10 Sweetest Examples Of WWE Payback

Revenge is a dish that’s best served cold - but payback is a b**ch.

By Jack Morrell /

The idea of ‘payback’ is the basis of every bit of business worth money since the industry began: the notion that people will pay to see the hero finally take down the villain.

Advertisement

In the old days, (before the pervasiveness of wrestling in popular culture and the need to up the ante made overbooking, gimmicks and stunts practically mandatory), feuds were built on delayed gratification: the babyface’s revenge would be put off over and over and over until finally he’d get his hands on the heel properly.

Now, there’s a reason why some arguably more famous feuds haven’t been included in this article. For example, everyone remembers Bruno Sammartino and Larry Zybysko’s legendary grudge of 1980 - but forgets that the cage match to blow off the feud was a scientifically wrestled bout won by Sammartino walking out through the cage door. Talk about an anti-climax.

Similarly, Matt Hardy’s dramatic showdown with Edge in 2005 was in a brilliant two-man Money In The Bank ladder match... that was buried on free television, in the middle of a Monday Night RAW dominated by an amazing Iron Man match between Kurt Angle and Shawn Michaels.

Satisfaction is the essence of payback. Sure, it’s good theatre to see a match full of blood and thunder, and a clean pinfall is still a benchmark for drawing a line under a feud - but payback needs to be sweet: for the babyface, and for the crowd. 

Here’s ten of the sweetest examples in WWE history...

10. Waking Up The Dead

“Before you embark on a journey of revenge, dig two graves.” - Confucius

Advertisement

Post-1998, you can’t be a main event babyface in the WWF/E if you’ve not feuded with the boss. In late 2003 the Undertaker (in his mortal, badass biker gimmick) was robbed of an almost certain victory over Brock Lesnar at the No Mercy pay-per-view when Vince McMahon interfered. The following week, the Undertaker was placed into an ‘impossible’ handicap match against Lesnar and the Big Show by incoming heel Smackdown manager Paul Heyman, with the gloating stipulation that if he won - hah! - then he could choose his own match.

Naturally, being a WWE babyface in peril, the Undertaker beat the odds, and in one of the most memorable segments in Smackdown history, collapsed on the ramp after the match and taunted by McMahon, the Undertaker named his match: Buried Alive, at Survivor Series… against McMahon himself.

The match itself was, as expected, a ten-minute, one-sided beatdown in which McMahon bladed early and bled heavily. About to bury his hated enemy alive, the Undertaker was assaulted by Kane, who threw his brother into the grave, allowing McMahon to dump a load of soil into it to get the win.

That booked the Undertaker off television for a number of months. In early 2004 however, ominous vignettes and weird happenings heralded the return of the Dead Man: the real deal, magical powers and all, which culminated in a match with Kane at WrestleMania XX.

The action itself may have taken around as long as the entrances did, but it was faster and more intense than you'd expect from the brothers, and extended the Undertaker’s WrestleMania streak to twelve-nil. However, what made it so special was the crowd’s delirious response to seeing the Undertaker, back in black (so to speak), and Kane’s manic, disbelieving response to seeing his brother back from the grave once more.

Selling fear and loathing like they were paying his mama’s medical bills, Kane’s performance was the cornerstone of the match. The outcome may have been a foregone conclusion, but thanks to his completely unselfish heeling about, we were treated to a deeply satisfying ending to the latest feud between the two colossi.

9. What Becomes Of The Brokenhearted

“For it is written, Vengeance is mine; I will repay, saith the Lord.” - Romans 12:19

Advertisement

Facing off against Batista at Backlash in 2008, Shawn Michaels faked a knee injury for a distraction victory. That match's special guest referee was a babyface Chris Jericho, who was furious at being complicit in Michaels’ cheating, and was superkicked over the argument. A match was made between the two for Judgement Day, at which Michaels beat his younger opponent.

However, the issue still bothered Jericho: the Heartbreak Kid had cheated, yet the fans loved him. Meanwhile, Jericho had uncovered the deception, but been booed over it. He confronted his hero again, and overwhelmed by jealousy and anger, assaulted Michaels, smashing his face through a monitor screen and turning heel.

