10 Wrestlers Who Couldn’t Legally Wrestle!

Ric Flair, Bret Hart and others fought the law - and the law won.

By Rex Jones /

Wrestling has had a problematic and troublesome relationship with the law over the years.

Advertisement

A large portion of WWE’s biggest talents, like The Ultimate Warrior, Bruno Sammartino and Brock Lesnar have at one time or another commenced legal proceedings and sued WWE over money, trademarks and slander. The federal government indicted the Chairman and CEO Vince McMahon after the steroid scandal hit the promotion and took him to court, before he was acquitted on all charges.

Current acts like Roman Reigns and Charlotte Flair were arrested for incidents before they signed contracts with WWE, and Jeff Hardy and Jimmy Uso have been arrested while working for WWE, with all their mug shots being on full display online. After all the cases he’s litigated over the years, WWE’s longtime lawyer Jerry McDevitt can fully attest that wrestling and the law can get very complex and entangled. CM Punk, too, knows this, given the lengthy and costly and stressful lawsuit he had to suffer through with WWE ringside physician Chris Amann.

When necessary, the law gets involved in wrestling. Whilst it’s well known injuries prevent wrestlers from performing, sometimes the law prevents them too.

Lawsuits and settlements stop talent from actively competing, sometimes when they’re even 100% healthy...

10. Road Warrior Animal

The Lloyd’s of London insurance policies have caused a lot of stress for performers and promotions over the years.

Advertisement

They were policies taken out by wrestlers in the early ‘90s that stipulated talent would be compensated financially if they suffered a career-ending injury whilst wrestling. Lloyd’s of London most likely thought the chances of this happening were small, what with wrestling being predetermined and all. One of the wrestlers that took advantage of the policy on offer was Road Warrior Animal.

After SummerSlam 1992, his longtime tag partner Hawk walked out of the WWF as well as the Legion of Doom, leaving Animal to fend for himself. Animal represented the LOD solo and often competed in handicap matches on live events. It was during one of these handicap matches with The Beverley Brothers that Animal legitimately injured his back. This would force him to stay out of the ring for three years. Animal collected pay cheques from Lloyd’s of London in that time, on the condition he couldn’t compete in any ring.

When he could no longer prove the injury was career-ending, Animal resumed wrestling for WCW in 1996, reuniting the Road Warriors with Hawk.

9. Rick Rude

‘Ravishing’ Rick Rude badly injured his back in a match at NJPW Wrestling Dontaku 1994 wrestling Sting, landing horribly wrong when he took a suicide dive from his opponent on the outside of the ring.

Advertisement

Rude managed to finish the match, even picking up the win and regaining the WCW International World Championship. He would later vacate the title and retire, collecting in on his Lloyd’s of London insurance policy, making his match with Sting at Dontaku his last as an active competitor. Rude would still make appearances for WCW, ECW and the WWF after this though, dabbling in colour commentary and managerial roles, like being the ‘insurance policy’ for D-Generation X in their early days - an inside reference to Rude’s insurance policy with Lloyd’s of London.

Rude was advertised at ECW Heat Wave (1997) to tag with Tommy Dreamer and The Sandman against Jerry Lawler, Rob Van Dam and Sabu, but ECW got around Rude’s injury/policy by quickly turning the match into an angle where Rude turned his back on his team by attacking them and taking no bumps, all the while wearing a polo shirt and jeans.

Eric Bischoff on his 83 Weeks podcast has explained how the Lloyd’s of London policies worked, especially in relation to Rude:

"Lloyd’s of London used to write policies for professional wrestlers. And they were expensive policies. If you were to become disabled as a result of your work in the ring, you would get a sizeable payoff. In Rick’s case, I think it was a $350,000 or $450,000 payoff. Somewhere in that area. But once you took that check, you couldn’t wrestle again. Getting that check means that you were permanently disabled. You had to get a doctor to examine you and sign an affidavit saying that due to your injuries you were no longer able to perform in the ring, and that was the end of your career. That would trigger the payout from Lloyd’s of London. And that’s exactly what happened to Rick."

8. Curt Hennig

In 1991, ‘Mr. Perfect’ Curt Hennig was suffering from bulged discs in his back as well as a broken tailbone, likely from being the best bump taker in the business.

Advertisement

Because of this, he decided to have one last (thrilling) match against Bret ‘The Hitman’ Hart at SummerSlam to drop the Intercontinental Championship. Hennig however returned to action in late 1992 and competed for a whole year until his back got the better of him and took time away from the ring once more. In between his breaks, he focused on being a colour commentator and managing acts like Ric Flair, Marc Mero and Hunter Heart Helmsley. Like Road Warrior Animal and Rick Rude, Hennig collected and cashed in on (or milked) his Lloyd’s of London insurance policy, which meant he couldn’t wrestle between ‘93-‘97.

