10 Worst Winless Records In WrestleMania History

Not everyone can amass a WrestleMania legacy like that of The Undertaker.

By Justin Henry /

It's an accepted part of WWE lore that designated punching bag/Andre stand-in Big Show has had the worst WrestleMania record. In the weekly storyline build for Cody Rhodes' Intercontinental title bout with Show at WrestleMania XXVIII, Rhodes pointed out Show's foibles on the 'grandest stage', including losses in a sumo match with Akebono, and getting knocked out by Floyd Mayweather, Jr. In truth, Show's WrestleMania record is far from favorable, but it still sits at 4-9, battle royal losses and pre-show appearances excluded. There was actually a time where Show won three straight WrestleMania matches between 2010-12. It's a losing record, but at least Show has four wins, period. There are a number of wrestlers over the years that have not gotten any wins at WrestleMania, let alone four. These days, getting to be a part of the pay-per-view card in something other than a battle royal either means the office likes you, or you're a B-list celebrity. So for Show to have racked up four wins, given he was once 1-8 at the event, is a minor miracle. As it turns out, there are ten performers (eleven, actually, one is a tag team) that boast a winless record at WrestleMania, with at least three losses. While few of these performers have the capacity to be the butt of a joke like Show, it's worth noting their WrestleMania futility. It should be noted that for the purposes of this list, failure to win a battle royal does *NOT* count as a loss, though the winning of a battle royal would count as a victory (thus, those performers wouldn't be included here). Also, pre-show matches are disqualified. This is only about the actual pay-per-view telecast.

Advertisement

10. Superfly Jimmy Snuka (0-3)

-WrestleMania VI - lost to Ravishing Rick Rude -WrestleMania VII - lost to The Undertaker -WrestleMania XXV - submitted to Chris Jericho in a handicap elimination match Even without considering his age, let's just say Snuka's chances of garnering one lone WrestleMania win have forever disintegrated. While Snuka did attend the original WrestleMania as a cornerman of Hulk Hogan and Mr. T, he soon underwent a four-year exile that coincided with his 1983 legal problems, returning at WrestleMania V in a surprise appearance. By then, Snuka was 45 years old, and his wattage had long dimmed. Primarily, Snuka was put to use as a springboard, mining whatever name value he had left to get over the next generation of wrestlers. His loss to Undertaker remains historic as the beginning of Undertaker's unmatchable win streak.

9. Koko B. Ware (0-3)

-WrestleMania III: lost to "The Natural" Butch Reed -WrestleMania IV: pinned in a six-man tag by Bobby "The Brain" Heenan -WrestleMania VI: lost to Rick Martel Despite Koko's popularity throughout the 1980s, his diminutive size worked against him in a WWF that was largely a land of looming giants. Ware's ability to connect with fans through infectious energy and charisma made it all the more disappointing when he actually did lose a match, which was often. If dark matches were permitted on the list, Ware wouldn't be ranked here. "The Birdman" went over on perennial fall guy The Brooklyn Brawler before the cameras rolled at WrestleMania VII. But ordinarily, Ware's job was similar to Snuka's: getting the next guys over, as was the case with the losses to Reed and Martel.

8. R-Truth (0-3)

-WrestleMania XXVI - with John Morrison, lost to Big Show and The Miz -WrestleMania XXVIII - with five other wrestlers, lost a twelve-man tag where John Laurinaitis and Theodore Long's jobs were on the line -WrestleMania XXXI - failed to win a seven-man ladder match for the Intercontinental title Truth makes the list without ever actually being pinned. Morrison took the fall in the first example, and Zack Ryder in the second. The third ended the way ladder matches are supposed to end, with one participant procuring the object suspended above the ring. It stands to reason that Truth is due some kind of feel-good WrestleMania win for his loyal service, namely his ability to get his role as an easily-confused dolt over. Perhaps it could be a tag team victory with a partner that will appear a bit later in the list.

7. Finlay (0-4)

-WrestleMania XXII - failed to win Money in the Bank -WrestleMania XXIII - failed to win Money in the Bank -WrestleMania XXIV - lost to JBL -WrestleMania XXV - failed to win Money in the Bank Quite similar to Shelton Benjamin's resume, although Benjamin did manage a tag team win at WrestleMania XIX. This was the stage of WrestleManias where the aimless midcard would be cobbled together in a ladder match to give them all something to do (now they have a battle royal for that). Finlay usually fell into that gray area of, "he's not in any major storylines, but we don't want to demote a man of his stock to the lowly pre-show." Finlay's lone proper match came against JBL, a decently-brutal Belfast Brawl in which the main highlight was JBL flinging a trash can down onto poor Hornswoggle, to audible cheers.

