10 Worst WWE Gimmicks Of The Ruthless Aggression Era

Back when you could see WWE creative brainstorm live on TV...

By Chris Humphries /

As the glorious days of the Attitude Era started to wane and the company rebranded, WWE found themselves in a unique position. Not only did they need to find a new direction with which to present themselves as a whole, but they also needed to come up with a way to shine the spotlight on more superstars than ever after acquiring talents from both ECW and WCW.

Advertisement

What ensued shortly after the Invasion and nWo angles was the RAW and SmackDown brand extension, which ideally, was the answer to an overcrowded locker room. Although both rosters housed a number of young talents who would go on to have legendary careers and many great matches followed as a result, the new character inventions of the Ruthless Aggression Era left much to be desired.

Some new wrestlers were introduced under questionable gimmicks that left fans scratching their heads, most notably Deacon Batista. His leader, Reverend D’Von, proved established acts were not excluded from having to play out half-cocked concepts.

Even John Cena’s Marky Mark shtick was a bit ludicrous, but it was far from the worst offender…

10. Mr America

Hulk Hogan may have returned to WWE well beyond his prime, but as illustrated during his WrestleMania X8 match with The Rock, as well as the crowd reactions during his following run as a face, fans still appreciated the veteran for all of his accomplishments in the professional wrestling business.

Advertisement

His name alone helped put butts in seats. But what was WWE to do with another globally recognized face?

Put a mask on it.

Following a short hiatus, Hogan became involved in storyline with Mr. McMahon that culminated in a fight “20 years in the making” at WrestleMania XIX. After the big bout of egos, the storyline took a twist and McMahon punished ‘The Hulkster’ by forcing him to sit out the remainder of his contract.

As a work-around, Mr America was born. Basically, it was Hulk Hogan under a blue mask. That was the entire idea. Somehow it was supposed to be entertaining to see him outwit the chairman every week in cartoonish skits. Once he was exposed, ‘The Hulkster’ was fired. Without any sort of redemption for the hero, the entire gimmick came off as pointless.

In real life, Hogan already quit WWE due to creative and financial frustrations by the time he was terminated on TV.

9. The ECW Zombie

Halfway into the Ruthless Aggression Era, WWE saw there was more to squeeze out of the ECW brand name after successes such as One Night Stand.

Advertisement

Unfortunately, the same triumphs led to WWE introducing ECW as its own show under their umbrella. At first, ratings were strong, but it wasn’t long before diehard ECW fans started to sneer at the invasive rebranding of their once-favorite hardcore wrestling product. What didn’t help retain fans was the lack of consideration WWE gave the acts it introduced to the show, which was evident as early as the debut episode on the Sci Fi network.

The ECW Zombie (R.I.P.) was a character that existed for no other reason than to please the Sci Fi network big wigs. In 2006, The Zombie appeared only once, had no motive, and lost to The Sandman. Although fans popped when he disposed of The Zombie, there were many better ways to make use of the hardcore veteran’s time, such as by placing him in a real match with an established talent.

On commentary, Tazz summarized everyone’s thoughts by stating, “I spent a lot of time in ECW, but what the hell is this?”

8. The Spirit Squad

When Ohio Valley Wrestling sent Ken Doane, Nick Mitchell, Nick Nemeth, Johnny Jeter, and Mike Mondo up to WWE, the sky was the limit. And Vince McMahon had just the groundbreaking idea to help get them over:

Advertisement

Make them cheerleaders.

Then, within the course of a year, The Spirit Squad went from defeating main event superstars to jobbing out to Sgt Slaughter. Going up against the likes of Shawn Michaels and Triple H only further hindered their chances of success, as the veterans were established and respected, while the newcomers were chained to a hokey gimmick no WWE fan at the time ever desired to see. If anyone wondered why their stint didn't last longer, they needed to look no further than the concept of the group itself.

They eventually lost to everyone they defeated on their way out. Worst of all, WWE elected to keep Kenny over Nicky, who would eventually become Dolph Ziggler.

7. The Dicks

When Ohio Valley Wrestling standouts Tank Toland and Chad Wicks arrived on the main roster in 2005, all they needed was a good look and decent gimmick to start making waves in WWE. But as demonstrated with many younger talents during the era, especially within the tag team division, that certainly wasn’t going to be the case.

Advertisement

How was "Ruthless Aggression" defined? To someone on the creative team, it somehow translated to "male strippers."

Instead of presenting the two as a legitimate threat to the tag team division, they arrived as Chippendale-type characters named The Dicks. The team did little to nothing outside of strut and spray body lotion and oil all over their opponents.

Creative gave them little to no thought, and so did the WWE Universe, as The Dicks were added to the Future Endeavored list five months after their debut.

6. B²

Outside of a dreadful ‘This Is Your Life’ segment, when highlights of John Cena’s career played, they seldom referenced his time back the Ruthless Aggression Era with Bull Buchanan.

Advertisement

Buchanan had a rough time trying to get over in WWE. His run as Recon of The Truth Commission was short-lived, as was his time in Armageddon. Serving as some kind of SWAT protégé to Big Boss Man didn’t do much to develop a character, and he was often the forgotten member of Right to Censor.

