10 Times Pro Wrestling Got Way Too Real

We working or shooting here?

By Lewis Howse /

It has been known for years that wrestling is premeditated entertainment. The matches are not real contests, although the wrestlers do naturally suffer for their art. You don't get slammed on plywood and steel every night without picking up a few injuries here and there. This is not secret to anyone who watches professional wrestling. Because we all know that wrestling is premeditated and scripted, we use it as escapist entertainment the same way that we do when we go to the cinema to see a film. We love to suspend our disbelief and become wrapped up in the drama. Wrestling diverts attention away from your real-life problems and allows you to become immersed in another world filled with over-the-top characters and storylines. Sometimes, however, wrestling can seem very, very real indeed. The shows may be scripted, buy every now and then reality invades fantasy land. Wrestling is a live show and, inevitably, things don't always go according to plan. Wrestlers, fans and promoters can all go into business for themselves and that creates uneasy moments where the viewer is not entirely sure whether what they're watching was supposed to happen or not. Over the years fans have been witness to many of these incidences. Here are ten times when pro wrestling got way too real.

Advertisement

10. JBL Busts Open The Blue Meanie At One Night Stand

WWE's original ECW One Night Stand pay-per-view in 2005 was a phenomenal success. The event did 325,000 buys on pay-per-view (surprisingly many WWE officials) and was a hit in the ring. Fans were buzzing after the event but that joy soon turned into indignation when they discovered that a very unpleasant incident had occurred at the end of the broadcast. During the show-closing brawl between the ECW originals and the WWE wrestlers who had been watching the show from the arena balcony, a visibly drunk JBL targeted The Blue Meanie and started punching him full force in the face, for real. The blows opened up Meanie's stitches from the previous night and he became very bloodied, his eye swelling shut. So what brought on this attack? Well, JBL had a reputation for being a bit of a bully backstage and, according to Meanie, he had never liked him during his run with the company from 1998-99. JBL commented on WWE's internet show Byte This that Blue Meanie had made comments about him on the internet and then poked fun at the fact that Meanie was married porn star Jasmine St. Claire who performed a record-breaking 300 sex acts with 300 men in 24 hours. Meanie considered filing a lawsuit against JBL and WWE after the incident but reconsidered. Instead, he was brought in for a couple of WWE appearances and even got a victory over JBL (in a worked match this time), where Steven Richards got some measure of revenge for his friend by nailing JBL with an evil chair shot. It was unprofessional behaviour by JBL. In wrestling, you look after your opponent's health and safety, first and foremost. JBL was being a bully, again, picking on somebody he knew he could mess with without fear of reprisals.

9. The Loose Cannon

Brian Pillman was on a mission to rattle everyone in the wrestling business during the mid-90s. At the end of 1995 Pillman began to hone his 'Loose Cannon' character, somebody who would frequently go off script and was always unpredictable. The formerly clean-cut and athletic Pillman traded in his former look and character for something far edgier. At Clash of The Champions in January 1996, Pillman exited the ring during his match with Eddie Guerrero and grabbed commentator Bobby Heenan, which was not supposed to happen. A clearly frazzled Heenan shouted 'What the f*** are you doing?' live on air and subsequently had to apologise. This was just the tip of the iceberg when it came to the Loose Cannon going into business for himself. A month later at the SuperBrawl PPV, Pillman referred to Strap Match opponent Kevin Sullivan as 'Booker Man'. Bischoff fired Pillman after the event, although it was all part of the plan: Bischoff, Pillman and Sullivan had agreed to give Pillman his release so that he could go and develop his character in renegade promotion ECW. The plan would soon backfire. See, Pillman never did go back to WCW. He had worked Bischoff and Sullivan and unwittingly made them give him his release so he could go and work for the WWF. Pillman appeared at the ECW show Cyberslam just a few days after SuperBrawl and ran down Eric Bischoff and then the ECW fans. He threatened to urinate in the ring before he was removed by security. It was incredibly realistic, state-of-the-art stuff at the time. Pillman would push the realistic nature of wrestling angles even further in the WWF in November with the infamous 'Pillman's got a gun' segment, where Steve Austin 'invaded' Pillman's home and was shot at with a 9mm pistol by his former Hollywood Blonde's partner. During the chaos, Pillman accidentally uttered the phrase 'get the f*** out of the way' for which he and the WWF had to apologise profusely for. The Loose Cannon pushed wrestling in a new, more realistic direction and even managed to fool many people in the business.

