10 Wrestlers Who Made Terrible Commentators
Ring skills don't always translate to the booth.
However you feel about the product in general, WWE commentary is in a pretty poor state at the moment and has been for some time. While not terrible, the trio of Michael Cole, JBL and Booker T on Monday Night Raw is distracting from the in-ring action. They spend more time bickering with each other than they do calling the moves of the performers, getting on the nerves of fans who can't enjoy the event.
There actually hasn't been a point in at least the last decade where the commentary could be called good; it's been that mediocre for that long. Only so much blame can be put on the announcers themselves, however. Most of what they're saying is completely contrived by Vince McMahon and other producers through the headsets they're wearing, and it couldn't be any more obvious.
There's a common misconception that wrestlers make for the best commentators, but that couldn't be any farther from the truth. They might have the knowledge of being in the ring and telling a story, but it's not that simple. Former stars of the squared circle have cracked under the pressure of being an announcer for all the responsibilities that come with commentating.
For every Jerry Lawler and Gordon Solie, there's a JBL or a Booker T, talented in-ring performers who have failed behind as announcers. With that in mind, this list will only look at wrestlers who have served as commentators for an extended period of time, not for a match or two.
10. Randy Savage
Not even one of the legendary performers in WWE history is exempt from this list of shame.
Savage was a near-perfect Superstar because he could seemingly do it all: his wrestling abilities were extraordinary, his mic skills were exceptional, and he was one heck of a character. There wasn't anything he didn't excel at, until he left the ring.
After wrapping up his illustrious career as a wrestler in 1991, he traded in his multicolored boots for a headset, sitting in on commentary alongside Vince McMahon and Bobby Heenan. With two of those three being among the greatest talkers of all-time, you'd think it would have been a dream team for commentary. You'd have been wrong.
Granted, Raw commentary two decades ago was significantly better than what it's devolved into, but that doesn't necessarily mean it was good. While passable as an announcer, he simply didn't capture that same magic he created when he was holding a live microphone; there was a disconnect there.
The Macho Man eventually found his way back into the ring, and perhaps it was for the best. When he left for WCW in 1994, it wasn't to be an announcer; it was to be an in-ring competitor, which meant he may not have have enjoyed being behind the booth as much as Vince thought he did.
9. Mick Foley
Similarly to Savage, Mick Foley will be remembered as one of the most tremendous talkers professional wrestling has ever seen. As Mankind, he cut promos that revolutionized the business, and his skills as a wrestler were equally excellent.
But once he retired from the ring, WWE struggled to find a role for him, shuffling him around from authoritative positions before finally settling on putting him behind the booth on SmackDown.
When Jonathon "The Coach" Coachman left for ESPN, Foley replaced him as SmackDown's lead color commentator. Being the sensational storyteller that he is, he seemed to be a perfect fit for an announcer, and although he gelled well with Michael Cole, he felt out of his element.
It wasn't long after he took the position that he wanted out of it, allowing his contract with the company to lapse in September. He debuted for TNA a few months later and, again, like Savage, it was as an authority figure and then as a wrestler, taking up commentary duties all of twice during his stint there.
The Hardcore Legend later remarked in his "Countdown to Lockdown" novel that it "wasn't working out creatively" for him. Over time, he grew tired of having Vince McMahon yell at him through the headset and decided to call it quits.
8. The Miz
The Miz doesn't often get credit for being one of the better talkers in WWE today. The peak of his mic work came during his WWE Championship run in 2011, but even his degrading promos directed toward Damien Mizdow during their recent stint together were above average.
Say what you will about his skills inside in the squared circle (though they have improved over the years), but he's exceptional at getting a crowd to hate him whenever he has a mic in his hands.
After dropping the WWE title, Miz floundered for some time and struggled with his various face and heel turns. With no prominent place for him on the show, he turned to commentary, which seemed to be a logical fit for him given his skills on the stick. He tried his hand at announcing on the September 3, 2012 edition of Raw and did well for himself, later earning a permanent spot on WWE's newest program Main Event as a color commentator.
But when calling the action, he was average at best, but even as a babyface, he spent far too much time talking about himself. And while his self-centered personality is perfect for when he's a heel, but as a commentator, it's too distracting from what's going on in the ring.
7. Alex Riley
Needless to say, Alex Riley's best run in WWE came shortly following his split from The Miz when he was given the chance to headline a handful of episodes of Raw. Although his feud with the former WWE champion was well-received, his momentum came to a screeching halt that summer when he was abruptly taken off TV. He sparingly appeared on the flagship show over the next two years, but was prominently featured on NXT and "WWE Superstars."
Following Matt Striker's release from the company in June 2013, Riley was primed to be his replacement and passed with flying colors. Sitting alongside Tony Dawson and Josh Matthews during his time on the program, he did well for himself. At one point, he received praise from one of the best commentators of all-time Jim Ross, along with JBL.
However, it wasn't until he transitioned over to NXT that his skills as a commentator began to digress.
As he became the resident heel commentator on the show, he was an annoyance and a disturbance, often ending on the losing end of arguments with the respected William Regal and Jason Albert. Thankfully, he did fans a favor by resuming his in-ring career recently on NXT and applying his craft back where it belongs: between the ropes, not behind the booth.
6. Byron Saxton
Little known fact: Byron Saxton was, in fact, a wrestler before becoming a commentator. However, you would never know that if you just watched Raw or SmackDown because he never made it past NXT.
He had a brief stint as a commentator for the ECW brand before the brand's demise in early 2010. From there, he transitioned into the role of a wrestler on the fourth season of NXT, being paired with Chris Masters as his pro. Despite showing some personality, he was eliminated fourth from the competition.
