10 Scrappiest WWE Underdogs

Da-da-da-DA-da-DAAAAH. Puppy. Power!

By Jack Morrell /

Everyone loves an underdog - the ones that no one really expects anything of, who surpass those lowered expectations to suddenly achieve something great. Sports fans - and this includes wrestling fans, of course - love to be pleasantly surprised, and love to see the Little Engine That Could story play out on the pitch or in the ring. It€™s the feelgood hit everybody talks about for weeks afterwards. Underdogs give people something to believe in, even if it€™s something as simple as the fact that the outcome of a match isn€™t always as you€™d expect. At their finest, the underdog can create the conditions for genuine emotional investment in their journey and their victory. But a quality underdog doesn€™t have to beat the odds to impress. They don't necessarily have to win - look at Rocky. They don't have to be the smallest person in the world, either: they don't even have to be the most loved. It€™s the effort that wins us over, the refusal to lie down and die. The payoff is a wonderful thing: but no underdog is ever a failure... if only they just keep getting up, keep trying, keep making us all believe. With that in mind, these are my picks for the scrappiest, most never-say-die underdogs in WWE history.

10. Santino Marella

Squeezing his way into the Elimination Chamber match for the World Heavyweight Championship in February 2012, small comedy midcarder Santino Marella was on a hiding to nothing from the beginning. His opponents included two genuine giants in the Big Show and the Great Khali, two blue chipper wrestlers in Cody Rhodes and Wade Barrett, and the champion himself, technical marvel and submission specialist Daniel Bryan. The leadup to the match involved Marella engaging in amusing parodies of Rocky€™s training regimen - and true to that underdog spirit, he ended up being one of the last two left in the match. His opponent was Daniel Bryan himself.Both men were roughly the same size and weight, and technically Santino - or rather, Anthony Carelli, the man behind the cod-Italian comedy gimmick - was an accomplished mixed martial artist himself. Of course, this wasn€™t a shoot: €˜Santino Marella€™ didn€™t have the skill to beat Daniel Bryan. Despite a tough stance and plenty of gumption, he couldn€™t help tapping out to the LaBell Lock in the end. Still, for a good five minutes the crowd were firmly behind the clown, determined to support him in his bid for the second biggest title in WWE. There aren€™t enough moments like that in wrestling: small bids to keep us on our toes, to make us think that something out of the ordinary might occur. Nice try, Santino.

9. Jeff Hardy

When he left WWE in 2009, Jeff Hardy was a top babyface star, a freshly established main eventer who€™d won both the WWE Championship and the World Heavyweight Championship in the final few months of his run for the company. It wasn€™t always like that. As a member of Team Extreme, Jeff was the slimline, knockabout Hardy Boy, the one leaping off ladders and flipping off turnbuckles. If a heel came along to merk the pair of them, Jeff was the one who€™d bump mercilessly into a boneless heap in the corner, who€™d let the other guy viciously ragdoll him to get them over. Hardy€™s singles push would be a stop-start thing, beginning in 2001 and again in 2002, skipping over his release over his substance abuse issues, and resuming in 2006 when he returned to the WWE. From losing to the Undertaker in a Ladder match for the Undisputed WWE Championship, to fighting the Samoan helicopter Umaga for the Intercontinental Championship, Hardy was always booked as coming from underneath, always on the back foot fighting courageously to come out on top. Incredibly, Hardy was booked to go over Triple H to determine the number one contender for Randy Orton€™s WWE Championship, and the match was set for the Royal Rumble in 2008. The build-up was dramatic, dynamic. He even got one of those €˜desire€™ two minute promos set to inspirational rock music; sadly in this case it was €˜Rooftops€™ by the Lostprophets, a band that have since been wiped, Benoit-style, from the pages of history. Hardy lost again, but looked great doing it - and the same thng happened at the Elimination Chamber, a noble, brave loss.There would be a minor setback with substance abuse issues before he finally defeated Triple H and Edge in a triple threat match for the WWE Championship. Following this, Hardy was on a level with the biggest names in the company. His underdog days were over.

