10 WWE Stars Who Overcame Terrible Gimmicks

The people who got over with some of the worst ideas in the history of the business...

By Jack Morrell /

Right now, if you were to google €˜terrible gimmicks wrestling€™, your laptop would give you a sad look and start playing the piano melody from the end of the Incredible Hulk TV show. There have been so many articles on the subject over the years, with top tens, top twenties €“ top FIFTIES €“ that it€™s almost like googling €˜breasts€™: whatever you€™re actually after, the results will not help you. Professional wrestling is famous for its terrible gimmicks. They€™re supposed to help differentiate performers from each other €“ but in the cartoon era of wrestling during the majority of the 1980s and 1990s, there seemed to be a WWF wrestler portraying an amped up, mulleted version of every occupation under the sun. A cartoon wrestling plumber? Here€™s T.L. Hopper. A cartoon wrestling garbage collector? Say hi to Duke €˜The Dumpster€™ Droese. A cartoon wrestling sailor? Incredibly, The Shockmaster in WCW wasn€™t Fred Ottman€™s first awful gimmick: remember Tugboat? We didn€™t think so. So many good workers, sandbagged by horrific gimmicks €“ but wrestlers who€™ve managed to get over despite the dead end characters given to them by management, that€™s a whole other story. Without being repackaged as someone else, there are a variety of ways wrestlers have succeeded despite bad gimmicks: total, blinkered commitment in the role, even in the face of bafflement and ridicule; unwavering support from the office (rare, in these days of stop-start booking); or a gradual movement into something more realistic and in keeping with the performer€™s natural instincts€

10. The Honky Tonk Man Has Left The Building

Presented as a babyface with an Elvis impersonator gimmick in 1986, Roy Wayne Farris was never destined for megastardom €“ he was too limited in the ring, and too obnoxious behind the scenes. But €˜the Honky Tonk Man€™ was bad pro wrestling voodoo, even for WWF in the eighties. Whether it was a gag related to his family connections to Memphis wrestling legend Jerry €˜The King€™ Lawler (they€™re cousins), or whether the temptation of the classic gimmicked guitar was too much for Vince McMahon to resist, this character - complete with gimmick appropriate theme music - would ordinarily have been the kiss of low-to-mid-card death for any wrestler. Farris made it work, though: turning heel with a combination of carny street smarts, backstage politicking and just plain throwing himself into the role with charismatic gusto, the Honky Tonk Man managed to become the longest reigning Intercontinental champion in WWF/WWE history. Scuttlebutt (like gossip in a sequined jumpsuit) says that he managed to extend the lifespan of his title run by persuading the office that it was bad for business for him to drop the title too soon, and made the trick work just often enough to still be in the record books today.

9. More Lukewarm Than Stone Cold

€˜Stunning€™ Steven Austin got quite a lot of traction as a singles competitor in WCW after turning on partner Brian Pillman splitting the Hollywood Blonds: he lifted the United States title from €˜The Natural€™ Dustin Rhodes just after Christmas 1993, and held it for 240 days. That€™s not the longest run of all time, but it would be 2006 before someone came close to it again. Things went rapidly downhill from there, though. Eric Bischoff fired Austin over the phone while he was sidelined with a triceps injury, with Austin claiming it was because Bischoff didn€™t know what to do with him. He would work at ECW for a few months under the name of €˜Superstar€™ Steve Austin while he learned how to cut promos: he€™d shoot on WCW€™s mishandling of his career, figuring out his own €˜voice€™, Finally, he€™d sign to WWF in late 1995 as€ The Ringmaster. Yes, the WWF office actually tried to market the business€™s biggest ever star with a name worthy of a Z-level Spider-Man villain. There wasn€™t even a real concept to go with the name, and (thank God) no ridiculous costume. The worst thing was that they€™d partnered The Ringmaster with €˜The Million Dollar Man€™, Ted DiBiase, one of the greatest talkers and managers in the business. The future €˜Stone Cold€™ Steve Austin, the gobbiest anti-hero in pro wrestling, was, more or less, playing a mute. Austin himself saw the gimmick as a stepping-stone €“ a way into the company. He had bills to pay, and a family to support, and he reckoned he could make something work in WWF if he just had the opportunity to work on television. Fortunately for Austin, the Ringmaster gimmick would be phased out the following March, and the unnecessary mouthpiece DiBiase left for WCW the following May. The awful Ringmaster gimmick, such as it was, would indeed be Austin€™s foot in the door: a month after DiBiase left WWF, Austin was booked to win the King Of The Ring tournament. That€™s where he debuted the Stunner as his finishing move, improvised the Austin 3:16 promo and, with hindsight, ushered in the Attitude Era. The rest is professional wrestling history.

