10 Things AEW Wants You To Forget About 2023

Tony Khan had a year that was less than "great" in 2023...

By Michael Sidgwick /

AEW was really great when it was good in 2023.

Advertisement

The Better Than You BayBay saga was prolonged and turned sour, but - aside from some of those naff pre-tapes - MJF and Adam Cole's relationship was for a while a stirring mystery that struck the perfect notes of emotion and cliffhanger suspense.

Bryan Danielson, one if not the greatest wrestler ever, should have been inducted into a Hall of Fame and sent to jail at the same time for his shockingly violent artistic masterclasses. Swerve Strickland appeared to crack that elusive main event bracket, which was some achievement. AEW isn't just full to bursting point with great upper midcard talent; that dam broke long, long ago, and it was Swerve who took that spot by the throat.

Kenny Omega was on fire in the ring, even if his feud with Don Callis didn't really click (a traditional fired-up babyface promo really wouldn't have gone amiss). When Lance Archer wrestled some doomed jobber in October, he was announced as "kicking his way down to the ring", which proved that the vintage wit hadn't deserted AEW. The decision to belt pandemic champion Hikaru Shida ahead of Wembley Stadium proved that the company still beats with the old heart.

However...

10. The Slow Decay Of Three Brands

AEW produces four different television programmes - and only one is truly "elite". Dynamite was uneven throughout 2023, but AEW still effectively positioned it as important.

Advertisement

Rampage is all but pinished as something worth caring about, outside of the odd, out-of-nowhere thrill, like the sequel to the Parking Lot Fight and Mistico's shock debut. Remember when you'd hear reports of fans absolutely gushing that they'd just watched some taped Match of the Year Candidate, like Bryan Danielson Vs. Eddie Kingston? Remember settling in to watch Rampage knowing that greatness awaited?

Those days are dead. Rampage is glorified Elevation: a dumping ground for barely used undercard acts and those who are under contract because they are close with management figures.

Collision launched and was mostly different, very, very good and actually worthwhile, although one match was always unreasonably long. When CM Punk departed, the show became the one night a week you'd get to see Bryan Danielson. That's good - great for 20 minutes - but the multiple In Action graphics and the unnecessary five-to-ten minutes tacked onto every main event underscored that AEW simply does not have enough ideas for five hours of TV every week. Contrast what happens at the top of the hour between Dynamite and Collision. Saturdays are fine, but unimportant.

Sometimes there are six hours, and Battle Of The Belts is not merely an obligation: AEW treats it like an imposition. Unlike Collision and even Rampage for a few months there, it never once developed an iota of prestige. Nobody, and this includes Tony Khan, gives a damn.

The effect is not great: AEW used to feel premium and elusive, and was the epicentre of conversation. Now, it's closer to a content farm than the original vision.

9. Double Or Nothing

Double Or Nothing was a very, very fun show to attend live - Karen Jarrett hit Aubrey Edwards with a guitar, and Matt Jackson kicked a bomb in Jon Moxley's face! - but it was less fun for those who paid a premium sum for it on pay-per-view.

Advertisement

The amount of outside interference was staggering, draining - totally ineffective after the first three times. The Acclaimed Vs. House of Black was just there; a nothing Trios match that failed entirely to fulfil the initial promise of a high-octane genre unique to the promotion.

(In general, the Trios title probably warrants an entry unto itself. The division was unexciting, in a once-thought impossible development, existing as an excuse to keep the Acclaimed on television).

Adam Cole and Chris Jericho's grudge match was a clunky dud and not a soul in the T-Mobile arena bought Adam Cole's performance as a badass at the finish. The final two matches were incredible and the last 10 minutes of FTR Vs. Planet Jarrett were overbooked in the best possible way, but as a show on the whole, Double Or Nothing laid bare the chronic lack of inspiration that had plagued the promotion.

AEW was a major critical success on pay-per-view elsewhere - but...

8. Not Great PPV Builds

AEW promoted some of the best wrestling matches ever on pay-per-view this year, and the range was incredible. The best Iron Man match ever, the best technical wrestling match ever, the best Death Match ever, some of the best, most crazed arena and stadium-wide brawls you're ever like to see: AEW is the self-styled "buffet", and its fans ate very well.

Advertisement

For six nights of the year.

AEW's TV output was wildly uneven, more on which imminently, and some episodes of Dynamite and Collision peaked at amazing - but the TV exists to build a destination event, and how often did AEW really make your heart pound in anticipation ahead of a major PPV weekend?

MJF Vs. Bryan Danielson was the most well-promoted match ahead of Revolution, and while it was wonderful to watch the Dragon run through a sublime gauntlet of different, exquisite pro wrestling matches, the story was a bit familiar four years into the promotion's history.