8. A Real-Life Love Triangle

When Matt Hardy required time off to recover from knee surgery in 2004, he was confident that his long-term girlfriend and travel partner Amy 'Lita' Dumas was in safe hands travelling with Edge, who was Hardy's buddy and also recently married (to Val Venis' sister). How wrong he was. Hardy discovered a secret phone that Lita had used to communicate with Edge. The texts and voicemails left little to the imagination and, when Matt confronted Lita about it she confessed. Matt threw her out of the house and took all evidence that the two were ever a couple off of his website. The news was soon public and Edge and Lita's names were mud. So what did WWE do about it? They fired Matt. Yup, not only had Matt lost the girl he thought he would marry and his close friend but now he was unemployed too. Fans sensed the injustice and began chanting 'You screwed Matt' towards the love rats at WWE events. WWE realised the chants weren't going to go away so they decided to capitalise it by bringing Matt back and placing him in a feud with Edge. Matt Hardy returned on Raw with a new 'worked shoot' character and promo style. He referred to Edge as 'Adam' and Amy as 'Lita' and vowed to make their life miserable. He had a lot of fan support and the angle had a lot of potential but, as is typical with worked shoot storylines, the line between fantasy and reality got a little murkier and the angle lost a lot of steam at SummerSlam where Edge hammered Hardy and the ref stopped the match after only five minutes of action. Edge won the feud decisively in a Lose-Leaves-Raw ladder match on the Raw Homecoming show in October 2005 and moved to Smackdown where he was given a couple of stiff beatings from that stickler for locker room etiquette, JBL. For a while, though, the feud was exciting and had fans guessing about what was real and what wasn't.

7. Daniel Puder Almost Breaks Kurt Angle's Arm

The 2004 Tough Enough competition was the first instalment of the show to be featured on proper WWE television, taking place on Smackdown. As per usual, WWE had its locker room leaders trying to intimidate and browbeat the rookies as a way to teach them respect and try to make them quit. For instance, WWE had to The Big Show go to the ring to try and punk them out and bodyslam them during one segment. Of course, the prospective wrestlers were specifically instructed never to say anything or fight back in any way, shape or form. Kurt Angle must have had this in mind when he challenged any one of the contestants to a real wrestling match in the ring. Daniel Puder, who had trained in MMA, stepped up the challenge after Angle had already defeated (and broken the ribs of) Chris Nawrocki. Angle and Puder jockeyed for position for a few seconds before Angle took him down to the mat, however, in the process of doing so Puder had manager to lock in a very real kimura submission hold on Angle's left arm. The commentators didn't sell the severity of the hold but Angle was in very real trouble. Panicking and under instruction from Gerald Briscoe (who was watching the situation unfold from backstage and knew what was going on) the referees counted Puder's shoulders down even though they were clearly off the mat. If the hold was on for just a second or two longer, Angle could have had his arm snapped. Angle immediately got in Puder's face after the impromptu contest and repeatedly asked him if he was 'f***ing stupid'. Puder was only reacting to the situation, to be fair to him, but it wasn't exactly smart to put one of the company's top stars in that position.

