10 Wrestling Pay Per View Concepts That Didn't Catch On
Battlebowl probably seemed like a good idea at the time...
It seems like every second wrestling pay-per-view comes with a concept these days. We've already had the Royal Rumble and Elimination Chamber in 2017, and with Extreme Rules just a couple of months away, it won't be long until we're on to the next one.
Shows like Money In The Bank and Hell In A Cell are typically the only places you can see the event's titular stipulation within a calendar year. WWE have a tendency to overdo it (three HIAC matches in one night was a bit much last year), but the gimmicks at least help the shows feel special, and it allows them to stand-out from faceless shows like Battleground and Fastlane.
Dozens of pay-per-view concepts have come and gone over the decades. Some, like Survivor Series and the Rumble, have stood the test of time to become important parts of the wrestling year. A huge number have been consigned to the past, however, and wrestling history is littered with gimmick PPVs that just didn't last.
The pay-per-views themselves entirely bad, but for various reasons, none were able to hold the wrestling world's attention for very long.
10. WWE Fatal 4-Way
WWE’s obsession with branding their pay-per-views with a specific gimmick peaked in 2010. Concepts like Hell In A Cell and Tables, Ladders, and Chairs have become an accepted part of the company’s annual schedule, but Fatal 4-Way is still the most mundane PPV concept WWE have ever had.
There’s nothing wrong with a good Fatal Four-Way, but there’s nothing particularly special about them either. HIAC and TLC matches should at least guarantee higher risks and an elevated sense of danger, but Four-Ways are as bog standard as it gets. Building an entire show around them was a daft idea, and left fans wondering if other equally riveting events like “WWE: Singles Match” were right around the corner.
The show itself featured three Four-Ways for the Divas, World Heavyweight, and WWE Championships. Each of those titles changed hands, but none of the show’s titular matches were anything more than average - and a filler Evan Bourne vs. Chris Jericho singles match was comfortably the evening’s best contest.
The highlight of the night was the fans chanting the recently dismissed Daniel Bryan’s name as the show went off the air, capping a hugely forgettable night, and a PPV concept WWE would never revisit.
9. NWA Bunkhouse Stampede
The Bunkhouse Stampede started life as an annual tournament held by Jim Crockett Promotions in 1985. Devised as a means of drawing attention back to JCP amidst increased competition from the WWF, it was a battle royal style match in which the wrestlers competed in blue jeans and cowboy boots, and weapon use was encouraged.
The stipulation was given its own pay-per-view event in 1988 - and it was a complete trainwreck. Featuring a torturous bore draw between Nikita Koloff and Bobby Eaton and a Barry Windham vs. Larry Zbyszko stalling festival, it was a real struggle to get through. The 30-minute Bunkhouse Stampede main event failed to turn it around.
Eight wrestlers were locked inside a steel cage for this particular Stampede, with the objective being to eliminate opponents by throwing them out the door or over the top of the structure. It was a chaotic, convoluted dud of a match with next to nothing in the way of actual wrestling, and the finish was a debacle: The Barbarian scaled the cage for absolutely no reason whatsoever, Dusty Rhodes knocked him off, and that was that.
The concept failed on every level, and the building wasn't even half full. Fortunately, this was the last time any company attempted a Bunkhouse Stampede PPV.
8. The Wrestling Classic
While WrestleMania 1 took place several months prior, The Wrestling Classic was WWE’s first ever pay-per-view. 'Mania only ever aired on closed circuit television, so really, The Classic was the true starting point for wrestling’s PPV revolution.
The show presented a single-night, 16-man single elimination tournament, with no fewer than 15 individual matches taking place across the two-and-a-half-hour runtime. A wrestling-centric show, you’d think, but no: The Wrestling Classic featured just 65 minutes of wrestling in total, and none of the matches broke ten minutes.
Most of the contests ran for about three minutes, which is obviously nowhere near enough time to tell a compelling story. As a result, The Wrestling Classic was a rushed mess of an event, and with three matches lasting less than a minute, it was impossible to get into.