In a further match six weeks later at the Great American Bash, Jericho targeted HBK’s (kayfabe) injured eye, causing the referee to stop the match.

When Michaels appeared at SummerSlam that year and attempted to announce his retirement from wrestling, Jericho confronted him once more, and matters escalated to the point that Jericho accidentally potatoed Michaels’ wife, taking the story to the next level.

Changing his mind about retirement, Michaels challenged Jericho to an Unsanctioned match at Unforgiven in September. Really only a new spin on the usual pre-PG no-DQ street fight, the match would supposedly absolve the participants and the company of any legal consequences from the violence to follow.

During the match itself, tables, ladders, chairs and other miscellaneous international objects came into play, as well as interference from Jericho’s sidekick Lance Cade. It wasn’t enough to stop a vengeful Shawn Michaels: he took both men out with a flying elbow, straight through a table.

Back in the ring, Michaels pinned Jericho’s arms while he was barely conscious, wrapping his fist in his own belt to punch him again, and again and again. And again. In a callback to the Great American Bash, the referee stopped the (damn) match, giving HBK the win. That didn’t stop the richly deserved beating: if anything, the post-match was even more brutal. Beside himself, Michaels even superkicked the referee when he tried to intervene.

8. The Entrepreneurs

“It seems to me that if there were any logic to our language, trust would be a four letter word.” - Risky Business

Advertisement

At 2005’s One Night Stand pay-per-view, the WWE’s first attempt at an ECW reunion show/cheap cash-in (depending on your point of view) featured a return to the old ECW vs. WWE feud.

Unfortunately, not everybody got the memo that the old antagonism was only ever a work. In one of the most notorious examples of unprofessional in-ring behaviour in wrestling history, John ‘Bradshaw’ Layfield targeted the hapless Blue Meanie and shoot on him under cover of the show-closing mêlée, delivering hard legit punches to seriously bloody his face.

Supposedly there was some heat between the two dating back years to Meanie’s first run with the WWE in the late nineties, and Meanie had since made comments about Bradshaw online. After the incident, JBL’s victim was in shock, and considering litigation: but the company had a better idea, booking the two men into a mini-feud.

Booked to lose to the Blue Meanie as a small punishment for the incident at One Night Stand, the company threw in some interference to protect JBL’s character - a chair shot from Meanie’s partner Stevie Richards and a spinebuster from Batista. Unfortunately for JBL, Richards knew the Meanie wouldn’t be booked to get in any serious offence, and took matters into his own hands.

To avenge JBL going into business for himself on his friend, Richards went into business for himself with the pre-booked chair shot, giving it as much welly as possible and cutting JBL open with the rim. This was payback on two levels: giving fans the Meanie’s revenge with the tainted pinfall victory, and giving the Meanie some real satisfaction with that vicious bash to the skull.

7. The Latino Volcano

“To survive a war, you gotta become war.” - Rambo: First Blood Part II

Advertisement

But there’s more JBL where that came from. Given an opportunity for Eddie Guerrero’s WWE Championship by heel general manager Kurt Angle in mid-2004, the big lug began trying to get into the champ’s head, interfering in his matches and cutting a racist promo on his family.

All that was bad enough - but after a month of mind games, the audience were informed on the May 6th edition of Smackdown that JBL had grabbed Guerrero’s mother and threatened her, causing her to have a heart attack. The following week, Guerrero was arrested for smashing the window of JBL’s limo, while JBL cleaned Rey Mysterio’s clock in the ring to send a message. The stage was set for a serious grudge match at Judgement Day that Sunday.

The match itself is usually remembered due to the horrific blade job that Eddie inflicted on himself. The match was intended to be a gorefest - however, Eddie hit an artery and lost far too much blood, so much so that it took a fortnight for him to fully recover.

But the story of the match was the champion’s revenge, and the blood definitely sold it. Eddie, dripping with claret, retained the title by disqualification after hitting JBL with the WWE Championship belt, and in the post-match angle, continued to beat the challenger down, despite the blood loss.

