10 Worst WWE Women’s Champions Ever
Female revolution? What female revolution?
Today, WWE are proud to present top female wrestlers like Charlotte Flair, Asuka, Alexa Bliss, Sasha Banks, Becky Lynch and Bayley. Back during the 1990s, throughout the Attitude era and even into the PG era, fans would have bitten your hand off for just one of those women. This 'Women's Revolution' WWE tout nowadays? It didn't exist until a few years ago, and the promotion's formerly lax outlook on females in general meant we witnessed some of the worst choices as champ in history.
Strong female titleholders we did see, such as Trish Stratus, Lita and Mickie James, were anomalies in a system that rewarded pin-up models who couldn't wrestle a lick. Beyond that, WWE booked drivel like male managers (in drag) making a mockery of equality in wrestling.
Next time you worry about the state of women's wrestling in WWE, just revisit the past to remind yourself how far things have come...
10. Jazz
During her three years with the company between 2001-2004, Jazz became a two-time Women's Champion. She's not on this list because she was a terrible worker though. No, Jazz is here because both her title reigns were pretty forgettable.
It's a shame Jazz isn't around today. Her work would be a much better fit for WWE's current female model than it ever was for the 'Divas' era. Back then, women were expected to wear skimpier outfits, appear in lingerie photoshoots and generally talk about how much fun they were having.
That didn't suit this ex-ECW bad-ass.
Jazz came along at the wrong time, and both her stints as Women's Champ felt ill-fitting in 2002 and 2003. She was a tough one to put on this list, and it was hard to put her below others when she could actually wrestle, but her face didn't fit in WWE.
9. Eve Torres
Eve Torres held the old Divas Title for a combined 260 days across 3 separate reigns between 2010-2012. As hard as she worked to improve in-ring, Torres was never up to scratch and had mediocre matches aplenty against everyone from Alicia Fox to Natalya.
When not even Nattie can make you look good, you know there's a problem.
Perhaps Eve wasn't the one to blame. Before joining WWE as part of the Divas Search in 2007, Torres worked as a model and dancer. Beyond good looks and a willingness to improve, Eve didn't have much about her, and always looked like she was playing wrestler rather than being one.
Torres isn't the only female champ in WWE history to have that problem, however: far from it. At least Eve, colourless matches and all, could run the ropes...
8. Kelly Kelly
Meanwhile, Kelly Kelly may as well have ignored the traditional Irish Whip entirely. Every time this swimsuit model tried to run the ropes, they barely moved. It didn't help that all of her matches came across as choreographed dance routines, rather than wrestling matches.
We get that wrestling is choreographed, but surely the whole point is hiding that in the heat of the moment. Kelly was incapable of stringing together matches that looked genuine, and the only reason she won WWE's old 'butterfly belt' was down to her sex appeal.
That single Divas Title run lasted 104 days before Beth Phoenix beat her at Hell In A Cell 2011. In her time as champ, Kelly beat Brie Bella in less than five minutes at Money In The Bank and Phoenix in just over six mins at both SummerSlam and Night Of Champions.
She, like many other swimsuit models not named Trish Stratus, was a failed experiment as champion.
7. Candice Michelle
One need only look at Vince McMahon's face during backstage segments with the woman to know he found Candice Michelle breath-taking.
To McMahon, a gorgeous woman like Michelle was everything he needed in a Women's Champion, and that's probably why Candice won the strap from Melina at Vengeance: Night Of Champions in 2007. Vince and fans alike would find out the truth quickly. Candice, for all her confidence and sexiness, was not a good pro wrestler. In the 105 days she held the Women's Title, Michelle failed to have a solid pay-per-view match even against top workers like Beth Phoenix.
What was it with WWE booking Beth against flimsy models?
Michelle never came close to matching that run. An unfortunate spate of clavicle injuries forced her to retire from the ring for good in 2008. She's only wrestled once since then, in a retirement match against Victoria for House Of Hardcore last year.
6. Bertha Faye
Aside from having some sweet, sweet entrance music (ahem) that left a lasting imprint on fans of the time, Bertha Faye is remembered for interrupting one seriously kick-ass feud between Alundra Blayze and Bull Nakano.
Together, Blayze and Nakano did everything they could to revive the fortunes of female wrestling in the WWF during the mid-90s. After apparently failing to live up to McMahon's expectations, Nakano was replaced by Faye, a veteran who had wrestled across the world as Ronda Singh.
The WWF repackaged Singh as an overweight piece of trailer trash who fell in love with Harvey Wippleman. We're not joking.
