10 Things WWE Wants You To Forget About Carlito

I spit in the face of people who don't want to be cool. My bodyguard just stabs them.

By Jack G King /

When looking back on Carly 'Carlito' Colon's WWE career, it's easiest to remember him as a capable midcarder with a fairly strong gimmick - and that's a damn shame. The son of Puerto Rican wrestling royalty, Carlito lived and breathed the business from a young age, evident in the ease with which he moved around the ring and his natural charisma. He has a handful of midcard title reigns to his name, but surely had the potential to go a lot further in WWE than he ended up going. Part of this may be down to the fact that Carlito broke through at roughly the same time as Cena, Batista and Orton, physically imposing superstars with a far more 'bankable' look. In today's less size-obsessed WWE, he may well have found the deck stacked more in his favour. There have been rumblings recently that Carlito might be on his way back to the company for another run (although with the recent return of Alberto Del Rio that seems less likely), which would be good for the fans. Despite his undeniable ability and charisma, however, Carlito's career will forever be associated with several unflattering moments.

Advertisement

10. The John Cena Stabbing Angle

Upon being called up from OVW, Carlito's first main roster feud was with the hot new US Champion on the scene, a certain John Cena. After defeating John in his first televised match - using his own chain to knock him out - the dastardly heel embarked upon an undefeated streak. Cena, naturally, came back for revenge. Then, in a storyline regularly cited as one of the most uncomfortable of the era, John was "stabbed" in a Boston nightclub by Carlito's bodyguard, a musclebound heavy by the name of Jesus (Aaron Aguilera). It was one of those angles with uncomfortable allusions to real-life violence, and cut far too close to the bone for many. This was done to excuse Cena while he went off and filmed The Marine, but Cena recovered before long (of course he did) and beat Carlito to win back his title, before downing Jesus at Armageddon 2004.

9. His 'Spit Or Swallow' T-Shirt

Now, before you say anything, bear in mind that a lot more was permissible in wrestling during the mid-2000s. WWE weren't bound by the restrictions of their modern-day PG rating, and storylines could generally take a more risque approach. However, WWE would still probably rather this t-shirt was stamped out of fans' collective memory, especially if Carlito were to ever return. Just imagine an arena full of fans chanting "spit or swallow *clap, clap, clap clap clap*". Hilarious? Yes. Appropriate? Sadly not.

8. The Metrosexual Gimmick With Rico

Before making his main roster debut under the now-familiar gimmick of Carlito 'Caribbean' Cool, Colon was originally made to try out a 'metrosexual' character. It's worth noting that, although this may sound fairly progressive, demonstrating an alternative lifestyle to the brawny WWE stereotype, we're dealing with Vince McMahon here. In his mind, 'metrosexual' was probably akin to 'homosexual', and he's never had a history of portraying homosexuality in a fair or accurate manner. Throw into the mix the fact that Carlito would have teamed with Rico - had the latter not suffered an eleventh hour injury - and the real direction of the gimmick becomes clear. Rico had debuted on the main roster as an overly-flamboyant "stylist", and it's likely Carlito would have suffered a similar fate. Carlito dodged a bullet with this one.

7. Being Teddy Long's Servant

Shortly after losing the US Championship to John Cena, Carlito suffered a legitimate injury. He stuck around on TV in a non-wrestling role during his recovery, but the nature of these appearances is something of an embarrassing blemish on his career. Ready for it? He became Teddy Long's manservant. Yes, the man who'd exploded onto the roster - spitting apple into the faces of SmackDown's most beloved superstars, defeating John Cena for the US Championship in his first televised match, and generally getting himself over as a future star - suddenly saw all his momentum sapped away, as he scrubbed floors and sold hotdogs for the GM. What did Carlito do in response? Did he take matters into his own hands and beat Long around the backstage area? Did he demand another US title shot upon recovering, determined to prove his worth? Nope, he did something much lamer instead: he started a petition. Unsurprisingly, his career never truly reached those early highs again.