6. Antonio Inoki Vs. The Great Antonio

If there's one thing you don't want to do against a Japanese wrestler, it's no-sell his offense and start clowning around in the ring. You definitely don't want to do that with Antonio Inoki, a Japanese icon and one of the most famous wrestlers of all time. Japanese wrestlers, generally speaking, know how to handle themselves should things get out of hand and there have been many instances of Japanese wrestlers shooting during matches to get a situation under control. This is exactly what happened when Antonio Inoki met The Great Antonio on December 7th, 1977. The Croatian-Canadian Great Antonio certainly didn't look like he lived up to his moniker: he was grossly overweight, had a terrible hair and beard combination and wore unsightly yellow trousers. He didn't look like he had an athletic bone in his body (despite being a former strongman). Like a lot of matches, the two were to trade the advantage a little before the inevitable Inoki win but things didn't go exactly according to the script. The Great Antonio, who hadn't done a great deal of pro-wrestling, began to no-sell Inoki's moves and strikes and started clowning around, slapping his considerable stomach and pulling cartoonish facial expressions. The crowd started to laugh, which wasn't the reaction Inoki desired. Inoki got even angrier after his clumsy opponent starting hitting him with clubs to the back which were delivered with excessive force. Taking matters into his own hands, Inoki began to legitimately slap the not-so-great Antonio before tackling him to the ground and kicking him in the face. His point made and his opponent bloodied, Inoki walked off and declared himself the winner.

5. Hulk Hogan Chokes Out Richard Belzer

With Hulkamania in full swing and the initial WrestleMania right around the corner, Hulk Hogan and Mr. T took to the talk show circuit to promote the extravaganza. An appareance on the show Hot Properties on March 27th, 1985 just days before WrestleMania would prove a costly one for Hulk Hogan and Vince McMahon. During the show host Richard Belzer goaded Hogan into showing him a couple of moves, all the while mocking Hogan and Mr. T. As cartoonish and unbelievable as the WWF was at the time, keyfabe was still enforced and Hogan didn't take to kindly to a weedy talk show host belittling his livelihood. After more goading, Hogan proceeded to put Belzer in a front facelock to prove wrestling's legitimacy. Of course a front facelock is a very real, very painful submission move when applied properly. It was too much for the slight Belzer, who passed out in the hold. When Hogan released him, he collapsed to the floor and cracked his head of the concrete, creating a noticeable wound. Mr. T insisted that he was just 'sleeping' as he lay unconscious on the floor. Hogan looked nervous as time stood still. Belzer made it to his feet and somehow managed to segue into a commercial break. Richard Belzer sued Hogan for $5m but settled out of court. Hogan deserved to pay for trying to intimidate and use force on somebody who couldn't fight back and who he outweighed by a good couple of hundred pounds. A similar incident had occurred before that when Dr. Death David Schultz slapped reported John Stossel after being asked if wrestling was fake or not. Schultz was fired over the incident (as well as for challenging Mr. T to a backstage fight). https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tbl92RqHVmk

4. The Brawl For All

The Brawl For All must have seemed like a good idea at the time but, in practice, it was something of a disaster for the WWF. The concept was simple - stage a legitimate tough guy tournament on Raw - but the results were very damaging for the company. The idea was pitched by Vince Russo (who else?) and was supposed to be a way to use a bunch of guys who weren't getting a lot of TV time or who creative didn't have anything for at that moment. Each match consisted of three one minute rounds. Competitors wore gloves and, in the event that there was no winner, it would go to ringside judges. With it being a real competition, injuries were inevitable. Steve Blackman, Road Warrior Hawk, Savio Vega and 2 Cold Scorpio all sustained or aggravated injuries during the tournament. Steve Williams, who was the favourite to win the tournament but was knocked out in the quarterfinals, sustained several injuries that put him out for months. The biggest blow had to have been to Williams' pride though: he was supposed to win the tournament and then feud with top star Stone Cold Steve Austin but he was battered by eventual winner Bart Gunn. Bart's reward for his tournament victory? A 35 second defeat to professional boxer Butterbean at WrestleMania XV. The Brawl For All might have been a good concept on paper but in practice it was really poor. A shambles from the start, fans in the arenas turned on the contest and chanted 'boring' and 'we want wrestling' while fights were in progress.