Hennig’s back was able to able to rest and recover in those years so he was no longer able to rely on Lloyd’s of London to pay his bills, so he signed a big money deal with WCW at the height of their popularity in ’97 and wrestled continuously until his untimely death in 2003, with his last match being against David Flair in TNA.

7. Ric Flair

In the spring of 1993, ‘The Nature Boy’ Ric Flair hosted a brief talk show called ‘Flair for the Gold’.

Advertisement

His Four Horsemen comrade Arn Anderson was usually sat at the bar in the background whilst Flair’s valet/French maid Fifi (Flair’s now real-life wife) would clean the set. The reason these segments came to be was because Flair was under a strict ‘non-compete’ clause after leaving the WWF in February 1993. WCW still wanted to capitalise on Flair though, so had him conduct interviews with Flair for the Gold. He would interview big-time talent like Sting, Davey Boy Smith and Steve Austin/Brian Pillman when they were The Hollywood Blonds.

Flair for the Gold is most famous - or infamous - for The Shockmaster’s hilarious debut, where he tripped over the set with his Stormtrooper helmet falling off.

Flair also provided commentary on a number of matches in the meantime, like Barry Windham’s match against The Great Muta at Superbrawl III for the Big Gold Belt, until he was able to return to the ring and wrestle at Clash of the Champions XXIII in a tag match with Arn against The Hollywood Blonds.

6. Pacman Jones

In 2007, TNA got into a working relationship with the NFL’s Tennessee Titans cornerback Pacman Jones, hoping to garner some mainstream press with the full intention of having him wrestle for the company in-between his football commitments.

Advertisement

The only issue was Pacman nor TNA ran this past the Tennessee Titans, who weren’t too pleased with this development, thinking he could get hurt wrestling and potentially miss games. The Titans filed a restraining order barring him from working for TNA, so TNA began scrambling. They reached a settlement with the Titans where Pacman could appear on TNA TV and PPVs, but could under no conditions "touch or be touched, use or be hit by any object or anything else that could injure him." It was a surreal situation in wrestling, with little precedent, and it was apparent to everyone watching their programming that Pacman couldn’t be touched in angles or in matches.

When Pacman was attacked and laid out at Hard Justice (2007), it was done off camera. When he won the TNA World Tag Team Championship with Ron Killings against Sting and Kurt Angle at No Surrender, Pacman made the pin but he was never touched. When the pair took on Team 3D on Impact! Pacman avoided contact with leapfrogs and ducking clotheslines. At Bound for Glory, TNA even instigated the ‘Freebird Rule’ so Pacman could avoid in-ring action, with Consequences Creed (Xavier Woods) replacing him in the match to defend the titles with Killings.

If you’re looking for an example of TNA’s incompetence, look no further than this debacle.

5. Speedball Mike Bailey

‘Speedball’ Mike Bailey has demonstrated his immense promise and potential on the independent circuit for years, making him one of Canada’s best modern day wrestlers. But he’s been barred from climbing the ladder any further since 2016.

Advertisement

That year, he was stopped at the border attempting to enter the US from Canada to work a show for Evolve, where it was found he had no working visa and subsequently was banned from entering and competing in America for five years. Bailey was in the process of securing a visa at the time through his work with CZW, but the process was going too slow, so Bailey chose to take his chances and continue working, not wanting to miss out on wrestling for Evolve. In unfortunate circumstances, as soon as the ban expired in 2020, the COVID-19 pandemic hit, making travelling problematic as well as fewer wrestling events being run than ever before. Hopefully Bailey will get his shot with AEW shortly, with Bailey and Kenny Omega speaking openly how they’re hoping for a rematch to their Pro Wrestling Guerrilla 20 minute thriller back in 2015.

Bailey has said recently regarding his future:

"I could teach full-time or I could keep travelling, or I can go to Japan full-time, or I can sign with any major company. Whatever makes the most sense at the time is what I'll do."

4. Yokozuna

WWE Hall of Famer Yokozuna was an enormous individual at his peak, once being billed as the "biggest Samoan wrestler ever".