This can't have been what Blayze meant when she suggested the WWF bring in experienced campaigners for her to wrestle. Less than three months after Faye and Alundra traded ownership of the Women's Title, the belt was dropped completely even before Blayze, as Madusa, dropped it into the Nitro trash.
5. Jillian Hall
Jillian Hall was in her element as an oblivious Britney Spears wannabe who believed she was a pop star in the making. That gimmick had legs, and might have stood a fighting chance of getting over - had WWE not decided to cut them out from under Hall for no reason on the October 12, 2009 Raw.
Mere moments after shocking Mickie James to win her first Divas Title, Jillian's shrill victory speech was interrupted by guest host Nancy O'Dell. The then-Access Hollywood star informed Hall that she'd have to defend against the woman she'd just drafted to Raw. Just like that, Jillian was moved aside for Melina.
It's a wonder WWE's cameras managed to grab a quick shot of Hall sporting the Divas Title at all. She'd never make it backstage with the belt, and has the distinction of being the shortest-lived champ in the title's lineage. Somehow, this was still better than pretending to have a growth on her face.
YouTube that, unless you're eating dinner.
4. Stephanie McMahon
If you think Stephanie McMahon taking credit for the women's revolution is sickening now, then jump into the nearest time machine and head back to the year 2000. Back then, Steph was WWF Women's Champion for 146 whole days.
During a summer spent with the belt draped over her shoulder like she was the second coming of Rockin' Robin, McMahon defended it exactly twice, both times against Lita.
To be fair, she wasn't a wrestler. Her McMahon-Helmsley Regime gimmick with Triple H and his D-Generation X cronies was over too, so it may not seem like the worst idea to put the title on Steph. Only someone who didn't watch quality female workers like Jacqueline and Ivory be pushed aside would say that.
Stephanie wasn't quite the well-rounded performer she is now in 2000, either. In over her head with a title she didn't deserve, McMahon was thankfully dethroned by an actual wrestler (Lita) who had earned the opportunity to carry the division.
3. The Kat
1999-2000 was a dark, dark time for women's wrestling in WWE. When the company weren't putting pensioners out there (Fabulous Moolah does get a free pass here due to her previous runs, but '99 was God-awful), they were presenting such classics as 'Evening Gown' and 'Chocolate Pool' matches.
Right in the thick gravy of it all, Stacey 'The Kat' Carter dressed up as Chyna and was booked to carry the Women's Title for 50 pointless days. She was the winner of the lingerie-based debacle at Armageddon 1999, and it'd be she who defended against Tori in a kiddie pool filled with chocolate on Raw.
Then, The Kat lost her title to a man. Wow.
Let's not ruin the surprise of who that man was though, because it's worth examining that nightmare separately. For Carter, being Women's Champion meant getting her breasts out on pay-per-view, frolicking around in various "sexy" substances and jobbing to others who were somehow worse.
2. Debra
Perhaps nothing sums up women's wrestling during the Attitude era more than then-Commissioner Shawn Michaels awarding Debra the Women's Title because her breasts were superior to and less over-exposed than Sable's.
Charlotte Flair vs. Sasha Banks inside Hell In A Cell this wasn't.
After winning the title from Sable in just 50 seconds on May 10, 1999, Debra defended it just the once. Her title loss to Ivory aired on the June 14 episode of Raw, but the match was actually taped on June 8. That means Debra's first ever title reign lasted 29 days in reality and a scant 35 days in TV land. Another swimsuit model who couldn't wrestle to save her life, Debra was more effective as eye candy during an era when that meant more to fans than seeing women properly work matches.
Her title reign was utterly insignificant, and it's one of the worst in history.
1. Hervina (Harvey Wippleman)
One thing tying all the other entrants on this list (one looking at the worst Women's Champions in WWE history, don't forget) together is the fact they were all female.
Well done, Harvey Wippleman. You have the dubious honour of being the only man to ever win a female title in WWE history, and your triumph marked the first Women's Title change of the new millennium on January 31, 2000.
Of course, Wippleman went under the name 'Hervina' to beat The Kat on Raw in a horrendous 'Lumberjill Snow Bunny' match.
Michael Cole's puzzled expression post-match was only topped by the knowledge this would be hard for the WWF to live down in coming years. We can't imagine why WWE didn't revisit this historic Women's Title moment when selling the importance of females before that first ever women's Royal Rumble...
Which other female Champions do you think were horrible? Let us know your thoughts down in the comments section below!