8. The Taxman Cometh

Mike Rotunda had worked in the WWF in the 1980s as part of a babyface tag team called the US Express, with his brother-in-law and future Four Horsemen founder, Barry Windham €“ but his greatest fame as a professional wrestler happened while under one of the most boring gimmicks ever created by anyone, anywhere. In 1991, returning to the WWF after a spell with NWA-affiliated JCP, later WCW, Rotunda was repackaged as I.R.S €“ Irwin. R. Schyster, an Inland Revenue Service tax man gimmick (itself a reworking of the even worse Wall Street stockbroker heel character he€™d used for the last year in WCW). While it was certainly an improvement over his terrible Gordon Gekko imitation (no one gives a stuff about stockbrokers, but tax collectors have been loathed since Biblical times), the character had no legs whatsoever. Only Rotunda€™s sound abilities in the ring and complete commitment to what little heelwork he could get out of the role made him one of the most reliable bad guys in the WWF between 1991 and 1995 €“ that, and his partnership with €˜The Million Dollar Man€™ in tag team Money, Inc and stable The Million Dollar Corporation. Where DiBiase would later unintentionally drag Steve Austin down, he helped elevate Rotunda by association. I.R.S. became one of the most famous WWF heels never to win a title, with crowd-pleasing feuds with Bret Hart, Razor Ramon, the Steiners and the Legion Of Doom, and most famously with the Undertaker.

7. The Doctor Will See You Now

For a man earmarked for great things, a product almost entirely of the WWE developmental system at a time when the majority of their stars had previously cut their teeth elsewhere, it€™s still astonishing that John Cena was given the gimmick of a ghetto-tough rapper €“ and symptomatic of exactly how far out of touch the company was and still is. Nothing€™s changed in the last decade. Let€™s be clear about this: there was not at the time and is not now a sizeable proportion of the WWE crowd secretly into hip hop, demanding representation on television. Hip hop gimmicks don€™t work for black wrestlers, even in 2014: the pro wrestling audience is far more oriented around heavy rock and metal, even after all this time. What€™s more, it€™s not like WWE were there in 2002 with their fingers on the pulse of Eminem€™s recent rise to success as a credible white hip hop superstar. This is the WWE we€™re talking about: they€™d based it on human punchline Vanilla Ice from a dozen years earlier, the man Cena had mimicked in fancy dress on a Halloween episode of Smackdown. But people who wrote Cena off hadn€™t heard about his now-legendary work ethic. John Cena may have had the support of the office, but he made the gimmicked €˜Doctor Of Thuganomics€™ live and breathe. The mic skills that would help propel him to the top of the business over the next couple of years paid off in spades when playing a rapper, even one as cringeworthy and clichéd as only WWE could put together. Of course, a gradual movement over to a Hulk Hogan style of cartoon babyface character and the erosion of Cena€™s credibility would later transform him into the most divisive WWE headliner in the company€™s history. That shouldn€™t take anything away from his achievement in getting over with a terrible, out-of-touch gimmick in the first place, though.

6. Racing In The Streets

The future €˜Hardcore€™ Holly ended his WWF/WWE career in 2009 after 16 years, having become a locker room leader, respected €“ if not necessarily liked €“ by everyone in the company and the majority of the fans. The real life Bob Howard could wrestle a fantastic match when given the opportunity, had a drop kick better than almost anyone else€™s in the business, and was a legitimate tough bastard, having been a professional bar fighter long before he started working matches. And his gimmick when he began? Thurman €˜Sparky€™ Plugg, happy-go-lucky wrestling NASCAR driver. Now, Howard never had a massive push from the office in his entire career, and over the years he resigned himself to playing jobber to the stars €“ making other people, often less talented people, look good to a paying crowd. Working his ass off and never complaining is what Bob Holly did, and probably still does. He managed to claw his way to a more realistic, appropriate gimmick €“ genuine tough guy and streetfighter €˜Hardcore€™ Holly €“ over years of hammering away at it, refusing to slack off, gaining the respect of everyone in management and everyone he worked with. He broke his arm when Kurt Angle botched a moonsault, carried on wrestling and finished the match, putting Angle over exactly as planned. He broke his neck when he and Brock Lesnar mistimed going up for a powerbomb, carried on wrestling (including repeating the blown spot) and finished the match, putting Lesnar over exactly as planned. He cut his back open with a foot long gash during a match with Rob Van Dam, refused point blank to stop wrestling (to the point of threatening to knock out the official who examined him if he tried to end the match) and went on another eight minutes to put Van Dam over exactly as planned. He went on a European tour as ordered, despite having a nasty staph infection: meaning that he nearly had his arm amputated when he came home. When he came back to work months and months later, he once again worked harder than everyone else. Resolutely old school, hard as nails and uncompromising in pretty much everything he does, Bob 'Hardcore' Holly is the pro wrestler€™s pro wrestler, and got over through sheer hardassed guts.

