10 WWE Gimmicks That Pushed The PG Era To Its Limits

Cult leaders, gangbangers, bunny boilers and booty shakers...

By Jamie Kennedy /

WWE.com

This past Sunday marked a full 10 years since WWE systematically stripped (intentional) blood from the product, instructed female performers to actually wear some clothes to the ring, cut most of the bad language from promos and officially went headfirst into a new dawn of PG certification.

Advertisement

Since that bold new direction started on the 22 July 2008 episode of SmackDown, the promotion's own guidelines have repeatedly wobbled despite a conscious effort to appease major shareholders, and there's even been hints of the old Attitude slipping through from time to time. How else could cult-leading psychopaths, homicidal siblings, racists or thieving gangbanger stereotypes be explained?

At times, the PG Era has delved into Vince Russo territory, and that risqué characterisation has stretched the current child-friendly protocol to its limits.

Advertisement

This isn't necessarily a bad thing, because some flexibility was always going to be needed in an industry like pro wrestling. Still, it's been fascinating to watch WWE occasionally dip a toe into provocative, smutty or controversial waters when they're supposed to be aimed squarely at young children.

Shake that booty and eat your cereal is one hell of a message...

Advertisement

10. Adam Rose (Party Animal)

WWE.com

On the surface, Adam Rose was no different to current dancing fool No Way José. He liked to party, hang out with fun-loving friends and attack well-meaning mascots for upstaging him during matches. OK, so José hasn't done that bit, not yet anyway.

Advertisement

Look beyond the smiling, easy-going demeanour of Rose and there was one clear influence for the character: often controversial English comedian Russell Brand. Everything about Rose's appearance and personality, from long flowing hair and quirky accent, to free-loving outlook and outlandish dress sense makes it clear he took inspiration from Brand's lifestyle.

The comedian, who went on to cite transcendental meditation as helpful in breaking his drug addictions, has been arrested 12 times for drug-related issues in the past. That's a rather controversial inspiration for a WWE gimmick created during the PG Era, but it happened.

Advertisement

Was Rose a child-friendly party-lover who kids could gravitate to, or was he a drug-addled rockstar wannabe who had touches of deranged cult leader about him? You decide.

9. R-Truth (Heavy Smoker)

WWE.com

"Would somebody please think of the children?"

Advertisement

Those were the words of one female fan on the 18 April 2011 edition of Raw when R-Truth attacked then-tag partner John Morrison and sparked up a cigarette live on air. His actions were a surprise. Smoking had barely been seen (if at all) during WWE's Attitude heyday, so it was shocking to watch someone proudly puff away on a PG show.

Later, Truth's love of cigs was played into his matches. For a brief spell, he'd wheeze away and take water breaks after fast-moving sequences or big moves. The whole thing was bizarre, didn't fit in with the kid-friendly portfolio WWE had worked so hard to present and seemed to glorify smoking culture.

Advertisement

Elsewhere on WWE programming, fans had grown accustomed to John Cena's childish antics, Santino Marella's goofy comedy and superhero-like masked characters like Sin Cara. It was a marked departure from that presentation when Truth whipped out the Marlboro, lit up and violently assaulted Morrison as he merrily toked.

8. Jinder Mahal (Victim Of Racism)

WWE.com

Attention, wrestling writers: racism never works, and it hasn't been an effective heat seeker since the 1980s.

Advertisement

That won't stop promotions from trying, and WWE are especially guilty of relying on nationalities, skin colour or religious beliefs to provoke prejudice. The latest example was Jinder Mahal, and it made the new WWE Champ look like a modern update of Attitude Era flop Tiger Ali Singh; that's not a favourable comparison.

Throughout his 170 days with the title, it wasn't uncommon to see Jinder stand proudly with The Singh Brothers and claim he was the victim of racism from North American bigots who hated the fact he had done so well for himself whilst wearing a turban or being proud of his Indian heritage.

Advertisement

The main problem here was that few despised Mahal for flaunting his ancestry. No, they hated him because the xenophobic mantra was boring, uninspiring and had been done to death. The result was a gimmick that insulted the audience and tried to paint innocent fans as racist morons (something that wouldn't fit in with WWE's corporate profile) in 2018.

7. The New Day (Booty Shaking Funsters)

WWE.com

Original plans for The New Day called for them to be a happy-go-lucky trio who proudly paraded black gospel roots. When fans rejected the group as babyfaces, they turned heel and began revelling in the heat they were getting for being so overboard. Somehow, that led to organic cheers and New Day turned face again.

Advertisement

That's when Kofi Kingston and Big E started shaking their asses like there were ants in their pants, Big E began spanking opponents during matches and Xavier Woods delighted in making more sexual innuendos than the old Carry On movies.

In just a few months, New Day went from proud African-Americans to booty-shaking, dick-joke-making funsters who sold cereal called "Booty-O's". Work that one out.

Advertisement

Lord only knows what parents sitting down to watch WWE programming with their young kids must think when Big E gyrates his crotch, shakes his booty, licks his hand before spanking other wrestlers mid-ring or the group tease making male genitalia out of fruit. Seriously.

6. CM Punk (Jesus Wannabe)

WWE.com

This entry almost belonged solely to Jeff Hardy, because it was he who raised the ire of CM Punk in 2009 and facilitated Punk's change from straight edge babyface to preacher with a God complex. After all, it was Jeff's much-publicised problems with drugs and alcohol that formed the basis for Punk's arrogant promos.

Advertisement

Think about that: a top babyface in the PG Era was touted as a drug addict, and it was explained away by announcers as the behaviour of a "charismatic enigma".

