10 Times WWE Pleasantly Surprised Their Audience
You get a happy ending! You get a happy ending! You get a happy ending! FINN GETS A HAPPY ENDING!
Perhaps by fluke rather than force, WWE has cultivated a mutually abusive relationship with its fanbase over the last decade or so. John Cena's crowd-dividing craic may have been well-handled by 'The Champ' himself, but it foreshadowed the opening of a wound between audience and office WWE never managed to heal.
Wrongly assuming every performer could cope under challenging similar circumstances, the company allowed Roman Reigns' own fractured relationship with the "Universe" to descend into the sort of incendiary hatred that could be heard from space. Hopefully 'The Big Dog' kicks out of his current ill health, but it took some scale of mismanagement to reach a point where - without a shred of flippancy - it took his devastating leukemia diagnosis to gain him unanimous love and support from the crowd.
This is a company that once used a Royal Rumble finish as a live litmus test when Vince McMahon couldn't decide between a 'Hitman' and a supposed American hero. An group that presented previously-suspended Superstar Jeff Hardy as a great babyface hope because the fans understood him even if the office didn't. An organisation that - eventually - realised that Daniel Bryan had to be a part of the WrestleMania 30 because it made pro wrestling sense even if it confused Vince McMahon himself.
The undercurrent of nastiness is new, and certainly shouldn't ever be the norm. Sometimes it's simply nice to be nice...
10. Hulk Hogan's 2002
Hulk Hogan's WWE Championship run may not have been the needle-mover Vince McMahon hoped for in 2002, but the version of the man he knew was the one he enjoyed pushing after a New World Order return quickly stalled after a WrestleMania 18 babyface turn.
Reinventing him as a contemporary version of his older self, Hogan's return to red and yellow didn't come with the laboured condescension of WCW's 1999 attempt but a hybrid blend of the 'Hollywood' gimmick that had served him well and the 'Hulkamania' look Vince constructed an empire around.
Though middling figures at the time suggested he wasn't a long term prospect on top, there was clear emotional investment if not financial from a dissilusioned and dissolving fanbase.
Hogan worked beyond expectations as result of the push. Defeating Triple H in an April 2002 clash that was better than it had any right to be, he lost clean(ish) in a stinker against The Undertaker the following month, squeaky clean to Kurt Angle in a fabulous match a month after that, and clean - save for the claret that covered his face - to Brock Lesnar on television to prep 'The Next Big Thing' for a SummerSlam main event against The Rock.
Never since then has he felt quite so welcome on the show.
9. Kurt Angle Replaces Roman Reigns
A bizarre mumps outbreak shortly before October 2017's Tables, Ladders and Chairs pay-per-view created the sort of ripple effect that had previously hamstrung WWE in the past.
Vince McMahon, for his faults, has a proven track record of over-delivering a replacement for the original intended output when he has to make changes, but few could have foresaw his off-the-wall solution to Roman Reigns' unexpected absence just days before a blockbuster main event pitting The Shield against five of Raw's finest fiends.
Helicoptering in Raw General Manager Kurt Angle to side with Seth Rollins and Dean Ambrose, WWE ramped up the anticipation for the main event tenfold with less than 48 hours to go, and spectacularly followed through with booking that saved his conversion to killer 'Wrestling Machine' for the closing moments of an otherwise-exceptional brawl.
It was one of the best possible scenarios pulled from the brink of one of the worst, and it wasn't the only fire they'd been forced to fight that night. From the fires of hell a 'Demon' re-emerged, but not to face a twisted sister. His new opponent was 'Phenomenal'...
8. AJ Styles Replaces Bray Wyatt
There's something about the unexpected Finn Bálor match (more on that later), that seems to bring the best out of everybody involved, but life's certainly made an awful lot easier when AJ Styles is the guy on the other end of the surprise.
'The Phenomenal One' was drafted over from SmackDown for one night only on the Raw-exclusive Tables, Ladders and Chairs pay-per-view back in 2017 when Bray Wyatt caught the mumps, and though it deprived us all of ever seeing what the f*ck the company had in mind for the wretched presentation of 'The Eater Of Worlds' Sister Abigail concept, it instead served as a reminder of what Bálor had to offer at the top of the card if actually pushed into the spot.
'The Demon' was a megastar in victory over the man that would be WWE Champion within weeks of the contest, whilst Styles kicked off what would perhaps go down as his best ever month within the organisation. Crucially, with no time to actually promote the contest, WWE were forced to ask their audience to appreciate the wrestling for wrestling's sake. Unsurprisingly, they adored it.
7. Embracing TNA
For all the years TNA/Impact Wrestling pretended to be rival WWE, nothing actually sold the concept more than Vince McMahon's refusal to acknowledge their presence on television.
Through genuine ignorance towards their product or a nagging feeling every time the group gently penetrated WWE's outer-walls, TNA were largely left on a Sports Entertainment island until said island drifted so far out to sea that the organisation could no longer even see them. And now they can't they're finally willing to show the world.
An influx of former Impact Zone headliners have since made their way into the company, and WWE have thankfully furnished Network documentaries and their ilk with plenty of moments that bolster their tales. It was best illustrated by the exception Hardy Boyz retrospective last year - a subtitled scene between a drug-addicted Jeff Hardy and Eric Bischoff during the younger brother's lowest ebb was a fascinating insight into his life's darkest timeline, and it wouldn't have been made possible without the loose working relationship that exists between the groups today.
It's a shame that Impact had to fade into virtual insignificance to get there, but their nightmarish future is at least the wrestling completist's dream.
6. The Signing Of Brian Pillman
Securing Brian Pillman's signature in June 1996 was a very un-WWE move for the WWE of the time, not least he because the contract he signed guaranteed him monies in a way few others had ever received.
