In late 2004, after two years of running nothing more than weekly shows, TNA finally secured a TV deal - allowing them to schedule and promote monthly WWE-style Pay Per Views. It was a huge step for the company, and one which would churn out some incredibly mixed results over the years. As important as the entirety of a PPV's card is, the main event can often make or break a show. A good ending has the power to send the fans home happy, nicely setting up the next few weeks of programming, while a poorly-booked or badly-executed conclusion can sour the entire Pay Per View. A PPV can end badly for a variety of reasons. Sometimes the main event can simply be a bad match, while often blame must lie at the feet of the bookers, rather than the hard-working men between the ropes. Occasionally a ludicrous stipulation or massively unpopular finish can ruin a show, no matter how good the match itself actually is. Here are the ten worst endings of TNA Pay Per Views (since their switch to a monthly format in 2004). An interesting point to note is the even spread of such endings throughout the past decade or so, demonstrating the unpredictable nature of a poor PPV conclusion. They can spring up at any time, whether a promotion is enjoying a successful boom period of languishing in the doldrums.
10. Kevin Nash Shocks The World, Turns Heel - Victory Road 2004
Victory Road 2004 was TNA's first monthly Pay Per View, and didn't exactly start off on the right track. The main event was a ladder match between Jeff Jarrett and Jeff Hardy for the NWA Championship (TNA's top belt at the time, before the creation of the TNA World Heavyweight Championship in 2007). Either man had an Outsider in his corner; Jarrett had Scott Hall, while Hardy was enjoying the support of a newly face-turned Kevin Nash. Understandably, given a very questionable track record, Nash has never been the most trustworthy of characters either in kayfabe or real life. His inevitable turn on Hardy, smashing the fan favourite with a Jarrett-style guitar as he climbed to victory, was therefore one of the least surprising swerves in wrestling history. It also confirmed fans' fears that TNA was becoming an old boys club, allowing past-it WCW stars such as Nash and Hall to come straight in and dominate the main event scene as an all-conquering stable. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1XvpKtZtno4
9. Jeff Hardy Falls Off A Ladder (Not In A Good Way) - Against All Odds 2011
Most entries on this list lean more towards the bad booking side of failure, as opposed to poor in-ring performances. However, this PPV flopped due to it's climactic spot coming off as nothing more than an unforgettable botch - one which could have seriously hurt both of the wrestlers involved. In fairness to Jeff Hardy and Mr Anderson, it was a fairly difficult manoeuvre. Anderson was supposed to deliver his finisher, the Mic Check, sending both men plummeting from a pair of ladders - only for Hardy to cunningly grab onto the overhanging belt, simultaneously saving himself from the fall and essentially winning the match. Instead, Anderson accidentally dragged Hardy down with him, sending Jeff crashing down between both ladders and coming dangerously close to a broken neck. To make matters worse, Hardy barely bothered to sell the fall, popping straight back up to scale the ladder and win the match. Also, note Hardy's hideous custom design of the TNA Championship - it looked closer to the WWE Divas Championship than a legitimate world heavyweight championship https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uMdoGJ50VGA
8. TNA Turn Their Biggest Babyface Heel (For No Reason) - Genesis 2010
The first main event on this list that actually provided excellent in-ring action - no great surprise considering the participants. AJ Styles and Kurt Angle squared off in a face-vs-face encounter for AJ's TNA Championship, putting on a fantastic back-and-forth contest. Unfortunately, all their good work was undone by a terrible booking decision. With the help of Ric Flair (who took out the referee as AJ tapped to the ankle lock), Styles turned heel to win the match, smashing Kurt with the title belt en route to victory. In hindsight, turning one of the company's longest-serving, most loyal babyfaces heel was a terrible idea - not least because he and Flair shared relatively little chemistry, and the storyline revolved around the notion of The Nature Boy making Styles his protege. Furthermore, AJ had only held the TNA Championship for a few months by this point, an incredibly long-awaited reign that would have best been executed with Styles playing the same fan favourite he always had. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O5i2Lc93vc4
7. TNA Turns Everybody Heel (For No Reason) - Bound For Glory 2010
TNA have always had a penchant for bloated heel stables in the vein of WCW's infamous New World Order. The formation of Immortal was a prime example of the company turning a needless number of main event figures heel to form an overgrown, roster-overshadowing group - and ruined Bound For Glory 2010 in the process. With Kurt Angle, Jeff Hardy and Mr Anderson facing off in a triple threat for the title, Bischoff hit the ring to interfere. Hogan hobbled down to the ring on crutches to stop him and the pair appeared to have an argument, only for Hardy to take the crutches and smash them over his opponents' backs. He subsequently won the match (and the belt), turning all three men heel and forming 'Immortal'. Abyss and Jeff Jarrett quickly joined the ring as allies, and the numbers only continued to swell. The main event was completely overshadowed by a forced, unoriginal storyline fans had seen many times before - and they reacted with predictable negativity. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FRLl-vkDvf0
6. That Old Sinking Feeling... - Against All Odds 2005
Another of TNA's first ever monthly Pay Per Views, Against All Odds boasted a main event with a particularly silly stipulation. Champion Jeff Jarrett squared off against Kevin Nash under the condition that his title would change hands in the event of a guitar-based disqualification. The cunning Jarrett, in a move the TNA booking team probably thought was hilarious, instead brought a cello out from under the ring. Unfortunately it broke as he prepared to hit Nash, forcing him to improvise. He hit Nash with the suspiciously soft-looking cello case, before attempting to strike him again with the body of the instrument. It was clumsy and horrible - but the worst was yet to come. A pair of run-ins suddenly confirmed to TNA fans that their favourite young stars wouldn't be getting a look-in for quite some time, at the top of the card at least. Billy Gunn ran in to help Jarrett, while X-Pac (or Syxx-Pac) came to the aid of Nash. Jarrett eventually retained after a belt shot. Hilariously, TNA hadn't yet thought of an original name for Gunn (as his WWE moniker was owned by Vince), leaving the announce team unable to refer to him by name. He wore a t-shirt emblazoned with the phrase "No Introduction Needed (you already know my name)". https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V_id2SIDvlU
