10 Wild Creative Pitches Wrestlers Made To Get Into WWE

Kenny Omega runs the ropes faster than anyone - and he was almost furious, too...

By Michael Sidgwick /

By now, provided you're a long-suffering fan of WWE - or even someone who really likes it, in spite of countless cases of promotional malpractice - you'll have endured the wild creative pitches that WWE has imposed on its talent.

Advertisement

Karrion Kross as the fourth (and worst) member of Demolition was something else, even by latter-day Vince McMahon standards. This is the cynical take, but it really felt like an indirect punishment to Triple H. They stripped Kross of every theatrical accompaniment with which he got over (or pushed) as a test or out of spite, decided he was too boring, and then said "Put a Gladiator mask on him or something". If Vince didn't want to look at Christian's face because he found it creepy, it was as if found Karrion's face too bland.

Keith Lee, a very articulate guy who played a just man very well - whose explosions mean so much more when his fair disposition is rattled by some heel pr*ck - was repackaged, dismally, as the 'Bearcat' in the same year of 2021 in a development far more problematic than is remembered.

This is the way it goes, or at least went: WWE was the biggest name in town, Vince knew all, and he wasn't about to let a wrestler have agency over their own career.

Certain intrepid developmental talents tried to work the system, however...

10. Santana Garrett Tries To Walk So That Nikki ASH Can Run

What happened, between 2001 and 2022, is that the creative writing staff cracked the actual description of their duties and pitched pure sh*t to Vince McMahon in order to spare themselves a rollicking.

Advertisement

Writers who admitted to being fans were laughed at, and considered marks. Writers who pitched wrestling-centric storylines evidently didn't get their stuff through. Collectively, they began to realise that it was easier to simply pitch dire, juvenile jokes and keep their mouths shut about the wrestlers they did like, because Vince treated a good faith recommendation as if it were a threat to his precious genius - a petulant "You think you know better than me?" fit that killed off many a promising career.

Eventually, the talent became aware of this cheat code and volunteered to do broad, wacky b*llocks just to get on TV. Nikki ASH played a kid's TV-level superhero, probably with a degree of earnestness, in fairness, but much funnier was Shane Thorne's enterprising, degrading bid to be, simply, "As Australian as I can possibly be". He was a Crocodile Dundee x Crocodile Hunter-styled fellow who lived in the presence of several deadly animals (in Australia; he wasn't conscripted to NXT UK).

Santana Garrett tried her luck along these lines too, telling Lucha Libre that she wanted to play the Wonder Woman-adjacent character she had worked under on the indies in WWE. If her infamous NXT match with Taynara Conti is any indication, she had in fact discovered a superpower, because it was worked in bullet time.

Garrett wasn't the only performer with a half-decent grasp of what the promotion actually was under Vince McMahon...

9. Chelsea Green Wanted To Be A Cult Member

As a segue from the Santana Garrett entry, she also revealed to Lucha Libre Online that there was a pitch to bring her in alongside Chelsea Green and Vanessa Bourne as part of a "bad girl group".

Advertisement

Perhaps because WWE did this about nine times over in 2015, they thought better of it.

When that half-arsed idea amounted to nothing, Chelsea Green took a more proactive approach. It was clear that creative had nothing for her, and when they eventually did, it was as just another wrestler on the card. The obscenely rich mega-corporation couldn't do any better than that, despite boasting the resources with which to hire the best creative minds imaginable, so they probably should have listened to Chelsea's own pitch: a devoted disciple of Seth Rollins when he was working his 'Visionary' gimmick.

She told the Ten Count podcast earlier this year that she always thought she could pull off the valet role, and she can. She accentuates Matt Cardona's act brilliantly, and Rollins really could have done with someone believing in his bulsh*t, because nobody else did.

She can play unhinged very well, too, so this would have worked - a lot better than "sermons" that were Lovejoy-level bad, only without that being the joke.

8. Tucker Wanted To Get On The Main Roster And Cook

No, not perform in peak mode; to literally cook.

