10 Ups & 1 Down From AEW WrestleDream
Bryan Danielson and Zack Sabre, Jr. achieve technical wrestling nirvana on an unforgettable night.
The build to WrestleDream embarrassed the profligate, experimental misfire that was the All In/All Out double-header.
While it never approached the on-fire, to-the-moon feeling generated ahead of Revolution 2020 and All Out 2021, Tony Khan, mostly, did a very good job of building the anticipation. It helps that he opted for a more pared-back approach with two key matches. Bryan Danielson Vs. Zack Sabre, Jr. and FTR Vs. Aussie Open operated under a simple, beautiful premise: who is the absolute best in their field of expertise?
This credible, sporting platform was refreshing in contrast to the convoluted, unfocused subplots that plagued AEW throughout August.
Khan did much of his signature dovetailing ahead of the Trios match between Kenny Omega, Kota Ibushi and Chris Jericho Vs. the Don Callis Family, but it all worked. It felt far more believable than the Elite Vs. Blackpool Combat Club series. Bluntly, it was easy to pinpoint why every wrestler involved hated the wrestlers on the opposing side.
Also, since Brawl Out, Omega has felt strangely distant from the promotion. Pairing him with Chris Jericho, who is never going to say no to a spot of mic time, has allowed Omega to feel present. Turns out a bit of exposition is quietly crucial. Omega felt like a concern again.
Julia Hart was one of the strongest contenders for a women's title match in quite some time, Swerve Strickland was long overdue a real test at the top of the card, and the Young Bucks, too, felt like they belonged.
Did the show live up to the hype...?
Downs...
1. One Match Too Far
In and of itself, WrestleDream was a phenomenal show - one that, given it was the third best of the year, underscores what a fantastic 2023 AEW has delivered on pay-per-view.
Even the best show, Revolution, went one match too far. Nobody in San Francisco could be arsed with Samoa Joe Vs. Wardlow, and nobody could be arsed with Ricky Starks Vs. Wheeler YUTA in Seattle.
It wasn't a bad match - it was actively damn good in places - but it didn't fully click, either. Starks and YUTA were already up against the adrenaline dump the crowd had experienced after watching home state hero Swerve Strickland defeat Hangman Page in a minor classic. Certain reversal sequences were mistimed, and the finish - YUTA struggled through his usual bottom-rope skin-the-cat spot before Starks dropped him with the spear - felt more like a mistake on YUTA's part than an enterprising counter on Ricky's. That didn't get either man over.
This was better off not happening. AEW could have - for once, and not to such an obnoxious extent - borrowed from WWE's approach and screened a few ads to act as a buffer between Swerve Vs. Hangman and Bryan Danielson Vs. Zack Sabre, Jr.
Instead, this match was fated to fail, and that was an odd choice. Awarding Starks a token win on PPV hardly matters when his match wasn't over. He remains on the threshold between the upper midcard and the main event. The match either accomplished nothing or less than nothing.
Time will tell if Starks was stigmatised by it.
Ups...
10. MJF Is Still Very, Very Over, But...
MJF is so over that his work is guaranteed to be loud and, by that metric, successful.
Dissenting voices online don't like it, feeling it is too "WWE" or that there's an insincere quality to his babyface work. That might be the point, in the case of a super long con, but even if it isn't, the MJF character is mimicking behaviours because that is what real, insecure people do when trying to make a connection. MJF shakes the ropes because he has seen other babyfaces doing it.
If that's a pretentious take on another comedy-tinged house show opener special, that is because there wasn't a great deal to it. MJF set up his babyface comeback and, intriguingly, a physically impossible spot in his pre-match promo, promising to body slam Dutch and stick Vincent's head up his "fat ass". He did both of those things, sort of, in a match that was cursed to begin with.
It existed to prolong the money-spinner that is Better Than You Bay-Bay, but now that team are on indefinite hiatus, this feels like it's actually beneath MJF. This was loud, and improbably dramatic, but did the fans actually suspend their disbelief - or were they just happy to play along with the novelty of watching MJF live?
The match was advertised, and the paying audience went banana.
That is the strictest definition of objective success, but is BTYB so over that this is it now on every other PPV for the duration of Adam Cole's stint on the sidelines?
9. A Strong TBS Title Match
The gutting thing about Kris Statlander Vs. Julia Hart is that it is impossible to shake the feeling that Julia has had her turn, and that two months of obscurity await.
