10 Things WWE Doesn't Want You To Know About AEW

"NXT is already the alternative..."

By Michael Sidgwick /

There are certain WWE fans who absolutely will not look elsewhere for a professional wrestling fix.

Advertisement

To them, WWE is pro wrestling. WWE transcends pro wrestling. It's a capitalist > art mentality conditioned by a relentless marketing campaign that has spanned generations. The subject of the condescension is fluid and era-dependant - Dubya See Dubya, the "high school gyms" of Bryan Danielson's Independent circuit, the "blood and guts" of AEW - but the purpose remains the same. WWE sends a barely-coded message to its fanbase in order to put itself over as the biggest, most sophisticated, most big-time product.

I was one of those fans, back in my teenage years. I opened up my first episode of Power Slam magazine in 1998, shocked and transfixed by the blood-soaked images of so many new worlds. There was a hesitation to enter them. ECW looked (and for UK viewers was) so lurid as to be inaccessible. The names in the Japanese results section were indecipherable and bland: where were the characters, the stipulations?

Over time, this stance softened. A willingness to explore beyond WWE's fading lustre drove a lifelong interest in wrestling on the fringe, but this is something WWE combats now with its new one-stop shop directive in the post-NXT era.

But that shop doesn't stock everything...

10. Blood And Guts Is Great

Vince McMahon, with searing hypocrisy, labelled AEW as "blood and guts" in an attempt to undermine its product to advertisers.

Advertisement

In the process, he referred to WWE as "sophisticated," the new definition of which includes "using bags that collect dog sh*t as a comedic prop", "a subtextual exploration of Bobby Lashley's girthy c*ck," and "Erick Rowan is a creepy-looking f*cker and has a pet rat or something".

WWE, unless it wants to get Brock Lesnar over as ridiculously overpowered (as distinct from ridiculously overpowered) does not do blood and guts wrestling. It does seven-act story-driven wrestling fought at a certain, comprehensible pace, no matter the actual pace of the talent involved, and the thing is, blood and guts wrestling absolutely rules. Cody Vs. Dustin Rhodes was an emotional masterclass drenched in the claret that put over the familial stakes as something unsurpassable in its high drama. The bumps taken in All Out's Escalera de la Muerte were mind-blowing. The various Lights Out matches, for better or worse, make wrestling feel dangerous again - and the schedule excuses it, or has done so far.

WWE's matches are anodyne. The fans are turning off, and something vital is happening on the other channel.

9. The Promos Are Unscripted

Can you imagine a relegation-haunted football manager trying to get "Survive and prevail" over as a way to convince fans that he is still the man for the job?

Advertisement

That's not a fair analogy, since football managers don't need to sell the next round of fixtures with verbal theatrics - but can you imagine a UFC fighter, in a bid to unsettle their upcoming opponent, referring to them as a "Superhero? More like super-villain. Conor McGregor, you are a snivelling little suck-up sell-out full of sufferin' succotash, son!"

*Khabib Nurmagomedov winks to the hard cam*

Look at the declining popularity of professional wrestling throughout this century. The most popular territories drew five-figure gates before 1984. WWE did not, in fact, expand the industry, only itself, and it prospered throughout two boom periods. When the Attitude Era faded, WWE changed the complexion of its creative team to hire ex-Hollywood writers in a presumed attempt to tell broader stories for people who would not ordinarily watch wrestling.

The era of the creative writer is the line through which the decline is traced. This isn't a coincidence; to the exact year, the written era is significantly less popular than the booked era.

AEW is booked, not written, its stars cut self-penned promos, and wouldn't you just know it - in just six weeks of TV, Dynamite has delivered the best heel and babyface promos heard in decades.

AEW is positively embarrassing WWE in this department, not that it needed to.

8. The Talents Have Creative Freedom

"[WWE] probably would have made me a creepy figure hanging out in a boiler room, jacking off or something..."

Advertisement

Those were the words of Darby Allin, speaking at Starrcast, comparing the AEW experience to the projected horror of the WWE experience. According to Allin, AEW asked him specifically how he'd like to be presented.

Most every WWE star you ever connected with used their own instincts to get over. Steve Austin watched a documentary on serial killer Richard Kuklinski; The Rock took to speaking in the third person on a whim; John Cena freestyled in earshot of Stephanie McMahon to escape his generic characterisation; Daniel Bryan thought it would be funny to ape the hyper-machismo of Diego Sanchez's psych-up routine. This mentality and savvy, that drives stars and artists, is verboten: earlier this year, Fightful reported that WWE is less open to pitches than ever because it implies incompetence on the writers, who, of course, are incompetent.

