10 Times Hell Froze Over In Wrestling

NEVER Say Never

By Jamie Kennedy /

During the 1990s, lead announcer Jim Ross was instructed to inform viewers that "anything can happen in the World Wrestling Federation". Clearly, this was supposed to be little more than a nifty marketing slogan, one designed to sell the unpredictable nature of the promotion's product. On more than one occasion however, it proved to be true statement.

Advertisement

Hell freezing over isn't restricted to the WWF/WWE either, companies like WCW, ECW, and even the NWA have all experienced things that seemed flat out impossible before they happened. Shocks are one thing, but the occasions listed here reflect times during which the world of pro wrestling was turned upside down.

Heel turns that came out of nowhere, surprise appearances that left everyone stunned, and even real-life forgiveness that came out of left field are all included. Furthermore, controversial inductions into wrestling's most prestigious ceremony and eye-popping match results beg to be explored.

Let's look at 10 times hell froze over in pro wrestling, leaving absolutely everybody (watching at home and from backstage) incredulous...

10. Brock Lesnar Returns To UFC

On 9 July 2016, Brock Lesnar made his return to Mixed Martial Arts as part of UFC 200. Under WWE contract, 'The Beast' appeared in the octagon in victory against New Zealand brute Mark Hunt. It wasn't something anyone could see have seen coming before the news was made public.

Advertisement

Despite Vince McMahon's assertions in the past that he's in a different business to the MMA juggernaut, it was still impossible to imagine him allowing a contracted talent to fight for real on someone else's show.

Furthermore, Brock was back in time for a fearsome SummerSlam destruction of Randy Orton, making the deal even more incredible. The fight came only a year removed from Lesnar himself suggesting that he was done with MMA, and fully-focused on things going forward with WWE.

As a competitive athlete, it seems he missed the preparation, hype, and satisfaction only real fighting can provide. This may have been something burning in the background between Lesnar and WWE, but that doesn't change the fact few predicted it.

9. WWE Creates A New Version Of ECW

The original Extreme Championship Wrestling is still remembered to this day as North American's outlaw promotion. A far cry from what the then-WWF and WCW were presenting, ECW offered something more raw, visceral, and satisfying for a more mature audience. WWE had something else in mind for the infamous letters.

Advertisement

Due to the success of the One Night Stand shows in 2005 and 2006, WWE decided to bring ECW back as a third brand to join Raw and SmackDown. Beginning with the 13 June 2006 episode, ECW was established as a WWE show. Initially, the company stayed true to some aspects of the original.

That didn't last long, certainly outside of the One Night Stand pay-per-views. It must have been hellish for someone like Paul Heyman, long associated with the heart and soul of ECW, to watch his Extreme brand reduced to a WWE 'C' show.

By the time Vince McMahon decided to cancel ECW in 2010, it was more akin to Sunday Night Heat or Velocity than a fully-fledged competitive brand. Original ECW fans everywhere were left seething.

8. Ric Flair Jumps To The WWF With The NWA Title

World Championship Wrestling's top title situation was a mess in 1991. Previously, the company had used the NWA Heavyweight Title, but decided to establish their own belt in 1991. Ric Flair defeated Sting that January to become WCW World Champion. Without a physical belt to call their own, WCW just continued using the NWA one.

Advertisement

Tradition called for champions to post a $25,000 deposit to the alliance, one they'd receive back once dropping the title. Upon falling out with Jim Herd, Flair left the promotion without his money. Therefore, he just decided to keep the actual belt upon joining the WWF.

Bobby Heenan appeared, hyping up Flair's imminent arrival as the 'real world champion'. With the NWA Title in his grasp, the manager then brought Ric onto programming. As he was flaunting the NWA's property on another show, legal action quickly followed.

Flair was forced to return the gold and start using a WWF Tag-Team Title belt instead at live events. The shock had already happened; it was mind-boggling to see the WCW Champion jump to the WWF with the NWA Title.

7. Eric Bischoff Shockingly Appears On Raw

Eric Bischoff and Vince McMahon did not like the idea of the other man getting the upper hand. On direct opposite sides of the infamous 'Monday Night War', Bischoff led WCW (ably backed by Ted Turner) against McMahon's WWF powerhouse. The result was one of the most exciting periods in wrestling history, as WCW Nitro went head-to-head with WWF Raw.

Advertisement

Previously, Bischoff had literally called McMahon out for a fight on WCW pay-per-view. In addition, he'd also given away results live on air, looking to undercut the pre-taped Raw and tout Nitro as live and fresh. This must have left Vince snarling, hating the fact that Bischoff was being so aggressive.

It was unthinkable to ever see 'Easy E' working for WWE once WCW went out of business, but that's exactly what happened. On the July 15, 2002 episode of Raw, McMahon announced Bischoff as the new General Manager of the program.

Pigs flying seemed like a more likely scenario than McMahon ever handing Bischoff a contract, even as nothing more than an on-air performer. It happened, and the former WCW boss still speaks highly of his WWE run to this day.

6. Jeff Jarrett In The WWE Hall Of Fame

The WWE Hall Of Fame hasn't been the measure of achievement in the industry from the second ceremony onwards - the McMahon family limo driver James Dudley's induction in 1994 highlighted in-house hypocrisy - but Jeff Jarrett's inclusion in the fold is no less astonishing.

Advertisement

There have been fewer performers with a bigger rap-sheet that 'Double J' since his acrimonious exit in 1999. Taking the $300,000 he believed he was owed from Vince McMahon before agreeing to drop the Intercontinental Title to Chyna on his final night with the company, Jarrett's separation from the company was compounded by a humiliating on-air sacking during the historic Raw/Nitro simulcast.