This is how it works, or rather doesn't work. The women you are asked to invest in disappear because there is no room to accommodate their growth.
And Julia Hart has grown, which this match indicated. So many women's matches are received with a bleak, apathetic silent hum. When this got rocking, fans - and not out of habit - chanted "This is awesome!"
It wasn't blow-away great and will not trouble any MOTY lists, but she and Kris Statlander - who incidentally is awesome as the Ace champion who can elevate anybody to her level - did a remarkable job. Mostly.
The size difference meant that few took Hart's heat sequence too seriously, and this was cursed with a "didn't get all of it" moment when Hart mistimed a senton, but the finishing stretch was awesome. Hart countering an aerial attempt with an overhead belly-to-belly suplex was excellent character work consistent with the House of Black's cerebral strategy, and Statlander slapping the mist out of Hart's mouth was a novel spot perfect for a smart babyface. The fans bought that Hart's awe-inspiring moonsault was the finish, and Statlander's timing, when just reaching the rope with her foot, was acute.
Statlander won with a cool Tombstone/Sunday Night Fever combination. The layout protected Julia, but will her creative do the same in the months to come?
8. A Very Good - But Not Great - Party Match
The Young Bucks won a four-way match over the Lucha Bros., the Gunns, and HOOK and Orange Cassidy, earning an any time, anywhere shot over FTR in the process.
(A win in California in a ladder match is a neat way of withholding the answer to the question of who is the best pure tag team of their generation, incidentally).
It was a very good match in places without ever reaching that heady rush of exhilaration that the Bucks elicit in their best, most demented party matches. What transpired to be an injury angle did not help the mood. It was all too believable that Fenix would suffer yet another setback; even before the events of the last few weeks, he was prone to injury and has regularly missed not inconsiderable stretches of action. Rather than galvanise the fans into getting behind Penta El Zero, the necessitated spot dampened the vibe - and the high-octane match quality, since Fenix is a genre specialist.
The action was still great, mostly, and the interlacing of fun and drama was effective. The Gunns calling back to the New Age Outlaws pinning one another back in 1998 was daft, amusing character work - of course they are dumb enough to think that would work - and in a cracking false finish, HOOK thought he'd tapped out Austin Gunn with REDRUM before it was revealed that Nick Jackson had made a blind tag.
This was a lot of fun, anxiety surrounding Fenix aside, but a certain delirium that the Bucks deliver on PPV - their clutch player run has been phenomenal - was missing.
7. FTR Just About Build On Their Legacy
FTR Vs. Aussie Open II was a very good match, but true greatness eluded it.
The signature excess of the AEW PPV worked against it. They followed an instant classic and a breathtaking trios match. Also, Mark Davis snapped his arm midway through.
It feels harsh, then, to critique it too much, but the work was beneath the level of their NJPW Royal Quest Match of the Year Contender. A great wrestling match should feel like a struggle, but this was the good and bad version of a struggle at the same time. It just felt like they were toiling in there, and while Davis suffering an injury was terrible enough under any circumstances, his storyline role as a total monster - those chops were vile - messed with the dynamic.
Despite playing out against an exhausted backdrop, much of the action was very, very good. Cash Wheeler bumped like a lunatic to tell the story that Aussie Open are the most physically imposing team in the world, and Fletcher's cut-off for the Dax Harwood hot tag was nanosecond-perfect. The challengers barely executed a Shatter Machine to prevent the finishing stretch from feeling like a breathless maelstrom, but the finish itself - a match-winning avalanche Shatter Machine from FTR this time - looked awesome.
The finisher theft cliché was deployed just over a month removed from All In, too, which felt like a diminished return. The Big FTR Match can feel patterned, and fans have watched a lot of them in 2023.
Conceptually, this probably wouldn't have reached true classic status even if the circumstances were more favourable.
6. Eddie Kingston Vs. Katsuyori Shibata Literally Slaps
Eddie Kingston Vs. Katsuyori Shibata was an unfussy crowd-pleasing sprint elevated by its intoxicating rhythm and mastery of the basics.
It wasn't without the keen attention to detail that elevates AEW, still, above every wrestling promotion on the planet. There are too many titles in AEW, so many that Khan booked two champions to lose at WrestleDream. That is far-from-ideal booking, but few have pointed that out because it's the norm nowadays: Shibata, ROH Pure champion and Hangman Page, ROH World Trios champion, both lost. As did NJPW World TV champion Zack Sabre, Jr., come to think of it.
