10 Wrestling Matches That Were Way Better Than Anyone Expected
Pleasant surprises...
Wrestling is all about hype - from hard pushes to gentle exaggeration to outright lies, it's the job of the promoter (and, by extension, his employees) to make any given event seem like the biggest and most spectacular one ever. With that in mind, it's no surprise that so many shows and matches fail to live up to the expectations that have been set.
At the same time, though, fans aren't sheep, and we've learned to see through some of the smoke and mirrors that accompany the coming of a major event. We can draw our own conclusions about which stars deliver in the ring and which don't, and that plays into what we expect when purchasing a show or a ticket.
The flipside, then, is that there are also matches that exceed our expectations. Sometimes the stars involved get past silly stipulations, unknown variables, or their own perceived limitations to deliver contests that impress the viewing public - maybe even to the point of achieving immortality as classics.
This list looks at just a few of those bouts that surprised us all, proving that the wrestlers involved were capable of that magic. Here are 10 matches that were way better than anyone expected:
10. John Cena Vs. The Great Khali - One Night Stand 2007
The semi-immobile Great Khali had a reputation for being a terrible worker that preceded him to WWE. Sure enough, when he did debut, even the legendary Undertaker could barely drag a watchable match out of him. Khali continued to stink up the ring throughout 2006 and 2007 before entering into a WWE Championship feud with John Cena.
The two first clashed at Judgment Day, where Cena managed to fell the giant and apply the STF to secure a submission victory. However, Khali's foot was under the bottom rope at the time, meaning that the match should have continued. That bout - which was actually one of Khali's better WWE encounters itself - set the stage for a falls count anywhere match at One Night Stand.
In the rematch, Cena managed to carry Khali to what was easily the best bout of his entire career, brawling through the crowd and up onto the stage. Finally, Cena hit an Attitude Adjustment off of a crane for the pinfall, shocking fans who thought Khali would drag the champ down with him.
9. AJ Styles Vs. Shane McMahon - WrestleMania 33
Shane McMahon can be a polarizing character for wrestling fans, but even the most ardent Shane defenders were let down by his match with The Undertaker at WrestleMania 32. "'he Boy Wonder's' first bout in seven years, that Hell in a Cell contest saw McMahon (and his awkward-looking offense) portrayed as the equal of 'The Phenom'. Undertaker's win put a merciful end to the contest.
McMahon looked even worse in his next contest, a Raw versus SmackDown match at Survivor Series that saw him beat Chris Jericho to a pulp with reckless punches. When rumors began to swirl in early 2017 that Shane would likely be wrestling AJ Styles at WrestleMania, fans were annoyed on behalf of 'The Phenomenal One', who had been WWE's MVP in 2016.
Thankfully, some smoke and mirrors - and the immense talent of Styles - managed to lead to quite a good opener at WrestleMania 33. Carefully planned spots (like McMahon catching a Styles 450 Splash with a triangle choke) made the match feel exciting, and when Styles eventually did win with the Phenomenal Forearm, his victory felt well earned.
8. Chris Jericho Vs. Ricky Steamboat, Jimmy Snuka, And Roddy Piper - WrestleMania 25
After taking exception with Mickey Rourke and the film The Wrestler, Chris Jericho decided to take his frustrations out on retired stars - namely Ricky Steamboat, Jimmy Snuka, and Roddy Piper. At the behest of Ric Flair, Jericho accepted a match with the three men, but it felt like a waste of Y2J at the grandest event of the year.
The bout was an elimination match, and Jericho quickly and unceremoniously eliminated Snuka and Piper - both of whom looked absolutely terrible. The real surprise, however, came when Y2J and Steamboat locked horns. 'The Dragon' was one of the best athletes in wrestling during his heyday, but the 56-year-old hadn't competed in a match since suffering a back injury 15 years earlier. Nevertheless, Steamboat stunned fans with an incredible performance, outworking almost everyone else on the show.
Jericho ultimately defeated Steamboat with the Codebreaker, but the former NWA World Heavyweight Champion was the real winner. He actually parlayed the performance into a brief comeback, and would wrestle Jericho in a singles match the following month at Backlash.
7. The Undertaker Vs. Shawn Michaels - WrestleMania XXVI
Fans expected Shawn Michaels and The Undertaker to deliver one of the best matches in wrestling history at WrestleMania 25, and they managed to exceed expectations with an encounter that still defies description. Michaels took Undertaker to the limit, but in the end, 'The Phenom' made sure that the streak remained intact.
The next year, the same fans were excited when Michaels challenged 'Taker to a rematch, but there was an understanding that it would be hard for the men to repeat history. Undertaker was only getting more and more banged up with every passing year, and this time, Michaels - who had spent much of 2009 on the shelf - was also in questionable health. The added no disqualification and "career versus streak" stipulations looked like a way of compensating for physical shortcomings.
Nevertheless, the two men went to war once again, and though this encounter was substantially shorter than their first match, it was every bit the equal of the WrestleMania 25 bout. Once again, Michaels threw everything he had at Undertaker, but not in a way that felt repetitive or excessive. When Undertaker finally told Michaels to stay down (in a scene reminiscent of Ric Flair's retirement match two years earlier), then hit him with a jumping Tombstone, another all-time classic had been written.
6. Money In The Bank - WrestleMania 21
These days, the Money in the Bank ladder match is a staple of WWE's calendar, and fans have seen several iterations of the match, both good and bad. Back when Chris Jericho first introduced the concept in 2005, though, it was a complete unknown. Fans had seen one-on-one ladder matches before, and the series of TLC bouts that came in the early 2000s added more players to the equation, but this would be the first time six men entered such a match with every man fighting only for himself.
