10 Things We Learned From American Nightmare: Becoming Cody Rhodes

WWE's new documentary on Cody Rhodes is must-see television. Here's why!

By Jamie Kennedy /

Anybody who has studied Cody Rhodes' career since 2016 could tell you he's a passionate soul who's driven by family and a burning need to improve oneself. Go further back and the same still applies - Cody's first forays onto WWE TV in 2007 showcased a raw rookie who only wanted to make his famous father proud.

Advertisement

That pride shines on like a beacon of hope throughout this new doc's runtime.

Two things will grab headlines immediately. Firstly, the fact that AEW is featured in a WWE documentary will tickle some. Second, Triple H's knowing comments about Tony Khan's promotion will stir up some chatter on social media, but that's to be expected. It's important to say that this deep dive on Cody's life and career has more to offer than cheap 'us vs. them' anyway.

There's a lot to glean from Rhodes' observations about everything from NXT, Stardust, leaving WWE, rejoining the company, WrestleMania and more. Other talking heads, like Hunter, Xavier Woods, The Undertaker and Brandi also keep the stories coming, and ensure the show never ambles along without some tasty info to feast on.

Here's everything learned from Cody's retrospective.

10. His First Memory Ever Is WrestleMania VI

Imagine your first childhood memory ever being WrestleMania. In fact, scratch that; imagine your first childhood memory ever being inside the ring at WrestleMania. Cody Rhodes can say that, because his earliest recollections include standing in-ring before 'Mania VI back in 1990.

Advertisement

Cody would've been just shy of five years old at the time, but he told WWE's interviewers that he doesn't remember much before Dusty placed him on the mat in Toronto on 1 April '90. Now, the man has hazy images of that gold WWF logo on blue turnbuckle pads burned into his brain, and he recalls thinking the top rope looked really high.

That's cool as f*ck.

Dusty teamed with Sapphire to take on Randy Savage and Queen Sherri at that pay-per-view. It wasn't the most high-profile bout of his iconic career, but the day would live with his son forever. Not many kids can say their first memories of dad include 'Mania.

9. Xavier Woods’ Master Plan

Xavier Woods wanted to wrestle Cody for decades. Literally.

Advertisement

The New Day man told cameras during the doc that he and Rhodes wrestled amateur for rival schools during their formative years. Get this: Xavier's grand plan was to beat Cody in front of a watching Dusty. Why? Well, he hoped the 'American Dream' might be impressed and agree to train him for the pros.

Then, all going well, that'd be Woods' ticket into WWE. There was one big flaw in his scheming though - Dusty was mindful of stealing the spotlight whenever Cody was wrestling, so he was never actually front and centre at the matches. Instead, dad watched from a distance so full focus went on his boy.

Xavier couldn't have known that at the time. He simply saw Cody as a rival that could help him get one step closer to his own pro wrestling ambitions. Why the hell has nobody pitched this storyline during WWE creative meetings?! Maybe they have!

8. His Story About Dusty Melted Brandi’s Heart

Millions of fans worldwide melted when an impassioned Cody showed off a picture of Dusty holding the old WWF Title on the tron shortly after returning last year. His explanation, one laced with slight embarrassment from Dusty upon revealing to his kid he'd never officially won the thing, fanned the flames of support.

Advertisement

Brandi found the whole thing charming too.

Cody showed her that same photograph when they first started dating, and said he wanted to win the WWE Title someday so his father would be proud. Brandi thought that was a gorgeous story, and it brought the young couple closer together. It also showed off the good heart Cody had.

People knew this anyway, but Brandi's words here reassert there was nothing disingenuous about Cody's Raw promo in April 2022. It was honest, heartfelt, and something he's carried with him throughout his entire wrestling career. Yes, including his AEW days and matches elsewhere.

7. Why NXT Was “Maddening” To Him

Countless members of WWE's current roster viewed Dusty Rhodes as a mentor during their NXT days. Seth Rollins, Roman Reigns, Bayley, Kevin Owens and many others have gone on record to describe Dusty as akin to a father figure, and... that always bugged the sh*t out of Cody.

Advertisement

The 'Dream' wasn't chuffed with WWE's treatment of Cody as Stardust back between 2014-2015, and he'd actively encouraged his son to quit if he wasn't happy either. The worst thing about all of this to Cody? NXT's young "Dusty kids" like Rollins and Reigns were heating up, and here he was playing a watered down version of Goldust without experiencing even half the success.

In the doc, Cody likened that to his dad having a baseball team but telling him he wasn't allowed to play. Triple H then kinda half-heartedly defended the Stardust idea by saying WWE cares more about the overall brand than individuals. Fair enough, but everyone thought the gimmick was rubbish by 2015.

No wonder Cody was miserable.

6. He Knowingly Tried To Get Fired

This might've been reported somewhere before, but it was news to yours truly.

Advertisement

Cody admitted to mixing whiskey with Gatorade and drinking it backstage. He’d mentally checked out by 2016, but claims the intention was never to get drunk or messed up. Instead, the frustrated Stardust was hoping his antics would catch WWE’s attention and make them cut the cord for him.