6. The Ladies' Man

Perhaps in an attempt to give Carlito a distinctive gimmick, once the shine of his initial run had worn off, he was paired with a number of female managers and valets throughout the rest of his WWE tenure - including Trish Stratus, Torrie Wilson, Brie Bella and Rosa Mendes. Of all of these, the most inexplicable was surely the first (Trish). His on-screen relationship with the Canadian Hall of Famer seemed strangely thrown together, and the pair demonstrated nary an ounce of chemistry as a couple. It didn't last very long at all, and ended abruptly when Stratus announced her retirement a couple of weeks later. The sceptical among us might cite this as another example of WWE meddling with a real-life relationship - similar to the rumours that have surrounded the Ziggler/Lana/Rusev triangle - as Trish was set to marry her childhood sweetheart upon retiring. How dare she have the temerity to settle down, and all that.

5. His Wellness Violation

On May 21st 2010, Carlito was released due to a violation of the WWE wellness program. Although hardly the only superstar in history to violate the program, he also refused to attend rehab for a reported painkiller addiction. After being released, he spent some time working for independent companies including AAA, before returning to his father's WWC promotion. Should Carlito ever return, this butting of heads would surely be raised again.

4. He Rejected A WWE Comeback

Last month, a lot of talk circulated regarding an impending return for the Puerto Rican star. According to the Wrestling Observer Newsletter, he rejected WWE's contract for financial reasons, feeling that the money offered was far too low. Being rejected by any wrestler is a surefire way of angering the biggest promotion in the world, and - after recent events - that ship may have completely sailed for Carlito. WWE have been desperate for top Latino stars for a while now, and since bringing back Alberto Del Rio at last week's Hell In A Cell, may decide that the Puerto Rican is surplus to requirements.

3. His Hall Of Fame Comments

In 2014, as part of his father's induction ceremony into the WWE Hall of Fame, Carlito made a couple of choice remarks that were sure to ruffle a few feathers among the WWE top brass. After receiving a very positive reception from the live audience, he began by saying he was more used to performing in high school gyms and bingo halls. So far, so self-depreciating - but worse was yet to come. He then made a comment about how the Colons had been shoved onstage after the Kliq (who were all present for Scott Hall's induction), and had their time cut as a result; "it's like I never left". Comments such as these are a little close to the bone, and especially dangerous considering Kliq-member Triple H's lofty position in the company. https://twitter.com/MikeWendtShow/status/452650747008524289?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw

2. Nepotism

Speaking of his father, the man himself has been involved in the two most controversial aspects of Carlito's career. Carlos Colon - the legendary Puerto Rican promoter and wrestling family patriarch - certainly wasn't shy of giving his son a few breaks during the early stages of his career. While working for Carlos' WWC promotion, Carlito has amassed 15 championship reigns throughout his career. Carlos - himself a record-breaking 26-time champion - certainly didn't mind giving his eldest a helping hand to get over. Although WWE are often keen to play up the ancestry of certain superstars, including Bret Hart and Randy Orton, no mention of Carltio's impressive WWC run was ever made onscreen.

1. Alleged Racial Abuse At The Hands Of Vince McMahon

In 'Ring of Hell: The Story of Chris Benoit and the Fall of the Pro Wrestling Industry', another uncomfortable story from Carlito's early breakthrough in OVW is recounted. It's important to note that the anecdote is told from one point of view (that of former WWE writer Dan Madigan), and therefore can't be taken entirely as fact - however, it certainly makes for shocking read, if even just a snippet of it is true.

Advertisement

Madigan states:

'I remember when I was working with Carlito when he just started. Vince wanted to talk to him to get to know him, and I was asked to attend the meeting to help work out a character. So we€™re there, Carlito€™s talking to him, just a normal conversation; Carlito comes from a normal background, has money. He speaks well. Vince interrupts Carlito mid-sentence and says to him, €˜Hey, can you spic it up some? Y€™know spic it up when you talk?€™ I look at Vince, this billionaire who just asked some Puerto Rican employee to €˜spic it up€™ right to his face, and I just look at Carlito and say, €˜Yeah, spic it up€™ like it was a joke'.

Advertisement

Yeah, come on Carlito, just 'spic it up' will you? Incredible.