Advertisement

Heavy Machinery were a fun throwback powerhouse act elevated by an absurd comedy element. In a great take, WhatCulture Wrestling's own Andy Murray described Otis as Tucker's pet, and that sums up their dynamic perfectly. Otis was a strange, animalistic man, loyal, nice but very weird and unable to form coherent segments, and his offbeat brand of charisma connected with people.

The tag team were broken up, of course, because that's what Vince did.

Playing another round of "What bullsh*t do I think Vince will like?", Tucker wanted Heavy Machinery to cook barbecue backstage when they weren't working a match on the show. He didn't flesh the idea out much, only noting that "I was trying so hard [at] having aprons made up for us" and "You're not going to tell me we wouldn't get good stuff".

Since this would have inevitably involved skits with Riddle stealing the meat because he had "the munchies" and R-Truth putting on a chef's hat to avoid detection as 24/7 champion, yes, Tucker can be told that he wouldn't get good stuff.

7. Big E Wants To Deliver

Mail.

Advertisement

He wanted to deliver the mail.

Big E is a delightful human being and excellent, multi-skilled pro wrestler. Is there a wrestling fan, even in this toxic, tribal landscape, who doesn't just think he's neat?

They can't be found, even under the 'Show More Replies' function on Twitter, which is essentially the 'Someone is calling you a c*nt or being wildly problematic. This is bad, even for Twitter. Are you absolutely sure you need this energy today?" function.

And you click yes, because you can't help yourself, but Big E acts as a reminder that there is some elusive good left in this anxiety-driver of a hellscape. It's fitting, then, that his "naive developmental guy makes ill-advised bid for stardom" pitch was so stupidly funny. Taking to Twitter as only he can, he recalled that he wanted to become a postal worker named 'Mel Mann', who presumably was to deliver promos via written letter, which would be opened by his opponents in wacky backstage skits.

This for more than one good reason never made it to TV, but if anybody could have made it work...

6. Kenny Omega Tries To Race Into The Fed

In 2011, Kenny Omega sat down with Colt Cabana on the Art of Wresting podcast to discuss his career, journey and hopes.

Advertisement

It's worth a re-listen; Omega was steadfast in his vision of what wrestling should be, or rather what it didn't have to be, and he went on to realise his convictions when it felt wildly improbable at the time. He traded developmental horror stories with his host, and discussed the ways in which he tried to escape the infamously disastrous feeder league that was Deep South Wrestling.

A total sh*t-show that barely bothered to book shows nor train wrestlers to do much beyond the absolute basics and killing them with cardio drills, DSW also encouraged a culture in which the trainees humiliated themselves in order to get out of training.

Omega had a half-decent idea to get on TV and out of hell, but this isn't that. That's on the next slide.

He wanted to do, or felt like he'd at least get on TV doing, a gimmick based on the Fast & Furious franchise. He reasoned that, since Paul Burchill was essentially playing Jack Sparrow, WWE was interested in ripping off the blockbuster scene.

Omega did fulfil the Bob Holly prophesy as the 'Belt Collector', but he never did get to race a car.

5. Kenny Omega Also Tries To Learn A Lesson

Kenny Omega: WWE developmental prospect always scans as strange. It happened, but it was never a good fit.

Advertisement

Omega actually enjoyed the conditioning drills to which he was subjected, but, by his own admission, never subscribed to WWE's strict approach. He thought it was stifling and unlikely to advance his career in a meaningful way, and he was ultimately proved correct upon leaving. His own unique approach transformed the very industry, where he was once a wacky no-mark that Deep South Wrestling higher-ups didn't know what to make of.

Any suggestion that he didn't want to commit to the system if it met him halfway is wide of the mark, however; this was a man who volunteered to spend a lot of time in the company of Matt Striker in order to get over.

Yes: as he recounted to Cabana, he pitched an idea to debut on television as the student of Matt Striker when he was working his teacher gimmick.

This really wasn't bad, as there was much to play with; the idea of a prodigious Omega becoming the teacher himself by showing Striker up gradually, and earning the support of fans along the way, actually had legs.

4. Rick Boogs Knows Where He's Working, At Least

Rick Boogs was born to be a prelim comedy act on North American TV, and that is far from an insult.

