10 Smartest Heel Plans In Wrestling History
These wrestling villains had it all worked out...
While there is definitely a place in the wrestling landscape for those foolish baddies designed to merely act as cannon fodder for our most cherished of heroes, there's still nothing quite like the sight of a wrestling evil genius getting the better of a babyface thanks to one hell of a cunning plan.
Said diabolical schemes have come in all shapes and sizes. But the end result, if executed effectively, tends to always be the same: an audience left with their jaws dangling off the floor as the dust settles on a despicable job well done.
Hell, in most cases, it's actually pretty hard to be genuinely mad at the following heelish names taking up a spot on this list, with the amount of thought, care, and attention that went into a lot of their unquestionably brilliant plots being just too darn impressive to completely fume at.
So, with all that in mind, it's time to take a closer look at everything from opportunistic antagonists pulling off the ultimate snatch-and-grab, freakishly dedicated heels who were rewarded for playing the long game, and many other undoubtedly masterful examples of a villain thoroughly outsmarting your favourites.
10. Edge Takes Advantage Of An Opportunity
Edge's New Year's Revolution WWE Championship heist still acts as one of the sweetest examples out there of a heel working smarter, not harder.
It's often forgotten when reliving the jaw-dropping turn-of-events that would eventually see Vince McMahon unleashing the then-Mr. Money in the Bank on John Cena shortly after surviving the Elimination Chamber that Edge had actually planted the first seed for his cash-in earlier in the evening.
On top of no doubt keeping an eye on The Face that Runs the Place throughout his first run with WWE's top strap, The Rated "R" Superstar clearly felt that the night of January 6, 2006 would be a particularly wise one to strike on - given the fact that whoever walked out of the chamber as champ would likely have just gone through physical hell.
So, in a bid to keep himself as fresh as possible, Edge would proceed to get himself disqualified during his Intercontinental Championship match with Ric Flair, nailing The Nature Boy with his briefcase whilst he was locking Lita in the figure-four.
Two spears later on in the night would bring that masterplan to a stunning and successful end, with Edge lifting his first WWE Championship after wisely resting up and picking his spot.
9. Chris Jericho Fools HBK With Christian Jericho
With the two wrestling icons going on to forge one of the finest feuds in modern wrestling history towards the end of the 2000's, it's easy to forget some of the absolute brilliance the pair found themselves at the centre of a few years earlier.
Hellbent on proving that he was every bit better than the legendary Shawn Michaels, who would be entering the 2003 Royal Rumble at #1, Chris Jericho opted to enter at #2 after winning an over-the-top-rope challenge on the January 13 edition of Raw.
But in an utterly inspired swerve on the night, hot on the heels of HBK making his way to the ring, Jericho's music set the stage for the entrance of a Y2J lookalike in the form of pal Christian.
Perplexed at what in the hell was happening, these few seconds of confusion soon allowed Jericho to take violent advantage of the situation, with Le Champion sneaking into the ring behind Michaels before emphatically pulverising his b*ll*cks.
A brutal beatdown and sickening chair shot to the skull soon resulted in Michaels' Rumble show being stopped. And so began a rivalry for the ages on the back of a truly cunning act of deception.
8. Kenny Omega Breaks Down The Forbidden Door To Seize The Belt
Unfortunately for The Purveyor of Violence, a certain Cleaner is about as resourceful as they come on his devilish day.
Jumping back to the latter stages of 2020, the masterful Kenny Omega had begun planting the seeds for a title collecting dynasty that would eventually take the business by storm.
The bringing of old pal Don Callis into the mix as a special guest commentator for his Full Gear AEW World Championship Eliminator tournament final match with Hangman Page was far more than a show of support.
The Forbidden Door was beginning to creak open, with Callis still acting as Impact Wrestling's executive Vice President. And it was Don who would pivotally hand his "family" the mic during another guest commentary spot at Winter is Coming, a weapon that would ultimately spell the end of Mox's run with the top strap.
Far from being done there, though, Omega and Callis would proceed onto the next stage of their epic scheme, welcoming the Good Brothers into AEW as The Elite's grip on the company only grew stronger by the week.
