10 Things WWE Wants You To Forget About SmackDown

A few incidents they'd rather you never knew about as Smackdown turns 15.

By Jack G King /

This week has cause for celebration within the WWE as it sees the 15th anniversary of SmackDown. Although less revered than Raw, the blue brand has certainly reached a stage now where it holds a very important place in wrestling history. With its distinctive look and "Ovaltron" set design, the new show proved an instant hit upon its 1999 début, connecting with fans hungry for extra wrestling during the tail-end of the Monday Night Wars. Unlike Raw's comparatively stable existence (staying put on the USA Network for most of its existence, bar a five-year deal with Spike TV), SmackDown has jumped between four channels during its fifteen year period on our television screens. Despite this - and a risky move from Thursday to Friday nights in 2005 - the show has often been seen as a preferable alternative to Raw, particularly due to a perceived focus on in-ring action in contrast to Raw's soap opera appeal. It certainly hasn't been plain sailing for the WWE's secondary show. Although Raw's infamous moments may live longer in the memory, SmackDown hasn't been short of controversy, shame, and even nationwide criticism. From scandalous moments on the show itself to shady political dealings backstage, the blue brand is just as shady and shocking a part of the wrestling industry as any other show. Here are a few notable incidents your memory may have let slip.

10. Brock Lesnar Throws Zach Gowen Down A Flight Of Stairs

You'd be forgiven for thinking that Brock Lesnar was detested enough by fans following his heel-turn on Kurt Angle in the summer of 2003. The beloved Olympian was double-crossed by Lesnar, the latter siding with Vince McMahon in a move reminiscent of both Stone Cold Steve Austin and The Rock. Bright things were clearly planned for his future, but the WWE curiously decided to waste the beginning of his heel push as a dominating bully, needlessly brutalising smaller wrestlers with ease. The most notable of such victims was Zach Gowen, professional wrestling's first one-legged competitor. Picked on by Vince and suffering a clear disadvantage, Gowen was a natural underdog who quickly gained the support of the fans. He actually picked up a victory over Brock on SmackDown, albeit by disqualification - after Lesnar had supposedly broken his one leg. This brutality was taken to a new level on the following week's show, on which Brock ambushed a wheelchair-bound Zach backstage and shoved him down a flight of stairs. The shocking incident seemed more a remnant of the controversial Attitude Era than a step forward, and has only aged worse in the current age of PG programming. It is understandably not a segment often revisited by the WWE's production team.

9. JR Is Drafted From Raw To Smackdown Without Being Told

Despite being one of the most beloved figures in WWE history, Jim Ross has been the recipient of awful treatment at the hands of his employers over the years. For whatever reason, Vince reportedly loves to see JR as the butt of a joke, often subjecting him to surprising pranks both backstage and on-air. One of the most unprofessional incidents occurred during the 2008 WWE Draft, in which Ross was switched from Raw to SmackDown without any prior notice, exchanging play-by-play roles with the younger Michael Cole. It was one of the most unceremonious ways imaginable to bring an end to his twelve year tenure as the main announcer of Raw. JR commendably held it together for the benefit of live television, but was unable to fully hide his annoyance as he walked stiffly to the adjacent SmackDown announce table. If the stunned reactions of JR and Jerry Lawler weren't enough to convince the watching audience that the whole thing was a mean-spirited shoot, a blog post on Ross' website the following day confirmed it. The legendary announcer stated that he was unhappy with the decision and considered quitting, but would instead strive to help SmackDown become the best television show in wrestling.

8. Paul Heyman Is Fired As Head Writer

SmackDown hit its creative peak in the period of 2002 to 2003, thriving under the innovative leadership of chief writer Paul Heyman. As well as lending his incredible charisma to broadcasts under the role of SmackDown General Manager, Heyman booked a series of incredible matches featuring the so-called "SmackDown Six", the combination of Eddie and Chavo Guerrero, Kurt Angle, Chris Benoit, Edge and Rey Mysterio. The fact that every one of these wrestlers went on to hold a world title (even Chavo, if we count the revived ECW Championhip in this category) stands testament to the young talent accrued by the blue brand during this period. Things were brought to a screeching halt when Heyman was fired in 2004, despite being named the Wrestling Observer Newsletter's illustrious 'Best Booker' two years prior. During a recent appearance on Steve Austin's podcast, Heyman shed further light on this issue. Apparently he was caught listening in to a Raw conference call by Stephanie and Vince McMahon, a move they considered a terminable offence. Admittedly, the brazen Heyman didn't help matters by admitting that he hadn't heard anything in the Raw meeting - because he had fallen asleep! This only enraged the McMahons further, but their hasty decision to remove him from the SmackDown booking team robbed the show of its most enthralling period to date.

