10 Signs WWE's Brand Split Just Isn't Working
Time to call it, guys.
When it was announced that WWE planned to channel the spirit of 2002 and split both top shows into two distinct brands, there were murmurs of excitement. Sitting alongside that mild anticipation, some pointed out that the roster wasn't exactly deep. Creating new, bankable stars has been a problem for WWE over the past few years.
Names such as Triple H, The Undertaker, Brock Lesnar, and even The Rock have been called upon to return from time to time, lending a hand when things look especially bleak. Hell, even Bill Goldberg's recent comeback shows that things have been trundling along since the WWE Draft. Management clearly didn't feel they had anyone on the regular active roster better-suited to facing Lesnar.
The brand extension started in earnest on July 25. That night's Monday Night Raw debuted a new aesthetic, one quickly followed by the very first episode of SmackDown Live the next night. Since then, excitement has died down a fair bit. That must be worrying for WWE.
Although it's still early days for the brand split, let's look at what the main teething problems are and why they're happening...
10. There's Not Enough To Distinguish Between Both Shows
Credit where credit is due, WWE have tried to add a whole host of little differences to help distinguish between Monday Night Raw and SmackDown Live. For example, the Raw announce desk is now permanently placed beside the entrance ramp, whereas the SmackDown version still sits at ringside.
Other contrasts come when analysing the way both brands shoot matches. Raw favours a much more standard WWE approach, whilst on SmackDown the company have added some new camera angles to try and spice things up. Sadly, none of these differences are really enough to create a clear split between both major shows.
Programming still often begins the same way. One wrestler or an authority figure enters the ring to cut a promo. Then, after that opening segment, we get a few matches and more of the same. Whilst it seems crass to criticise WWE for what can be expected during a wrestling show, there's little to tell Raw and SmackDown apart even post-Draft.
Unfortunately, the latter is still coming across as a less-important variation on the flagship. Making that even more tragic, there are different stars on each show. WWE have to find a way to make that work for them; the actual wrestlers themselves should be what offers a clear parallel.
9. Most Fans Are Picking A Side
Talk to any number of pro wrestling fans and it becomes clear that most have a favourite show. For some, Monday Night Raw will always be the crown-jewel of WWE programming. For others, SmackDown has a better roster and the 2-hour format means the broadcast is tighter and maintains focus.
The very nature of any brand split dictates that fans will also be divided. On the surface, this isn't a problem for WWE. After all, creating that division means that people will be more likely to care when 'Team Raw vs. Team SmackDown' matches are presented.
Scratch just beneath that surface and problems start to crop up. Why would WWE management want any customer to choose between parts of their product? Going back to the previous point, people favour Raw or SmackDown because they don't like something about one of the shows. That loyalty isn't born out of thinking the 'better' program is flawless.
Surely having a better balance would be of benefit to WWE? Fans should be enjoying Raw and SmackDown for different reasons, not because they consider one side lame.
8. So Many Repeat Matches
Come Hell In A Cell, it will be the third time since SummerSlam that Roman Reigns vs. Rusev has been scheduled for use on pay-per-view. Admittedly, the SummerSlam match didn't end up happening, as Reigns ambushed his foe before the bell could even ring. Still, that excuse aside, it's pretty bold of WWE to expect significant fan interest.
The Cell stipulation has been tacked on to try and stir up that intrigue. As much as the match will likely be enjoyable, Raw's creative team can't use Rusev vs. Reigns going forward. Both men need a break from one another, and they're far from alone.
Analyse the card for Hell In A Cell and it becomes clear that repeat matches are law in WWE nowadays. Kevin Owens vs. Seth Rollins, Charlotte vs. Sasha Banks, and T.J Perkins vs. Brian Kendrick all join Reigns vs. Rusev in being rematches.
Over on SmackDown, the same problem persists. Dolph Ziggler and The Miz faced one another for the WWE Intercontinental Title at both Backlash and No Mercy. There's a reason for these repeats, and it's something the promotion must address.
7. Lack Of True Roster Depth
It's futile to complain about the return of enhancement talent exhibitions to WWE television, especially when such a tactic has led to newfound success for guys like James Ellsworth. Peel back the exterior a little on this decision and a wider issue is revealed. The WWE roster just doesn't have great depth overall.
For every exciting Kevin Owens vs. Seth Rollins situation, one fans know will provide a good match, Raw features a fair few bouts hardly anyone cares about. Leaping to the defence of those watching, fans haven't been given any good reason to care about guys like Titus O'Neil or Darren Young, let alone performers like Sin Cara or Bo Dallas.
There are so many names on both Raw and SmackDown that just pad out the numbers more than adding anything valuable. It's true that not everybody can be a top star, however there's a real difference between having a full roster and filling the ranks with performers crowds don't care about.
A prime example of this occurred on the latest edition of SmackDown. Baron Corbin vs. Jack Swagger was complete throwaway, doing little for either man.
6. Lack Of Genuinely Exciting Returns
When the brand split was first announced, all sorts of articles started popping up pondering who WWE would bring back in order to shore up the rosters on both Raw and SmackDown. Names like John Morrison, MVP, and even Kurt Angle were thrown around, each one adding more excitement to the idea.
Exactly none of those men have returned. Shelton Benjamin was signed, before then going down to an injury that will keep him on the shelf for some time. Benjamin would have been an asset to SmackDown Live, and the former United States and Tag-Team Champion seems like a top star next to some who have made a comeback.