5. €˜The Hurricane€™ Blows Everyone Away

If Bob Holly had it rough with his gimmick and made it work as much as a guy with no push could, Gregory Shane Helms probably had it worse: saddled with a comedy superhero gimmick, and a cruiserweight star to boot, Helms didn€™t even have the necessary size to benefit him in moving up the ranks. But Helms had €“ and has €“ intelligence, creativity and what Mick Foley used to call testicular fortitude. He threw himself headlong into one of the most hilariously silly gimmicks in history, that of a delusional man who thought he was an invincible superhero, and got over with the crowd for four years, from 2001 to 2005 - even briefly taking on The Rock. When he finally got a break to try a more realistic heel persona, Helms ran with it, onscreen and off, adding size and attitude, and becoming the longest reigning Cruiserweight champion of all time at 385 days, and the longest reigning champion €“ of any kind €“ in Smackdown€™s history. During his reign Helms upped his game still further, carrying the cruiserweight division on his back practically singlehanded. At two separate points, he was feuding with the lot of them, all at once. Gregory Helms was forced to have major neck surgery for a serious issue with two broken vertebrae pressing on his spinal cord in mid-2007, shortly after dropping the Cruiserweight title. He was out for over a year, never recovering his momentum in WWE. With his talent, promo skills and work ethic, the sky could have been the limit otherwise: had he been working in WWE only a few years later, it€™s entirely possible that he and CM Punk could have spin-kicked through that glass ceiling together.

4. Samoa€™s Rising Son

A classic example of what happens when the office comes up with a terrible, terrible gimmick and then rams it down everyone€™s throats. For those who don€™t recall, Yokozuna was a sumo wrestler character played by an eight year Samoan-American veteran professional wrestler from one of the most famous and prolific wrestling families in history. You can€™t reasonably expect much from a company that gave half the incredibly talented Anoa€™i family the mute-savage monster foreigner gimmick €“ but at least they were asked to play with their own cultures. Despite being billed as coming from Polynesia (possibly as a way of heading off accusations of genuine racism and cultural appropriation), Yokozuna would rip off everything Japanese culture had to offer, with his ring entrance, hair and gear being based on the ceremonial aspects of sumo (itself an honourable amateur wrestling profession that dates back two millennia). To add further insult, €˜yokozuna€™ is the highest ranking title in sumo. It€™s like if Kurt Angle had called himself €˜Gold Medal€™. Rodney Anoa€™i€™s new character was pushed to the moon as an unstoppable monster heel, winning the Royal Rumble less than three months after debuting in late 1992, and the WWF championship from Bret €˜The Hitman€™ Hart at Wrestlemania for about five minutes before dropping it back to Hulk Hogan. He€™d then feud with Lex Luger€™s patriotic babyface character in one of those crypto-racist WWF storylines of the eighties and nineties that makes you want to wash a lot after reviewing. There€™s no question that, before his ballooning weight made him a danger to himself and others in the ring, Anoa€™i was a talented professional wrestler €“ more than that though, he was the recipient of one of the most concerted pushes ever given to a WWF/WWE superstar€ even if it was as a borderline racist monster heel, a gimmick with no legs to it.

3. To Catch A Sexual Predator

€˜The Bizarre One€™ was, and possibly still is, the oddest gimmick that WWF/WWE have ever placed upon their programming€ a weird, uncomfortable hybrid of underground fetish clichés, drag queen, deranged, movie-obsessed stalker and sexual predator, depending on the era and whether he was playing a babyface or a heel. People watching Dustin Runnels as the child-friendly Goldust on today€™s PG-13 WWE programming probably don€™t realise exactly how close to the bone the character was in the mid-to-late nineties: especially into the rise of the Attitude Era. He€™d grope and molest other wrestlers in the ring, ostensibly as a distraction tactic, playing an x-rated, fetishistic version of the €˜Exotic€™ Adrian Street gimmick of the sixties, seventies and eighties, and playing on homophobia across Western culture. Having a sexually omnivorous heel character alone could be considered a homophobic issue €“ the macho world of professional wrestling has never been been a safe space for men to explore their sexuality. But having a gay or bisexual heel character experimenting with cross-dressing, who regularly intimidated and frightened babyface characters with his thinly veiled sex offender tendencies €“ essentially, a fetish-loving gay character played as a violent sex pest who should have been placed upon a register €“ was too far even for WWF/WWE. When sufficiently motivated though, Dustin Runnels €“ son of the American Dream €“ is one of the most talented professional wrestlers out there, something he€™s demonstrated to a new audience since returning to WWE to team with his younger brother Cody. He€™s had to deal with bizarre and uncomfortable gimmicks for nearly twenty years (his child-abducting weirdo Seven in WCW actually managing to beat Goldust for sheer offensiveness), and got Goldust over through sheer commitment, hard work and talent. Today€™s WWE character, shorn of the horrendous sexual politics that made him so offensive, and partnered with Cody as Stardust, is one of the most popular and entertaining on WWE television.