Over five additional minutes, Guerrero, every inch of his face a vivid scarlet, blasted JBL with another title belt shot and with chairs, opening up the bigger man in turn. Even as JBL tried to escape backstage, Guerrero followed him up the aisle to complete the beating, having to be dragged off him by three people to return to the ring, barely able to stay upright, but still able to hold the WWE Championship aloft.

Later in 2004, Eddie would rely on his real life friend to take the title from him when the pressure of being the WWE Champion became too much to bear. But for that one night, Latino Heat was a merciless, fighting champion who didn’t take !*$% from anyone.

6. I’m A Paul Heyman Guy

“You see it's our style to keep it true, I've had a bad year, a lot to go through. I've been knocked out, beat down, black and blue…” - Rancid, ‘Fall Back Down’

Advertisement

In July 2013, Paul Heyman, CM Punk’s representative/best mate, turned on the former WWE Champion to cost him the Money In The Bank ladder match, and therefore a guaranteed shot at the title he’d lost earlier in the year.

As schisms go, that’s your generic heel-turn-into-grudge-match play… except that it’s not, context applying a couple of extra layers here. It was Punk who’d been turned babyface when he returned at Payback in June after three months off: he and Heyman had been nasty, grandiloquent heels together during his epic run at the top.

Heyman was still a villain, through and through, and proved it at Money In The Bank. More than that though, Punk’s backstory made it clear that he was ‘a Paul Heyman guy’: that this was his mentor, the man he owed his WWE career to. What’s more, Punk was a former two time Money In The Bank winner, and the clear kayfabe favourite. That all combined to make the betrayal far more personal, and the stakes that much higher.

The rivalry got even more personal in the lead-up to the big matches: each man was one of the best of his generation on the mic, and the promos were like hot fire. At SummerSlam, Punk found his way to Heyman blocked by Brock Lesnar: the two delivered a blistering near half hour of no disqualification action. Lesnar went over, but the following Monday Punk was back behind the wheel and gunning for Heyman again, with the sneaky rationale that WWE couldn’t afford to keep Lesnar coming back just to save Heyman from a whupping.

Curtis Axel was the next ‘Paul Heyman Guy’ to get in Punk’s face, and then Ryback was next. Punk was forever getting Heyman just where he wanted him, and then being blocked and knocked back. Finally, at 2013’s Hell In A Cell pay-per-view, Punk cornered Heyman on the top of the Hell In a Cell cage. There was nowhere to run: Punk obliterated his former friend and delivered the GTS on top of the cell. Two weeks later on RAW, he'd deliver a post script to a rapturous reception.

5. Breathing Fire

“Come not between the dragon, and his wrath” - King Lear

Advertisement

For a verrry long time, WrestleMania 3’s standout match between ‘the Macho Man’ Randy Savage and Ricky ‘The Dragon’ Steamboat was considered the best match in WrestleMania history.

From all appearances, people are going for the Undertaker’s first bout against Shawn Michaels these days. Still, that doesn’t affect the astonishing nature of the Savage/Steamboat contest, especially considering the time period involved. 1987 WWF was not a haven for technical masterclasses, let’s put it that way.

In amongst all the accolades given to the match itself, people tend to forget that the match was the culmination of a long and bitter feud between the two men. On an episode of Superstars in November 1986, Savage barely scraped a win over Steamboat for his Intercontinental Championship when the Dragon was counted out - and ‘the Macho Man’ being who he was, assaulted Steamboat as he was greeting fans at ringside on his way out. He injured Steamboat’s throat with the ring bell, keeping him out of competition until January.

During the intervening period, Savage would gloat about having ended Steamboat’s career - that is, until the babyface hero reappeared, saving George ‘The Animal’ Steele from the same kind of injury he’d received, and threatening revenge. The stage as set for their WrestleMania match, which completely stole the show as well as providing sweet catharsis for the good guy.

Best of all was the callback to that first post-match beatdown. Steele was in Steamboat’s corner for the match, and saved him from yet another larynx injury with the ring bell, paying him back for the rescue back in January and allowing Steamboat to pick up the victory, in the comeback of the year.