Saxton returned to TV in 2012 as a commentator for the NXT brand where he's been ever since. Despite being behind the booth for well over five years, he has shown no signs of getting better. He isn't terrible by any means, but he comes across as being too bland and doesn't stand out like Tom Phillips, Renee Young and even Rich Brennan do.
He was given the opportunity of a lifetime to call the action by himself in the wake of Brock Lesnar's destruction on the March 30 edition of Raw, but fell flat; Jerry Lawler had to be sent out to ringside to save him and the broadcast. He's been featured on SmackDown, NXT and "Superstars" as of late, but he's better off behind the scenes working as an interviewer rather than as an announcer.
5. JBL
JBL is an interesting case: he can be good when he wants to be, but more often than not as of late, he's been absolutely unbearable to listen to. As previously noted, most of that has to do with what's being fed to him through the headset, but it's gotten to the point where he just needs to go.
The self-proclaimed "Wrestling God" retired from the ring the first time around in 2006, replacing Tazz as the color commentator for SmackDown. While he was never the greatest wrestler in the history of the business, he was always a talented talker, and that shone through in his time behind the booth on the blue brand. Him and Michael Cole had excellent chemistry together that effectively enhanced the action in the ring; what happened to that JBL?
He returned to action in late 2007 only to retire for a second time a year and a half year before coming back to the company to fill in for Jerry Lawler following his heart attack in 2012. The Raw trio of him, Cole and Jim Ross was near perfect and the closest the commentary on Monday nights came to being great in recent memory.
Since 2013, however, he's served as the cheerleader for The Authority, constantly putting down whoever he works with and adding next to nothing to the product.
4. Lord Alfred Hayes
If you think the current state of commentary is bad, you'd be wise to not go back to the days of Lord Alfred Hayes on WWE Network.
Hayes spent the first 20 years of his pro wrestling career as an in-ring competitor, though he never wrestled for WWE. He was brought into the company in 1982 as a commentator, and it quickly became clear that his in-ring experience lent nothing to his commentary work.
Vince McMahon was no Jim Ross or Gordon Solie himself, but at least he knew what he was talking about most of the time and had the voice of an announcer. It wasn't his English accent that made him insufferable to listen to but rather his forced laugh and his tendency to ramble. Although he had that "old school" feel to his announcing, over time it became a struggle for viewers to understand a single thing he was saying.
Fans are often harsh on Michael Cole for his constant plugging of the WWE Network and the WWE App, among other things. Hayes was an awful announcer alone, but imagine if he was asked to do everything that is required of Cole and other commentators today? You would be better off watching Raw on mute, as if you didn't already.
3. Brad Maddox
Better known for his stint as Raw general manager, Brad Maddox did at one point serve as a color commentator for a few of WWE's programs. In regards as to whether he was any good, if he was, he wouldn't have been placed on this list; let's just say that much.
Maddox made his WWE debut in late 2012 as a referee who went rogue when he cost Ryback the WWE Championship in the main event of Hell in a Cell. Although he was taken out of commission a few short weeks later, he continued to make appearances on programming demanding a Superstar contract, though he was often squashed by the likes of Randy Orton, The Great Khali, Brodus Clay and others.
Meanwhile down in NXT, he was doing color commentary every other week with Tony Dawson. His mic skills teetered on the line between being bad and passable, but he did well for himself on the January 16, 2013 edition of Main Event and seemed to have a future in announcing. Unfortunately, we were all deceived.
The former Raw GM spent too much time behind the booth trying to be funny when all he was, was bothersome to listen to. He was pulled off commentary to fully focus on his authoritative duties in the summer of 2013, which wasn't much better.
2. Ernest Miller
If you can't recall Ernest "The Cat" Miller's commentary tenure, it was more of a "blink and you missed it" kind of thing, thankfully.
In the absence of Tazz at the November 26, 2002 SmackDown tapings, WWE raced to find a replacement, ultimately settling on Miller. He had recently returned to the company a mere month earlier and management wanted to experiment with him on the headset; however, they didn't know what they were getting themselves into.
As agile as he was, "The Cat" was never known for his talking ability, and he failed miserably. He had experience as an announcer in WCW, but even then he wasn't any good. Obviously, WWE didn't tune in to the final days of Nitro (much like most fans) to hear this for themselves.
On this fateful Thanksgiving night, he showed he wasn't up-to-date on the product, he didn't have a clue what he was talking about, and he had little to no chemistry with Michael Cole. Never before had fans longed for Tazz on commentary. In so many words, it was a disaster; yet, WWE made him the official color commentator of Velocity for a time in 2003 before releasing him from his contract the following year.
1. Booker T
As a professional wrestler and more importantly, as an entertainer, Booker T more than earned his place among the immortals in the WWE Hall of Fame when he was inducted in 2013. As an announcer, however, he was (and still is) the farthest thing from being legendary.
Booker T's return to WWE at the 2011 Royal Rumble event was met with much anticipation from fans hoping to see him back for an in-ring return. Despite lacing up his boots one last time for a few minutes in the Rumble match, his on-air role with WWE going forward wouldn't be as a wrestler but rather as an announcer.
He debuted as the newest addition to the SmackDown announce team on the Friday following the Rumble, immediately sending the message he had very little to no experience as a commentator. Fans cut him some slack at first, but when he didn't improve over time, it became clear that we were stuck with him for the long haul and that it was going to be one bumpy ride.
He hasn't added much to the Raw announce team since replacing Jerry Lawler earlier this year. You may find his classic catchphrases such as "Oh my goodness!" and "Shucky ducky, quack quack!" funny, but as an announcer, he was and still one of the worst wrestlers-turned-commentators of all-time.