10 Wrestlers Who Had Their Gimmicks Stolen

A good gimmick is hard to come by, so why not steal one?

By Douglas Scarpa /

A wrestler€™s gimmick or character is their livelihood. It€™s what enables them to get over and connect with the fans. As proven time and time again, the right character is extremely important. Steve Austin floundered in WCW€™s midcard with the €œStunning€ gimmick, but as Stone Cold, he rocketed to superstardom. Kevin Nash failed miserably in his various WCW gimmicks but achieved great success as Diesel in the World Wrestling Federation, and later as himself in the nWo. With the right gimmick a superstar can be born. However, it€™s not easy to come up with a great character or find one that connects in the perfect way with the crowd. There have been a great deal of lackluster and utterly terrible characters over the years. So, when a good gimmick is found, it€™s something to be cherished. Because of this, many wrestlers resort to simply ripping off what€™s worked in the past. There€™s been a lot of so-called gimmick infringement in wrestling€™s history. However, we€™re not here to talk about the guys who took some established ideas and qualities. Instead, we€™re going to take a look back at ten wrestling gimmicks that were blatantly stolen. No changes, no tweaks -- these gimmicks were plagiarised. Join us as we count down 10 wrestlers who had their gimmicks blatantly stolen from them.

10. Doink The Clown

Matt Borne was a 12-year veteran of the business when he made his return to the World Wrestling Federation in 1992. He had competed with the company for a brief period in the mid-80s, although he was mostly used as a jobber. Prior to his Federation re-debut, Borne was best known as Big Josh in WCW -- a lumberjack who danced with bears. However, Borne got the break he had been looking for all along in €˜92 as the evil and villainous Doink the Clown. As Doink, Borne showcased his technical wrestling ability and prowess on the mic. He would pull mean-spirited pranks on other wrestlers, before tying them up in his dreaded Stump Puller submission hold. By 1993, Doink was beginning to achieve moderate success, even competing against Bret Hart at SummerSlam. However, in September of that year, Matt Borne was released from his WWF contract due to an ongoing drug abuse problem. Despite Borne€™s release, the character of Doink lived on. In the years to come, a handful of wrestlers would compete under the facepaint of Doink the Clown. Steve Lombardi and Steve Keirn -- better known as the Brooklyn Brawler and Skinner, respectively -- made brief appearances as the character. However, it was Ray Apollo who would permanently don the paint as Doink.
With Apollo portraying the character, Doink morphed into a more typical, kid-friendly clown. He was even accompanied by a little clown, named Dink, following his face turn. Apollo€™s Doink was a shell of Borne€™s, and the character died a slow death before being done away with completely in 1996. Doink has since made a handful of appearances in WWE -- often portrayed by Lombardi.

9. Max Moon

Konnan is a wrestler who went on to achieve fame and success in WCW. There he helped to usher in the era of the cruiserweights -- as he was responsible for the signing of many luchadors. He also became well known as a member of the New World Order and the Wolfpac. However, in late 1992, Konnan was given an opportunity in the WWF. The Mexican superstar was signed by the company and was subsequently given an elaborate character. Konnan was to be known as Max Moon, a cyborg from outer space. Moon wore a bright blue outfit and mask with attached foam tubing, as well as a jet pack and pyro-shooting gauntlets when making his entrance. After only three appearances on television, the end seemed near for Max Moon. Konnan left the company, as he simply stopped showing up to WWF events because of his growing popularity in Mexico. The Federation reportedly spent a great deal of money on the cyborg€™s elaborate outfit and entrance attire. As such, it was decided to simply hand the gimmick off to someone else. Paul Diamond, who luckily fit in the suit, was given the Max Moon character.
Diamond was a veteran in the ring, best known as part of the Badd Company duo, as well as the masked member of the Orient Express. Max Moon had made his debut in the WWF in September of €˜92, however, by early 1992, the character would vanish forever. Diamond donned the blue suit for just a handful of months before being released from his contract. Luckily, no one else was given the Moon gimmick following Diamond€™s departure.

