10 Things You Learn From Rewatching LAST Time WWE Raw Lost In Ratings War

Can an Attitude Era Raw from 22 years ago inspire a present-day change in WWE attitude?

By Andrew Pollard /

It feels like barely a week goes by where this statement isn't made, but this week saw WWE Raw hit an all-time low when it comes to ratings.

Advertisement

Sadly, Vince McMahon's sports entertainment juggernaut has been on a steady, worrying ratings decline for the past several years. While it's one thing to not hit the 7.4 ratings highs of the heady days of the Attitude Era, it's something completely different to only just stumble past an average of 1.5 million viewers for your supposed flagship show.

To add further concern to McMahon's ratings headache, this was alarmingly the first time that AEW outdid WWE in the vital 18-49 demographic - with the December 9 Dynamite hitting a 0.45 rating in this demo, compared to just a 0.41 by this week's Raw.

How Vince and WWE brass bounce back from yet another record-setting ratings low, that remains to be seen. If recent years offer up any indicator, we'll likely get false promises of change from the McMahons or yet further wacky ideas like Raw Underground.

For WWE, it's been 20 years of ratings dominance when it comes to wrestling programming. Looking at the history books, the last time WWE was on the losing end of a ratings battle was on October 26, 1998, where WCW Nitro toppled Raw for the final time.

Upon sitting down to revisit that particular episode of Raw, here are ten things that you find yourself picking up on.

10. It Was On The Back Of Vince Wetting Himself

People can often lambast the Attitude Era as being a time when the quality of wrestling was often neglected in favour of putting more of a spotlight on promos and outlandish antics. While that is true, so many of those promos and outlandish segments were ridiculously entertaining.

Advertisement

In a landscape filled with memorable moments, one of the most beloved of that period was Vince McMahon p*ssing his pants on live TV after 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin pulled a gun on his boss.

When revisiting the last time in history that Raw lost out in the ratings to a wrestling rival, it's a little jarring to immediately realise that this ratings loss came the week after McMahon micturated under the watch of the Texas Rattlesnake.

The October 26, 1998 Raw opens with a wheelchair-bound Vince promising revenge on an Austin who's fighting to win his job back, and it's only then that the penny drops that this episode of the company's flagship show aired directly after one of the most famous segments of the Attitude Era.

One would assume that a segment as iconic as the gun-toting Austin and p*ss-pants Vince would have seen a guaranteed Raw ratings win the following week. Instead, WWE was on the losing side of its back-and-forth battle with WCW on that night.

9. The McMahons Were All Over The Show - And It Worked!

The October 26, 1998 Raw opened with Vince McMahon and his cronies, and barely five minutes of the show goes by without Vince making an appearance - all as his ongoing rivalry with Steve Austin continued to play out.

Advertisement

Not just was Vince McMahon all over Raw, but so, too, was Shane McMahon (who rehired Austin on this night). Unlike recent years though, the constant presence of the McMahons never felt overbearing. These days, a five-minute in-ring promo from any McMahon results in the audience letting out a groan and reaching for the TV remote. Back in '98, however, Vince and Shane were used in effective ways, in entertaining segments, and they genuinely added to the overall product.

Of course, seeing the father and son McMahon duo in such pivotal roles on WWE programming of old, that just reiterates how the WWE of today still clings onto the past in its desperate attempts to save sagging ratings. Audiences turning off? Let's wheel out the McMahons to promise change. Need a legitimate star to face the Undertaker at WrestleMania? Time to get Shane on the phone. And what's that, Shane? Raw Underground, you say...

8. Awful, Awful Finishes

The WWE is a promotion that's still riddled by horrendous match finishes to this day. Having a three-hour Raw and a two-hour SmackDown to fill, in addition to PPVs and other C-shows, WWE has to come up with creative ways to not burn through rivalries or definitive finishes. And thus, the "creative ways" usually end up circling back to the tried and trusted DQ finish or a distraction roll-up.

Advertisement

Stepping back in time 22 years, you're immediately slapped around the face with this continuous problem for WWE programming.

On a card consisting of eight matches, half of the bouts on this classic Raw end in a DQ. Even in the matches that don't have a disqualification finish, there's plenty of shenanigans going on.

There's dissention amongst the Legion of Doom following Droz's loss to the Rock. There's a 3-on-1 assault on Kane following his victory over Gangrel. The infamous distraction roll-up comes out to play in getting the New Age Outlaws a victory, which itself was followed by a post-match beatdown from Mark Henry and D'Lo Brown. Not to forget the main event, of course, for Steve Austin's win over Ken Shamrock saw interference from Mankind.