3. Bully Holly?

Bob 'Hardcore' Holly has a bit of a reputation for being a bully. Holly was never a hazer or a ribber or anything like that but he was definitely a locker-room enforcer and wasn't afraid to throw somebody out of the locker room if they were acting disrespectful. But that's not the main reason why Holly has a reputation for bullying. Holly's reputation mainly stems from working stiff, with one incident in particular sticking out in fans' minds. Holly was a guest trainer during the second season of Tough Enough and was a participant in a multi-person tag match with the rookies. At one point during the match, Holly seemed to be working extra stiff with eventual winner Matt Cappotelli. Holly booted Matt in the ribs, gave him a few harsh clubs on the back and then proceeded to stomp him in the face. Matt got a bloody lip and a black eye and the contestants gave damning testimonials. Why was Holly being so stiff with the young Cappotelli? Wasn't wrestling supposed to be scripted? Well, Holly was just working the same way he worked with everyone ('snug' is the way he describes it). It was just dramatised for the sake of television, with Matt going on television the next day and crying and saying that he wasn't sure if he could continue. In a business like wrestling, with the very serious injuries and surgeries that guys have to endure and even wrestle with, a black eye and a bloody lip is the least of your troubles. Holly gave it but he also took it and has stated many times that he welcomed people giving him receipts because he preferred to work that way. The incident divided opinion, with many complaining that Holly was a bully and took liberties on somebody that he knew wouldn't fight back and others saying that Holly was protecting the business. For some, it was a case of professional wrestling getting way too real.

2. Savage And The Snake

1991 was not a time where you would expect realism in wrestling. Not quite ready to focus on athleticism and the 'New Generation', the WWF still in cartoon mode. On an episode of WWF Superstars, however, fans were treated to an ultra-realistic angle between two of the Cartoon Era's biggest stars. Jake Roberts had been calling out Macho Man Randy Savage (who was 'retired' and commentating at that point) but Randy had stayed in the announce booth. After Roberts had won a quick squash match he began insulting Savage again, Savage had had enough and went towards the ring but the referee stopped him (he was retired after all) and Roberts pounced, attacking the Macho Man. Roberts continued to attack Savage and eventually tied him up in the ring ropes. It was at this moment that the angle took a turn for the real. Jake picked up his pet cobra and placed it on Savage's arm. The cobra was genuinely biting him. Savage had, of course, agreed to let this happen and it was an undoubtedly shocking visual. The snake continued to bite long past it was supposed to and even Roberts began trying to shake him loose. Savage truly was one-of-a-kind. Not many wrestlers would let a king cobra bite them for the sake of a wrestling angle, but he did. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Sbv54NTqEmo

1. Mass Transit

ECW was notorious for its bloody brawls and wild stunts but nothing could prepare fans for what happened on an ECW house show on November 26th, 1996. The card was scheduled to featured Axl Rotten and D-Von Dudley against The Gangstas (New Jack and Mustafa) but Rotten was absent due to a family emergency. A local kid called Eric Kulas, who was untrained and only seventeen years old, volunteered to replace him and lied to Paul Heyman, claiming that he was in fact older and had been trained by Killer Kowalski. Kulas, who weighed around 350lbs, wrestled with a bus driver gimmick under the name Mass Transit. Apparently Kulas was telling the other participants of the match what he wanted them to do, a sign of disrespect. This was noted by New Jack. When Kulas said he wanted to bleed in the match but had never done it before, New Jack happily volunteered to cut him himself. At the end of the match, New Jack cut Kulas deeply. Very deeply. Video footage of the incident shows New Jack asking Kulas if he was okay (he clearly wasn't) before they continued to work him over in the ring. Kulas' father stopped the match by screaming 'ring the f***ing bell, he's only seventeen' as paramedics rushed to the ring to try and stop the bleeding. Kulas was lying in a pool of his own blood as fans and wrestlers began to panic. ECW fans was used to seeing a fair amount of blood, but this was clearly not supposed to happen. As the medics were tending to Kulas, New Jack picked up the microphone and said 'I don't care if the motherf***er dies'. While this might have been an in-character promo, New Jack has made secret of the fact that he's not sorry about what happened and would do it again if he was put into the same situation (New Jack has been involved in similar incidences since). The incident scared off pay-per-view providers and had legal implications for New Jack and ECW. New Jack was acquitted of all charges.