Still, it was Punk who brought Hardy's issues up on television, and it was he who chastised him for leading a lifestyle so reliant on prescription medication. Meanwhile, young fans in the audience looked on confused by what Punk was talking about, and must have later wondered why he was pouring alcohol away by the bottle in-ring.

Advertisement

Punk's outspoken hate of Hardy's life choices or habits wouldn't have been so shocking pre-PG, but they stood out when WWE were promoting such a family-friendly product.

5. Matt Hardy (Jealous Brother Turned Attempted Murderer)

WWE.com

Though 2009 wasn't the first time WWE had experimented with a Hardy vs. Hardy storyline, their latest attempt did take things a lot further than previous examples. In '09, Matt admitted that he had burned down Jeff's house, and that came after he'd owned up to running Jeff's car off the road and almost killing him.

Advertisement

Nice.

There was nothing PG about one brother conceding that he had tried to murder his family and even holding aloft a dog collar that belonged to Jeff; Jeff's dog had perished in the aforementioned fire, and it was pinned on Matt. He hated his younger sibling so much that he'd happily kill family pets to make a point.

Advertisement

This was quite the shift from the veteran babyface character Matt had been playing as ECW Champion. Sure, WWE needed something big to explain why he was suddenly supposed to be a major player on SmackDown, and yet there was surely another way to go about that without casting Matt as a psychopathic killer.

4. Jack Swagger & Zeb Colter (Racist Xenophobes)

WWE.com

Almost like he was predicting future US President Donald Trump's policies, the out-of-touch character of Zeb Colter bemoaned immigration when he debuted in 2013. Specifically, Colter took issue with (what he deemed) illegal immigrants coming over the United States border, and he regularly lectured fans on keeping their country pure.

Advertisement

That irked right-wing political commentator Glenn Beck, who was furious at seeing Tea Partiers miscast in an industry he clearly didn't have much time for anyway. His negative coverage of the story was so strong it later forced WWE to release a kayfabe-shattering video justifying Colter's character.

The truth is that old Zeb was so good at playing the zealot that his wordy promos and talk of real-world issues stood out from usual wrestling storylines. Further, it was rather weird to see WWE try their hand at such a political storyline and fit it snugly into a PG environment.

Advertisement

It wasn't long before WWE changed direction, softened Colter from borderline racist to patriotic old man and eventually turned both he and Swagger babyface. Their characterisation had hoped to stir feelings in politically active fans; a strange tactic when aimed at kids.

3. Cryme Tyme (Gangbangers)

WWE.com

At least Colter and Swagger weren't stealing Lita's panties and trying to sell them off to the highest bidder live on pay-per-view.

Advertisement

That was Cryme Tyme's gig. JTG and Shad Gaspard were akin to characters ripped right out of Rockstar's GTA: San Andreas, and they proudly bragged about all the "swag" they'd stolen from other roster members. In other words, Cryme Tyme were stereotypical black gangbangers who revelled in breaking the law.

Such cliched antics may have been fine when the team debuted in 2006 (except, well, they weren't), but they continued to act like gangsters well after the July 2008 cut off point for that kind of Attitude. In an era now obsessed with appeasing corporate sponsors, it was amazing to see WWE continue on with characters who were, for all intents and purposes, supposed to be hood rats.

Advertisement

Although Cryme Tyme did become less about gang and gun culture before splitting in 2010, it's still true that they were a controversial hangover act from one era into the next. "We're bringing the hood to you" indeed.

2. Bray Wyatt (Psychopathic Cult Leader)

WWE.com

One popular explanation for Bray Wyatt's character is that he's a take off of Robert De Niro's Max Cady in the 1991 flick Cape Fear. There are parallels to Cady's violent mood swings and psychopathic behaviour, but Wyatt's presentation also shared immediate comparisons to a much more frightening (and real) person.

Advertisement

He looked and talked just like 1960's/70's cult leader Charles Manson.

Bray's bizarre grip over his Wyatt Family charges like Luke Harper, Erick Rowan and later Braun Strowman reeked of Manson's own powerful hold on his Manson Family followers. Charles often spoken in interviews with the same cryptic, self-assured and almost-babbling delivery Bray has perfected in promos too.

Advertisement

Taking inspiration from someone linked to nine murders and initially sentenced to death when WWE are aimed at children is bold. There's no doubt Bray's character and his Wyatt Family gimmick are based on Manson's own creepy commune and unhinged conduct.

1. AJ Lee (Bunny Boiler)

WWE.com

Shortly after being jilted by Daniel Bryan and blamed for his embarrassing World Heavyweight Title defeat to Sheamus at WrestleMania XXVIII, AJ Lee developed a mentally unstable character that purposefully messed with male minds. In effect, she became what the urban dictionary would describe as a "bunny boiler".

Advertisement

Over the span of the next few years, Lee toyed with Bryan, CM Punk, John Cena, Kane and Dolph Ziggler. Her involvement with each man wasn't typical; instead of playing second fiddle to her lovers, AJ manipulated them with freakish behaviour and played them against one another.

It was a brave character, especially when the product was supposed to be strictly PG and WWE knew young girls would be watching.

Advertisement

In fairness to Lee, she excelled in the role and somehow appeared as a powerful, independent women despite always being attached to male superstars. That wasn't a given. Not just anybody could have played the gimmick so effectively or skirted the fine line between good taste and offensive characterisation with such ease.

-

Advertisement

What other PG Era characters do you think have pushed boundaries, and why? Let us know down in the comments section below!