7. The Mysterious Pilot Episode

Although the first actual broadcast of SmackDown was a pilot episode in April 1999, the WWE doesn't consider the show to have débuted until later the same year. This mysterious original episode was aired as a one-off special, and makes for sobering viewing considering some of the names involved. The figure of Owen Hart (even in his fated Blue Blazer gimmick) is a reminder of the tragedy that would befall the company only a month later, while Darren Drozdov - or Droz - is seen wrestling D'Lo Brown in an eerie prelude to their catastrophic rematch in August. While Droz's paralysing neck injury also took place on an episode of SmackDown, it would be unfair to include this as a moment the WWE would rather we forgot, especially considering their good treatment of Drozdov following the incident. He was employed as a writer for the promotion's magazine and website, and was able to partially recover from his paralysis by regaining movement in his arms. This stands in stark contrast to TNA's high-profile release of Jesse Sorensen following the fracture of a vertebrae in his neck, a move made especially disgusting considering Dixie Carter's earlier promise that Sorensen would always have a job with the company.

6. Embarrassing Débuts

Due to its status as the "B Show" of the WWE, SmackDown has often been used as something of a proving ground for new workers looking to progress up the ladder. This function of the show has been diminished in recent years with the addition of NXT to the company's programming, especially as the most promising new stars are often hot-shotted straight onto Raw. This has left modern-day SmackDown in a creative rut, playing out secondary feuds and matches of little consequence while saving all the main storylines for Monday night. In its earlier years, however, Smackdown was the show to watch for viewers eager to see the potential stars of the future pay their dues. Although WWE occasionally show highlights of John Cena's 2002 début, in which a testosterone-fuelled Cena marches bravely out to the ring and clocks Kurt Angle with a right hand, the full match is never aired due to his eventual defeat. The first matches of Batista and Orton are decidedly more embarrassing with the benefit of hindsight, despite the fact that both men were able to pick up victories. Randy's clean-cut babyface act would never be referenced today, especially as it contrasts so flagrantly with his Viper persona. He was able to defeat Hardcore Holly, but had to rely on a rollup to do so. Batista has the most outlandish début of the three, acting as an ecclesiastical henchman to "Reverand" D-Von Dudley. The Animal's "Deacon" gimmick was thankfully dropped shortly before his rapid rise up the card.

5. Michael Hayes Almost Kills Cena's Push

Now that John Cena is inarguably one of the biggest superstars in wrestling history, it's difficult to view his rapid rise as anything other than meteoric. However, a considerable speedbump almost derailed his progress in November 2003 in the shape of creative team member (and former Fabulous Freebird) Michael Hayes. With a recently face-turned Cena winning the affection of crowds via his partnership with established favourite Chris Benoit, it seemed only a matter of time until he was pushed further up the card. Hayes pitched an idea involving Cena blindsiding the Rabid Wolverine following a tag victory over the Full Blooded Italians, theorising that it would portray him as an unpredictable loose-cannon in a similar vein to Steve Austin. The suggestion was roundly rejected by the SmackDown booking team, but Hayes took it to Vince McMahon anyway - falsely claiming that it had been approved by everybody. His idea was put into the show, Cena blasted Benoit with the FU, and it was met with universal confusion. It has since been theorised that Hayes' suggestion wasn't entirely in the best interests of Cena, and that the Raw-based writer was intentionally trying to slow the roll of a hot new SmackDown star. Whatever the real reason behind his decision, it's certainly a hiccup WWE would rather not have to admit happened.

4. The Great Khali Becomes World Heavyweight Champion

It seems slightly strange to think of The Great Khali as anything other than the comedy babyface he plays today, especially given his lacklustre in-ring ability, but he actually spent his first few years with the company as a dominant monster heel. Although clearly not the best wrestler in history, he was entirely believable as a dangerous villain, standing easily over seven foot tall and dwarfing such giants as Kane and Undertaker. However, the SmackDown booking team pushed Khali to a ridiculous degree when he was made World Heavyweight Champion in the summer of 2007. Khali was scheduled to face Edge for the title at The Great American Bash, but the champ was forced to drop the belt due to injury. Although admittedly faced with a depleted roster, the creative staff could surely have found a preferable alternative to the Punjabi giant. The SmackDown battle royal in which he won the belt featured plenty of viable champions, including Angle, Batista and Kane.Nevertheless, Khali was bafflingly given the chance to run with the title. His reign lasted a disastrous two months, including a string of horrible PPV matches, until he mercifully lost to Batista at Unforgiven.