8. Daniel Puder

Here's a shoot for a change, rather than a storyline. A Tough Enough contestant in 2004 with some mixed martial arts and pro wrestling experience under his belt, Daniel Puder was well aware that there would be an element of hazing to his time on the competition, and WWE lived down to his expectations when, on the October 28th Smackdown, the Big Show was told to legitimately shove him hard into a locker backstage for alleged disrespect. It was on the following week€™s Smackdown that things got out of hand. The Tough Enough kids were ringside as Kurt Angle, one of the toughest men to ever win a gold medal for amateur wrestling at the Olympics, continued the harsh hazing, putting them through a squat thrust competition, which Puder won. The prize? A shoot, against Angle himself, right there and then. However, Puder€™s fellow contestant Chris Nawrocki was mistakenly identified as the winner, and was quickly taken down and submitted with a neck crank. Three of his ribs were broken in the process. Puder, up next, saw the writing on the wall and realised he was going to need to protect himself or let Angle walk all over him. He chose the former, and the two grappled furiously in the ring before Puder, allowing the smaller Angle to bull him into the ropes, locked in a keylock on Angle€™s right arm. In doing so, Puder lay back on the canvas and his shoulders were counted down by the referee. Angle would later express his irritation that the kid had, essentially pinned himself€ but anyone could see that the hold was locked in, and that Angle was seconds away from legitimately having his arm broken if Puder didn€™t relinquish the keylock.Why the agents in charge saw fit to book a shoot rather than a worked confrontation is anyone€™s guess: there was no way of knowing how it would end up. Puder, by all accounts an arrogant young man with little wrestling ability and less personality, would end up winning the Tough Enough competition but being released a year later in a cost-cutting move. It didn't really matter: the biggest moment of his career was when he stood up to veteran bullying on behalf of Chris Nawrocki, himself and every other Tough Enough rookie fed up of being hazed by overgrown kids. 'Olympic hero' Kurt Angle is still being asked amused questions about the incident to this day.

7. Maven

Another Tough Enough winner, Maven lasted longer than most, despite a skill set limited to looking pretty and delivering a really nice dropkick. His first feud, a miniature grudge with Taz, set up his stall: he would be the perennial new kid, trying to make a name for himself in the face of relentless bullying. And then came his entry into the 2002 Royal Rumble, and one of the biggest upsets that match has ever seen: Maven eliminated the Undertaker.The enraged Big Evil beat Maven all the way back to the locker room and the match continued for everyone else. However, technically the rookie hadn€™t been eliminated - just thrown through the ropes - and the following night on RAW, he was awarded a match for Chris Jericho€™s Undisputed Championship, on the basis that he€™d been prevented from continuing in the Rumble. Maven would, of course, lose that match, and then take another post-match beating from the Dead Man. The following week, however, Maven would face the Undertaker for his Hardcore Championship, and (with some judicious assistance from The Rock and Tough Enough trainer Al Snow, was successful in beating him.Maven wouldn€™t get much of an opportunity on television again - there was a moment in late 2004 when he€™d be part of the winning team at Survivor Series, and get a title shot against Triple H for the World Heavyweight Championship, but the match was shot through with interference, and still the outcome wasn€™t in any doubt: 2004 Triple H didn€™t do jobs to undercarders.

6. The Hurricane

A cruiserweight holdover from WCW, Gregory Helms developed his comedy superhero alter ego €˜The Hurricane€™ once he€™d debuted for the WWF - and for the most part, audiences loved his po-faced heroics and refusal to back down from a clear mismatch. Helms was so much fun in the role that he managed to get over despite repeated losses. Finally, he was rewarded for all his hard work by being booked into a small feud with the company€™s biggest star, The Rock, in the weeks leading up to WrestleMania XIX. The bigger heel belittled the Hurricane, putting him down and making him the butt of his jokes and catchphrases - if you€™ve seen The Rock do it once, you€™ve seen him do it a hundred times. The difference was that the Hurricane didn€™t know the meaning of the word quit, and seemed to have no idea that he was outclassed and outgunned. In every promo, he€™d wait till the end and then bring out a zinger that would embarrass and annoy The Great One.Finally, on March 10th 2003, the two faced each other in a singles match - and thanks to some timely interference from a certain Texas Rattlesnake, the Hurricane rolled up The Rock for the unexpected win. The match helped cement the story going into WrestleMania XIX, gave a bright new star a little boost and put a fair few smiles on faces. Excellent work all round.