Chris Jericho's post-All Out title celebration was the perfect recent illustration of why this approach works. AEW trusted him, an all-timer of a promo and one of the industry's most creative minds ever, to get it over. In the process, Jericho created a new character in just 10 minutes: Le Champion. He also created a meme, a t-shirt, and a prop with which to celebrate his wins. The champagne bottle will clearly become a foreign object. too.

Wrestling is art.

AEW is a canvas for artists.

7. AEW Is TV-14

WhAT ABOut tHE AttITUDe ErA?

Advertisement

"Vaunted" is the word Cody used to describe the period in WWE history from 1997 to 2001, and he was right. Comments sections everywhere mourn this unrecoverable time period, and you can see why: it marked the last time the company felt vital, and that's more to do with agency and star power than any exposed t*t or unprotected chair shot. People love the edge and danger and (ironic) maturity of it all.

AEW has tapped into this sentiment by offering a TV-14 product that takes slight inspiration from it, in such a way that offers the same, admittedly cheap thrill.

Clearly operating under a one "sh*t" every two weeks rule, the "naughty little swear words" are effective. Chris Jericho's latter day ring style is that of a brawler. His stuff looks more painful than ever, and so when he threatened to "beat the ever-loving sh*t" out of Cody at Full Gear, you could believe him. Jim Ross said "sh*t" on the premiere, when calling Jake Hager's shock debut, and it put the man over. It was more "Sh*t! He actually looks pretty great!" than "Crap, it's Jack Swagger!"

It serves a purpose beyond the hur-hur element; it puts the promotion over as serious business for adult fans, as well as putting over the physicality of the upcoming matches.

6. The Schedule

WWE's house show schedule is antiquated, and in 2019, appears to serve no real purpose.

Advertisement

Fewer fans than ever attend house shows, they are actively losing money, and their continued existence means WWE stars must perform in a certain gear in order to withstand the grind.

There is but one benefit, and even that barely qualifies as a benefit unto itself; per several accounts, talent enjoys working house shows relative only to how unfulfilling "TV days" are. To quote Big Show, waiting around for "some friggin' idea that absolutely sucks" is like bashing oneself in the head with "a hammer". The talent enjoys the relative freedom of clowning around away from the cameras; it's a sort of gruel preferable to creative starvation.

AEW's schedule is far less rigorous; the company does not promote live events, and will only offer four pay-per-view events per year. The stars of AEW work once a week, if that. It feeds the inherent daredevil instincts of the performers, in that they give all of their bodies to the match.

This yields two benefits to fans. If they care about the wellbeing of performers, they aren't tortured through a slow-acting meat grinder, and if they don't, matches are full-on, committed, event-worthy spectacles.

5. "Wrasslin'" Is Actually Good

They told us for years, with the pejorative of wrasslin', that pro wrestling was something to be ashamed of. WWE divorced itself from its emulated sports roots to become a bastardisation of it under the vision of "sports entertainment". And because WWE monopolised under this mentality, it intensified.

Advertisement

Wrasslin' is defined by WWE, more or less, as boring old match-heavy programming that dared consider itself a "great sport" voiced by men with southern accents who were by definition dumber and less pleasing on the ear. Wrasslin' is something that had the temerity to take itself seriously; sports entertainment, in contrast, used the genre through ingrained shame as a platform to tack soapy drama onto the thin semblance of competition.

Vince McMahon hates the word "tournament", and only rarely promotes them. They are too closely associated with the sport he never reckoned WWE was. AEW promoted a wonderful World Tag Team Championship that created stars in Private Party and SCU. The win/loss ranking system breeds storylines divorced from cucks and monsters and graphics of dogs with an inability to properly bark. No match is booked on the fly, because it is presented as something germane to reality.

AEW is believable - as should, in its own context, be every entertainment medium.

4. AEW Is The Premier Storytelling Company

"We make movies," Vince McMahon famously said on the Beyond The Mat documentary, and his body language reeked of total condescension: the lip-smacking and the raised eyebrows painted a picture of a man above it all.

Advertisement

WWE makes sh*tty movies - quite literally, in the case of the Marine franchise - but also tells sh*tty stories. They are a nightmare of continuity, the heroes are wet, and they are often retconned into oblivion. And this is WWE's selling point. Stephanie McMahon compared WWE to Shakespeare a few years back, for f*ck's sake, but still, the perception is there. WWE tells stories, Indy guys do flips.

