10 Wrestlers Who Innovated New Stipulation Matches

Money in the bank.

By Michael Sidgwick /

The origins of certain stipulation matches are untraceable.

Advertisement

The outlaw days of professional wrestling were swarmed by self-serving egotists in a super secretive, close-knit industry that protected itself. A comprehensive oral history of it naturally does not exist, and if it did, one could dispute virtually every account. Wrestling is a con curated by conmen. It's part of the fascination, or at least it was, until provable, excruciating lies were spouted endlessly by Conrad Thompson's carny podcast co-host network.

The first recorded Steel Cage match was purported to have taken place - so fittingly, given the city's mythical history with the stip - in Atlanta, Georgia, in 1937. It's a romantic way of looking at it, but it's not definitive; accounts of earlier iterations can be traced back to earlier that decade.

The 'Hardcore' match and its derivations also share a shadowy, imprecise history, the patent claims of which span Memphis, Puerto Rico, Detroit. The Battle Royale, the most quintessential wrestling gimmick match there is, predates wrestling itself. There was no creator; only an enterprising plagiarist with an idea very likely shared by somebody else across the country.

But, in a year that has enforced the full dawn of a new attraction, credit can be apportioned for the more modern ones...

10. Dusty Rhodes - WarGames

The first WarGames matches were incredible spectacles that hold up to 2020 scrutiny because f*ck improved athletic standards: they were fights so brutal steel had to contain them.

Advertisement

The presentation of the match was a perfect hybrid of outrageous theatre and gritty realism. If it looked overblown, in an awesome sort of way - two rings! Two cages! - it felt ultra-violent, with all that disgusting plasma appearing to ooze from the magazine pages that captured its jaw-dropping allure.

The structural formula Dusty Rhodes devised was another perfect fusion: of anticipation and brutality.

One feeling informed and intensified the other. As the heels outnumbered the babyfaces, a sense of wrongness drove bloodthirsty vengeance; the red claret cascading from the heads of the battered heroes was reflected in the red mist of the tormented fans, who punched the air when the parity was restored. The build and release cycle began anew, as the drama graduated to a brutal blur of a crescendo, culminating in the Match Beyond - a phase so punishing, a combatant had to yield to it for mercy.

Rhodes created the match having drawn inspiration from Mad Max: Beyond Thunderdome, and was very keen to credit Klondike Bill for facilitating his vision "like a mad scientist".

9. Dusty Rhodes - Bunkhouse Stampede

The Bunkhouse Stampede was a less-celebrated Dusty Rhodes creation, but one that is remembered affectionately enough in certain circles. People mourned the wilderness years of one Dusty creation, and it wasn't this, to put it that way.

Advertisement

But it was cool idea, and a damn popular one in certain areas, consistent with the blood and guts ethos of awesome, prime Jim Crockett Promotions. It was a slight - but very characterful - tweak on the Battle Royal that was aged very quickly by its successor counterpart up north.

Many of the combatants entered the ring in their street clothes, to get the match over as a scrap more real or more violent than the wrestling, and weapons were permitted. Of course, this being wrestling, signature weapons were used, quite charmingly, including the spikes worn by the Road Warriors. Powder flew across the ring, chains were scraped against faces, throats were strangled: it was a fun and violent match, but it wasn't unique enough to become truly iconic, nor did it present the very best of the promotion's style.

The Bunkhouse Stampede had a distinct and earthy southern flavour, hence why its aesthetic hasn't carried over - and the 1988 event was so horrendously organised and received that it developed a stigma so rotten that the quality of the earlier, wilder matches have been condemned by association.

8. Chris Jericho - Money In The Bank

Chris Jericho's pitch to create the Money In The Bank Ladder match was as much a solution as it was an idea - a tremendous concept devised by one of the industry's most powerful ever minds.

Advertisement

With John Cena and Batista set to dominate the WrestleMania 21 headline picture ahead of their coronations as the new quasi-Hulk Hogan and Ultimate Warrior figures, the new tier left behind a stacked upper midcard with little to do. This was before the Network allowed for a limitless run-time, and before WWE had the luxury - the luxury this match indirectly created - of promoting multi-man matches as artless appeasement strategies.

The process unfolded in rare, perfect synergy between worker and booker. Jericho recognised the deficit on the card, and responded to "boring" Triple Threat Submission match ideas with a six-man Ladder match pitch.