5. Rey Mysterio

This probably seems like a no-brainer - after all, he€™s been called €˜the biggest little man in the WWE€™ for so long that he might as well have changed his name to €˜Underdog€™ and barked his way to the ring. Still, it€™s often forgotten that Rey Mysterio has had a tough road at times in US wrestling. In WCW, he became incredibly popular but still found himself marginalised and disrespected by the office, forced to remove his mask in a nothing angle, heedless of the cultural significance that that had for a luchador. In WWE, they had more respect for him and his traditions: but they will always be the land of the giants. Every wrestler under six foot tall has to prove themselves ten times over to earn the spot that a bigger guy might be handed overnight, and Rey is significantly under six foot tall. Mysterio ended up in a peculiar position: he was a superhero, not a traditional wrestler. He never played a heel again, and as a virtuous, sweetheart babyface a good foot shorter than even his more middle-sized opponents, WWE would take some serious convincing to book him as a serious threat to any of the larger men on the roster.That went on for nearly thirteen years. Given Mysterio€™s status in the company over that time, picking one match or one feud as an example of his underdog position is ludicrous - but then it€™s fairly ludicrous that a character so over, a performer so talented, a wrestler with such frenetic, superlative offence, was booked as a perennial underdog in the first place.

4. Daniel Bryan

In any other company, Daniel Bryan would never have been considered an underdog. In Ring Of Honor, it was the fans that began chanting that he was the best in the world, and his intense, stiff technical style was booked as being fearsome to behold. But, as I€™ve mentioned, WWE traditionally expect any wrestler under six foot tall to earn his spot ten times over in order to be considered for the main event, and Daniel Bryan was no exception. To have the former 'American Dragon' (who was obviously one of the most legit professional wrestlers in the entire company from day one) come across as an underdog required some significant, specific booking choices. So: he was booked as a wrestling nerd who didn€™t know anything about women, real life or how to make it in the big leagues, and was routinely and deliberately buried by the announcers. He would lose at WrestleMania XXVIII in 18 seconds; he would express major self-doubt while in a top level tag team with WWE veteran Kane the following year; he would lose his feud with Bray Wyatt in early 2014, only weeks after spending the second half of 2013 in the main event chasing a WWE Championship that WWE didn€™t want him to keep hold of. He was called a farmyard animal, a garden gnome, and his very real relationship with Brie Bella was mocked on camera. Bryan€™s ascension to the very top level of the company was an accident, and his glorious WrestleMania moment only happened at all because the original plans sucked so hard that the office was worried that the fans would hijack WrestleMania XXX as they had the Royal Rumble. Bryan would receive the ultimate underdog moment when he jerked the curtain and worked the main event at the show, defeating three quarters of Evolution over the course of the event to win the WWE World Heavyweight Championship.