8. La Parka

The unofficial Chairman of WCW, La Parka was easily one of the most entertaining cruiserweights in the company. Frequently seen carrying a steel chair, playing air guitar, and dancing to the ring, La Parka was a mysterious masked luchador from Mexico. Sadly, La Parka was never able to attain the WCW Cruiserweight Championship -- a gross miscarriage of justice, if there ever was one. Despite his lack of a title reign, La Parka thoroughly entertained the WCW masses during his four-year run with the company. However, La Parka -- real name, Adolfo Tapia -- ran into some trouble upon his return to Mexico. Tapia had previously competed with the AAA promotion and upon his departure for WCW in 1996, AAA€™s owner, Antonio Pena, assigned the La Parka gimmick to another competitor. Billed as La Parka Jr., the doppelganger was meant as a way to capitalize on Tapia€™s popularity in the United States. Surprisingly, there were no real disputes or issues between Tapia and Pena initially.However, trouble arose when Tapia returned to Mexico and began competing for AAA€™s rival, CMLL. A legal battle ensued, and ultimately, Tapia was forced to change his name. Now dubbed L.A. ParK, standing for La Autentica ParK -- essentially the Original Parka -- Tapia has continued to compete around the world. Furthermore, despite the name change and a subtle mask design change, Tapia continues to employ the same techniques he did at the height of his fame.

7. Sting

Jeff Farmer is not a name that is familiar to many wrestling fans. If the name does ring a bell, it€™s likely because of this:Sadly, that€™s a different Jeff Farmer than the one we€™re here to discuss. Farmer got his start with World Championship Wrestling as one half of the Thunder and Lightning tag team. Never heard of them? Okay, well, how about Cobra? He was embroiled in an intense feud with Sgt. Craig Pittman. No? How about Sting? You€™ve surely heard of Sting. Well, Jeff Farmer competed as Sting in WCW. While Steve Borden is the only real Stinger -- and the original -- Farmer had a three-year stint with the Southern promotion as an impostor Sting. The real Sting had walked out on the company in the midst of the New World Order storyline. Later that year, fans were under the impression that the Stinger had returned. However, fans were angry when Sting began to attack WCW wrestlers and side with the nWo. It was all revealed to be a play by the heel faction, who had hired an impostor.
Dubbed the nWo Sting, Farmer stuck around for longer than anyone likely expected. He even picked up a victory over the real Stinger in Fall Brawl 1996€™s WarGames match. While he remained under contract to WCW, Farmer traveled to New Japan Pro Wrestling and joined their nWo Japan faction. He continued to compete as the nWo Sting and did pretty well for himself before abandoning the gimmick around the year 2000.

6 & 5. Buddy Rogers & Ric Flair

The original €œNature Boy,€ Buddy Rogers was one of the top wrestling competitors in the world during the 1950s and €˜60s. Rogers innovated the €œNature Boy€ gimmick -- a flamboyant, bleach-blonde, braggadocious heel. In the height of his career, Rogers captured the NWA World Heavyweight Championship. Following a falling out between Vince McMahon Sr. and the National Wrestling Alliance in 1963, Rogers was named the first ever WWWF Champion. Just one month later, on May 17th, Rogers was defeated in less than a minute by Bruno Sammartino for the title. Rogers returned to the NWA territories shortly thereafter and began feuding with Ric Flair. At the time, Flair was a young, up-and-comer in the Mid-Atlantic territory. In order to garner more appeal -- and to raise the ire of Rogers -- Flair began calling himself the €œNature Boy.€ The two feuded over the nickname and gimmick for sometime, before Flair finally upset Rogers on July 9, 1978.
However, Flair was not the only competitor to steal Buddy Rogers€™ nickname, look, and figure four finishing maneuver. Buddy Landel also took the gimmick as his own in the early 1980s. Despite not reaching the heights of either Rogers or Flair, Landel still achieved moderate success as the €œNature Boy.€ Landel naturally feuded with Flair over the gimmick, and was supposedly even set to be Flair for the NWA World title at one point. Unfortunately for Landel, his flight was delayed and his plane arrived late, thus, the title switch never took place.