3. Michelle McCool And Mickie James' Bullying Storyline

Although the WWE writers often save their most shocking storylines for Raw (Kane's "Katie Vick" saga springs immediately to mind), a few angles crept onto SmackDown that were in similarly bad taste. Michelle McCool's feud with Mickie James certainly ranks among the worst of these, which saw Mrs Undertaker brand her opponent "Piggy James" and sidekick Layla mock her by dressing in a fat suit. This angle would have been disgraceful even if Mickie was at all overweight, but the fact that she was in decidedly better-than-average condition makes it all the more worse. One can only begin to imagine the sort of confusion and insecurity this angle could have heaped upon young female fans of the WWE in particular. James herself disagrees, stating that "it shed some light on a big issue in our school system and on the internet [...] it was an attempt to address bullying and tell a story with it". While this may well be the case, the heavy-handed manner in which the angle was handled ensured it was rightfully blasted by critics and fans alike. The WWE were rightly awarded the Observer's "Most Disgusting Promotional Tactic" award in 2009.

2. Melina Accuses Batista Of Sexual Assault

Here we have yet another example of SmackDown attempting to engage with very serious themes in a heavy-handed and offensive manner. This storyline is less well-remembered than the outrage over "Piggy James", perhaps because it was rightfully axed after only a few weeks due to a Batista injury. It's scary to imagine the depths this angle could have plumbed given time - we'd probably be looking back on it as one of the worst storylines of all time. Luckily we only saw the beginning of the arc, and that was offensive enough. Probably inspired by Melina's real-life affair with Batista at the expense of boyfriend Johnny Nitro, the angle called for Melina to seduce the Animal backstage - thereby distracting him from a tag team title match against MNM. It would prove to be an unsuccessful scheme, as Batista was later shown leaving the locker room and thanking her for the "warm-up" before handily beating Mercury and Nitro alongside Rey Mysterio. The next week, Melina held a press conference in the middle of the ring claiming to have been sexually harrassed by Batista, the clear implication being that she was lying for sympathy and that the babyface Batista had been given complete consent. The Animal's injury is probably looked back on as something of a blessing in disguise by the WWE, as they could have ended up in incredibly deep water had the storyline been given a chance to continue further.

1. Muhammad Hassan Sparks Outrage

A predictable entry to top the list, yet one it is almost impossible to overlook as the worst incident in SmackDown's fifteen year history. Muhammad Hassan seemingly had everything in his favour in 2005: a great look, a marquee feud with The Undertaker, and a boatload of heat. The only drawback was his outdated foreign gimmick, one in especially poor taste given the fragile political and cultural climate of post 9/11 America. As well as dangerously controversial, Hassan's Arabic gimmick was also wildly inaccurate. The worker's real name was Mark Copani, just about the most Italian-American a person can sound. In typical WWE fashion however, the company were determined to sacrifice decency and good sense for a big reaction. In fairness to Hassan, he handled his promos in a mature and progressive manner, claiming that the crowd treated him unfairly due to his ethnicity. The only problem is that he was also a dastardly heel, therefore justifying the negative reactions thrown his way. The WWE might have gotten away with it if their timing wasn't so appalling. In one of the most notorious wrestling broadcasts ever, Muhammad's manager Daivari was easily defeated by The Undertaker in a squash match. Hassan then strode out onto the entrance ramp and dropped to his knees in prayer, as a team of masked men in military fatigues charged the ring and beat down The Undertaker. They then lifted Daivari over their heads like a martyr and carried him to the back. This would have been a highly controversial angle even at the best of times, but the fact that the London bombings occurred between the taping and airing of SmackDown sparked national outrage. Under fire from several media outlets across the globe, the WWE were forced to drop Hassan and Daivari from their programming entirely, sending them back to the developmental program to adjust their characters. Although Daivari would return to manage Kurt Angle and The Great Khali, Hassan was sadly released, an unfortunate victim of the worst incident in SmackDown's lifetime.