2. From Cane To Sledgehammer

Since Triple H€™s dual gimmick has been that of hard man main eventer and backstage backstabber for donkey€™s years €“ wielding a sledgehammer in one hand and a shovel in the other €“ it€™s tempting to forget the embarrassing regressive midcard character that Paul Levesque was handed upon joining the WWF in mid-1995, that of effete, sneering old school American nobility, complete with period dress, cane and lessons on etiquette. Despite his impressive stature, clear ability in the ring and excellent mic work, this was a gimmick that was doomed to failure, especially with the Attitude Era heading towards WWF like an oncoming train. A smart student of the game €“ backstage and in the ring €“ Levesque was well aware of it, but by this time he had cannily attached himself to the promotion€™s top dogs, the Kliq, as their waterboy and baggage handler. The weird costumes were gradually ditched, as were the olde worlde mannerisms, the character becoming more of a badass and amending his name to simply €˜Triple H€™. A minor hiccup aside, when he was made the scapegoat for the infamous kayfabe-breaking hug as the Kliq split amicably in 1996, his rise to the top was the result of a combination of impressive ring work, embracing the Attitude Era full on with D-Generation X, and clambering into a highly influential role backstage, often on the backs of others. Today, the character€™s full name (Hunter Hearst Helmsley) and the name of his finishing move (the Pedigree) are the only holdovers from that cringeworthy gimmick.

1. Back From The Dead

The prevailing narrative surrounding the WWF/WWE career of Mark €˜Undertaker€™ Calaway is that the various permutations on the €˜Dead Man€™ character he€™s portrayed on and off for the last quarter of a century together constitute the most successful gimmick in the company€™s long history. While the office€™s protection of and total support for the character have gone a long way towards the advancement of the character, there€™s really only one person who can claim credit for the legendary status of the Undertaker, and that€™s Calaway himself. Let€™s not forget that, in late 1990, this cartoon zombie gimmick was everything that was embarrassing about being a fan of pro wrestling if you were over the age of twelve. Not only that, but the apparent undead Undertaker€™s whole character was based around his lack of selling, speech or facial expressions€ all things necessary to the bastard art of professional wrestling. To begin with, having the obvious skills of Bill Moody, aka Paul Bearer, as his manager went a long way towards helping the mute, lumbering giant get over as a heel. Although Calaway was a fast, agile young man, his gimmick required him to slow to a crawl and reduce his moveset to around four moves, one of which was a chokehold. The original Undertaker gimmick not only required the user to avoid actually working the crowd, or working his opponent, but also required him to pretend that he could barely work at all. The monster heel is traditionally a flash-in-the-pan gimmick: once the endangered babyface finally triumphs over him, which must inevitably happen, the gimmick is on borrowed time. The Undertaker€™s gimmick was, essentially, a monster heel with no up side: the supposedly supernatural components were cheesy, his matches were borefests, and the only exciting thing about him was his size and unstoppable nature. Of course the only possible thing to do was to turn him babyface. As time went on, Calaway managed to gradually turn the character into more of a genuine wrestler: he would sell more and more, developing facial expressions and an actual speaking persona as the gimmick evolved, moving faster and faster in the ring and therefore increasing the level of moves available to him as a consequence. Completely accidentally, the Undertaker would also become undefeated at Wrestlemania, the worked €˜accomplishment€™ that would later be capitalised on in storylines and referred to as the Streak. Huge, talented, ferociously loyal, hard as nails and more old school than Miskatonic University, Calaway and his Undertaker character were always going to be Vince McMahon€™s favourite projects. The most successful gimmick in professional wrestling history, it may be€ it was also originally one of the worst of all time, a terrible idea made legendary by talent and perseverance. What€™s your least favourite but most successful gimmick of all time? Tell us all about it in the comments!