10 Worst WWE United States Champions Ever
"Don't boo me, you should be booing yourselves"...
Hot damn, that is one sweet, sweet belt.
Sorry, but it is. If we're briefly talking title design, then that current WWE United States variation is one of this writer's absolute favourites. When the company relaunched their own version of the NWA/WCW classic in 2003, it was a beautiful day. It's so pleasing on the eye that there's been no need to change it since. The same can't be said of the dudes holding it.
Things all started so well when Eddie Guerrero won a blistering tournament final against Chris Benoit at Vengeance 2003 to become the first champion since WCW's US Title was abolished in 2001. The rejigged SmackDown belt was a credit to the brand, had a fine kickoff champ and the future looked bright. So much for that then, huh? There have been some utterly atrocious US Champions since.
The worst of the bunch are housed here, and the timescale examined ranges from 2005-2019. In that 14-year span, WWE's treatment of such a fine-looking championship has ebbed and flowed between excellence and abhorrent. The age-old phrase, 'the belt doesn't make the man' comes to mind...
10. Orlando Jordan (2005)
Think of this as a throwback to a time when WWE really didn't have a star-making blueprint.
To that point, Orlando Jordan supplanted John Cena as United States Champ in early-March 2005. That's the same Cena who had held the belt for the majority of '04 with distinction and wasn't yet a maligned force in the eyes of fans. No, he was a popular babyface who (in some respects) looked like the next coming of Steve Austin.
Then, along came Orlando, a guy who never seemed to fully grasp what it meant to be a wrestler. In fact, he played wrestler rather than actually being one, and it came across to the fans. Thus, his 170+ day reign as US Champ came and went without much excitement. By the time Chris Benoit beat him at SummerSlam, there was a sigh of relief.
Jordan is only guilty of doing his best, to be fair. Unfortunately for him and WWE, his best wasn't quite up to scratch, and he was a poor successor to the likes of Cena and Booker.
9. Zack Ryder (2011)
Only a fool would claim that 'Long Island Iced-Z' Zack Ryder wasn't over in 2011. Back then, he who likes to sing to the radio was name dropped by everyone from John Cena to The Rock. Get this: they did it so they'd look cool. That's how much fans were digging Ryder at the time.
WWE refused to play ball at first, and they blatantly didn't view Zack as anything more than a background figure.
At TLC 2011, they relented somewhat and put Ryder over Dolph Ziggler for the US gold. It was a quite stunning beginning to the pay-per-view, had fans pumping their fists with a hearty, "Woo! Woo! Woo!" over and over again and seemed to be the start of something special for Zack.
It wasn't though. 29 days later on the 16 January 2012 episode of Raw, Ryder was staring at the arena lights for Jack Swagger. Rather conveniently, he's the next entry.
8. Jack Swagger (2012)
2011-2012 was hardly the best period for the United States belt. The poor thing was passed around more than any other, and that made it hard for fans to give a flying toss about who was champ this week. Jack Swagger's reign was emblematic of those problems with hot-shotting, and it was totally forgettable.
After beating Zack Ryder, Swagger held the belt for 49 days. That was it.
If WWE had stuffed a few meaningful defences for Jack or even a feud to speak of in there, that might've been OK. They didn't, and so his first stint as United States Champion passed Swagger by. Not only did he beat a paper champ to win it, but Swagger actually became one himself.
Worse, he'd drop the title to another time waster WWE's writers couldn't be bothered to write anything worthwhile for. That's arguably more insulting to fans than dismissing Ryder's popularity or giving Swagger such a pointless reign.
7. Santino Marella (2012)
Why is it arguably more insulting? Well, Santino Marella was actual gold as Intercontinental Champion back in 2008. His bold claims that he'd top The Honky Tonk Man's 454-day whopper were entertaining as all hell, and they gave Santino and his championship some purpose.
That purpose was solely missing from his US Title stretch.
167 days. That's how long Marella held the belt for in 2012. One hundred and sixty seven days. In close to five and a half months, he produced exactly nothing of note. In fact, Marella didn't even defend the United States prize on pay-per-view at all before losing it to Cesaro on the SummerSlam 2012 pre-show.
His only matches were another Kickoff win over The Miz before Extreme Rules, a non-title 'Tuxedo Match' against Ricardo Rodriguez at No Way Out and a spot in one of the MITB matches at the show of the same name. Marella as US Champion was crap.
6. Baron Corbin (2017)
Like him or loathe him (it's supposed to be the latter), Baron Corbin does get some heat from fans. Sure, he's hardly Dwayne Johnson on the mic, but we'd say he's done alright for himself considering what 2017 was like. That year, Corbin won Money In The Bank in June, surrendered his briefcase by August then lost to John Cena at SummerSlam.
It's fine though, 'cause a throwaway US Title reign towards the end of the year would solve everything, right?