6. Crush (0-4)

-WrestleMania VII - with Smash, lost to Genichiro Tenryu and Koji Kitao -WrestleMania IX - lost to Doink the Clown -WrestleMania X - lost to Macho Man Randy Savage -WrestleMania XIII - pinned in a six-man tag by Road Warrior Animal Crush makes history by not only being winless at WrestleMania, but by losing with what were essentially four different gimmicks, all under the 'Crush' name. WrestleMania VII featured the real-life Brian Adams as the junior member of the legendary Demolition team. In the loss to Doink, he was surfing-strongman Crush. A heel turn later in 1993 meant that by the time he faced Savage, he was treacherous Japanese sympathizer Crush. By 1997, he was paroled convict Crush, complete with forehead tattoo. Damien Sandow never had an identity crisis like this.

5. MVP (0-4)

-WrestleMania XXIII - lost to Chris Benoit -WrestleMania XXIV - failed to win Money in the Bank -WrestleMania XXV - failed to win Money in the Bank -WrestleMania XXVI - failed to win Money in the Bank As stated before, such was life in the latter half of the 2000s, where good talent was plucked from their aimless trajectories, and dropped down into the chaotic ladder match. Such matches began to bleed into one another after a while, especially as the same talents began appearing in them annually. In the case of MVP, a gifted talker that could carry his end of a story, his only WrestleMania match with any concrete background came against Benoit for the United States title. MVP would eventually win the belt two months after WrestleMania, but not before putting Benoit over in a solid undercard match here.

4. Goldust (0-4)

-WrestleMania XII - technically lost to Rowdy Roddy Piper -WrestleMania XIII - lost to Hunter Hearst Helmsley -WrestleMania XIV - with Luna Vachon, lost to Marc Mero and Sable -WrestleMania XV - failed to win a fatal four-way for the Intercontinental title Goldust has certainly appeared at WrestleMania since 1999. His Hardcore title match with Maven at WrestleMania X8 never technically concluded, due to Spike Dudley interfering and pinning Maven himself. He also appeared in both Andre the Giant battle royals, the PPV edition in 2014 and the pre-show version in 2015. As was noted with R-Truth, maybe you hope that WWE is setting them up for some sort of tag team win at WrestleMania in order to pay off the work they've put into the company, particularly Goldust. No doubt Dustin Runnels raised the bar in the 'I'd do anything to stand out' approach toward wrestling two decades ago.

3. The Dudley Boyz (0-4)

-WrestleMania 2000 - failed to win the triple ladder match -WrestleMania X7 - failed to win the Tables, Ladders, and Chairs match -WrestleMania X8 - failed to win a fatal four-way for the World Tag Team championship -WrestleMania XX - failed to win a fatal four-way for the World Tag Team championship WrestleMania is Groundhog Day when you're Bubba Ray and D-Von Dudley, whose longevity as a duo has meant that they're credible enough to reinforce the potency of whoever the tag team champions are at the moment. You know, if the Dudleyz were to team up with Goldust and Truth to beat, say, The Social Outcasts on the main WrestleMania card this year, that wipes out thirty percent of this list in one swoop. Then again, Wade Barrett and Bray Wyatt are each one loss away from qualifying anyhow, so replacements are on the way.

2. Mr. McMahon (0-4)

-WrestleMania X7 - lost to Shane McMahon -WrestleMania XIX - lost to Hulk Hogan -WrestleMania XXII - lost to Shawn Michaels -WrestleMania XXVI - lost to Bret Hart With possible exception of the plodding exhibition with Hart, it's hard not to be charmed by a Vince match, given his willingness to kill himself for the audience's enjoyment. The match with Michaels itself is probably the most entertaining one-sided match of all time, at least until Brock Lesnar's wars with John Cena in recent years. The overbooked zaniness was hardly better than in the match with son Shane. There, Vince's wife Linda received a deafening pop from 67,000 fans that Roman Reigns wishes he could earn, simply by rising up from a wheelchair and kicking Vince in the crotch. Just about anything where Vince plays an unapologetic villain from 1998-2006 is sheer gold. With WrestleMania the ideal place for blow-offs, McMahon knew how to lose in style.

1. Jeff Hardy (0-5)

-WrestleMania 2000 - failed to win the triple ladder match -WrestleMania X7 - failed to win the Tables, Ladders, and Chairs match -WrestleMania X8 - failed to win a fatal four-way for the World Tag Team championship -WrestleMania XXIII - failed to win Money in the Bank -WrestleMania XXV - lost to Matt Hardy A mish-mash of the stunt-show/four-way tag clusters that occupied many a wrestler, Hardy was more than natural for ladder-based insanity - he'd helped popularize it. In fact, if not for a wellness suspension in March 2008, it's believed that Hardy would have won Money in the Bank at WrestleMania XXIV, and continued the main event push he was receiving at the time. It's actually unbelievable that Hardy technically owns the worst record in WrestleMania history, and by recently re-upping his deal with TNA, it doesn't look like that will change any time soon.