The Elite Vs. Blackpool Combat Club programme carried the Double Or Nothing build - the Four Pillars Four-Way was a noble failure undermined by each challenger deciding that something called the "worked shoot" was a cool, state-of-the-art device - and it still wasn't great. The brawls ruled, but why, really, were the BCC and the Elite fighting? Bryan Danielson was basically playing a proxy CM Punk. The whole thing felt hollow and convoluted.

Forbidden Door and WrestleDream benefitted from a pared-back approach - the best wrestlers wrestled the best wrestlers to determine who is the absolute best - but the All In/All Out double-header was an irritating venture into the content farm era. The build to MJF Vs. Adam Cole was funny, emotional, compelling, unpredictable - almost every type of good story in one package - but elsewhere, Christ.

Kenny Omega working a glorified Dynamite match in Wembley Stadium was stupid, and the people who defended it are those who will watch AEW because of its initials alone no matter how poor it might become.

7. The Attendances

In virtually every city or town AEW ran in 2023, fewer people attended than they had in prior years. This was a bleak, sobering trend, particularly when you consider what happens in 2024. The company isn't getting hotter, put it that way.

Advertisement

Certain gates - not all, mind you - bordered on the humiliating.

In 2021, as fans returned, those packed, more intimate buildings were ablaze with heat. Brightly lit and throbbing, you could see every, up-for-it face. 2023 feels different.

AEW often runs huge, cavernous arenas that could in theory hold close to 15,000 people. Collision - which has not remotely helped, and indeed dilutes interest among the ticket-buying public - often attracts punters in the 3,000 range. The lack of interest filtered into the atmosphere. It sounded and just felt empty, bleak, a visual and aural reminder that AEW simply wasn't as hot as it once was.

If you go to watch a Raw taping, you're all but guaranteed to see each of the top stars wrestle, or certainly the majority of them. AEW's rotating cast policy means you might not see one of Jon Moxley, Bryan Danielson, Kenny Omega, MJF, Chris Jericho...

Is that the primary reason? Or was AEW just generally flat creatively?

Ticket prices didn't help, but be real: if AEW was at its absolute best, the punters would flock to it.

6. What DIDN'T Happen

There's much for AEW to fret over what the promotion did do - more on which imminently - but it was a year to forget for they didn't.

Advertisement

Bluntly, and this has been a problem for at least two years, Tony Khan has signed too many top names. This has caused a bleak sort of havoc on the narrative; even without a formal rankings system, Khan can't book too many top stars to win because they'd be in contention for titles, and then he'd have to beat them.

Konosuke Takeshita best highlights this issue. He pinned Kenny Omega, former AEW World champion, twice in the space of a week. Take was not figured into the World title picture, and Khan became particularly enamoured with TNT champion Christian Cage in the autumn. Jon Moxley needed sprucing up, and so he was given the International title. There was nothing for Take to really "do", so he instead paraded as a bodyguard figure for Don Callis and didn't work a singles match on TV between July and October.

The ranking system disappeared in part because of Khan's greedy recruitment policy. He can't push everyone, so instead, he made a very unfortunate habit of treating multiple wrestlers like paperwork he'd hidden in his drawer at 4:55PM on a Friday.

This had a suboptimal effect on programming...

5. The Effects Of Poor Planning

Who does AEW want to push - and who are you, the viewer, truly meant to get behind?

Advertisement

The answers to these questions were very hazy in 2023, the effect of which was less than ideal. The more you are conditioned not to care, the harder it is to give a damn in the future. There's an exponential effect at work here, one that plagued the general vibe of the promotion.

As covered, Konosuke Takeshita's wins over Kenny Omega meant little to his title prospects. The ultra-charming powerhouse Willow Nightingale won the women's Owen Hart Cup before doing virtually nothing afterwards. Fans used to chant "You're a wrestler!" at the incredible Daniel Garcia, but, underscoring how stop/start his philosophical epiphany arc was, they seemed happy to receive him as an amusing undercard clown deeper into 2023.

Andrade el Idolo was another fitful presence with a low ceiling on Collision. Keith Lee is just another wrestler who can't win that often because he'd have to do something meaningful, and there is simply no room.

Ultimately, because Tony Khan had assessed his new signings on an individual basis, without thinking of his roster as a narrative ecosystem, he made it very difficult to care about the wrestlers he booked.

4. The Random Babyface Alliances

Babyfaces should have friends, otherwise they're unlikeable losers who don't really warrant your support. At the same time, heels need to get heat and should not be thwarted every single time they beat a babyface down.

Advertisement

It's a tricky balance to get right, one that opens up plot holes quite often, but AEW gets it right much of the time.

This is a narrative paradox of sorts, one that Tony Khan has made more complicated than it needs to be by assembling a series of all-star babyface squads. Khan likes to book multi-man matches in order to tease singles matches, and he did so with a meme-friendly angle throughout 2023.