The industry was changing rapidly at the time, and few performers were as ahead of the curve as the 'Loose Cannon'. He'd worked his way out of WCW just to potentially go back there on double the money, and used ECW as the unfiltered platform to do as pleased to ensure that both major organisations had to part with plenty to get him on board. The plan worked to near-perfection until a horrific car accident left him with injuries that not only threatened to end his in-ring career but expedited a drug dependency that would contribute to the end of his life just over a year later.
Without such hindsight though, Vince McMahon took the gamble on Pillman in order to try and claw back an edge in the ever-building war with his opposition to the south. For all his physical and mental fragilities, Pillman sought to earn every cent he was paid during his remaining time with the group. Every promo and commentary stint was the sheer delight audiences had hoped for, even if the matches paled in comparison with his older efforts.
5. Brock Lesnar Vs Roman Reigns (Vs Seth Rollins)
Brock Lesnar's WrestleMania 31 WWE Championship match against Roman Reigns was already over-delivering before Seth Rollins raced down the enormous ramp with his Money In The Bank briefcase in hand.
'The Big Dog's bloody grin served as a mark of his indestructibility in the face of somebody that has assumed total domination as normal. Roman wasn't getting cheered, but many of the fans that ordinarily hurled disdain at him were suddenly frozen in frazzled awe at his remarkable fighting spirit before they were bailed out by the strains of Rollins' entrance music echoing out from the stadium speakers.
Delivering the fan-friendly solution at the exact right moment, WWE provided a winner the entire venue could leave satisfied over, a surprising WrestleMania ending that left the community in shock and a genuine historic first - no other holder of the briefcase had ever chosen the 'Show Of Shows' finale to spring their surprise challenge.
Rollins - by this point the heel 'Architect' and destroyer of The Shield but not yet quite the abused step-child of Triple H and Stephanie McMahon - was popular enough on his own terms to be the one to take the title even if it set both Reigns and Lesnar on a revenge mission in the aftermath.
4. All About Bret
A rare public apology from Vince McMahon to talent and fans alike, Bret Hart's pointed WWE Championship coronation at WrestleMania X was apparently so exciting that McMahon himself had to leave the broadcast booth to get involved.
One year earlier, Hart had been forced to point Hulk Hogan towards the ring to take a title he'd worn proudly just minutes earliers. 12 months on, and Hogan's 1980s co-star Randy Savage was pointing towards 'The Excellence Of Execution' as the entity trusted with guiding the company through their choppiest waters to date.
Choppy waters that would include rivalling 'The Hulkster' himself as he moved to WCW to try and turn their business around just a year after helping tank WWE's for his own gains. For once and for a change, McMahon genuinely and earnestly put his faith in Bret and atoned for his gross misjudgment a year earlier.
Under the hallowed roof of Madison Square Garden and surrounded the babyface roster in a literal and figurative show of support from the bulk of the locker room, 'The Hitman' was at long last the man.
3. ECW One Night Stand 2005
It's not uncommon in an industry fuelled by hyperbole for wrestlers and promoters to talk up situations in an act of profiteering rather than profundity, but One Night Stand 2005 survives reviews and rewatches with such power that if one of the performers on the card called it the greatest night of their life, it'd be easy to believe.
Paul Heyman's the biggest worker of the bunch, but his tears felt real enough for him to have to banter them off during his impassioned speech midway through the show. Tommy Dreamer wears his ECW heart on his sleeve so visibly it's a wonder he hasn't died from blading it during every reunion show - but nothing ever appeared as pure a reminder of his happiest time than this June recreation of a once-beloved spectacle.
WWE smartly monetised ECW in the best way (before settling on the dirt worst a year and a bit later...), and predictably, it's because Vince McMahon gave Paul Heyman virtual autonomy for one night only. Even the show-closing sequence in which Tazz topples Kurt Angle to kick
2. Making Amends
Yet another positive element of modern-day WWE that Triple H has been the one to take credit for in place of Vince McMahon himself, the re-emergence of many old faces on product that had once frozen them out has been far more common this decade than at any point in the company's history.
The old adage used to be painfully true - nobody ever left on good terms. In the 1980s it was because of diametric philosophical opposition, in the 1990s WCW's major money offers, and the 2000s because McMahon no longer had the time nor truck for sentimentality.
If not Hunter himself, something must have played to McMahon's softer side in later years. Wrestlers thought never to be part of the product again are unearthed for moving Hall Of Fame moments, then given beautiful sendoffs when they sadly pass. For all the organisation does wrong, it services fans with the memories and matches of anybody it chooses in its position as the gatekeeper of all wrestling.
For such a narrative to not be entirely and laughably false, this embrace was as necessary as it was welcomed.
1. Finn Bálor Replaces Braun Strowman
WWE did a magnificent job of elevating Finn Bálor over the course of a single evening in order to prepare him for a charge against Brock Lesnar at the 2019 Royal Rumble - imagine if they'd spent a year or so doing it instead.
What's particularly bizarre is that this was possibly the plan all along. Braun Strowman's iffy injury worries may also have been wobbling the company, but it seems as though common sense prevailed and 'The Monster Among Men's moment in the sun may not be underneath the heat of the Phoenix sky.
Bálor - as Bálor, not 'The Demon' - can lose to Brock in credible fashion and potentially leave a painted-up rematch with him on the table for future use. Lesnar seems more willing to actually work with those half his size, and Bálor delivers main event displays when - shockingly - he's permitted to wrestle main events.
Regardless of the Royal Rumble result, Finn's likely to leave in the best position he's been in since his SummerSlam flirtation with the war-paint. Like all the other times over the last few years, WWE lost interest again almost immediately. If Bálor wants 2019 to reflect a "New Year, New Him", Vince McMahon needs to embrace an identical change.