5. The Orlando Screwjob - Slammiversary 2006
Of all the ill-advised Montreal Screwjob re-hashes in wrestling history, the worst received was perhaps the infamous Orlando Screwjob of Slammiversary 2006. Again it was Jeff Jarrett who benefitted from the shenanigans, ascending a ladder to win a King of the Mountain match and claim the NWA Championship once again. He did so with the help of Earl Hebner (the referee involved in the original Montreal incident), who blatantly pushed over a ladder as babyfaces Sting and Christian climbed to victory. Fans immediately clocked on, showering the ring with plastic bottles and general trash as Jarrett triumphed once again. Bear in mind that this happened in the main event of TNA's biggest show of the year, their equivalent of WrestleMania. The fans' fury is more than a little understandable, and to make matters worse, the result was immediately voided. Authority figure Jim Cornette came out to strip Jarrett of the belt, ending the biggest PPV of the year with a vacated championship. In the ensuing weeks, it was revealed that Hebner was actually part of no conspiracy - rendering the entire storyline nonsensical and pointless. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MENjk-wkIgg
4. Bobby Roode Receives A Massive Push...And Loses - Bound For Glory 2011
In 2011, Bobby Roode was benefitting from the push of a lifetime. A loyal servant of TNA from the company's beginning, Roode was a good in-ring worker with great charisma, capable of getting over as either a face or heel. His ascendance during the Bound For Glory series to challenge champion Kurt Angle at the climactic PPV was well booked, leaving TNA with the easy decision of making Roode the victor. Instead, Hulk Hogan well and truly put his foot down. Rood and Angle reportedly only found out on the day of the show that the planned finish (a sensible Bobby victory) was not happening, and that Kurt was actually going to retain. He did so in nefarious fashion, rolling Roode up and grabbing a nearby rope for leverage, leaving Roode - and an entire arena full of fans - bitterly disappointed. It turned out that Hogan didn't think Bobby was ready, believing the future instead lay in the hands of "young stars" like Jeff Hardy (a man who had already held the WWE's World Heavyweight Championship multiple times in his career). To make matters worse, Angle almost immediately dropped the belt anyway - losing to Roode's partner James Storm on a throwaway episode of Impact. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tELf9gQw7hg
3. Abyss, Flair And Styles Act Out A Farce - Destination X 2010
No-contest PPV main events will always be looked on unfavourably, but few were as lazily-booked, or as farcical as the conclusion of Destination X 2010. AJ Styles (backed up by manager Ric Flair and lackey Desmond Wolfe) faced babyface challenger Abyss for the TNA World Championship. Now a full heel, AJ tried every trick in the book to keep ahold of his title, while the brave Abyss soldiered on. Eventually Abyss chokeslammed Styles through the ring, prompting referee Earl Hebner to call for the bell - allowing AJ to keep his belt by virtue of a no-contest. Hogan, acting as Abyss' mentor, came down to raise his charge's arm, despite the challenger not actually winning the belt. Flair and Wolfe engineered a brawl, and ended up comically failing into the hole as well they tried to escape Abyss' wrath. The TNA fanbase immediately saw through such a cop-out of an ending, and gave it the ridiculing it deserved (as the video below demonstrates). https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r5GPmeVVAAg
2. Randy Savage Pins The Champ After A Single Punch - Turning Point 2004
TNA's second ever monthly Pay Per View suffered from an even worse ending than the first, one which saw the criminally past-it 'Macho Man' Randy Savage appear to commit a heinous crime of booking. Champions should, as a rule, be made to look strong - or at least cunning enough to keep ahold of their belt by nefarious means. Jeff Jarrett was made to look neither in Turning Point's main event, a six-man tag match between 'The Kings of Wrestling' (Jarrett, Nash and Hall) and the makeshift team of Jeff Hardy, AJ Styles and Savage. The Macho Man reportedly had a breakdown of sorts backstage, unwilling to go out and wrestle the entire match. Instead he ran out for the closing sequence only, reversing Jarrett's sunset flip and nailing him with a right hand. The pinfall followed. That's right, a man who enjoyed his peak some 15 years prior had just pinned the NWA Champion, making both he and the belt look incredibly weak in the process. It turned out to be Savage's last match ever, as he retired shortly after due to health concerns. Had he stayed, however, the rumoured plan was to have him actually win the belt from Jarrett at the next PPV. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eL-3mH7OHWk
1. Jeff Hardy Wrestles On Drugs - Victory Road 2011
Jeff Hardy's now-infamous showing at Victory Road 2011 is made all the more unacceptable by the fact that he still had previous drug-related charges hanging over his head at the time. His main event against TNA World Champion Sting was one of the most shambolic incidents ever witnessed inside a wrestling ring, especially for a company of TNA's stature. Hardy emerged from the back in a clear state of intoxication, stumbling around and glaring wide-eyed at the camera. Sensing that the match needed to be ended as quickly as possible, Eric Bischoff came out under the pretence of adding a last minute no-DQ stipulation (while actually relaying messages to Sting). After a few seconds of bizarre posturing, Hardy was quickly dropped by Sting's Scorpion Death Drop finisher, and held down for a clearly involuntary three count. The crowd screamed their disapproval, chanting "bulls***", to which Sting unprofessionally (but understandably) replied "I agree". It remains one of the worst incidents in the history of the business, and the most shambolic ending of any Pay Per View in TNA's history.