Orange Cassidy...teaming with Bandido?!

lol!

You'll never remember who teamed with Orange Cassidy to take on the JAS in June, because a lot of these temporary babyface squads come and go and are basically answers to difficult trivia questions.

The answer is Keith Lee and El Hijo del Vikingo.

Orange Cassidy has teamed with virtually every face in the company this year (in addition to his actual Best Friends stable): Sting, Darby Allin, HOOK, Adam Cole, Roderick Strong, Katsuyori Shibata, Penta El Zero Miedo...

This is a bit of a problem in itself, in that it underscores how random and trivial Dynamite is too often, but consider the ramifications of this "Hey, check out this weird and wonderful match graphic!" approach.

Eddie Kingston got his ass kicked for minutes on end by Jeff Jarrett's cronies on the October 21 Collision. Eddie had teamed with - yes - Orange Cassidy at All In: London. Cassidy went to war with Eddie, but didn't make the save two months later. AEW used to be the company that rewarded a super close watch; now, they can't even remember their own continuity.

A lot of stuff you are expected to forget just...happened this year.

3. Tony Khan's Twitter Storm

Due to some sport or other, on October 10, AEW Dynamite was "time-shifted" and put head-to-head with WWE NXT.

Advertisement

WWE loaded up the show with John Cena, the Undertaker and Cody Rhodes - and were always going to win. Khan should have counter-programmed but let his Title Tuesday show speak for itself, realistically.

Undermining the idea somewhat, Tony Khan had previously revealed that he was told to do his anti-corporate, us-against-the-machine marketing tactic by...a corporation. Warner urged him to depict his AEW league as a snotty, defiant "challenger brand" in contempt of their bigger rival.

Khan, and this was amusing for a short while before he signed Ric Flair, went studs-up with both feet. He buried Vince MxMahon’s alleged sexual misconduct and, referencing Curb Your Enthusiasm, called Shawn Michaels a bald a**hole. If NXT had announced a DX reunion, Khan was surely seconds away from reminding his followers that Triple H once performed in blackface.

He then, following a bloodbath loss in total viewers, made sure to mention that Cena and 'Taker had never before appeared on a show that had drawn under one million viewers.

So who was the real loser, huh?

...AEW, handily.

'Poster Tony' worked better when AEW did actually face an existential threat, but when a lot of AEW's problems were of his own making, he had better, more productive things to do than cry foul.

Maybe knuckle down and work out a way to bring back the rankings system?

2. CM Punk

It's hard to forget that CM Punk existed.

Advertisement

His run was exceptional, and he's CM Punk: the epicentre of everything. His dramatic exits, plural, left an unshakeable cloud over everything. AEW was the company that could leave your mouth agape when a match graphic flashed on the screen. Through the embrace of all styles and the opening of more than one Forbidden Door, impossible was nothing. The match wasn't exactly good, but it was still magic, in principle, that AEW ran back Chris Jericho Vs. Juventud Guerrera in 2021.

Punk's exit has ruined that feeling because CMFTR Vs. The Elite is the one that got away. It's hard to forget about Punk whenever the Bucks do anything that isn't working a match with him. They are inextricably linked forever.

Collision is two good if ultimately unnecessary hours now, and it's hard to watch the suspiciously long main events knowing that the show was a CM Punk vehicle. Now, it's just a mostly fine reminder that AEW does not have four hours' worth of ideas a week.

Forget those incredible stooging masterclasses opposite Satoshi Kojima and Samoa Joe, because you only got a taste of the CM Punk heel run you'll never forget.

AEW has attempted to erase CM Punk from its history - but the mark he left inside of the ring and out is indelible.

1. Tony Khan Sleepwalked Into Every Booking Mistake Ever

A gigantic roster of talent, more than a handful of which have intimated on Twitter or in media interviews that they aren't happy.

Advertisement

An excessive amount of titles for which these wrestlers can compete, rendering too many of them valueless.

Five tiring hours of television - at an absolute minimum - every week.

Because there are several ostensibly major wrestlers, it's not a great idea to have them lose too often, so when they do, it's almost invariably as a result of interference ran by a heel manager or an entire stable.

Also, as covered, the warehouse of talent can't all get pushed at the same time, and thus fan investment wanes.

AEW is still considerably better than every other promotion to have entered a state of decline, but the point remains - you could apply those five italicised sentences to WWE in 2019, and they'd fit. They also describe AEW in 2023.

Again, AEW is miles and miles better than that, but Tony Khan, grappling with that difficult second album after completing his grand plan to turn Hangman Page into the main character, has stumbled into making every mistake every North American promoter always seems to end up making.

More worryingly still, this sort of fire is very difficult to put out. You can't just go back. The situation is too messy and complicated, shaped by ego and fraught politics.

Advertisement