Or maybe not. Baron wasn't a popular choice to dethrone the ever-green AJ Styles in a Triple Threat match that also involved Tye Dillinger at Hell In A Cell. People didn't want to see him get the title for two reasons. Firstly, he'd been booked to sh*t the bed on a supposedly guaranteed World Title reign. Secondly, he was replacing AJ.
70 days of mediocrity later, Corbin dropped the strap to Dolph Ziggler in another Triple Threat at Clash Of Champions and that was that; the 9-day Ziggler title reign almost made it on here, and it would've had it not been part of a larger narrative.
5. Matt Hardy (2008)
Sorry, hardcore fans, but the once-proud ECW name was mud by 2008. WWE had relegated Paul Heyman's vision to a watered-down version of Sunday Night Heat that blended a bizarre mix of stalwarts like Mark Henry and Matt Hardy with up-and-comers like Sheamus, Evan Bourne and more.
Somehow, someone thought it'd be a smashing idea to put the United States Title in the middle of all this.
Matt won the belt from former partner MVP at Backlash in April, and things initially looked good. Hardy's win got a nice response from fans in Baltimore, and it was a cool way to give him some revenge for Porter's treachery. Then, they moved Hardy to 'C' show ECW and sent the US Title along for the ride with him.
WWE corrected their mistake by putting SmackDown star Shelton Benjamin over Hardy at the Great American Bash. Think about all that for a second: a title with NWA/WCW lineage was promoted as an ECW championship on a WWE pay-per-view once promoted by the NWA and WCW.
4. Kalisto (2016)
Kalisto has never recovered from his association with the US Title.
Since holding the belt across two stints during the first half of 2016, the high-flying masked man (who was once touted as the 'new' Rey Mysterio) has been shipped off to the Cruiserweight division, suffered an aborted mini-push as a singles on Raw and formed the overlooked Lucha House Party.
Hell, even Rey Mysterio himself has returned to WWE and become the 'new' Rey Mysterio. That, whether anyone likes it or not, has cancelled any and all plans to shoot Kalisto up a notch, and his flirtation with solid mid card success feels like a lifetime ago. It's tough to wrap one's head around the fact he held the US Title for a combined 120 days.
Much like others on this list, he wasn't allowed to do much with that period. After regaining the belt from Alberto Del Rio at the 2016 Royal Rumble, Kalisto worked a run of pre-show matches then lost it to Rusev at Extreme Rules.
3. Jinder Mahal (2018)
For an example of how far Jinder Mahal's stock has fallen, one need only look at the 30 seconds he lasted in this year's Rumble. No offence intended to Johnny Gargano, but Mahal is a former WWE Champion, and he was made to look like a chump by the NXT man before being eliminated.
It'll take more than a few cries of "Shanti" to heal Jinder's wounded pride.
After working his balls off to get into supreme physical shape, WWE rewarded Mahal with some aforementioned World Title glory. Once that faded, he was thrust into the United States Title picture and bagged the belt at WrestleMania 34. You'll know from reading prior entries how well that worked out for him.
Jinder's reign lasted eight days before he made the jump to Raw as part of the 'Superstar Shakeup' and immediately lost to Jeff Hardy. That excuse to put the title back on SmackDown did nothing to make Mahal look like a force to be reckoned with on Monday nights.
2. R-Truth (2019)
WWE might as well tell Rusev right now that they point blank refuse to push him as either a menacing heel or a beloved babyface. It doesn't seem to matter how much the Bulgarian connects with fans, because he's consistently undermined.
See the latest SmackDown for proof.
Shinsuke Nakamura can sneak into this entry too. His brilliant heel turn on AJ Styles at 'Mania 34 has been spoiled by the awful 'Nak-America' storyline and the fact he's trading titles like Pokemon cards with Rusev and now R-Truth. Yes, R-Truth, as in the same joke comedy character who was ousted from the Rumble so Nia Jax could play Chyna.
Truth is your new United States Champion, for...some reason. Don't get us wrong, he does have some entertainment value, but the delusional moron gimmick he plays shouldn't result in title wins, certainly not in 2019.
1. Bret Hart (2010)
R-Truth's US Title reign is already better than Bret Hart's.
Oh how the pitchforks will be out for that one, but it's the truth (pun intended). There's no way in a million years that the 'Hitman' should've been given a singles belt in 2010. The legend couldn't bump, was coming off a disastrously one-sided beatdown of Vince McMahon at WrestleMania XXVI and had no business wrestling.
His win over The Miz on the 17 May episode of Raw was one of the most embarrassing in the program's long history. It really was. Hart used to be such a world class talent, and he could always work rings around anyone he was sharing the spotlight with. Watching him shuffle around a decade past his prime was excruciating for any Bret fan.
Things worsened when he vacated the title the next week and became Raw's General Manager. His seven-day reign upended Miz's momentum, p*ssed all over a title he would have held with pride in his youth and generally stank the place out.
Who else would you consider to be one of the worst WWE US Champs of all time? Let us know down in the comments!