Being repackaged as B², an enforcer for Cena during his ‘Master of Thuganomics’ phase, certainly didn’t further his career, either. With a lack of in-ring skills as well as charisma, Buchanan was reduced to another sidekick role, one whose only contribution was yelling “Boo-Yah” at the end of Big John’s rhymes.

And although he never received one more shot at redemption, WWE felt no less of an empty place.

5. Kerwin White

One night on RAW, Chavo Guerrero came out with his black hair dyed blonde and wearing a pressed shirt with khakis instead of his usual tights. On this night, the WWE Universe cried a bit when he announced he was now Kerwin White.

Advertisement

As a proud member of a legendary wrestling family, there was no reason to strip away all signs of his heritage, but nonetheless, WWE creative felt turning Chavo into a “white guy” was a terrific way to get him over as a heel.

The concept was that he was going to expose the company in some way, presumably for racist actions, by denouncing his roots and appearing white. Or something like that, despite the fact he then engaged in all of the things he once stood against. In the end, the gimmick simply came off as offensive, especially when considering his catchphrase, "If it's not White, it's not right."

4. Eugene

Nobody could imagine the WWE of today picking at a mental disorder, but from 2004 to 2007, that’s precisely what they did.

Advertisement

Nicholas Dinsmore was brought onto the RAW as a character named Eugene, who was the nephew of Eric Bischoff. The story was that Bischoff was ashamed of his disabled son, and he had William Regal “babysit” him during the shows. Of course, more often than not, Eugene kibitzed in the dealings of other superstars and found himself in serious trouble.

WWE presented Eugene in a humorous light, but sadly, the entire bit relied on the fact he had an unspecified learning disorder, and when angered, he went into a lunatic rage that sometimes saw him victorious against the most unexpected adversaries.

Not only was the concept of Eugene fairly one-dimensional, it also painted a poor light on those with disabilities, as he was constantly portrayed to be a burden on other superstars, his shortcomings were used as the punchlines to many ribs, and he was seen as someone imitating his favorite wrestling legends rather than being a wrestler himself.

3. Big Dick Johnson

WWE was never known for being too clever with the names of their superstars, but even some of their worst offences were mere plays on words. However, no one got the memo when concocting the idea for a male stripper named Big Dick Johnson.

Advertisement

Some might have blamed WWE creative at the time for a lack of ingenuity and for giving the WWE Universe nightmares from which they feared they’d never awaken. In this instance, though, the writers weren’t completely to blame, at least not creative member Chris DeJoseph, who played the role - McMahon himself added that 'BIG!' descriptor. Of course he did.

He claimed the team brainstormed over who would run into Mr. McMahon during an on-air paternity suit, which ultimately boiled down to an overweight stripper. The character then stuck around and seemingly served no other purpose than to make McMahon chuckle over an obvious euphemism and the fact that a chubby man danced around in a thong.

2. The Mexicools

During the Ruthless Aggression Era, WWE had a knack for swooping up WCW talent to give them a half-hearted shot on their programming. With this in mind, WWE gained access to lucha legends Psicosis, Super Crazy and Juventud Guerrera. So what did they do?

Advertisement

They introduced the three as a John Deere-riding stable named The Mexicools.

On the surface, the in-ring skills of the cruiserweights could have more than compensated for their lackadaisical gimmick, but for some reason, they never showcased any of the dazzling feats that brought them acclaim.

Instead, they were reduced to a group of landscapers with distasteful gags only a racist grandfather would have enjoyed, some as juvenile as labelling their lawnmower “Juan Deere” or bringing a new rake over to the Spanish announce table during each show.

The group may have claimed they were proud of their heritage, but it came across as though they only knew the unfortunate stereotypes.

1. Muhammad Hassan

All things considered, Muhammad Hassan had the in-ring prowess and verbal skills to make it as a top WWE superstar. Sadly, it was the spoiling of his gimmick as well as poor timing that saw him depart before his World Heavyweight Championship reign.

Advertisement

Hassan sought to eradicate all labeling of Arab-Americans as “terrorists,” a stereotype which he blamed on post-9/11 paranoia. The WWE Universe may have jeered him, but his pursuit was not without some nobility.

On its own, the edgy storyline might have continued to propel Hassan, but WWE pushed the envelope too far early on. For instance, when he finished a promo, he would clasp his hands and pray out to Allah. Muslim-Americans lashed back at WWE, and soon he appeared to pray after his promos, but never did so vocally.

A few adjustments and perhaps Hassan’s character may have got over. But instead, all regard for cultural sensitivity was abandoned in favor of an infamous segment on SmackDown. Hassan prayed after Daivari lost to The Undertaker, and five men emerged to assault and choke out ‘The Phenom.’

The skit was in poor taste and the timing couldn’t have been worse, as the '07 London Bombings took place three days later. Although the footage was pulled from European circuits, it aired unedited in North America and drew the ire of many major media outlets and sponsors, something which rattled UPN and led to the premature departure of the Hassan character.

Advertisement