It's also notable how only two matches on the card last for more than five minutes, that being the Outlaws vs. Snow and Foley clocking in at 5:28, and then Austin vs. Shamrock running at 6:16.

As alluded to elsewhere, that was commonplace for the Attitude Era, with more focus being on colourful angles and character development rather than lengthy, high quality in-ring action. But still, awful finishes or outright no-finishes are as bad then as they are now.

7. Everybody Felt Like Stars

It's night and day when comparing the WWE product of today to what the company put out 22 years ago. One of the most clear and obvious differences upon a rewatch of the *good old days* is that everyone back then felt like a star.

Advertisement

In a two hour broadcast, no single featured performer ever felt close to an afterthought. Sure, not everybody had as much attention on them as Steve Austin, but you could see that the creative forces of the time were doing their best to let you know what each and every wrestler was about. Even if somebody didn't necessarily feel like a legitimate star, they still at least felt relevant and that the company had a modicum of plans in place for them.

When looking lower down on the food chain, 'Man's Man' Steven Regal was trying to get himself involved in the European Title picture; Darren Drozdov was trying to prove himself as a suitable member of the Legion of Doom; Tiger Ali Singh was against the Godfather and his pimpin' ways; the Oddities and Kaientai were overflowing with personality; and Gangrel... good lord, Gangrel and THAT entrance still kicks just as much ass all these years later.

In comparison to today, the current WWE product is full of wrestlers are are just, well, there. As in, they have no purpose, they have no direction, and they're simply disposable bodies on a roster that only gives any significant storylines to those higher up the card.

6. Billy Gunn Does Not Age

While we all age over time and the wrestling business particularly takes its toll on ones physical appearance, Billy Gunn clearly does not age like the rest of us.

Advertisement

Currently working as a trainer and semi-regular on-screen talent in All Elite Wrestling, Billy looks like he's barely aged a day when looking back at 1998. To think, the WWE Hall of Famer was on the cusp of turning 35 at the time of the October 26, 1998 Raw - and nowadays he's 57 and looking near-identical to his younger self.

D-Generation X was at a strange place in October '98. Long gone were Shawn Michaels and Rick Rude, Triple H was out with an injury, and Chyna was being held off TV. For the trio of Billy Gunn, Road Dogg and X-Pac, the traditional black and green of DX had yet to be incorporated into their attires, and the group was clearly just treading water until Triple H was cleared to return.

In terms of involvement on this particular Raw, Billy and the D-O-Double G got involved in X-Pac's opening match encounter with Steve Blackman, the three took part in a Mötley Crüe performance, and then the New Age Outlaws successfully defended the Tag Team Championships against Al Snow and Mankind.

5. So Many Stars In The Wings

In hindsight its easy to pinpoint which wrestlers of 1998 were always destined to become the next major stars to lead the then-WWF forward, but even at that time in '98 we could all see certain stars were being groomed for superstardom.

Advertisement

With Austin in the midst of his legendary rivalry with Vince McMahon, and the Undertaker paired off with Kane, the Rock and the absent Triple H were two names at the time who so many had high hopes for. Obviously those hopes would come true, and both stars went on to have Hall of Fame careers.

Away from that, though, and there were numerous other talents who were positioned in a way that had you thinking that they, too, could be the next big thing. Ultimately, they might not have gone onto achieve that anticipated success, but WWE made sure to deliver these names on TV in a fashion that led you to buy them as potential main event acts, even if they never truly went onto become main event acts.

A prime example of this is Ken Shamrock, who found himself in the main event against Steve Austin on this episode of Raw. It wasn't just being in the main event with Austin that made Shamrock feel special, for the overall presentation of Kenny throughout this Raw offering meant you would every bit buy Shamrock as a bona fide main event player in WWE opted to pull that trigger on him down the line.

Compare that to WWE programming today, and it's embarassing how few current wrestlers are served up to audiences in a way that makes them believable if and when a main event spotlight comes knocking.

4. Fans Gave A Sh*t!

Even though October 26, 1998 saw Raw beaten out in the ratings war by Ted Turner's WCW, it's not like today where the WWE product so often fails to illicit any semblance of a positive response from arena crowds. Well, when fans were allowed to be in attendance, of course.

Advertisement

Back in '98, you're instantly struck by how boisterous the in-attendance fans are. From the first minute to the last, Raw is consistently soundtracked by screaming fans. It's not just your marquee names like Steve Austin, Vince McMahon, the Rock and Kane who draw huge responses from the crowd, but every match on the card is full of chants, wild cheers, ferocious boos, and then there's the delightful visual of signs, signs and more signs dotted across Madison, Wisconsin's Kohl Center.