4. The Undertaker

The Undertaker is perhaps the WWE€™s most iconic character. While others have achieved more popularity and mainstream attention -- such as Hulk Hogan and Steve Austin -- the Undertaker is one of the longest lasting gimmicks in wrestling. While Taker€™s best days are behind him -- with rumors of a possible retirement on the horizon -- the Deadman€™s legacy remains. Despite competing as the Undertaker character for nearly his entire career, Mark Calaway is not the only man to lay claim to the moniker. In 1994, with Calaway sitting at home due to injury, a new Undertaker was introduced. Initially, this incarnation of the character was simply treated as the real deal. Portrayed by Calaway€™s personal friend, Brian Lee, the UnderFaker (as fans would dub him) had aligned himself with the €œMillion Dollar Man€ Ted DiBiase. After some time, DiBiase and his impostor Undertaker were confronted by Paul Bearer. Bearer claimed that he had been in contact with the real Deadman and a match was set between the two Undertakers for that year€™s SummerSlam. The genuine Undertaker returned and defeated the impostor in their main event match -- although it took three tombstones to seal the deal. Ultimately, the fake Taker would never be seen again, as he was vanquished by the one and only Deadman.

3 & 2. Razor Ramon & Diesel

On September 4, 1995, World Championship Wrestling aired the debut broadcast of Monday Nitro -- a new primetime program on the burgeoning TNT cable network. At the end of Nitro€™s debut edition, the first shot in the Monday Night War was fired as Lex Luger strolled to the ring and stated he was €œsick and tired of playing around with kids.€ With Luger€™s defection to WCW, Nitro was quickly established as being the place where anything could happen and anyone could show up. In 1996, WCW upped their game, as Scott Hall and Kevin Nash invaded the company. It was a major coup for the company and a devastating blow to the World Wrestling Federation. Hall and Nash were best known as Razor Ramon and Diesel, respectively. Now, they were on WCW programming, having left Vince McMahon€™s WWF in the dark of the night. McMahon and the Federation looked like fools, but they quickly came up with an idea. The conclusion was reached that the WWF didn€™t need Hall and Nash, because they still owned the rights to their characters. Therefore, in September of 1996, Jim Ross announced that Diesel and Razor Ramon were returning to the Federation. The next week, Ross delivered on his promise, but it was then that fans realized he wasn€™t being entirely honest.Diesel and Ramon returned to Monday Night Raw, but it wasn€™t Nash and Hall. Instead, Ramon was portrayed by Rick Bognar, while Glenn Jacobs acted as Diesel. Fans were not impressed, and the angle quickly tanked. It was all meant to be a slight against Nash, Hall, Bischoff, and WCW, but it failed miserably -- making McMahon and the WWF simply look bitter. Both Bognar and Jacobs tried their best, but they were in an unwinnable position. After a few months, the angle was dropped. Bognar returned to Japan, where he had achieved moderate success as Big Titan. Meanwhile, Jacobs was repackaged as the Undertaker€™s evil brother, Kane.

1. Sin Cara

This is the most recent example of a wrestler having their character blatantly stolen. Sin Cara was a hot prospect for the WWE. Signed in 2011, the former Mistico debuted with the company almost immediately. And almost immediately, things went terribly wrong. Sin Cara quickly became more well known for messing up his own moves than for his colorful character and high-flying style. Furthermore, the luchador was suspended just three months after his debut for a Wellness Policy violation. Despite his constant botching, Sin Cara was popular among younger fans. As such, WWE decided to continue to use the character on television but replace the man under the mask. The former Hunico began competing under the Sin Cara hood, and upon the original Cara€™s return, the two became embroiled in a feud over the gimmick. Ultimately, the original Sin Cara was able to defeat the impostor and send him packing. However, the tale doesn€™t end there.Earlier this year, the original Sin Cara -- Luis Urvie -- was released from his contract. Urvie has since returned to Mexico where he competes as Myzteziz -- as he had his original Mistico gimmick stolen, as well. Again, WWE decided to continue using the Sin Cara character, and Hunico has donned the mask ever since.