He doubled down on the divide by founding TNA as the closest North American rival to the Vince McMahon empire. Still curiously something of a silenced brand in WWE canon, Jarrett was presumed part of McMahon's permanent no-fly-zone back when one still existed.

The second generation star's two tumultuous exits from the company he created (as well as a controversial Cash-For-Gold cul-de-sac and a known alcohol abuse problem) were just add-ons to a furthered exile until the latest 'never say never' barrier was kicked down with a single congratulatory Triple H tweet on February 19th 2018.

5. Hulk Hogan Turns Heel

In 1996, Hulk Hogan was still hawking the same red and yellow act that had earned him millions in the WWF of the 1980s. The formula had long-since grown stale, and Hogan needed something to help make him relevant again. Eric Bischoff had just the ticket: he wanted to turn 'The Hulkster' heel.

Advertisement

This must have caused Hulk a few sleepless nights. He had been wrestling's premier good guy for over a decade, but he did need something drastic to recapture his status and prolong his career. At WCW's Bash At The Beach 1996 pay-per-view, Hogan went through with the plan.

When Hulk dropped a leg on Randy Savage and stood tall with Scott Hall and Kevin Nash, the wrestling world was in awe. Putting things into modern perspective, this was like John Cena turning full-blown heel in 2016; it just didn't seem feasible.

Forming the New World Order, Hogan was installed as the pack leader. It was a calculated risk that paid off, but it could so easily have backfired had fans turned their backs on the idea.

4. The New World Order Helps WCW Overtake The WWF

By far Eric Bischoff's best idea at the helm of WCW, the New World Order storyline completely revolutionised the company. Scott Hall started the trend, shockingly appearing on the May 27, 1996 edition of Nitro. He was quickly followed by Kevin Nash, and the pair joined forces as The Outsiders.

Advertisement

In a genius move, it was never expressly said on-air that Nash and Hall were invading from the WWF. That was the insinuation, but it was never outright said to fans. When The Outsiders added Hulk Hogan to their midst at Bash At The Beach and formed the nWo, WCW started to really fly.

Around a month before the pay-per-view, Nitro beat Raw in the weekly ratings for the June 6 program. That would kick off a run of 84 consecutive weeks of victories, before Raw clawed back and topped Nitro once again.

For Vince McMahon and the WWF loyalists, this must have been unbelievably humbling. Like it or not, the facts state that WCW became the top company in North America for around a year and a half.

3. Vince McMahon Buys The Shell Of WCW

As he would with many of his rivals, Vince McMahon had the last laugh. Considered by many to be the death of the WWF/WWE as a truly innovative company, 23 March 2001 will nonetheless go down in history as a remarkable date. On that day, McMahon purchased the remnants of WCW and eradicated the last of his competition.

Advertisement

Mere days later, WCW presented the final ever episode of Monday Nitro on March 26. The show was a simulcast with WWF Raw, meaning Vince would appear on the WCW flagship and brag about owning the company. Nobody watching could believe what they were seeing. It was quite the extraordinary situation.

In reality, McMahon had purchased 24 talent contracts from the ailing promotion, as well as various WCW trademarks and event titles. He must have felt on top of the world as he salivated over the near future, being able to create a storyline pitting his WWF troops against invading WCW forces.

23 March 2001 will forever be remembered as one of the most shocking days in pro wrestling history: it was inconceivable to picture Vince McMahon owning WCW.

2. The Undertaker Loses At WrestleMania XXX

There will never be another wrestling legacy like The Undertaker's WrestleMania winning streak. From WrestleMania VII in 1991 onwards, 'Taker went undefeated at the event until WrestleMania XXX in 2014. Securing 21 straight victories on wrestling's grandest stage, it seemed like 'The Streak' would never come to an end.

Advertisement

In fact, some had even concluded that The Undertaker would retire before WWE had the chance to end the legacy. By his own volition, 'The Deadman' decided to stare at the lights for the first time at 'Mania, doing the honours for Brock Lesnar. As soon as the referee counted his shoulders down, the air was sucked out of the Mercedes-Benz Superdome.

Eyes bulged out of skulls, hands were placed on heads, and mouths were left agape. Lesnar had achieved something nobody thought would happen: he had ended 'The Streak'.

Beforehand, the idea of a winning streak had been used to promote The Undertaker's appearances on the annual supershow. Without it, WrestleMania didn't seem quite the same. Certainly at the time, there was a weird mix of anger and surprise that the winning run had been halted.

1. Bret Hart Does Business With WWE After The 'Montréal Screwjob'

At the 1997 Survivor Series, Bret Hart watched in horror as Vince McMahon called for the bell. Putting a literal stop to Hart's match with Shawn Michaels, McMahon had screwed Bret out of the WWF Title. On his way to WCW, the Canadian wouldn't have the chance to rectify the situation, and he left with a bitter taste in his mouth.

Advertisement

For close to 13 years, Hart never worked with the WWF/WWE. Aside from a brief reunion to discuss a DVD project in 2005, he claims he rarely considered coming back to the company. That all changed in early-2010, when Bret sauntered out on the 4 January 2010 episode of Monday Night Raw.

Agreeing a truce with Shawn Michaels, he had also privately patched things up with McMahon behind the scenes. That didn't stop WWE from booking a feud between the pair, culminating in a disjointed match at WrestleMania XXVI.

After the 'Montréal Screwjob' in 1997, it seemed unlikely that Bret would ever forgive McMahon, Michaels, and the WWF. Since 2010, he has appeared sporadically, and the Survivor Series drama appears to be in the past.

What other occasions can you think of when hell froze over in wrestling? Let us know your thoughts down in the comments section below!

Advertisement