10 WWE Legends That Require A Career Reevaluation
Are Kane & The Undertaker REALLY Showstoppers, Icons and Main Eventers?
Received wisdom is a rather gross reality of professional wrestling analysis.
Fans form opinions based on all sorts; the time they got into watching, recency bias and favouritism to performers based on deep-rooted emotional connections often beyond explanation. When shared - particularly by enough loud voices on the internet - these connections become an accepted truth instead of a reasoned view alone.
It's why Dave Meltzer gets grief more for how he rates New Japan Pro Wrestling matches than how he rants on subjects he's not qualified to speak on. People that don't even watch the product nor read his output make assumptions that he's biased because of other things they've read. One ill-informed take reflects the other and the circle of confusion continues in earnest.
The floodgates of public opinion flew open as social media took over the old methods of internet reporting - fans are no longer "internet fans in their Mom's basement" so much as the are plugged-in and engaged influencers on a constantly evolving product.
More than any other crew, the current crop of performers are held to entirely different standards than wrestlers from years gone by. Those stars - for better and worse - may warrant a rethink...
10. Jeff Jarrett
What is it about wrestling fans that make them favour the bosses, rather than the workers?
The infamous "Jeff Jarrett held WWE up in 1999" story has for years painted 'Double J' as the robbing swine gleefully swindling a small fortune out of innocent po-faced promoter Vince McMahon on his last night. Laying down for Chyna before escaping out the side door to Nitro, swag-bag and Lone Ranger mask in-tow.
The reality was far less dramatic - Jarrett had roughly calculated what he was owed as part of WWE's complex delayed pay system for the pay-per-views and live events he'd already worked. Furthermore, he took advantage of a contractual oversight on the company's part, not his own.
Jarrett was an at-times fabulous pro wrestler but an even better worker. He worked his way into an outstanding WCW deal after taking a small fortune from McMahon, then kickstarted his own promotion when he knew full well there was no chance of a job with the company following his misdemeanour.
The master of making a little bit more than he started with, Jarrett's one of the last of a breed of performers that knew the realities of the business they were in and exploited it as well as they possibly could.
9. Sable
The picture above this entry reflects WWE at their most exploitative in 1998. The story - in one image - of a product at it's most titillating but furthest away from the wrestling your parents watched, even if your Dad probably cast a wandering eye over when this sort of stuff made air.
The reason for it all was Sable. For all Sunny had incredible charisma and sensational pro wrestling instincts in 1996 and 1997, it was Rena Mero's rise in front of her husband Marc in 1998 that gave the product bonafide, mainstream-friendly sex appeal.
Sable had in spades, and it far outweighed the need for her to be good at much else. She's thus overly-criticised in post-script as a hanger-on, despite legitimately rivalling Stone Cold Steve Austin in popularity for much of his original tenure on top. She burned out incredibly fast after a 1999 fall-out with Vince McMahon, but she burned brighter than most performers from the main roster today.
A first-ballot Hall Of Famer if such ballots were actually A Thing, Sable's lack of interest in such plaudits perhaps best reflect how she ultimately won in the end. She got in, knew her worth, got out and lived (with Brock Lesnar) to tell the tale.
8. Sheamus
It took making Sheamus and Cesaro tag team partners for the lack of anything better to do to actually give both the spotlight they deserved in 2016, but the unit's done even more for the much-maligned 'Celtic Warrior' than the largely-loved 'Swiss Superman'.
Sheamus was rocket-strapped in 2009 when a shove on John Cena through a table won him the WWE Championship amidst rumours of a politically-motivated friendship with Triple H, and he struggled to shake off wider audience malaise in the years that followed. Worse was to come when - following an unwanted babyface turn - he beat Daniel Bryan at WrestleMania 28 in an 18-second squash that kickstarted two movements. One was an unrelenting charge of support behind the future of the loser, the other a critical mass of hatred piled on the supposed winner.
The great matches he assembled during this time were thus lost to disinterest and disdain from the 'WWE Universe' that did at least motivate his 2015 heel turn after an injury return. All still looked lost before 'The Bar', but he remains the only villain detestable enough to get Roman Reigns cheered during their troubled WWE Title trades.
7. Sid
The Justice/Vicious surnames were never quite as efficient as the 'Sycho' (sic) moniker he was afforded during his most successful WWE run in 1996/97, but it was Vince McMahon often accused of the condition every time he relied on the returning monster in spite of his chequered past.
Sid's punching technique never remotely advanced beyond bang-average, but the power of his fists didn't matter when the power of his fist-bumps were sending Madison Square Garden into an absolute frenzy against former favourite Shawn Michaels.
Treat yourself to International Incident: In Your House from July 1996 for hard evidence of how big a star the man briefly was. Fans go absolutely insane for his every (limited) move, and continued to for the remainder of the year up to and including his title win.
This wasn't McMahon blinded by biceps as was the case in 1992; this was The Chairman striking while the iron was white hot in hopes of flogging as many tickets as possible to his Alamo Dome overreach at January 1997's Royal Rumble. Sid and Shawn couldn't quite sell the ginormous building out with their rematch, but the violent and charismatic giant made the perfect foil for the hometown hero to strike gold a second time.
6. Ken Shamrock
'The World's Most Dangerous Man' was the industry's most obvious victim when the wrestling business attempted in vain to pick up the pieces left in the crossfire of the Monday Night War.
Parting ways with Vince McMahon just over two years after he signed on the dotted line, Shamrock luckily left a legacy during one of the more lucrative periods in company history. Though not a star of The Rock's magnitude nor a performer on par with Hulk Hogan, he keeps a spot reserved on the level below - remembered much in the same way your grandparent might ask you if The Undertaker's "still going". Not bad for a two-year run, but the man deserved more.