Advertisement

Not the most refined pro wrestler, he has found the ideal WWE-friendly niche and was really starting to connect with crowds before suffering an unfortunate and serious injury at WrestleMania this year. Animated, charismatic, goofy - while perfect Vince McMahon fodder, the difference is that his heavy metal dumbass persona was actually amusing enough to raise a smile beyond the audience of one. Doing the air guitar during an abdominal stretch and caterwauling like Rob Halford, Boogs took a shockingly long amount of time to get to the main roster, considering his act was Fed-ready from the moment he first appeared in Full Sail.

He revealed on After The Bell with Corey Graves that, desperate to get on TV before actually making it, he once pitched an artist persona who would go by 'Art Von Boogs', who'd taunt or threaten his opponents in a manner not unlike Dexter Lumis.

It was doomed too out there, which is just as well: that high-pitched squeal would have been wasted, otherwise.

3. EC3 Wants To Be John Cena

Yes, EC3 was actually signed to WWE when he made the following pitch in early 2019, but just barely.

Advertisement

His stock was low, having failed on a TakeOver stage so carefully produced that it was meant to make failure impossible, and his main roster call-up scanned as total desperation. He wasn't promoted as a new potential game-changer but rather "Another act from NXT!"

He didn't talk - trust Vince McMahon to ignore a performer's best attribute - and went 50/50 with Dean Ambrose in a short, mind-scrambling TV programme. He played babyface, and since it was untenable - fans wanted Ambrose to stay, and got behind him - he turned with no explanation seven days later. Michael Cole hurriedly explained the change by mentioning that he'd talked to EC3 earlier that day who had disclosed that he was a "lethal dose of toxic masculinity". He might have just been going through the show notes with Vince, in fairness.

When recounting this strange period on Talk Is Jericho, it was then that EC3 had the idea - to stay in WWE, as it transpired - to play a babyface with no idea that fans despised him. Like John Cena, only on purpose. WWE had tried something similar with Bo Dallas, which didn't really take.

Kurt Angle had already perfected the bit, and every iteration thereafter drew an unflattering comparison.

2. Bob Holly Calls His Shot

A slight deviation on the actual theme here, since Bob Holly was already firmly established in WWE when he delivered the immortal line, but the line is so immortal that there is always an excuse to bring it back into the contentsphere.

Advertisement

As Bruce Prichard recounted on 'Something To Wrestle', the story goes that at one time, WWE sought creative pitches from its roster in a meeting. It wasn't their usual practise, and sensing this, one Bob Holly grasped the rare opportunity.

"Hey I got an idea. How about you give me the belt?" Holly is said to have asked.

"And then what, Bob?" came the reply.

"And then I beat everybody!"

Just an absolutely amazing thought process.

No notes.

Well, some notes, because the bluntness is just so fantastic: the idea of Holly literally beating everybody on the roster at Armageddon to WrestleMania and on every show in between. Then, when he ran out of names to beat, WWE would sign more wrestlers for Holly to beat. Then they'd use their feeder system to develop yet more wrestlers for Holly to beat.

The man said "everybody".

He wanted a Sammartino run, only without the DQs.

1. Bobby Lashley Wanted To Get Fat

Throughout the pandemic, not that the bloody thing is in the past tense sadly, a lot of people gained weight. I did. There was nothing to do except work in between helping out with the parenting, and once that was over, and you were permitted your one allocated bit of outdoor exercise, which was basically a walk in the exact same place, it was all too easy to simply eat your feelings.

Advertisement

Imagine getting paid to do that?

Another bit of a cheat here, since Bobby Lashley was already in WWE, but that's what he wanted to do, incredibly enough. Maybe working Apollo Crews for literally three straight months wasn't something worth putting on Twitter as "GOATed faction", since Bobby would rather have...done that.

Speaking to the Notsam Wrestling podcast, he said he wanted his character to absorb an embarrassing loss, enter a severe depression, and "just be fat" until MVP shook him from his stupor and got him back to winning ways. He reckons that crowds would have enjoyed watching him shed the weight and become the hoss destroyer all over again.

The problem, and Vince McMahon pointed this out, is that it is surely impossible for Lashley, an actual freak, to put on the weight.

Advertisement