That’s rough, but Rhodes was going through a lot after his dad’s death. Perhaps realising that, WWE didn’t fire him for acting out. No, he fired them in 2016 and decided enough was enough. It was time to stop bashing his head against a proverbial brick wall and see what else was out there in the wrestling world.

It was a massive risk, obviously, but Cody felt like it was the best option open to him. What was the alternative? Continue to be absolutely f*cking down about playing Stardust and feeding on creative scraps every week?

5. AEW & New Japan Make It In

This is already one of the biggest aspects of the doc people are talking about.

Advertisement

Some fan-made footage from All In made it onto WWE's show, and Peacock did a nice job of acknowledging Cody’s career post-release between 2016 until his return in 2022. This is perhaps the first time WWE has properly done that, and it’s a good thing too. It would’ve been brutal to pretend he only wrestled on the independents, or something.

Seeing The Young Bucks, Wrestle Kingdom, etc on a WWE-produced documentary is rather surreal somehow, to be fair. Imagine WCW footage had popped up on WWF docs back in the '90s - that's what this is like. It'll be a big selling point for some sitting on the fence about watching.

Honestly, drink it all in (pun intended). Hearing phrases like "forbidden door" (which is also the name of an AEW pay-per-view) uttered on what is effectively WWE programming feels almost taboo. Cody was right to push for this stuff, because it's a big part of his story.

4. The Undertaker Was Impressed By AEW

Right, time to dispense with some pretence first and foremost! The Undertaker doesn't pretend to be some AEW fanboy who gets giddy about seeing matches like Omega vs. Ospreay. However, the legend does admit he's impressed that Cody left WWE to bank on himself.

Advertisement

The fact Rhodes developed a brand new company and helped build it from the ground up with his friends does earn 'Taker's respect. He's happy to acknowledge that not many wrestlers would've taken that sort of risk at the time, especially back in 2016 when there wasn't a major company waiting to snap Cody up.

What a glowing endorsement from one of the best to ever do it. No doubt Tony Khan will be grinning from ear to ear when he sees this bit of the doc, and rightly so. It's recognition from a WWE icon that moments like All In and AEW's formation changed the landscape of modern wrestling.

Very cool.

3. Reports About His AEW Exit Were Wrong

Some will probably be slightly disappointed to find out Cody refuses to reveal exactly why he left AEW in 2022 here. It's true - Rhodes doesn't pinpoint one definitive thing, but does say that some of the reported reasons online at the time were way, way, way wide of the mark.

Advertisement

He didn't leave All Elite due to money grumbles, or because of problems with other workers in the promotion. No, Cody said it was more to do with "a personal issue" and his burning desire to chase the biggest dream he's ever had: Becoming WWE Champion for his father.

Triple H calling AEW "a secondary promotion" will ruffle some feathers, but anybody shocked by that at this stage needs a reality check. Hunter (or indeed any member of upper WWE management interviewed for the doc) was never going to heap praise on the competition.

Maybe Cody will reveal the unnamed "personal issue" he referred to someday.

2. Inside Scoop On HIAC Is Fascinating

Rewatching Cody's war of attrition vs. Seth Rollins at Hell In A Cell 2022 remains painful. Of course, no amount of fan grimacing could match the actual physical hell Cody was going through. He'd torn his pec muscle days before the match, but begged WWE officials not to cancel plans.

Advertisement

Ever wondered what Seth's reaction to the injury was when he received word? It's here. Rollins asked, "Are you f*cking kidding me?!", and was horrified when Rhodes said he was not. The doc includes some super-compelling voice clips of Cody asking for the bout to go ahead unhindered too, which is a fun bonus.

They're worth checking out.

Nobody could quite believe that Rhodes still wanted to go through with a Cell match in that state, and he later admitted backstage to lying about how much or how little pain he was in. In reality, Cody almost vomited during the match, which really says it all.

1. “Why Should I Be The One?”

An awful lot of folks were left steaming mad when Cody lost to Roman Reigns back at WrestleMania 39. "Finish the story" had become the talking point heading into that weekend, but WWE elected to keep the Undisputed Title on Roman and plough forward with The Bloodline implosion story.

Advertisement

Cody rationalised losing to Roman on the doc. Here, you'll see him point out that Reigns had been booked to slay some pretty big names, so he wasn't sure if he was the right one to end that dominance when Roman as champ was clearly still working. It's an interesting bit of self-assessment.

One of the cooler moments from the show is seeing Triple H embrace Rhodes backstage at 'Mania and reinforce that he'd just headlined the biggest show of the entire year. That's something his father had never done, which Hunter was quick to point out.

Most fans remain bummed out that Cody lost, but it didn't kill his babyface fire and it's nice to see behind the scenes moments like this in retrospect.

For more wrestling, check out 10 Times WWE Nepotism CRUSHED Hot Angles and 10 Current Wrestlers Already BETTER Than Your Favourites!

Advertisement