Tap-outs became commonplace under the auspices of the Shamrock ankle lock; one of several Mixed Martial Arts experimentations during the period he dominated the scene. The 'Lions Den' was their short-lived take on UFC's Octagon when that organisation still appeared niche rather than the multi-billion dollar venture it is today.
A genuine innovator, Shamrock deserves respect beyond the banter he generates laughing at old footage of him "snapping". No sophomore effort during the mid-2000s may have scuppered his Hall Of Fame chances, but the WWE Network offers means and methods for his work to be respected in other ways.
5. X-Pac
There was no point during his two spells with WWE that Sean 'X-Pac/1-2-3 Kid Waltman' wasn't an absolutely phenomenal wrestler, but badly outstaying his welcome (alongside much if the remaining features of the Attitude Era) post-2001 forever cast him as a dated and boring buffoon.
After wowing fans and friends backstage with his majestic skill in 1993, he was the locker room litmus test less than a year later. Newbies were given Waltman to work with to prove their worth, just as they were when he returned from WCW in 1998 decked in the green and black of D-Generation-X.
A fiercely reliable flyer on offence, he was an outstanding defensive performer too, scraping sympathy from the shoes of the sh*ttiest wrestlers to the point where his relatively short 1999 unit with Kane lingered long after they parted ways for the good of Triple H's heel turn later that year.
Watched out of the Invasion era vacuum, his Light Heavyweight Championship contests are a joy beyond the bored boos the battles receive. His act was a tragically busted flush by then, but his work between the ropes hadn't remotely lost its lustre.
4. Kevin Nash
The butt of jokes, disdain and derision for decades, Kevin Nash's legacy amongst many is that of a fortuitous f*ckhead, earing away at his employers for his own self-worth. The evidence for the prosecution is ostensibly vast but badly lacking in context.
He was a low-drawing champion during the industry's lowest-drawing period but was switched on outside of the bubble enough to understand what made his character so appealing in the first place when he pioneered the Sports Entertainment anti-hero role in early 1996. This skill can't be understated - he employed it again to reign in Hulk Hogan's silliness when it came time to establish the New World Order as something completely different to the wrestling norm. It was one he lacked when returning in 2011 as the spoiler of CM Punk's SummerSlam party, but black-gloved fingers are pointed wrongly if they're pointed towards 'Big Sexy' for the catastrophic demise of that storyline.
Scripting himself to end Goldberg's streak - an accusation he denies having actual control of - remains the most tricky to justify two decades after it occurred, but here goes; the fans go absolutely f*cking bananas for it. Kevin Nash knew how to get over and stay there. Few colleagues at the time had that skill so well mastered.
3. Dolph Ziggler
WWE really know what they're doing with the current Dolph Ziggler/Drew McIntyre partnership.
Following their electric Hell In A Cell victory over Dean Ambrose and Seth Rollins, the 'Scottish Psychopath' literally carried 'The Show Off' backstage, simply on the off chance that fans had missed how they'd been presented in every other aspect for the better part of a month. McIntyre is the project here, the designated success story, and the babyface turn at Dolph's expense will conclude the comparisons to Shawn Michaels and Diesel that were once, admittedly, laughable.
The references to 'HBK' and 'Big Daddy Cool' seemed like a rib because just about everything else linking Ziggler to 'The Showstopper' was. He set about calling himself "the greatest in-ring performer in the history of the company" whilst throwing his second-rate superkicks looking like a third-rate sexy boy. Either under instruction or of his own volition, Dolph was playing the tribute act well because his own career had gone up in smoke months earlier.
This latter-day run should serve him well, but it's just about all he really deserves. His last remaining fans may say he was an unappreciated all-timer, but carving out a serviceable midcard run over the last decade was perhaps his ceiling all along.
2. Santino Marella
In its own time, Santino Marella's comedy was seen as a breath of fresh air available to audiences gradually choking to death on the polluted state of WWE's mid-2000s output. Now a generation removed from the cult of 'The Cobra', much of it looks incredibly tired.
There were more complex reasons as to why so few new performers got over during a rather barren period for the company, but Santino's on-the-nose gags and on-the-throat finisher reflected how few stars genuinely broke through underneath so much lowest common denominator content.
His matches were of some value on house shows, but his work on television badly sagged after the 2007/08 heel peak of his career. No longer purpose-serving by the time he had no choice but to turn his japes on the heels, Santino was the selected star for what should still be considered the low ebb of women's wrestling in WWE.
2009's 'Miss WrestleMania Battle Royal' looked bad enough on paper that Trish Stratus and Lita both said No to an easy payday - the decision to award it to a dragged up 'Santina' completely vindicated their concern. The crop at the time weren't fortunate enough to gain permission to turn it down.
1. The Brothers Of Destruction
Expected to be the recipients of the most unlikely pro wrestling comeback match this decade, The Undertaker and Kane will be providing Shawn Michaels a base to bounce off of thanks to tenure rather than talent.
The most sacred of cows in 2018, the past several years of 'The Deadman's career have done much - rather fittingly - to bury a mid-2000s resurgence few predicted during the doldrums of the 'American Bad *ss' era. WrestleMania one-offs were at least enjoyable until he hit a Brock Lesnar brick wall in 2014. Returns haven't so much diminished but died, since.
On the other side of his hot tag, Kane's attentions have understandably been elsewhere over the past couple of years, but can anybody name a genuinely brilliant Kane contest outside of that time he dropped Albert with a hurricanrana in 2001?
And two wrongs have rarely made right, either. The Brothers Of Destruction were almost always deployed as thoughtless squash-merchants, with the quality of their work typically not up for analysis as long as fire and fireworks served as a dark distraction. As singles stars, their contributions are occasionally overstated, but as a doubles act they're quite possibly the most overrated.