Advertisement

His last match for the WWF was at Survivor Series 1996 in a traditional Survivor Series elimination match in which he squared off against fellow big man Vader. The WWF were gravely concerned for Yokozuna around this period, with his weight only increasing with every passing month. It was only through Vince McMahon continuously believing Yokozuna when he told him he would drop weight that he remained on the active roster for as long as he did. The WWF sent Yokozuna home after Survivor Series and put him on a strict exercise and diet program, wanting and hoping to save his life.

It still wasn’t enough to get medically cleared; he failed a physical with the New York State Athletic Commission that prevented and barred him from wrestling in that state. As a result, the WWF had no choice but to let him go in 1998, with the WWF not wanting to be liable for any potential heart issues.

Yokozuna competed on the indie circuit following his release in states where physicals were easier to pass, where his weight ballooned to a staggering 760 lbs until his untimely passing in 2000.

3. X-Pac

At TNA Lockdown 2010, the former 1-2-3 Kid and X-Pac was scheduled to tag with his friend Scott Hall to take on Team 3D, but was replaced at the last minute by Kevin Nash.

Advertisement

Rumours began circulating to his whereabouts, with many believing Waltman had no-showed the event. He had only returned to the company three months prior on the much-hyped and promoted January 4th Impact!.

It turns out TNA knew at short notice he wouldn’t/couldn’t wrestle at Lockdown, with the Missouri Athletic Commission banning Waltman from wrestling due to his hepatitis C diagnosis. As a result, the following week TNA wrote him off TV completely when they filmed a segment where he was attacked off-screen and found laid out in a pool of blood (much like Pacman Jones when he couldn’t wrestle for the company).

Waltman has recently commented on his diagnosis and claimed he’s cured of it, noting he’s looking to wrestle once again sometime in the future:

"I had hepatitis C for a long time. I tested positive when I came back to TNA and was doing that stuff with Kevin and Scott and Hogan came in with Eric, all that. So after that, I couldn’t get cleared in certain states with athletic commissions and so TNA and WWE couldn’t really have me in matches, so I would just do little matches and nothing serious, no blood or whatever. Just this year, just this year I got cured."

2. Brock Lesnar

When Brock Lesnar shockingly gave his notice to WWE at a SmackDown taping in 2004 a week before his major match with Goldberg at WrestleMania XX - in the hope of pursuing an NFL career - it came with some consequences.

Advertisement

Lesnar was handed an extensive ‘non-compete’ clause by WWE which prohibited him from wrestling for a lengthy period of time. This wasn’t an issue for Lesnar at the time, but after his NFL career came to an end in August 2004, Lesnar needed to work to satisfy the lifestyle he was living. Lesnar started looking into his wrestling options.

He filed a lawsuit in February 2005 against WWE asking a court to rule the non-compete clause unenforceable, which in turn was his legal loophole to wrestle for NJPW, debuting in October 2005 and winning the IWGP Heavyweight Championship immediately. Lesnar wrote in his autobiography regarding the matter:

"I had never thought about wrestling in Japan, or anywhere else for that matter, because WWE had me sign that non-compete agreement which said I could only wrestle for Vince, and I thought I was on the shelf until 2010. I also guessed that Vince McMahon was going to do everything in his power to stop me from making a living. I figured going to Japan would be a great experience. I’d pick up some excellent coin, eat some fresh sushi, have some good times with Brad (Rheingans), and deliver a great big ‘screw you’ to Vince."

1. Bret Hart

Bret Hart was another wrestler tied into the Lloyd’s of London insurance policy.

Advertisement

Bret had to walk away from wrestling in 2000 after Goldberg mule kicked him into retirement at WCW Starrcade 1999, with him later suffering a stroke after falling off his bike. Lloyd’s of London were sceptical of the severe concussion he received in his match with Goldberg, having been taken advantage of years prior with Road Warrior Animal and Curt Hennig claiming they suffered career-ending injuries only to return to full-time competition years later. So Bret sued Lloyd’s in 2004 for unpaid benefits and breach of contract, which he won the following year. A big issue arose when Bret made his long-awaited return to the WWE in 2010, with WWE keen on presenting a match/angle hybrid where Bret would take on Vince McMahon at WrestleMania to seek revenge for the Montreal Screwjob.

Lloyd’s of London became involved when the match was close to being announced, curious of how Bret could compete in a match after suffering career-ceasing injuries. WWE were even willing to book Bret in a tag match with John Cena against Vince and Batista on the night, if it made circumstances easier.

WWE, Bret and Lloyd’s of London came to an agreement where a No Holds Barred Lumberjack match between Bret and Vince was allowed to go ahead at WrestleMania XXVI, with Bret having to no bumps, which was obvious when he wrestled in less than ideal matches in 2010 and 2011.

Advertisement