Of course, this ended Savage’s incredible, iconic 414 day run with the title. The Dragon was earmarked for an equally long babyface run, but upset management by asking for time off, and would drop the title to the Honky Tonk Man two months later. The rest is history… it just wasn’t the Dragon’s history.

4. The Greatest Love Story Of All Time

“The greatest thing you’ll ever learn is just to love, and be loved in return.” - Moulin Rouge

Advertisement

The story of ‘Stone Cold’ Steve Austin versus Mr. McMahon isn’t really the story of the working class joe, the blue collar icon, versus a tyrannical boss. When you add up all the narrative beats, it’s the story of two violent egos butting heads, and an obsessive, almost sexual need for domination.

To begin with, the central conceit of the angle was that Austin was the most popular guy in the company and McMahon's golden goose, at a time when they needed every cent they could find behind the sofa. Austin was an invaluable commodity, and needed to be promoted in the main event, but he refused to do as he was told.

The feud was all about escalation: it started with persuasion, a gentle reminder of his place in the hierarchy: Austin publically embarrassed McMahon and told him to go to hell. It ramped up into petty disciplinaries and a volatile work environment: Austin publically embarrassed McMahon and told him to go to hell.

It progressed through sanctioned whuppings masquerading as wrestling matches, to out-and-out prison beatings: Austin publically embarrassed McMahon, told him to go to hell and beat the !*$% out of everyone he sent to punish him.

Neither man would ever back down, but Austin remained frustrated. Mr. McMahon wasn’t a wrestler, so payback was almost always by proxy. Finally, at the St. Valentine's Day Massacre pay-per-view in February 1999, Austin used McMahon's obsession with him as the hook, and his WrestleMania title shot as bait. He got his one on one match, inside a steel cage match. It’s the WWF/E equivalent of ‘get a room’.

Naturally, the match wasn’t really a match: it was an excuse for the hated heel to be beaten sh*tless by a popular babyface with a serious grudge, the ultimate wrestling catharsis. McMahon tried using the debuting Paul ‘Big Show’ Wight as his ace-in-the-hole, but Austin still pulled off the beatdown and the win.

Austin and McMahon weren't done there, not by a long, long shot. However, the mutual hatred was by now so over-the-top that it was losing all logic and narrative coherence.

This was the right place and the right way to give the crowd the satisfaction they needed: although it does make you wonder why the pair of them didn’t just sleep together and get it over with.

3. What Goes Around, Comes Around

"Success is the best revenge." - Anon

Advertisement

One of my personal favourite moments of payback wasn’t just against one man. It was a vindication of a fan favourite’s career, personal revenge against a man who’d betrayed and deeply hurt him, and pure, visceral payback to the guy that kept laying the smack down on him for no good reason.

That’s right: it’s January 4th, 1999, one of the most infamous nights in pro wrestling’s long, infamous history. It’s the night Mrs. Foley’s baby boy won the WWF Championship.

As a subservient, gormless lackey to the eeevil Mr. McMahon, Mankind had come to see the horrible old b*stard as kind of a father figure. An abusive, distant father figure, true - but beggars can’t be choosers. And McMahon finally seemed like he was beginning to appreciate poor old Mick, appearing to groom him as his hand-picked champion.

Of course, it was all a horrible lie. At the tournament final to crown a new WWF Champion at Survivor Series 1998, McMahon repeated the events of the previous year’s Montreal Screwjob and, with Mankind in The Rock’s lame version of the sharpshooter, ordered the bell rung without a submission and the title awarded to the new Corporate Champion: The Rock.

The crowd surged to rally around the new underdog babyface over the coming weeks as he sought vengeance. He finally found it at the RAW taping on December 29th 1998, when (with a little help from his friends) he beat his hated rival for the title he’d been robbed of, and screwed McMahon over in the process.

