the time a necessary "2.0" makeover took place.
Overexposure and over-indulgence were common complaints of the weekly show from mid-2019 onwards, as attempts to book dependable episodic television were undermined by panicking through weekly ratings defeats. AEW Dynamite's freshness and quality rendered NXT dated anyway, but when the pandemic struck six months into the war, the gap between the two shows somehow widened even further.
All Elite Wrestling shouldn't have ran shows anymore than WWE, but for two hours a week, the empty Daily's Place actually performed wrestling's key function of distracting its viewers from the real world. In contrast, WWE and especially NXT tried first to no-sell the circumstances before leaning into cartoonish nonsense, under-thought average matches and lashings and lashings of grit and grime.
It was the polar opposite of what people wanted or needed, all produced by people refusing to believe there was a problem. The Capitol Wrestling Center doubled down on the issues while pretending it was re-establishing identity, but whatever "black-and-gold" had once been was now long lost.
WWE is too insulated for that to happen, but Hunter himself might not be.
3. Borrowing Bad Stuff As Well As Good
Despite humiliating his pet project in a war Triple H never wanted to fight and never really had the ability to win, All Elite Wrestling has proved something of a quiet inspiration in this bold new era for WWE.
Hunter has surveyed the television travel schedule and made smart booking choices centred around what might pop local crowds. He has - in grand and immediate fashion - loaded up WWE with stables to facilitate feuds without burning out the key components or live audiences on the pairings themselves. And he's brought lots of familiar faces out to big reactions to ensure there'll be discourse the morning after.
But already, he might be leaning into the excessive side of Tony Khan's tropes. Chad Gable was brutalised in his hometown in a way not dissimilar to how Vince McMahon might have booked it, and with way less creativity than was originally implied. Stables aren't a shortcut to success, as is being proven by Hit Row and the tepid reaction to Damage CTRL's bland story. And especially as relates to the deluge of debuts...
2. There's An Expiration Date On All The Returns...
...and we're at it now.
Triple H has brought back or redebuted so many former faces (and heels) in his short time atop WWE that it's becoming easier to forget one when reeling off the list.
The pops generated by Dakota Kai and Iyo Sky's respective returns and call-ups at SummerSlam feel longer than just three months ago, and perhaps that's something to do with Hunter getting high on his own supply?
It's a problem AEW have experienced, and it's not just the diminished returns of lowkey responses to surprise appearances either. All those wrestlers need something to do, and the less that's provided for them, the more the brand looks small-time for struggling to cope. WWE shouldn't experience that specific problem, but it already feels as though certain nice-ideas-at-the-time were just that and nothing more. Hit Row were embarrassed by Legado Del Fantasma on television, the bloom is off the Karrion Kross rose again, and it's by accident rather than design that half this article digs out Johnny Gargano but there's just been so much to pick at since he came back.
Bray Wyatt's comeback was an unqualified and objective success, but already at Week 3 in his bold new direction, things feel troublingly familiar with the character. WWE's still some way from Big Damo and Johnny Elite's AEW cameos feeling like they never even happened, but that doomed destination often arrives before it's too late to reverse the hearse.
1. Johnny Gargano's Main Roster Run So Far
What on earth is going on here?
Johnny Gargano decision to re-sign with WWE after stepping away in December 2021 looked incredibly shrewd when he appeared as a surprise on the August 22nd edition of Monday Night Raw.
The former NXT Champion's next destination had been a source of great discussion and debate, not least due to several high profile former colleagues making up a sizeable part of the All Elite Wrestling roster. But as that show looked increasingly bloated, a newer fresher Raw looked lean by comparison. As did Gargano, who returned from DadBod exile in amazing physical condition and with what looked like an earnest desire to live his next Shawn Michaels dream of being a smaller guy making it all the way to WWE's apex.
Why, then, is he being made to suffer the undignified barriers of old?
Grinning along with the Dexter Lumis/Miz story (more on that elsewhere) and dancing around in JBL's cowboy hat when he's working his own matches, Gargano's coming across like the insufferable d*ckhead Vince McMahon would have loved. This is all scanning as a stupid WWE test he has to pass before he can get on with the job of being likeable and winning belts. Triple H knows this - he made him funny as a heel after making all the money with him as a babyface.
A fix now will solve it, but why - again - did they have to do the bad thing by comparison first?