Khan can't use his best talents without walking backwards into beating a champion, which underscores the problem, but it was pointed out by the wonderful Excalibur that, had the match adhered to Pure rules, Kingston would have ran out of rope breaks.
This defiantly strong style match - and its soulful, hard-hitting brevity - was just joyful. After a macho exchange of chops, Kingston was out-wrestled by Shibata on the mat. This was the core idea of the match; Kingston had to survive Shibata's brutal striking onslaught, but Shibata, dominant, took the piss. This was his undoing; in a wonderful spot, making exquisite use of Shibata's mischievous, cruel streak, he annoyed Eddie with a series of Kawada kicks.
This enraged Eddie, but Shibata ate and no-sold his Uraken finish. Eddie, and he's the best at this, kept fighting - and in a great finish avenged the disrespect by defeating Shibata with his hero's high-stack powerbomb.
5. Trios Mayhem Borders On The Incredible
Not everything was as well-executed as the layout intended, but mostly, Kenny Omega, Kota Ibushi and Chris Jericho Vs. the Don Callis family was outstanding.
In a strange and roundabout way, this version of Kota Ibushi works now. Fans have lowered their expectations and adjusted to the reality, and he's still so good at animating himself that he remains the only wrestler who can go to "that place" without descending into cringe. He did so in a great sequence in the back half of the match, one elevated by Will Ospreay's brilliance. He took an Ibushi strike like the lights went out immediately (there are few lights in the man's head to begin with, but you get the idea).
For the first time since arriving in AEW in what realistically is a strange run, Ibushi completed his part of the Cross Slash admirably. He's still not the same, but fans are used to it all now.
There wasn't a great deal of narrative ingenuity to this - the heels cheated, the babyfaces hot-tagged, Callis used the bat to win it for his team when the ref lost control of the all-action overspill - but the various pairings were built towards brilliantly, and the action mostly soared.
Omega and Ospreay were the highlight outside of a pulsating exchange between Omega and Sammy Guevara capped off by a brutal, spectacular shooting star to the outside. Ospreay countering the One Winged-Angel with a hurricanrana before flattening Omega with a Sky Twister press indicated that they have yet another out-of-this-world singles in them.
Did Chris Jericho kick out of Guevara's Codebreaker at one because it draws him closer to Omega in their ongoing storyline, or because he saw it and thought it looked cool?
Jury's out!
4. Darby Allin Proves Himself A Worthy PPV Headliner
The story here was beautifully told - just fantastic heel work on the part of Christian Cage.
In the build, he buried Darby as a stuntman unable to actually wrestle. Allin then outwrestled him in the first fall, won by hooking Cage's turtleneck over his head in a positively awesome moment of babyface intelligence. Cage, that hypocritical bastard, then slowly destroyed Allin in a garbage wrestling match because there are few better at actually invoking true disgust from the audience. Before that, in a great spot that furthered the story, Darby countered a Christian spear with a bulldog. That ruled: when it came to pure wrestling, Cage was literally Darby's bitch.
The match verged on the harrowing in the second and third falls, by which time Cage had removed the apron and padding from the ring. At long last, Darby's insanity appears to have caught up with him. He took a bump back and elbow-first into the ring steps from the apron. It looked horrific, and indeed was: per Allin, he took himself for an x-ray after completing his media obligations.
One small criticism: Cage thwarted the stretcher job by scaling the top turnbuckle and blasting Darby with a frog splash. This was a bit too close to the key spot in Page Vs. Swerve. Still, as a spectacle, this was very, very compelling, and the stretcher job allowed Cage to cut up the ring without dragging it out forever. That bit is usually far too long for its own good.
At the finish, after kicking out of a Killswitch on the exposed wooden boards, Nick Wayne turned on Darby, as foreshadowed on TV.
And then...
3. Adam Copeland Is All Elite
After the main event, Christian Cage's new heel stable attacked Darby. This set the scene for Adam Copeland's AEW bow.
In the sort of very theatrical presentation that absolutely works in the context of a debut, a short vignette of Copeland riding a cycle into the arena was screened. This doesn’t matter, since the subsequent angle was white-hot, but the former Edge rode past a stadium erupting in fireworks. The symbolic connotation was that he had left the big time behind.
Again, didn't matter: the pop he generated was electrifying, and his timing, when teasing the heel turn before striking Nick Wayne with the steel chair, was the work of a total master. Cringeworthy as he was towards the end of his WWE return run, he knows exactly how to whip up high drama. His vengeful assault on the heel gang was expertly arranged.