Foley was hoisted into the air and carried around the ring in celebration. Unbeknownst to him that night, a few days later there’d be cause for even more. When that night’s RAW was finally broadcast in the new year, WCW - Foley’s old employers, who’d never seen anything in him or his Cactus Jack character sufficient to warrant stardom - carried on their usual practice of spoiling the taped results of RAW on their live Nitro show.

Announcer Tony Schiavone was instructed to tell the WCW audience at home the results of the WWF’s main event, and sarcastically added, "That'll put a lot of butts in seats." And so it did: estimates are that 600,000 households turned over to watch Foley’s moment of triumph, thanks to WCW’s gaffe.

2. The Rhodes Less Travelled

With the unholy alliance of Triple H, Stephanie McMahon, and their figurehead Randy Orton into The Authority at SummerSlam 2013, there was a lot of weight being thrown around the WWE.

Advertisement

They’d screwed over Daniel Bryan, picked on Dolph Ziggler and abused the Big Show, and the latest in line was Cody Rhodes.

Placed in a match with the WWE Champion, Rhodes was told that he’d be fired if he didn’t win - and he just about came up short. The following week, Cody’s brother Dustin - aka Goldust - came back to fight for his brother’s job, but he too couldn’t quite come out on top.

At every stage, Orton, Stephanie or Triple H would stick the knife in, savouring the humiliation being heaped on the Rhodes boys. It got worse: when their legendary father, ‘the American Dream’ Dusty Rhodes called the Authority out over the matter, he was belittled, intimidated and assaulted.

His boys retaliated, and a match was made between the Rhodes brothers and two-thirds of The Shield for the Battleground pay-per-view: if they won, they’d get their jobs back… but if they lost, the Dream would be fired from his position as NXT General Manager.

It was the first time that Cody Rhodes and Goldust had ever partnered together and at Battleground, they came up trumps. The Dream fended off interference from Dean Ambrose, and Cody hit the Cross Rhodes on Seth Rollins for the win.

The family that fought together, stayed together, and the brothers earned their jobs back. In a highly charged emotional victory celebration, the locker room emptying out to congratulate them on stage.

1. Grapefruits For Breakfast

"Stronger than lover’s love is lover’s hate. Incurable, in each, the wounds they make." - Euripideslinda vince

Advertisement

As a horrible boss, an unprincipled liar and an over-the-top megalomaniac, there’s few pro wrestling villains worse than Mr. McMahon. He’s abused, threatened and humiliated pretty much every major babyface of the last twenty years, but probably the worst things he ever did were to his own family.

It’s difficult to feel sorry for Stephanie or Shane: after all, they’ve switched sides so many times and returned to embrace their grotesque old man so many more. But his wife Linda? She’s the McMahon who’s always stayed a little in reserve, and is usually presented as the voice of reason, the representative of fair play.

In 2001, the McMahons were splintered: Vince had demanded a divorce from Linda, sending her into a grief-stricken catatonic state. Engaged in a lurid, awful affair with a pre-awesome Trish Stratus, McMahon kept his wheelchair-bound wife around and sedated to punish and humiliate her while he carried on with his plastic fancy woman in front of her.

It all came to a head at WrestleMania X-Seven, when Vince took on Shane in a street fight, his son being sick of his father’s horrendous behaviour, while Linda - the lights on, but nobody home - looked on from ringside. Dragging her into the ring, McMahon made her sit and watch as he pummelled and destroyed their son, until finally, to cheers, Linda stood and kicked the Genetic Jackhammer straight in his notorious grapefruits.

That allowed referee Mick Foley and Shane enough time to recover, and both men beat McMahon down sufficiently that Shane could hit a dramatic Coast-To-Coast dropkick across the ring and into a garbage can covering his father’s face, giving him the pinfall victory.

The feelgood vibe didn’t last long: Vince came back out in the main event to help orchestrate ‘Stone Cold’ Steve Austin’s heel turn against The Rock. Still - Linda had been vindicated, and the spousal abuse storyline ended in the best way possible, with the abused spouse emasculating the cheating, malignant husband in front of millions of people. There’s no one there or at home on the night of April Fool’s Day 2001 who didn’t spring up and cheer the greatest nutshot in pro wrestling.

Advertisement