Would there simply be too many people involved, making the whole thing a mess? Would the lack of a teamwork factor damage the psychology of the bout? It turned out that any worries were quickly put to rest. The fighting was intense, with strange alliances being formed in the heat of the moment and the number of competitors assuring that there were no breaks in the action. In the end, the bout was such a success that it became a tradition, and then a pay-per-view event.
Of course, having guys like Shelton Benjamin, Chris Jericho, Christian, and Edge in the match didn't hurt, either.
5. Roman Reigns Vs. Randy Orton - SummerSlam 2014
Most fans remember SummerSlam 2014 for Brock Lesnar's main event obliteration of John Cena, but there was arguably something even more significant on the undercard - Roman Reigns's first major one-on-one pay-per-view match.
After the breakup of The Shield in June, Seth Rollins and Dean Ambrose began feuding with one another while Reigns was seemingly bumped straight into the main event. For a couple of months that meant that he was involved in multiple-man matches for the WWE Title, but he soon began feuding with The Authority - and specifically the unit's golden boy, Randy Orton. That led to a singles match between the two at SummerSlam.
Reigns had proven himself a dynamic presence in tag team matches, but could he handle a long singles bout - and against Randy Orton, who's decidedly hit or miss in such situations? It turned out there was nothing to worry about, as the two men delivered a bout that, while not quite at "classic" level, was a great piece of wrestling action.
Reigns kicked out of an RKO and ultimately won with the Spear, but more importantly, he showed just how talented he was. It's been a rough three years in terms of his usage, but he's certainly always game for a great contest.
4. Kazuchika Okada Vs. Tetsuya Naito - NJPW 40th Anniversary Show
Kazuchika Okada's upset of Hiroshi Tanahashi for the IWGP Heavyweight Title in 2012 was certainly shocking, but it didn't necessary change the overall perception of 'The Rainmaker'. The 24-year-old was still considered an amazing up-and-comer, but seeing as how his exciting win came over a miracle worker like 'The High-Flying Star', there was no guarantee that Okada was ready to truly carry the company by himself.
The real test for 'The Rainmaker' would come in his first title defense, when he put the belt on the line against Tetsuya Naito - who, at the time, was another exciting young star with limited experience in the main event. The match between the two was signed for New Japan Pro Wrestling's 40th Anniversary Show.
Those who doubted Okada were silenced by the match, which got unanimous praise and was considered by many analysts to be one of the top bouts of the year. Okada, who won with the Rainmaker in just under 29 minutes, showed great confidence as champion, proving that he was up to the task of supplanting Tanahashi as NJPW's ace. Five years later, it's little wonder 'The Rainmaker' is the best in the world.
3. The Rock Vs. Kurt Angle - No Way Out 2001
Kurt Angle proved he was a pro wrestling prodigy in 2000, wowing fans with his performances and winning a host of titles - including the WWE Championship. Unfortunately, for all his talent, his booking left something to be desired, as even an Olympic Gold Medal wasn't enough to pull him out of the "undeserving heel champion" role. It was clear that his first title run was something of a flop.
By early 2001, there was no question that the real money for WrestleMania was in one more showdown between Steve Austin and The Rock, and so when Angle was announced as defending the WWE Title against 'The Great One' at No Way Out, the result seemed a foregone conclusion - surely the jingoistic clown would fall to WWE's top star.
The Rock did ultimately beat Angle for the belt, but it was in a far better match than anyone expected. Prior to No Way Out, Angle started exhibiting a ruthless mean streak that gave his character a more serious tone, and it served him well during the match with The Rock. Angle tried to break Rock's leg with his brand-new Ankle Lock submission hold, and even kicked out of the Rock Bottom and People's Elbow. Finally, another Rock Bottom put an end to Angle's reign - and one hell of a contest.
2. Brock Lesnar Vs. John Cena Vs. Seth Rollins - Royal Rumble 2015
When Brock Lesnar returned to WWE in 2012, his first match back came against a very game John Cena. The two had one of the most brutal matches in recent company history, with blood and danger aplenty. Two years later, they met at SummerSlam, and fans were left equally shocked by just how one-sided Lesnar's rout of Cena was.
There were expectations of a third classic between the men at the 2015 Royal Rumble, but when The Authority added Seth Rollins to the bout, it looked to screw up the dynamic. After all, as the two most-protected men in the company, Cena and Lesnar gave the match a "big-fight" feel, but Rollins - for all his talent - was playing an undeserving weasel. It looked like a mistake.
There was no reason to fret. Seth Rollins - who pulled out all of the stops in possibly his best WWE performance - was the perfect addition to the match, playing a spoiler for both Cena and Lesnar and nearly stealing victory on more than one occasion. 'The Architect' nearly took Brock out of the match after an elbow drop through the announcers' table, but 'The Beast' came back to pin Rollins, ending a wild brawl.
1. Cactus Jack Vs. Randy Orton - Backlash 2004
The feud between retired hardcore icon Mick Foley and 'The Legend Killer' Randy Orton was built quite well in the early months of 2004, but seemed to hit a snag at WrestleMania XX. At that show, Foley and The Rock teamed up in a loss to Orton, Batista, and Ric Flair that felt like an anticlimactic waste of talent.
Orton was pleased that he had pinned Foley, but the legend was there to rain on his parade, reminding him that he beat a retired author. If Orton really wanted to prove himself, he'd take on Cactus Jack in a hardcore match at Backlash. It was a tall order, but Orton accepted.
The excitement of seeing Cactus Jack back in the ring gave way to skepticism when fans realized that it had been four years since Foley's last major match, and that Orton didn't have any classic outings to his credit. Still, the two men made magic, with Foley and Orton both taking a beating en route to Orton going over in war - à la Triple H at the 2000 Royal Rumble. Foley made Orton that night, and there's no doubt that Orton's performance played a major role in his becoming World Heavyweight Champion four months later.