Instantly, this nebulous match was more exciting - but was it meaningful?

Brian Gewirtz - who you might remember as the one man on that Ruthless Aggression documentary who didn't talk bullsh*t - asked this very question. Jericho had the idea for the match to double as a title shot, which Gewirtz workshopped into the enduring Money In The Bank concept.

And for once, Vince's prop-obsessed brain came in handy; the iconic briefcase was his one demand.

7. Matt Hardy - Cinematic

The origins of the in-vogue cinematic match are, like most genres, knotty and unverifiable.

Advertisement

WCW produced mini-movies in the 1990s - phenomenally awful mini-movies - and the WWF experimented with pre-taped elements in its most lowkey creative year, 1996, splicing recorded footage with live elements to create new match genres in the form of the Hollywood Backlot and Boiler Room Brawls.

Lucha Underground pioneered a cinematic presentation and narrative framework, with cut scenes and intentionally fantastical storyline elements removed entirely from an emulation of sport. Japan's Dramatic Dream Team promotion embraced the absurd, but the punchline was the intentionally clumsy welding of trad pro wrestling onto utterly incongruous locales.

It was Matt Hardy who sensed the the possibilities of a full stylistic shift, and created in 2016 what was since dubbed the 'Cinematic' match: a full-on, pre-taped, edited short film with no delusion of reality whatsoever, in which wrestling happened. The boundless imagination of the endeavour, and the freedom afforded by the post-production process, allowed for an endlessly mutating hybrid genre, a universe, in which farce and slapstick meshed with meta elements to create a new whole unto itself.

WWE, under these trying circumstances, has since borrowed inspiration, and a key creative component in Jeremy Borash, to make best use of its pay-per-view attractions - to actually create a sense of escape, and not a depressing, ironically deafening reminder.

6. Triple H - Elimination Chamber

The notion of Triple H not taking storyline credit for his real invention of the Elimination Chamber match is a sort of stirring but sobering gut-punch akin to finding out that Old Man Marley from Home Alone wasn't a small bean regarder.

Advertisement

This concept underscored Triple H's keen, manipulative intelligence, in addition to his ability of pushing something through in which he has a personal investment.

The Elimination Chamber match was his cover version, in effect, of WarGames - a match Vince never much fancied. It wasn't his own, which is always a consideration, but the cold financial reality, of the double ring set-up wasting valuable, expensive front row real estate, was the primary one. The Chamber match, a stunning triumph beyond those awkward, tentative tumbles onto the hard steel, adapted the concepts of a roofed cage, countdowns and wincing brutality. The spectacle wasn't quite the same, but the seemingly magnetic glass pods created a new layer of violence to the environment.

Ultimately, the match wasn't a huge draw - just 20,000 domestic buyers preferred it over the ailing King of the Ring format in 2002 - but it was cherished by enough hardcore fans to become an institution that almost invariably produced a belter.

5. Carlos Colón - Inferno

The Inferno match is a strange one to parse.

Advertisement

Visually, it's compelling pro wrestling theatre, and the shooting flames add a totally cosmetic and pointless - but stupidly fun - spectacle element, which is ideal, since every version in WWE involved boring old f*cking Kane. But it never drew, the oxygen-deprived talent hated working them, and the very fractional increase in entertainment value probably wasn't worth the very real risk of incineration and, in the not too improbable event of those flames torching the crowd, mass litigation.

TL:DR: not worth the effort, as pretty as that picture^ looks.

An inherently dangerous match that hardly facilitated a technical classic, almost naturally, its origins can be traced to the mythically wild and scary Puerto Rico territory. "Once the show starts, chaos is there," as Savio Vega told Kayfabe Commentaries.

The 'Fire' match, an invention of legendary, controversial WWC figurehead Carlos Colón, functioned in much the same way as a Japanese barbed wire death match; a suspenseful thriller in which the drama is engineered mostly in the space between the action.

It's an on-the-nose take, but the visual of the fire fused perfectly with legendarily rabid locals to create a spectacle you'd be afraid to take in live.

4. Pat Patterson - Royal Rumble

Vince McMahon infamously declared it "stupid", but it is WWE's most popular self-created stip precisely because it's the opposite of that. The Royal Rumble was an inspired, genius idea of Pat Patterson's, who recognised the enduring appeal and spectacle - and the boring, confusing bit - of the battle royal.