AEW is perfecting the art of pro wrestling storytelling.

The succession of incident is incredible in those faction wars. The Inner Circle formed as Chris Jericho's ego safeguard, and exist to further his campaign to reshape AEW in his hubristic image, which of course draws the men behind the company into a fight for its soul throughout intricate angles, in which the motivation of each moving part is considered very carefully.

And because AEW stars are encouraged to perform as themselves, style and mentality drives the narrative, not tacked-on, soapy drama. Kenny Omega was sent a message by Jon Moxley at Double Or Nothing; to fully understand it, he entered Moxley's violent domain by proving himself against Joey Janela. Moxley reframed his G1 Climax exploits in AEW canon as a means of studying his opponent.

And this is without considering Cody and Chris Jericho's transcendent babyface versus heel grudge feud, the best in several years, MJF's Machiavellian rise to infamy, the sporting framework that itself breeds competition and stakes at the purest level...

3. Age Is Just A Number

WWE doesn't like to feature "old" people on television, unless, of course, they need a stadium to fill, or they're in for a bollocking from the USA Network, or Mohammad bin Salman wants Mantaur booked for the next propaganda exercise.

Advertisement

Old, to Vince McMahon - and this as rich as he is - repels the 18-49 target demographic. Old is unfashionable, irrelevant, an actual eyesore. This is why he himself only appears onscreen when things are desperate.

AEW is dominating NXT in the target demo with a heavy senior presence because that senior presence lends the broadcast a sense of authority and sentiment. Tony Schiavone is quietly crucial to the presentation; his genuine glee at how far pro wrestling has come is a blessed sound, and his connection with Cody is warming, too: it really builds the idea of his interior life, the reality of which helps character investment.

Jim Ross is inconsistent at the booth - he sold MJF's heel turn like a master, but he needs to accept or at least cover for the in-house style of lenient officiating - but at his best, his seniority puts over the action with an authority that only comes with experience.

The very notion of Schiavone, Ross and Tully Blanchard putting over this youth movement creates the effect that it is for everyone, and bringing in genius old minds from the harsh wilderness furthers AEW's perception as the babyface company.

2. AEW Cares About Its Fans

WWE does not care about its fans because it doesn't need to.

Advertisement

The revenue stream generated by the consumer is dwarfed by corporate funding, but even before the TV deals masked the institutional rot, the company, to the point of parody, ritually bantered off its fanbase. The series of events that led Daniel Bryan to WrestleMania XXX were astonishing, they pushed Roman Reigns down your throat like a stomach pump, and so of course it produced bile, WWE has cancelled countless house shows and tours to accommodate the GSA, instructed you to not care about talent you audibly cared about, pushed wrestlers you audibly didn't, cancelled or bait-and-switched matches at the last minute...

AEW exists to service the fans. It exists because those WWE fans are so disenfranchised, and so far, the signs are promising. Shawn Spears is the rule-proving exception, in that he's a clear office favourite pushed despite having not connected with crowds. Elsewhere, Tony Khan appears to have spent the last several years of his life scouring message boards and responding to various complaints.

AEW is sensory inclusive; WWE shines blinding lights into your face at WrestleMania.

1. The Brutal Truth Behind AEW's Mission Statement

WWE doesn't want its fans to know about AEW, and will label it "pissant" or "blood and guts", to undermine it because it came into existence through how rampantly unpopular WWE is.

Advertisement

It's wild; a group of enterprising performers paired up with a billionaire and said, basically, "WWE is pretty awful right now, so let's create a product that is its exact opposite". WWE created its own competition by becoming a carcass, creatively, and inviting vultures to its stench.

WWE feels lame and meaningless. AEW funded what was cool, and stripped back the niche comedy to implement a results-based sporting framework. WWE feels heavily scripted and is, of course, written. AEW books, doesn't script, and allows its performers to connect with crowds as themselves. WWE does not listen to fans; AEW refines itself as it evolves, almost abandoning the comedy of Being The Elite outright and shortening its pay-per-view runtimes. WWE will simply not acknowledge certain cities, if they are not deemed glamorous; AEW promotes every show with a localised slant.

Ultimately, given the vast resources and profile and history WWE can use and market, AEW should by rights not exist - and it only does because WWE is so drastically out of touch with its fanbase.

Advertisement