And it was this intelligent reinforcement that killed just about any hope of Mox wrestling his strap back away from his nefarious rival at Revolution.
And the best part? This was all part of a plot that was five years in the making, with Callis eventually revealing on Impact that he'd been acting as the "Invisible Hand" in Kenny's life ever since he met him 27-years earlier...
7. A Million Dollar Twin Bribe Costs Hogan The Strap
It's pretty well known that everyone had a price for The Million Dollar Man back in the day.
But arguably the most controversial and ingenious example of Ted DeBiase using his millions to get precisely what he wanted came during February 5, 1988's The Main Event as the chuckling villain outsmarted The Hulkster en-route to finally getting his paws on the WWF Championship.
With DiBiase enlisting the services of Andre the Giant in a bid to seize the title from Hulk Hogan at the event, one of the biggest shocks of the time soon went down as Dave Hebner opted to suddenly count the three despite The Immortal One's shoulders being off the mat.
As it goes, this wasn't actually Dave at all, it was Earl Hebner... you know, his twin. What a world.
Earl had been bribed by The Million Dollar Man to pull a fast one of the soon-to-be-departing babyface icon, with Hogan set to take some time off to film No Holds Barred. And with Dave locked in a closet during the bout itself, DiBiase was able to effectively buy the belt off of Hogan thanks to Andre quickly surrendering the strap to him shortly after.
6. Flair Inevitably Turns On The Stinger
Sometimes a devious plan is just so damn effective that even when you can smell it coming a mile off, there's still no guarantee that a hero will be able to avoid the incoming danger.
And that's precisely the position The Icon found himself in back when he formed an unlikely partnership with none other than The Nature Boy in the lead-up to WCW's Halloween Havoc 1995.
Heading into the pair's match against Ric Flair's one-time pal Arn Anderson and Brian Pillman, a great many refused to completely believe The Dirtiest Player in the Game would have the much-loved Stinger's back entirely. Not even after Flair was battered by The Enforcer on the first-ever episode of Monday Nitro.
And sure enough, Anderson and Pillman once again attacking Flair on the night of the PPV acted as little more than another sneaky step towards leaving Sting in a truly vulnerable spot and eventually adding one more all-important member to the latest version of The Four Horsemen.
After sitting out much of the contest due to said beatdown, Naitch finally arrived late in the day, only to receive his hot tag and instantly beat the p*ss out of Stinger alongside his fellow scheming a-holes.
Inevitable? Sure. But that still didn't make the sight of Flair and co. pulling a fast one on the valiant Sting any less shocking to behold.
5. Mark Henry Pulls The Ultimate Retirement Swerve
An angle so outstanding that it still leaves some folks second guessing whether each subsequent in-ring retirement speech is 100% legit nearly a decade on.
Coming into his June 17, 2013, appearance on Monday Night Raw opposite John Cena, Mark Henry had made a few headlines with his post-Extreme Rules strap match loss to Sheamus comments of "I'm going home."
So, when Henry hinted at a potential retirement from in-ring action on Twitter in the lead-up to that June edition of the red show, fans were fully expecting a heartfelt send-off for the dominant powerhouse.
And for a minute there, it felt like that was precisely what was being delivered, with The World's Strongest Man donning his now infamous salmon jacket and telling both WWE Champion Cena and those watching around the world that he was "formally retiring" from the active roster.
In truth, though, this was all a simply stunning ruse designed to lure Super Cena into a devastating trap.
Henry's true ambitions to finally take home the belt that had alluded him his entire career were exceptionally laced throughout said "farewell" speech. But before John or anyone else had a chance to figure that out, The Leader of the Cenation had been epically slammed through the canvas.
4. Seth Rollins Buys-In To The Authority
A chair-shot heard around the world.
On the back of becoming easily the most popular faction the company had seen in some time and utterly powering through just about every obstacle in their way, The Shield added arguably the most notable notch to their belts yet in the besting of Evolution.
But they don't call him the Cerebral Assassin for nothing, do they?