3. The 1-2-3 Kid

By the time Sean Waltman signed a contract with the WWF in 1993, he€™d already been wrestling for four years, had had career-making matches with and against Jerry Lynn in the US and Japan, and suffered a near career-ending injury when an opponent landed on his head after a botched suicide dive. That didn€™t make a lick of difference, of course - the WWF didn€™t acknowledge the previous careers of their new recruits, and back in the 1990s, WWE was still very much the land of the giants. Waltman wasn€™t short, but neither was he stacked. Initially losing to Doink the Clown, Waltman would cycle through various permutations of €˜Kid€™ - Kamikaze, Cannonball, and finally simply €˜the Kid€™ - until his game-changing match on Monday Night RAW on 17th May 1993, when he upset Razor Ramon to win his first match on national television.The crowd went bananas. To those of us watching that night, it was one of those moments you just wished you could rewind. Back in 1993, RAW was mostly squash matches and middling midcard bouts: on Tuesday May 18th, the only thing my mates wanted to talk about was the 1-2-3 Kid. For a while, the urban myth that it was a referee snafu - the perils of live TV! - was leaping from person to person faster than syphilis on speed, and I know people that believe it to this day. The 1-2-3 Kid didn€™t stop there, of course. The WWF milked that underdog dollar for all it was worth. Razor challenged him to another match and put up ten grand of his own money if he won. The Kid was supposed to win again but botched the finish (a somersault plancha from the top rope to the outside), landing on his head and concussing himself. Somehow, he still found the wherewithal to just plain steal the money and run from the building, saving the match, the angle and his fledgeling career. The angle was over like clover. The Kid wouldn€™t lose another match on television until SummerSlam.

2. Zach Gowen

If Zach Gowen ends up being a footnote in WWE, it€™d be a crying shame. His history of substance abuse in later years notwithstanding, it€™s an incredible thing for survivors of cancer and victims of amputation to remember twenty-year-old, one-legged Gowen working with Hulk Hogan and busting out moonsaults and dropkicks against the Big Show, Brock Lesnar and even Vince McMahon himself. One of the most courageous underdogs in WWE history, Gowen started off as a plant that was attacked by €˜Rowdy€™ Roddy Piper, who pulled off his false leg (memorably, he initially tried twisting off the real one before realising his mistake). Helping Hogan€™s €˜Mr. America€™ character out drew the ire of Mr. McMahon, who pitted a babyface Stephanie McMahon and Gowen against the Big Show in what was billed the first ever €˜real€™ handicap match. With help from Kurt Angle, the two went over the giant. In a grudge match against McMahon at Vengeance in 2003, Gowen would rally back to kick a chair into McMahon€™s face. The match was scripted and rehearsed to a fault, but the blood that poured out of McMahon€™s head wasn€™t planned. Fortunately, it looked amazing and only added to the story of the match, which McMahon would win.That would become the Zach Gowen story for a while afterwards, being involved in losing efforts until his feud with Matt Hardy culminated in a win at No Mercy 2003. Some people thought that Gowen€™s inclusion in fairly competitive matches showed wrestling up for the over-the-top, theatrical spectacle it was. However, these were the same wrestling geeks that were clamouring for the return of the Dead Man version of the Undertaker over the more realistic American Badass/Big Evil, so what do they know?

1. Bayley

Ignoring the dubious way that Bayley began life as a character in NXT two years or so ago, and there€™s no doubt that her ascent to the NXT Women€™s Championship has all the hallmarks of a classic underdog storyline It€™s the story of two years of gradual building, two years of organic growth in the eyes of the fans to the point where Bayley was one of the most over babyfaces on the roster - if not the most over. Bayley was an innocent who became experienced, but who never lost the core of the character that everyone had loved to begin with. You couldn€™t help but root for her. You couldn€™t help but will her to win every time she got into the ring. As much as Zack Gowen was a greater underdog in the ring; as much as the Daniel Bryan €˜yes movement€™ was more melodramatic and grandiose; as much as the 1-2-3 Kid delivered a genuinely surprising, crowd-pleasing storyline; there€™s something about Bayley. She was constantly portrayed as being on the back foot like Gowen (if you€™ll forgive the expression), but with Bryan€™s connection with the crowd.And Bayley lost. She lost a lot - she was beaten up, betrayed and humiliated, and because the fans loved her, they felt every bruise and every tear along with her. All of this pain built up Bayley€™s backbone over time, but it didn€™t change her. She chose to remain a nice person: the nicest person, in fact. She chose to remain Bayley. Developing a core of steel to reinforce her sweet-as-apple-pie, huggable exterior, Bayley became the champion the fans had wanted Daniel Bryan to be.