The likes of Jinder Mahal and Curt Hawkins just haven't been enough to elicit genuine thrills from those watching. The only other major return is Goldberg, although it seems like the former WCW World Champ will only stick around for a few matches at best, possibly before being inducted into the WWE Hall Of Fame.
Where are all those names who were supposed to come back and add some much-needed star power to the roster?
5. Brock Lesnar & Randy Orton Ignored The Rules Almost Immediately
Weeks before the WWE Draft even took place, it was revealed that Randy Orton would go one-on-one with Brock Lesnar at SummerSlam in August. During the Draft itself on July 19, Orton was positioned on SmackDown Live and Lesnar was drafted to Monday Night Raw. Straight away, many were scratching their heads wondering how WWE planned to build the pay-per-view match.
On just the second week of Raw since the brand split, SmackDown star Orton invaded the program and nailed Brock with an RKO as Lesnar stood mid-ring being talked up by Paul Heyman. In one fell swoop, WWE had completely undermined the idea of Raw and SmackDown featuring exclusive rosters.
Orton vs. Lesnar was an anomaly, booked before the Draft. Whilst that's true, the writing team must have known their plans for the Draft when scheduling the marquee bout.
Lesnar proceeded to then intrude on SmackDown and gain revenge, once again shattering the boundaries between both shows. No sooner had the split started than WWE were overlooking it in order to properly build towards SummerSlam.
4. Survivor Series Is Going To Boil Down To Routine 'Us Vs. Them' Mentality
Fans who have been watching for longer than just a few years will recall the terrible scheduling in 2009 and 2010 that had the Bragging Rights pay-per-view falling just before Survivor Series. The core premise of the former was to present a 'Team Raw vs. Team SmackDown' match, with both sides fighting it out to see which was superior.
Of course, Survivor Series has traditionally always featured at least one elimination style match itself. This meant that Bragging Rights encroached on what the older pay-per-view had to offer. Worse yet, fans just weren't that interested in some paper-thin brand battle that mixed heels and babyfaces together for no real reason.
For Survivor Series 2016, WWE hope that three elimination-style matches pitting Raw against SmackDown will enthral viewers. Using history as a sounding board, there's no evidence to suggest it will. This is something the company have tried before; it didn't work then and it's hard to see it working now.
There would have been some merit in a well-booked 'WWE Universal Champion vs. WWE World Champion' scenario, ironically for bragging rights. Simply throwing a whole load of talent out into the ring for a multi-man match doesn't quite inspire the same way.
3. Pay-Per-Views Are Coming Around Way Too Fast
On the subject of pay-per-views, WWE have presented no less than five supershows since the beginning of the WWE Draft. Admittedly, one of those (Battleground) fell right before things properly started on the July 25 edition of Monday Night Raw. Nonetheless, the company have crammed so many big shows into a three-month period.
Looking at things from a more positive standpoint, having extra content available on the WWE Network is difficult to class as a bad thing. This represents better value for money across the board. Sadly, it also feeds into an earlier point about repeat matches and exposes the lack of depth on the Raw and SmackDown rosters.
Take the most recent string of pay-per-views as an example. Backlash took place as a SmackDown event on September 11, before being followed by Raw's Clash Of Champions just two weeks later on September 25. From there, the blue brand presented No Mercy on October 9 and the red will produce Hell In A Cell just weeks after that on October 30.
This approximate two-week cycle is hectic, as the creative team barely have time to breathe before being hit with another show.
2. The Women's Division Wasn't Strong Enough To Be Split
Rewind to WrestleMania 32, Charlotte, Sasha Banks, and Becky Lynch were tearing the house down in a Triple Threat encounter designed to crown the new WWE Women's Champion. Clearly the most accomplished females on the main roster, the trio delivered in a big way on the largest stage.
Analyse the present day and it's still true that Charlotte, Banks, and Lynch are the best female performers on the main roster. Recently, they have been joined by Bayley. As good as she is, it'll take time before she becomes established on Raw.
Although there are other women helping to pad things out, the women's roster just wasn't deep enough to thrive upon being split in half.
On Raw, there are only nine female wrestlers, one of which (Paige) is currently serving a suspension and another (Emma) who hasn't even been featured since the WWE Draft. Over on the SmackDown side of things, the talent pool is even thinner. The blue brand only houses seven females, and champion Becky Lynch has been injured for the past few weeks.
WWE could have done with consolidating all of those women onto one show, rather than spreading them thinly across both.
1. Commissioner & GM Dynamic Feels Strange
Perhaps above all else, WWE have baffled everybody by adding even more authority figures to their core programming. Before the brand split, Triple H and Stephanie McMahon were the chief authoritarians on shows, occasionally backed up by Vince McMahon himself. Now, Raw and SmackDown have more figures calling the shots than ever before.
Shane and Stephanie McMahon were installed as the Commissioners for both SmackDown and Raw respectively before the Draft. Over time, they revealed that Mick Foley would be the General Manager on Raw and Daniel Bryan would be his opposite on SmackDown. Since then, there's been a weird dynamic on both shows.
Bryan and Shane get along a little better on SmackDown. At the same time, Bryan still has to answer to McMahon. The same goes for Foley on Raw, who regularly has his power undermined by the presence of Stephanie.
If anything, WWE needed to move away from the idea of authority figures for a while and just let the wrestlers do their thing. Unnecessary explanations for why each match is taking place are exactly that: they're redundant.
-
Do you agree that the WWE brand split isn't exactly on fire? Let us know what you think down in the comments section below!