The Classic was a flop, but the WWF attempted to revise the single show tournament format at WrestleMania IV. Predictably, that show was a complete disaster, too, and while WWE have ran multiple tournament-themed shows since then, the idea of blazing through a 16-man tournament in one sitting died a long time ago.
7. WWE Capitol Punishment
As far as PPV concepts go, Capitol Punishment was as flimsy as it gets. The pantomime worlds of wrestling and politics have continually come together over the past few decades, but basing a whole PPV on political humour was a terrible mistake. Taking place in Washington, DC in June 2011, the show was peppered with horrendous comedy segments featuring an unconvincing Barack Obama impersonator, culminating in him doing Spinaroonies with Booker T.
The show itself wasn’t particularly exciting, though there were a handful of good matches in CM Punk vs. Rey Mysterio, Dolph Ziggler vs. Kofi Kingston, and Randy Orton vs. Christian. WWE even did a great job with their Washington-themed set design, but let’s be honest: a PPV headlined by John Cena vs. R-Truth was never going to set the world on fire.
WWE decided against following-up on Capitol Punishment, and with Linda McMahon currently serving on Donald Trump’s cabinet, we definitely won’t be seeing another show like this in the next four to eight years. Few fans had anything positive to say about the political skits at the time, and re-watching them in 2017 only amplifies their stupidity.
The whole event reeked of an excuse for the Republican-leaning McMahon family to poke fun at the Democrat president, and the concept was needless.
6. WWE Bragging Rights
Inter-brand competition is almost completely non-existent in WWE’s current state, but WWE at least attempted to promote it during the original brand split. Having used SmackDown vs. Raw as the premise for several years worth of video games, WWE decided to cash-in and transition it onscreen in 2009.
Theoretically, Bragging Rights was the only time WWE fans could see red and blue wrestlers competing against each other. That was the unique selling point, but the shows themselves were pretty lacklustre. Neither 2009 nor 2010 actually featured a Raw vs. SD match in the main event, and escalating apathy towards the brand split curbed fan interest in Bragging Rights. It flopped as a concept, and the brand split was completely done away with the following year.
Perhaps Bragging Rights would have fared better, had it came about earlier in the brand split when fans were still excited about the split rosters. Regardless, WWE did the event a disservice by presenting just three inter-brand matches in 2009, and one the following year.
There has been little to no talk of reviving the PPV for the current brand split. If the previous two shows are anything to go by, this is a good thing.
5. WWE Breaking Point
Like Fatal 4-Way and Capitol Punishment, Breaking Point was a pay-per-view gimmick that WWE ran only once before realising it was a flawed concept. Taking place in September 2009, it was actually a pretty decent show all-round. Highlighted by a tremendous John Cena vs. Randy Orton WWE Title match, it’d be a stretch to call Breaking Point one of WWE’s best PPVs that year, but it was nowhere near as awful as some of the shows on this list.
The show’s gimmick just didn’t work. Every major match was given a submission-based stipulation, and the show featured an I Quit match, a Submission Count Anywhere tag match, and CM Punk and The Undertaker’s World Heavyweight Title Submission Match. The latter was particularly bad, with WWE pulling a Montreal Screwjob-esque finish (in Montreal, of course) by having Teddy Long restart proceedings following a legitimate submission.
There are only so many stories you can tell within the confines of a submission-based match, and WWE drained the well at Breaking Point. They forced a bunch of wrestlers not at all known for their technical expertise into stipulations that didn’t suit them, and while the quality wasn’t atrocious, the show was poorly received.
4. WCW Battlebowl
Battlebowl was the bane of many a WCW fan’s existence in the early ‘90s.
Debuting at Starrcade 1991, it was a Lethal Lottery-esque system in which a handful of randomly-drawn tag teams competed for the right to fight in the actual Battlebowl (and over-the-top elimination battle royal) itself. Winners advanced, losers did not, and one man would stand victorious at the end of the evening.
The matches stunk and completely derailed Starrcade ‘91 and ‘92, but WCW weren’t dissuaded. They granted the gimmick its own self-titled pay-per-view in 1993, and while the show-closing battle royal was fun, the setup matches were dreadful. Few of the thrown-together teams had any chemistry whatsoever, and while the likes of Ric Flair and Cactus Jack tried their hardest to raise the bar, they couldn’t pull it off.