Advertisement

It required a new marketing spin and structure, to get over as something worth watching and an attraction unique to the World Wrestling Federation, and Patterson's concept was so exceptional that it all but ruined the appeal of the old format. It also made every subsequent revision pale in comparison. Every other tweak on the genre felt desperate, or confusing.

All of them were pointless. It will never be beaten.

This is a match that guarantees 28 pops and yet has featured Drew Carey, Doug Gilbert and Tom Brandi. It's a match that delivers multitudes of suspense and anticipation. It's a match in which, latterly, entire generations can collide. It's a match that spawns the dumbest of fun comedy and the grandest of stakes and career-defining triumph.

It's a match that, after 30 years, bookers can still tinker with - CM Punk's cult recruitment, Brock Lesnar's spree of destruction - because Pat Patterson both painted a masterpiece and built the canvas.

3. Vince Russo - Reverse Battle Royal

When Vince Russo devised a battle royal, only in reverse, he wasn't to know how right he would get it: he created a variation as sh*tty as the Royal Rumble was great.

Advertisement

He did, in fact, get the battle royal backwards.

More harebrained scheme than "idea", one could poke a hole in it at the sounding of the opening bell, and it is inexplicable that nobody in the room did when he pitched it.

The very first phase of the match was a psychological disaster. It was, in effect, a running race that nobody ran, a swerve within a swerve, except this one wasn't intentional but rather something Russo, the idiot, the imbecile, didn't think about. Even if the wrestlers paired off in perfect synergy, counting down the time with some synchronised brawling, the whole thing would have looked farcical, with a question mark hovering over the scene so noticeably it might as well have been hooked to a karabiner.

This didn't happen. The optimum scenario here was "very contrived", and it was, somehow, worse. Several wrestlers stood, clueless, outside of the ring they had to simply enter so as not to lose.

Even Ryback knew how to do that.

2. Jim Cornette - Hell In A Cell*

If proof were needed that an honest-to-Christ tenured pro wrestling mind is needed within WWE's creative process - just in case the most dogsh*t promos you've ever heard don't count - consider the conception of one of WWE's greatest ever creative triumphs.

Advertisement

The Hell In A Cell gimmick was a Jim Cornette creation - or, more accurately, a Jim Cornette adaptation.

He drew inspiration from the famed Last Battle of Atlanta fought - bloodily - between Tommy Rich and Buzz Sawyer. Unlike the traditional steel cage match, a roof covered it, a simple, mostly aesthetic touch that conveyed the extent to which the animosity had to be contained.

Cornette, a keen historian with a deeper love of the southern '80s territories than the WWF, used it for inspiration when creating the Hell In A Cell gimmick. He updated it, somewhat ironically, given his latter reputation, to account for the advanced ring style; the space between the mesh and the ring allowed for a more athletic and dynamic match, with the claret-drenched ultra-violence remaining firmly intact.

The WWF's more filmic psychological approach worked in synergy to create a positively awesome hybrid of pro wrestling, old school and new, and horror cinema.

1. Terry Funk - Empty Arena 

It's very strange to consider that the empty arena match - this depressing monstrosity of form mandated by a generational crisis - was actually born out of choice.

Advertisement

It's not remotely strange to consider that the first match was pretty awesome and is remembered to this day because it was Terry Funk's idea and Terry Funk was in it.

"The empty arena was my idea," Funk told Sports Illustrated earlier this year. "Nobody told me what to say, nobody told me what to do. I was my own creator."

Lance Russell was also awesome. This "thing", as he called it - and he was right to, since it was unprecedented, and he was savvy enough to sell it as such - played out to the TV crew like a mystery. Russell wondered aloud whether it would look good enough to air, if it even happened. The groundbreaking match saw Funk attempt to claim a bounty put over Jerry Lawler's head with his own set of rules. There were to be none of the fans that roared Lawler out of agony so many times. No police. No referee.

It was just a fight.

And it was a captivating if not very good one; furious, flailing limbs barely landed, and when it more resembled a wrestling match, it never looked hokey; Funk made sure to blast Lawler with a piledriver on the concrete to maintain the tone of transgressive brutality.

Advertisement