And fresh off of Batista waving farewell to the WWE Universe and Evolution on June 2, 2014, Trips revealed a plan B that would masterfully rid him of the thorn in his side that was the trio and change up the landscape forever.
Buying in on the "Evolution of Seth Rollins", The Architect of The Shield decided to coldly sever ties with the brothers he would later claim were little more than "business partners", feeling that aligning with The Game's Authority was the wiser move if he wished to succeed on his own.
And with one catastrophic swing of a steel chair, Seth simultaneously stunned the masses and made Papa H mighty proud. After all, it's all about the game, and how you play it...
3. The Rock Aligns Himself With The Corporation To Get Ahead
And speaking of one-time beloved babyfaces cruelly turning their backs on their people in pursuit of personal glory, has there ever been a more calculated and unexpected turn than the one that went down at Survivor Series 1998.
Vince McMahon had made it painfully clear that he'd placed all of his eggs into Mankind's basket heading into the Deadly Game WWF Championship tournament at the event, but this was all designed to merely set the stage for the ultimate twist during the eventual final.
With The Rock acting as arguably the most popular anti-hero in the company at that point, fans were fully on-board with the idea of The People's Champion walking out of St. Louis, Missouri as the new top champ. But in a rather painful case of "be careful what you wish for", it was soon revealed late in the day that Rocky had been conspiring with Mr. McMahon all along.
Before Mankind knew what hit him, Vince had pulled off his second screwjob in two years and embraced his new Corporate champ.
But why Rocky, why? Well, it turns out that The Great One never forgot about the days of "Die Rocky, Die". So, he'd actually been planning on sticking it up the People's candy asses ever since.
2. MJF Uses Regal To Win The Big One
MJF's duplicitous actions as he edged closer to a showdown with Jon Moxley over the AEW World Championship at Full Gear 2022 were nothing short of magnificent.
After fooling the world into believing he'd potentially given the idea of not relying on back-up a chance and subtly convincing the villain of all villains that he was a potential "Devil" worth getting behind, Maxwell executed a devilish piece of business his Lordship could be proud of.
In the wake of The Firm taking out MJF, the Brit eventually had no choice but to offer his services to the seemingly "weak" star of tomorrow on the night of his main event battle with Will's BCC teammate. And yet another piece fell perfectly into place as the Dynamite Diamond Ring was traded out for a brass one en-route to World title victory.
And with this final stage of the master plan to topple Mox and set out on a Reign of Terror for the ages complete, Maxwell proceeded to coldly bin off Regal with a sickening cheap shot a few weeks later. Regal's services were no longer needed after extracting everything he needed from the well-respected veteran.
Simply put, the Triple B holder is better than you and just about everyone else playing the game at this moment... and you know it.
1. Ole Anderson's Master Plan
Ole Anderson had locked horns with Dusty Rhodes throughout much of 1979, with the duo finding themselves at the centre of many a tag team encounter as the former often teamed with Ivan Koloff to take on The American Dream and whoever he'd roped in to the fight on that chosen night.
Yet, at some point down the road, Anderson appeared to have a change of heart.
Turning his back on villainous partner Koloff, Ole started to make pals with the babyfaces of Georgia Championship Wrestling over the next year or so. And it was this shrewd move that ultimately led to an unexpected alliance with Dusty and an eventual steel cage showdown with The Assassins.
Both sides were told to choose a special guest referee for the incoming war, with the heels opting for Koloff and the apparent faces going for Gene Anderson.
But then, before the action could even properly get underway, Rhodes was swiftly thrown into a five-on-one attack, with the unanticipated turn very nearly causing those in attendance to scale the fence to save the battered babyface.
Far from being a sudden attitude adjustment, though, Ole would later explain that he'd dedicated a year-and-a-half of his life to convincing Dusty he could be trusted.
He took beatings from his oblivious pals. Pretended to fight the good fight. And his secret mission to rid the world of Dusty once and for all not only led to Rhodes being utterly massacred inside of The Omni, it also reminded the world why Ole was truly a gloriously evil mastermind to be reckoned with.