Simply put, people cared.

With a roster of widely varied characters, short matches that stopped audiences becoming bored, and the sort of storylines that were designed in the same mould as The Jerry Springer Show, there is an energy on display 22 years ago that has long been absent from WWE.

That's not to say that there haven't been wrestlers who fans have cared for over the past two decades, it's just that the fan investment and fan interaction of today are so vastly below the levels they were the last time WWE was toppled in the ratings.

3. The Talent Were Allowed To Be Bigger Than The Company

For anyone who's followed the wrestling business over the past decade or two, it's fair to say that no modern-day grappler has been allowed to truly feel bigger than WWE.

Advertisement

Of course, this is all by design. For example, instead of selling WrestleMania on the stars involved in the main event, WrestleMania these days is sold on the WWE brand and the WrestleMania spectacle. Looking at 1998, WrestleMania XIV was sold on Steve Austin vs. Shawn Michaels and obviously the role of Mike Tyson. Skip ahead to 1999, WrestleMania XV was sold on Steve Austin vs. the Rock.

Contrast that to the last several WrestleManias, and it's clear that we're now in extremely different times. As a counterpoint, wrestlers come and go. You have your first nine WrestleManias closed out by the visage of Hulk Hogan, so what happens when Hogan leaves the company? Steve Austin headlines several WrestleManias as the hottest star the business has ever seen, but what happens when Austin has to call time on his career? You rely on the Rock to be your star attraction, but then what happens when Hollywood comes a-calling?

On that hand, you can understand why WWE now promotes the WWE brand as its major selling point rather than its talent, yet that can be viewed as a lazy approach that allows WWE to not fully invest in making their wrestlers into true game-changing, needle-driving megastars.

2. You Want To See More

By the time that the October 26, 1998 Raw concludes with Steve Austin giving his famous middle-finger salute, the first thought is that you want to see more of this.

Advertisement

Obviously that applies to Austin, but the two-hour show as a whole leaves you eagerly chomping at the bit to see what is next for the stars and stories you've just watched. Suddenly, the DQ finishes, the run-ins and the extremely short matches are forgotten and you realise that, whilst there are irksome elements, the show is nothing if not entertaining and it powers forward at an unrelenting pace. It's one of those times where you wish the WWE Network had an autoplay feature where the next episode immediately starts up.

It's with no sense of hyperbole to say that a lot of us still find ourselves watching Raw only as part of some bizarre sense of Stockholm syndrome. We watch Raw because we watch Raw. It's what some of us have been doing on a weekly basis since Raw launched in January 1993, and it's purely by habit that we still tune in each week 27 years later. Not just Stockholm syndrome, mind, for there is still that slight blip of hope that resides deep inside wrestling fans that maybe, just maybe, this next Raw is the one that's a triumphant return to form.

Regardless of why we still watch, the end result is usually the same - a gloomy, disheartening three hours of tired tropes and underserved characters that has you contemplating whether next week will finally be the week you pull Raw from your viewing habits.

As for the anticipation to see more in 1998, the follow-up to this episode WWE pull in a 4.8 rating, surpassing WCW.s 4.1 number and marking the beginning of the end for Ted Turner's World Championship Wrestling.

1. The Insane Numbers Difference

Having now finished taking a trip down memory lane, there's no way to say that this was a bad episode of Raw. Far from it, in fact. This was a fun, engaging, brisk revisit of a show that is somehow now 22 years old.

Advertisement

Not just was this a good episode of Raw, it's an episode that still managed to pull in a decent rating despite being beaten out by WCW Nitro on this occasion. While Nitro won out with a 5.1 rating, Raw still managed to hit a 4.5 rating itself. A little bit of digging and some quick (likely questionable) maths suggest that this defeated Raw was viewed in approximately 4.3 million homes - and let's face it, what WWE would do to achieve even half that number right now.

This past Monday night, the three-hour broadcast of Raw averaged 1.527 million viewers - the lowest number in Raw history! Not only is that a third of the viewers that the October 26, 1998 episode did, the scary thing is how October '98 was nowhere near the peak of WWE's viewing figures. Skip ahead a year, and it was just seen as 'the norm' for Raw to be pulling in viewers in the 5 million range and beyond.

To think, WWE did a 4.5 rating on October 26, 1998 and was bested by rival promotion WCW. Here in 2020, barely 1.5 million recently tuned in for a go-home show that ran unopposed by any wrestling rival.

Advertisement