Vader won the event, but there was no tangible prize. He was WCW Champion at the time, and with no rewards announced prior to the event, the conclusion was flat and pointless. Having someone else eliminate Vader could have at least been used to set up an eventual title match, but no. WCW got nothing out of this event, and while the Battlebowl match was revisited against three years later, the PPV itself fell by the wayside.
3. WWE December To Dismember
For many ECW loyalists, December To Dismember was the night on which the final remains of Paul Heyman’s iconic promotion were laid to rest.
With December To Dismember, Vince McMahon took the last vestiges of ECW’s legacy and threw them straight into the trash. The show featured a seemingly endless stream of low blows against the company, its fans, and Heyman himself.
The ECW revival was always a bad idea, of course. WWE completely sterilised everything that made the original company special, and while One Night Stand 2005 was an excellent idea (and an even better show), December to Dismember was the polar opposite. It was safe, clean, sanitised: everything that ECW wasn’t, and it soon put an end to WWE’s idea of producing more ECW-specific pay-per-views.
The concept of promoting ECW PPVs with a different feel to the product found on Raw and SmackDown was a solid idea - but WWE did nothing to differentiate it from their mainline shows. The ECW brand became “Raw Lite” shortly after debuting, and December to Dismember was the final nail in the coffin. The brand endured, but the ECW PPV concept died almost immediately.
WWE did away with brand-specific pay-per-views entirely a few months later.
2. WWE Taboo Tuesday
Taboo Tuesday was the second time WWE had experimented with the viability of hosting a pay-per-view on a Tuesday night rather than the traditional Sunday. The first experiment (1991’s This Tuesday In Texas) produced a small buyrate and immediately put plans for more mid-week PPVs on the back burner. WWE obviously thought enough time had passed by 2004, when the first Taboo Tuesday was held.
As well as experimenting with the time slot, Taboo Tuesday was born from a desire to increase the level of interaction between WWE and their fanbase. Thus, fans were given the opportunity to influence things like stipulations and match participants through an interactive poll - but they rarely had a substantial impact on the matches themselves. The validity of these polls was always highly questionable, and while giving the fans an increased say should have drummed up extra interest, it clearly didn’t work.
Both Taboo Tuesdays (2004 & 2005) were among WWE’s least-watched pay-per-views of the year, and the Tuesday night concept was deemed a failure. The show was renamed Cyber Sunday, and survived all the way to 2008, when it was eventually replaced by Bragging Rights.
If anything, Taboo Tuesday's failings only emphasised that Sunday night PPVs are an unbreakable wrestling tradition.
1. Heroes Of Wrestling
Heroes Of Wrestling must have seemed like an amazing idea at the time.
It was 1999, and wrestling was hotter than ever. With the WWF in the ascendency and WCW on the decline, a promoter named Bill Stone thought he’d cash in on the soaring market and wrestling’s longstanding obsession with nostalgia. His vision was to collect dozens of wrestling stars from the 1980s and early 1990s then book them against each other in a series of dream matches, with quarterly shows planned if Heroes Of Wrestling hit an initial target of 40,000 buys.
Unfortunately for Stone, what transpired was the consensus worst wrestling event of all time. The show fell 11,000 short of its target buyrate, and was dogged by bad production values, worse commentary, and calamitous matches. Nikolai Volkoff and The Iron Sheik vs. The Bushwhackers was a legitimate minus five star match, Yokozuna was so huge he could barely walk to the ring, and Jake Roberts showed-up blackout drunk, cut an incomprehensible promo, and disgraced himself during the main event.
The concept was shelved immediately, but perhaps it was inevitable. Nostalgia only goes so far, and sometimes, the stars of the past are best kept in their respective eras. The vast majority of Heroes’ performers were years removed from their prime, and only 2 Cold Scorpio and Julio Fantastico looked anything like their old selves.
It’s a show that every wrestling fan should go out of their way to watch once in their lifetime, but as a concept, Heroes Of Wrestling was a beautiful disaster.