Prediction: his face run is extremely popular if a little too earnest, but, like his storyline brother, he rediscovers the dark patter within to revive a flagging legacy.
2. Swerve Strickland Ascends
Just how good is Wrestler X?
This is a question that is very pressing in 2023. There is a veritable horde of excellent 8/10 wrestlers in AEW - far too many, in fact - so many that it's hard to determine who is capable of ascending.
Who among the Wardlows and Malakai Blacks and Daniel Garcias is truly great enough to become undeniable? To be one of the very first names on the upcoming PPV format sheet?
Swerve Strickland Vs. Hangman Page was meta-premised on that exact query, and Swerve passed the referendum. The match was a triumphant slow-burner loaded with overwhelming main event-level drama.
Page played situational heel, and, as with most things, is excellent at it. At Double Or Nothing 2022, he tried to saw CM Punk's skin off with his forearm, and he took that nasty form into this match with his attempts to dismantle Swerve's hand. Swerve was even more nasty in response, and this was his diamond-sharp wrestling mind on full display. After proving himself capable of drawing fans into a slower, more deliberate PPV match, he knew precisely when to pick his big spots.
In a great moment, as Page was tended to by the medical staff, Swerve decimated him with a stomp from the top turnbuckle to the apron. Swerve, and this is ambitious, presents himself as a remorseless psychopath. Delivering the kill-shot when his opponent was for all intents and purposes already dead, that was magnificent character work.
The match was brutal - a Dead Eye on the ring steps was particularly gruesome - but both men did an unreal job of crafting the tone and letting the sense of unease linger throughout.
Must-watch brilliant and can't-watch unsettling at the same time, this was a minor classic - but it somehow wasn't the match of the night...
1. Considerably More Than A Dream Match
You could watch Bryan Danielson Vs. Zack Sabre, Jr. spoiled, and still believe that Danielson will lose. You could watch the match countless times and still hold a sense of doubt over the outcome. That's how incredible it was. That's how phenomenal Danielson's selling was.
Beyond the obvious - precious moments with your loved ones and all that b*llocks - this is what the professional wrestling fan lives for. There is no better feeling than watching a match one expects to be a classic and it exceeding those expectations within seconds. This was a five-star match before the first strike was thrown.
The sheer depth of strategy here was transcendent. The actual application of technique was glorious, obviously, but the small moments of panic, of regrouping, of finding a limb to reverse or neutralise the pressure: that's what made this a masterpiece. It was impossible to watch this match and not believe professional wrestling to be real. If the purpose of the form is to make the audience suspend their disbelief, this match perfected the form.
It mutated into a grotesquely violent strike-heavy affair deeper into the runtime, but even the technical exchanges were disgusting. How can you best Hiroshi Tanahashi's dragon screw, for crying out loud?
The American Dragon managed it. Christ almighty, the selling here was out of this world. You could almost hear ZSJ's ACL rupturing, and yet the man was merely selling the illusion of pain.
The tenor of the match changed when ZSJ won the mental portion of the chess game by baiting Danielson into using his barely repaired right arm. Jon Moxley was outstanding on commentary, and received most of the plaudits, but Nigel McGuinness entered the performance of a lifetime. He sold the threat of Danielson even exposing that right arm as a career-ender of a strategic error. And then Danielson sold it himself, lulling fans into the match entirely.
It was perfect. That's the only apt word.
It somehow felt like a performance and an anti-performance at the same time. Consider the use (or not) of Danielson's Cattle Mutilation. ZSJ - deepening the ultra-realistic idea that he had prepped for this over a span of years - evaded it almost the second Danielson had applied it. This deep cut from the Dragon's repertoire was sacrificed for the immersive feeling that this match was real.
To use an analogy, imagine a popular rock band teasing the audience with a wildly popular cult favourite song that they never play, playing only the opening bar of a riff, and that audience going nutsregardless. The match, unlike few others in the history of the medium, was bold enough to sacrifice every easy dramatic principle in service of an idealised state of realism - and yet it wasn't remotely pretentious or up its own backside. Danielson won with a second Busaiku knee. A submission did not win it. Zack should point this out and demand 500 rematches, all of which should be held under a two-hour time limit. The first 499 should go to a draw.
That is hyperbole, obviously, but these two could probably do something in the 500th that nobody could anticipate.
Intricate, horrifying, dramatic, realistic, passionate, vile: this was otherworldly.